DCDiana Fritz Cates

Diana Fritz Cates

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Diana Fritz Cates has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Dharma Saṃkaṭa in the Mahābhārata: Existential Struggles and Real Repercussions

    by Veena R. Howard, Diana Fritz Cates

    Sometimes humans face perplexing situations in which we must make a choice. We are bound by multiple obligations, and each of them requires a different and incompatible course of action. One or more obligations must go unfulfilled. We might also anticipate that, by neglecting an obligation, serious, detrimental consequences will follow for us or for others. The choice may be further complicated by the fact that we care deeply for people who could be negatively affected by our choice. Weighty situations such as these are known in ancient Indian literature as dharma saṃkaṭas. This essay reflects on two instances of dharma saṃkaṭas from the Mahābhārata, namely, the respective conflicts in the narrative of “The Hawk and the Dove” and in the dialogue of Prince Arjuna with Lord Kṛṣṇa on the battlefield, followed by post‐war ruminations. These stories can help contemporary readers to think critically and creatively about dharma saṃkaṭas that may not be fully resolvable.


  • Circle consciousness

    by Jiyun Park, Diana Cates, Matthew Arndt, Kristy Nabhan-Warren

    The study of religion addresses diverse ways in which people perceive and construct worlds of meaning. This thesis argues that perceptions of natural phenomena are often limited by natural philosophies that assert linear, static, and mechanical models of reality or grid consciousness. It introduces, instead, a model of Circle Consciousness, which calls attention to fractal and biomorphic energies-in-motion, spanning micro (sub-atomic) to macro (cosmic) scales, revealing geometric meta-patterns that invite corresponding extensions of consciousness. Hidden energies and dimensions of reality, and thus new possibilities for the future, emerge in a process of tracing a simple form – the circle – through spherical, toroidal, and knotting forms, each of which flows into the others like breath. Tracing the growth of forms can reveal what David Bohm characterizes as an implicate order of wholeness. Recognizing that one is both an agent and an integral part of an intricate dance of nature may contribute to healing of trauma, much of which is rooted in perceptions of separateness and the possibility of non-belonging. A model of Circle Consciousness emerges in engaging with the thought of several scholars who have worked at the fluid edges of physics and metaphysics, most notably Theosophist Dr. Hans Jenny, physicist David Bohm, and physicist Edward Witten. Jenny invented the Cymascope, which shows how sand shape-shifts under the influence of resonant frequency vibrations to reveal patterns that one can also recognize as fruit, flower, and seed cycles. Bohm showed that scientific prediction limits inquiry by concealing a fundamental unity that is hidden beneath and animates observable reality. Witten proposed M-theory, which reveals a unity among multiple theories of the nature of nature, each representing elementary particles as loops of vibrating “strings.” Together these thinkers confirm what many artists and artisans have long intuited and expressed in patterns like sri yantri mandalas.

  • Ethics of the inheritable genetic modification of human embryos via CRISPR technology

    by Darcy Metcalfe, Diana Cates, Kristy Nabhan-Warren, Jenna Supp-Montgomerie, Scott Williamson, Robert Cargill

    There is a long and continuing history of racialized science and medicine in the U.S. Given this history, Black women are at special risk when it comes to recent developments and applications of gene-editing technologies. There is good reason to be concerned that CRISPR techniques, in particular, will be used to pursue the embryonic inheritable genetic modification (EIGM) of human embryos in ways that wittingly or unwittingly perpetuate racial injustice and the well-documented U.S. failure to honor Black women’s reproductive autonomy and well-being. This dissertation elucidates Pauli Murray’s interpretation of the diverse processes by which race has been constructed in U.S. history and how these processes connect with a pattern of U.S. medical and scientific surveillance and control of Black women’s reproductive capacities. It also articulates Murray’s religious and ethical views regarding how this pattern can be disrupted, beginning with a change in people’s perspectives concerning the relational and interconnected nature of existence. Her view serves as an ethical challenge for bioethicists and members of medical-scientific communities to examine their current ways of thinking and clarify what justice requires of them as observers and contributors to face-paced developments in human genetic engineering.

  • Better living through anger

    by Jan Rippentrop Schