Georgia Clancy
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Georgia Clancy has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Catrin Evans
School of Health Sciences, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK
4 shared publications - Andrew Booth
ScHARR, The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK
3 shared publications - Bhuvan Majmudar
Egality Health Ltd., London, UK
3 shared publications - Catherine Henshall
Oxford School of Nursing and Midwifery, Oxford Brookes University, Oxford, UK
3 shared publications - Helen Spiby
School of Health Sciences, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK
3 shared publications - Kerry Evans
School of Health Sciences, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 21 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Research Methodology
Co-producing principles of engagement to improve the inclusion of black women in UK maternity and neonatal research: a qualitative study
Background: Black women in the United Kingdom persistently experience poor health outcomes in pregnancy and childbirth compared to white women. These healthcare inequities have multiple causalities, and are rooted in intersecting structural, systemic, institutional and sociocultural factors. This is exemplified by the underrepresentation of Black women in healthcare research. Mistrust in research, shaped by historical exploitation and contemporary discrimination, alongside organisational barriers within research delivery, continues to limit equitable research participation. Aim: To critically explore how maternity and neonatal research opportunities are offered, understood, and experienced by Black women and research delivery teams, and to co-produce Principles of Engagement (PoE) to support more inclusive research practices. Methods: An exploratory qualitative design was employed, informed by the Double Diamond framework. In the discover phase, seven online focus groups were conducted with Black women and community representatives ( n = 26), as well as research midwives ( n = 24). Data was analysed using reflexive thematic analysis to define key themes. These findings, alongside patient and public involvement and engagement (PPIE) input, and evidence from a recent systematic review, informed the develop phase, generating draft Principles of Engagement. In the deliver phase, these principles were iteratively refined, discussed, and rated through three online consensus workshops with stakeholders ( n = 20). Results: Four interrelated themes were generated from the focus groups: (1) Trust as a precondition for ethical participation; (2) Making research inclusive and accessible; (3) Power, agency and relational decision-making; and (4) Motivation and value of participation. During subsequent consensus workshops, eight Principles of Engagement were generated; all eight principles were rated as 100% important in the final consensus round. Conclusion: Research engagement was found to be socially negotiated and structurally shaped rather than a solely individual choice. Inclusive intent alone was often insufficient without resourced structural support and relational accountability. Our findings have been translated into novel, co-produced and system-ready principles of engagement which aim to advance equity in UK maternity and neonatal research. Embedding these principles in research practice has the potential to improve trust between clinicians and Black women, widen research participation and improve the fairness, transparency, and relevance of maternity research.
- 21 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Research Methodology
Open AccessCo-producing principles of engagement to improve the inclusion of black women in UK maternity and neonatal research: a qualitative study
Background: Black women in the United Kingdom persistently experience poor health outcomes in pregnancy and childbirth compared to white women. These healthcare inequities have multiple causalities, and are rooted in intersecting structural, systemic, institutional and sociocultural factors. This is exemplified by the underrepresentation of Black women in healthcare research. Mistrust in research, shaped by historical exploitation and contemporary discrimination, alongside organisational barriers within research delivery, continues to limit equitable research participation. Aim: To critically explore how maternity and neonatal research opportunities are offered, understood, and experienced by Black women and research delivery teams, and to co-produce Principles of Engagement (PoE) to support more inclusive research practices. Methods: An exploratory qualitative design was employed, informed by the Double Diamond framework. In the discover phase, seven online focus groups were conducted with Black women and community representatives ( n = 26), as well as research midwives ( n = 24). Data was analysed using reflexive thematic analysis to define key themes. These findings, alongside patient and public involvement and engagement (PPIE) input, and evidence from a recent systematic review, informed the develop phase, generating draft Principles of Engagement. In the deliver phase, these principles were iteratively refined, discussed, and rated through three online consensus workshops with stakeholders ( n = 20). Results: Four interrelated themes were generated from the focus groups: (1) Trust as a precondition for ethical participation; (2) Making research inclusive and accessible; (3) Power, agency and relational decision-making; and (4) Motivation and value of participation. During subsequent consensus workshops, eight Principles of Engagement were generated; all eight principles were rated as 100% important in the final consensus round. Conclusion: Research engagement was found to be socially negotiated and structurally shaped rather than a solely individual choice. Inclusive intent alone was often insufficient without resourced structural support and relational accountability. Our findings have been translated into novel, co-produced and system-ready principles of engagement which aim to advance equity in UK maternity and neonatal research. Embedding these principles in research practice has the potential to improve trust between clinicians and Black women, widen research participation and improve the fairness, transparency, and relevance of maternity research.
- Open Access
- 21 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Research Methodology
- Vol. 26 (1)
A systematic review and meta synthesis of barriers and facilitators to Black women’s participation in healthcare research
Background: Black women are under-represented in clinical research, contributing to persistent health inequities and undermining the validity and generalisability of research findings. Understanding facilitators and barriers to their research engagement is essential to addressing these challenges. This study aimed to identify and synthesise evidence on barriers and facilitators which influence Black women’s participation in healthcare research, to inform inclusive recruitment strategies and equitable research designs. Methods: This systematic review was conducted in accordance with PRISMA guidelines and registered with PROSPERO (CRD42024587308). Findings were narratively synthesised using thematic analysis and discussed iteratively through Patient and Public Involvement. Five databases were searched (CINAHL, PsycInfo, Embase, MIDIRS, MEDLINE) for studies published since 2010. Papers in any language were screened for inclusion. Patient and Public Involvement members informed review objectives and data interpretation. Primary research studies reporting on Black women’s experiences, attitudes, and facilitators/barriers to participating in any type of healthcare research. Studies were included if ≥ 50% (to ensure primary representation) of the sample recruited were Black women. Results: Seventy-two studies were included. Most were from America and spanned research areas relating to oncology, Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV), dementia, maternity, and general health. Five overarching themes identified how Black women’s participation in healthcare research is shaped by a complexity of factors. These were mistrust , interpersonal experiences, altruism, self-interest, and low health/research literacy and awareness . Patient and Public Involvement consultations concurred that the findings aligned with a “bridge and barriers” analogy, illustrating how various factors can facilitate or prevent Black women from engaging with research opportunities. This provided a clear framework to guide culturally sensitive implementation for researchers, healthcare professionals, and policymakers. Conclusions: Inclusive strategies for recruiting Black women into research must focus on co-constructing a bridge between communities and research systems. This requires structural and systemic change in research delivery environments and ongoing collaborations with all stakeholders including Black women, healthcare system providers, and research teams. Trial registration: PROSPERO (CRD42024587308).
- 21 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Research Methodology
- Vol. 26 (1)
Open AccessA systematic review and meta synthesis of barriers and facilitators to Black women’s participation in healthcare research
Background: Black women are under-represented in clinical research, contributing to persistent health inequities and undermining the validity and generalisability of research findings. Understanding facilitators and barriers to their research engagement is essential to addressing these challenges. This study aimed to identify and synthesise evidence on barriers and facilitators which influence Black women’s participation in healthcare research, to inform inclusive recruitment strategies and equitable research designs. Methods: This systematic review was conducted in accordance with PRISMA guidelines and registered with PROSPERO (CRD42024587308). Findings were narratively synthesised using thematic analysis and discussed iteratively through Patient and Public Involvement. Five databases were searched (CINAHL, PsycInfo, Embase, MIDIRS, MEDLINE) for studies published since 2010. Papers in any language were screened for inclusion. Patient and Public Involvement members informed review objectives and data interpretation. Primary research studies reporting on Black women’s experiences, attitudes, and facilitators/barriers to participating in any type of healthcare research. Studies were included if ≥ 50% (to ensure primary representation) of the sample recruited were Black women. Results: Seventy-two studies were included. Most were from America and spanned research areas relating to oncology, Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV), dementia, maternity, and general health. Five overarching themes identified how Black women’s participation in healthcare research is shaped by a complexity of factors. These were mistrust , interpersonal experiences, altruism, self-interest, and low health/research literacy and awareness . Patient and Public Involvement consultations concurred that the findings aligned with a “bridge and barriers” analogy, illustrating how various factors can facilitate or prevent Black women from engaging with research opportunities. This provided a clear framework to guide culturally sensitive implementation for researchers, healthcare professionals, and policymakers. Conclusions: Inclusive strategies for recruiting Black women into research must focus on co-constructing a bridge between communities and research systems. This requires structural and systemic change in research delivery environments and ongoing collaborations with all stakeholders including Black women, healthcare system providers, and research teams. Trial registration: PROSPERO (CRD42024587308).
- Open Access
- 30 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
A Systematic Review and Meta-Synthesis to Explore the Barriers and Facilitators to Black Women’s Participation in Healthcare Research
Background: Black women are under-represented in clinical research, contributing to persistent health disparities and undermining the validity and generalisability of research findings. Understanding facilitators and barriers to their research engagement is essential to addressing these challenges. Objective: To identify and synthesise evidence on barriers and facilitators which influence Black women’s participation in healthcare research, to inform inclusive recruitment strategies and equitable research designs. Design: This systematic review was conducted in accordance with PRISMA guidelines and registered with PROSPERO (CRD42024587308). Findings were narratively synthesised using thematic analysis and discussed iteratively through Patient and Public Involvement. consultations. Data Sources: Five databases were searched (CINAHL, PsycInfo, Embase, MIDIRS, MEDLINE) for studies published since 2010. Papers in any language were screened for inclusion. Patient and Public Involvement members informed review objectives and data interpretation. Eligibility Criteria: Primary research studies reporting on Black women’s experiences, attitudes, and facilitators/barriers to participating in any type of healthcare research. Studies were included if ≥50% of the sample recruited were Black women. Results: Sixty-nine studies were included. Most were from America and spanned research areas relating to oncology, Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV), dementia, maternity, and general health. Five overarching themes identified how Black women’s participation in healthcare research is shaped by a complexity of factors. These were mistrust , interpersonal experiences, altruism, self-interest, and low health/research literacy and awareness . Patient and Public Involvement consultations concurred that the findings aligned with a “bridge and barriers” analogy, illustrating how various factors can facilitate or prevent Black women from engaging with research opportunities. This provided a clear framework to guide culturally sensitive implementation for researchers, healthcare professionals, and policymakers. Conclusions: Inclusive strategies for recruiting Black women into research must focus on co-constructing a bridge between communities and research systems. This requires structural and systemic change in research delivery environments and ongoing collaborations with all stakeholders including Black women, healthcare system providers, and research teams. Systematic review registration: PROSPERO (CRD42024587308).
- 30 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessA Systematic Review and Meta-Synthesis to Explore the Barriers and Facilitators to Black Women’s Participation in Healthcare Research
Background: Black women are under-represented in clinical research, contributing to persistent health disparities and undermining the validity and generalisability of research findings. Understanding facilitators and barriers to their research engagement is essential to addressing these challenges. Objective: To identify and synthesise evidence on barriers and facilitators which influence Black women’s participation in healthcare research, to inform inclusive recruitment strategies and equitable research designs. Design: This systematic review was conducted in accordance with PRISMA guidelines and registered with PROSPERO (CRD42024587308). Findings were narratively synthesised using thematic analysis and discussed iteratively through Patient and Public Involvement. consultations. Data Sources: Five databases were searched (CINAHL, PsycInfo, Embase, MIDIRS, MEDLINE) for studies published since 2010. Papers in any language were screened for inclusion. Patient and Public Involvement members informed review objectives and data interpretation. Eligibility Criteria: Primary research studies reporting on Black women’s experiences, attitudes, and facilitators/barriers to participating in any type of healthcare research. Studies were included if ≥50% of the sample recruited were Black women. Results: Sixty-nine studies were included. Most were from America and spanned research areas relating to oncology, Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV), dementia, maternity, and general health. Five overarching themes identified how Black women’s participation in healthcare research is shaped by a complexity of factors. These were mistrust , interpersonal experiences, altruism, self-interest, and low health/research literacy and awareness . Patient and Public Involvement consultations concurred that the findings aligned with a “bridge and barriers” analogy, illustrating how various factors can facilitate or prevent Black women from engaging with research opportunities. This provided a clear framework to guide culturally sensitive implementation for researchers, healthcare professionals, and policymakers. Conclusions: Inclusive strategies for recruiting Black women into research must focus on co-constructing a bridge between communities and research systems. This requires structural and systemic change in research delivery environments and ongoing collaborations with all stakeholders including Black women, healthcare system providers, and research teams. Systematic review registration: PROSPERO (CRD42024587308).
- Open Access
- 21 July 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Digital Health
- Vol. 4 (7) , e0000944
A mapping survey of digital clinical consultations in maternity care in England
Many areas of healthcare are exploring the use of digital technologies with the aim of improving and expanding care to service users. In England, maternity care is currently undergoing a digital transformation in line with the National Health Service’s (NHS) Long Term Plan, which seeks to enhance care delivery and accessibility through digital tools. However, there is a lack of data on the current use and practice of digital consultations across the country. This project aimed to map and explore how digital clinical consultations are currently being used by NHS maternity care services in England. An online survey was designed to capture data on current practice, guidance and procedures to address potential inequalities. The survey was distributed to each NHS Trust (n = 121) that provides maternity care (specifically to senior maternity care professionals and digital maternity leaders who could provide an overview of how digital consultations were being used where they worked). The survey was open between January and March 2024. 53 completed surveys were received representing 39 different organisations (32% of those currently providing maternity care in England). Quantitative summary statistics indicated that telephone consultations were the most commonly used digital modality across all stages of the maternity care pathway. Thematic analysis identified barriers such as a lack of staff consultation and lack of staff training on the use of digital consultations. It was uncommon for women to be asked about their consultation preferences or assessed for individual needs. In conclusion, the findings reveal significant variation in the use of digital consultations, highlighting a gap between policy intentions and practice. Key areas for improvement in the delivery and implementation of digital consultations include staff training, systems to record women’s consultation preferences/needs, and more research to support digital inclusion. The findings of this survey have the potential to have applications beyond maternity care and in different geographical contexts.
- 21 July 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Digital Health
- Vol. 4 (7) , e0000944
Open AccessA mapping survey of digital clinical consultations in maternity care in England
Many areas of healthcare are exploring the use of digital technologies with the aim of improving and expanding care to service users. In England, maternity care is currently undergoing a digital transformation in line with the National Health Service’s (NHS) Long Term Plan, which seeks to enhance care delivery and accessibility through digital tools. However, there is a lack of data on the current use and practice of digital consultations across the country. This project aimed to map and explore how digital clinical consultations are currently being used by NHS maternity care services in England. An online survey was designed to capture data on current practice, guidance and procedures to address potential inequalities. The survey was distributed to each NHS Trust (n = 121) that provides maternity care (specifically to senior maternity care professionals and digital maternity leaders who could provide an overview of how digital consultations were being used where they worked). The survey was open between January and March 2024. 53 completed surveys were received representing 39 different organisations (32% of those currently providing maternity care in England). Quantitative summary statistics indicated that telephone consultations were the most commonly used digital modality across all stages of the maternity care pathway. Thematic analysis identified barriers such as a lack of staff consultation and lack of staff training on the use of digital consultations. It was uncommon for women to be asked about their consultation preferences or assessed for individual needs. In conclusion, the findings reveal significant variation in the use of digital consultations, highlighting a gap between policy intentions and practice. Key areas for improvement in the delivery and implementation of digital consultations include staff training, systems to record women’s consultation preferences/needs, and more research to support digital inclusion. The findings of this survey have the potential to have applications beyond maternity care and in different geographical contexts.
- Open Access
- 1 May 2025
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- p. 1-77
How to Implement Digital Clinical Consultations in UK Maternity Care: the ARM@DA Realist Review
Background: Digital transformation is a key component within the National Health Service Maternity Transformation Programme. The COVID-19 pandemic led to an acceleration of digital innovation, in particular, the use of digital clinical consultations (telephone/video consultations). The ways in which digital clinical consultations can be optimised and utilised alongside the traditional maternity care pathway remains unclear, however, with particular concerns about the potential for digital care to exacerbate inequalities. Objective: To explore how digital clinical consultations can be implemented in a clinically safe, appropriate and acceptable way within UK maternity services? For whom? In what settings? And for what purposes? Design: A realist synthesis combining an evidence review of diverse sources (2010 to the present) from Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development countries with insights from key stakeholder groups (healthcare professionals, service users and community organisations). Data sources: There were three main sources: (1) published primary and secondary research; (2) grey literature (such as policy documents and maternity safety reports); and (3) stakeholder insights. Methods: A realist synthesis adopts a theory-driven approach which seeks to understand how a complex programme works, for whom and under what circumstances. The review had three iterative phases: (1) refining the review focus and developing initial programme theories; (2) retrieval of evidence for data extraction and analysis (using on a realist logic to identify key contexts, mechanisms and outcomes); and (3) testing and refining the programme theories. Results: The final synthesis included 93 evidence sources (reviews, reports and 77 primary studies), with priority given to UK-focused studies. Study samples included a focus on healthcare professionals (n = 17), women (n = 45, of which 14 focused on vulnerable groups) or both (n = 15). Clinical and safety-related outcomes were reported in 12 studies. Fifteen programme theories were developed. A conceptual framework was produced that illustrates the inter-relationship between key contexts in maternity care through which different interactions activate mechanisms to produce outcomes of interest. The findings suggest that digital clinical consultations can be acceptable and appropriate if implementation includes personalisation and informed choice for women, as well as support and autonomy for staff. The relationship and connection between women and their healthcare professional are proposed as key mechanisms that support safety and engagement in care. Limitations: Some of the evidence lacked details regarding specific settings, interventions or sample characteristics. This limits the extent to which findings can be applied to micro-level contexts. Stakeholder groups contributed key insights to the review at all stages. In spite of efforts to achieve diversity within these groups, there may have been experiences or identities that were missed. Conclusions: Four ‘CORE’ implementation principles were identified to guide future practice and research: C – Creating the right environment, infrastructure and support for staff; O – Optimising consultations to be responsive, flexible and personalised to different needs and preferences; R – Recognising the importance of access and inclusion; and E – Enabling quality and safety through relationship-focused connections. Future work: Future research should embed equity considerations and should focus on understanding digital clinical consultation within specific maternity systems (like triage/helplines), services (such as specialist outpatient clinics) or groups of women (e.g. with digital literacy or communication needs). Funding: This synopsis presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research as award number NIHR134535.
- 1 May 2025
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- p. 1-77
Open AccessHow to Implement Digital Clinical Consultations in UK Maternity Care: the ARM@DA Realist Review
Background: Digital transformation is a key component within the National Health Service Maternity Transformation Programme. The COVID-19 pandemic led to an acceleration of digital innovation, in particular, the use of digital clinical consultations (telephone/video consultations). The ways in which digital clinical consultations can be optimised and utilised alongside the traditional maternity care pathway remains unclear, however, with particular concerns about the potential for digital care to exacerbate inequalities. Objective: To explore how digital clinical consultations can be implemented in a clinically safe, appropriate and acceptable way within UK maternity services? For whom? In what settings? And for what purposes? Design: A realist synthesis combining an evidence review of diverse sources (2010 to the present) from Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development countries with insights from key stakeholder groups (healthcare professionals, service users and community organisations). Data sources: There were three main sources: (1) published primary and secondary research; (2) grey literature (such as policy documents and maternity safety reports); and (3) stakeholder insights. Methods: A realist synthesis adopts a theory-driven approach which seeks to understand how a complex programme works, for whom and under what circumstances. The review had three iterative phases: (1) refining the review focus and developing initial programme theories; (2) retrieval of evidence for data extraction and analysis (using on a realist logic to identify key contexts, mechanisms and outcomes); and (3) testing and refining the programme theories. Results: The final synthesis included 93 evidence sources (reviews, reports and 77 primary studies), with priority given to UK-focused studies. Study samples included a focus on healthcare professionals (n = 17), women (n = 45, of which 14 focused on vulnerable groups) or both (n = 15). Clinical and safety-related outcomes were reported in 12 studies. Fifteen programme theories were developed. A conceptual framework was produced that illustrates the inter-relationship between key contexts in maternity care through which different interactions activate mechanisms to produce outcomes of interest. The findings suggest that digital clinical consultations can be acceptable and appropriate if implementation includes personalisation and informed choice for women, as well as support and autonomy for staff. The relationship and connection between women and their healthcare professional are proposed as key mechanisms that support safety and engagement in care. Limitations: Some of the evidence lacked details regarding specific settings, interventions or sample characteristics. This limits the extent to which findings can be applied to micro-level contexts. Stakeholder groups contributed key insights to the review at all stages. In spite of efforts to achieve diversity within these groups, there may have been experiences or identities that were missed. Conclusions: Four ‘CORE’ implementation principles were identified to guide future practice and research: C – Creating the right environment, infrastructure and support for staff; O – Optimising consultations to be responsive, flexible and personalised to different needs and preferences; R – Recognising the importance of access and inclusion; and E – Enabling quality and safety through relationship-focused connections. Future work: Future research should embed equity considerations and should focus on understanding digital clinical consultation within specific maternity systems (like triage/helplines), services (such as specialist outpatient clinics) or groups of women (e.g. with digital literacy or communication needs). Funding: This synopsis presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research as award number NIHR134535.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2025
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 13 (22) , 79-80
Optimising digital clinical consultations in maternity care: a realist review and implementation principles
This article consists of a citation of a published article describing research funded by the Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme under project number NIHR134535, and is provided as as part of the complete record of research outputs for this project. The original publication is available at: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-079153 Objectives: The COVID-19 pandemic has led to increased use of digital clinical consultations (phone or video calls) within UK maternity services. This project aimed to review the evidence on digital clinical consultations in maternity systems to illuminate how, for whom and in what contexts, they can be used to support safe, personalised and equitable care. Design: A realist synthesis, drawing on diverse sources of evidence (2010–present) from OECD countries, alongside insights from knowledge user groups (representing healthcare providers and service users). Methods: The review used three analytical processes (induction, abduction and retroduction) within three iterative stages (development of initial programme theories; evidence retrieval and synthesis; validation and refinement of the programme theories). Results: Ninety-three evidence sources were included in the final synthesis. Fifteen programme theories were developed showing that digital clinical consultations involve different mechanisms operating across five key contexts: the organisation, healthcare providers, the clinical relationship, the reason for consultation and women. The review suggests that digital clinical consultations can be effective and acceptable to stakeholders if there is access to appropriate infrastructure/digital resources and if implementation is able to ensure personalisation, informed choice, professional autonomy and relationship-focused connections. The review found relatively less evidence in relation to safety and equity. Conclusions: Due to the complexity of maternity systems, there can be ‘no one-size fits all’ approach to digital clinical consultations. Nonetheless, the review distills four ‘CORE’ implementation principles: C—creating the right environment, infrastructure and support for staff; O—optimising consultations to be responsive, flexible and personalised to different needs and preferences; R—recognising the importance of access and inclusion; and E—enabling quality and safety through relationship-focused connections. Service innovation and research are needed to operationalise, explore and evaluate these principles, particularly in relation to safety and equity. PROSPERO registration number: CRD42021288702. Funding: This publication was funded by the Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme as a part of award number NIHR134535. This article reports on one component of the research award ARM@DA: A Realist Inquiry into Maternity Care @ a DistAnce. For more information about this research please view the award page [https://fundingawards.nihr.ac.uk/award/NIHR134535] DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-079153
- 1 March 2025
- Published by National Institute for Health and Care Research in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
- Vol. 13 (22) , 79-80
Open AccessOptimising digital clinical consultations in maternity care: a realist review and implementation principles
This article consists of a citation of a published article describing research funded by the Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme under project number NIHR134535, and is provided as as part of the complete record of research outputs for this project. The original publication is available at: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-079153 Objectives: The COVID-19 pandemic has led to increased use of digital clinical consultations (phone or video calls) within UK maternity services. This project aimed to review the evidence on digital clinical consultations in maternity systems to illuminate how, for whom and in what contexts, they can be used to support safe, personalised and equitable care. Design: A realist synthesis, drawing on diverse sources of evidence (2010–present) from OECD countries, alongside insights from knowledge user groups (representing healthcare providers and service users). Methods: The review used three analytical processes (induction, abduction and retroduction) within three iterative stages (development of initial programme theories; evidence retrieval and synthesis; validation and refinement of the programme theories). Results: Ninety-three evidence sources were included in the final synthesis. Fifteen programme theories were developed showing that digital clinical consultations involve different mechanisms operating across five key contexts: the organisation, healthcare providers, the clinical relationship, the reason for consultation and women. The review suggests that digital clinical consultations can be effective and acceptable to stakeholders if there is access to appropriate infrastructure/digital resources and if implementation is able to ensure personalisation, informed choice, professional autonomy and relationship-focused connections. The review found relatively less evidence in relation to safety and equity. Conclusions: Due to the complexity of maternity systems, there can be ‘no one-size fits all’ approach to digital clinical consultations. Nonetheless, the review distills four ‘CORE’ implementation principles: C—creating the right environment, infrastructure and support for staff; O—optimising consultations to be responsive, flexible and personalised to different needs and preferences; R—recognising the importance of access and inclusion; and E—enabling quality and safety through relationship-focused connections. Service innovation and research are needed to operationalise, explore and evaluate these principles, particularly in relation to safety and equity. PROSPERO registration number: CRD42021288702. Funding: This publication was funded by the Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme as a part of award number NIHR134535. This article reports on one component of the research award ARM@DA: A Realist Inquiry into Maternity Care @ a DistAnce. For more information about this research please view the award page [https://fundingawards.nihr.ac.uk/award/NIHR134535] DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-079153
- Open Access
Optimising digital clinical consultations in maternity care: a realist review and implementation principles
Objectives The COVID-19 pandemic has led to increased use of digital clinical consultations (phone or video calls) within UK maternity services. This project aimed to review the evidence on digital clinical consultations in maternity systems to illuminate how, for whom and in what contexts, they can be used to support safe, personalised and equitable care. Design A realist synthesis, drawing on diverse sources of evidence (2010–present) from OECD countries, alongside insights from knowledge user groups (representing healthcare providers and service users). Methods The review used three analytical processes (induction, abduction and retroduction) within three iterative stages (development of initial programme theories; evidence retrieval and synthesis; validation and refinement of the programme theories). Results Ninety-three evidence sources were included in the final synthesis. Fifteen programme theories were developed showing that digital clinical consultations involve different mechanisms operating across five key contexts: the organisation, healthcare providers, the clinical relationship, the reason for consultation and women. The review suggests that digital clinical consultations can be effective and acceptable to stakeholders if there is access to appropriate infrastructure/digital resources and if implementation is able to ensure personalisation, informed choice, professional autonomy and relationship-focused connections. The review found relatively less evidence in relation to safety and equity. Conclusions Due to the complexity of maternity systems, there can be ‘no one-size fits all’ approach to digital clinical consultations. Nonetheless, the review distills four ‘CORE’ implementation principles: C—creating the right environment, infrastructure and support for staff; O—optimising consultations to be responsive, flexible and personalised to different needs and preferences; R—recognising the importance of access and inclusion; and E—enabling quality and safety through relationship-focused connections. Service innovation and research are needed to operationalise, explore and evaluate these principles, particularly in relation to safety and equity. PROSPERO registration number CRD42021288702.
Open AccessOptimising digital clinical consultations in maternity care: a realist review and implementation principles
Objectives The COVID-19 pandemic has led to increased use of digital clinical consultations (phone or video calls) within UK maternity services. This project aimed to review the evidence on digital clinical consultations in maternity systems to illuminate how, for whom and in what contexts, they can be used to support safe, personalised and equitable care. Design A realist synthesis, drawing on diverse sources of evidence (2010–present) from OECD countries, alongside insights from knowledge user groups (representing healthcare providers and service users). Methods The review used three analytical processes (induction, abduction and retroduction) within three iterative stages (development of initial programme theories; evidence retrieval and synthesis; validation and refinement of the programme theories). Results Ninety-three evidence sources were included in the final synthesis. Fifteen programme theories were developed showing that digital clinical consultations involve different mechanisms operating across five key contexts: the organisation, healthcare providers, the clinical relationship, the reason for consultation and women. The review suggests that digital clinical consultations can be effective and acceptable to stakeholders if there is access to appropriate infrastructure/digital resources and if implementation is able to ensure personalisation, informed choice, professional autonomy and relationship-focused connections. The review found relatively less evidence in relation to safety and equity. Conclusions Due to the complexity of maternity systems, there can be ‘no one-size fits all’ approach to digital clinical consultations. Nonetheless, the review distills four ‘CORE’ implementation principles: C—creating the right environment, infrastructure and support for staff; O—optimising consultations to be responsive, flexible and personalised to different needs and preferences; R—recognising the importance of access and inclusion; and E—enabling quality and safety through relationship-focused connections. Service innovation and research are needed to operationalise, explore and evaluate these principles, particularly in relation to safety and equity. PROSPERO registration number CRD42021288702.
- Open Access
- 22 April 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Women and Birth
- Vol. 37 (4) , 101616
A mixed-methods study of women’s birthplace preferences and decisions in England
- 22 April 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Women and Birth
- Vol. 37 (4) , 101616
Open AccessA mixed-methods study of women’s birthplace preferences and decisions in England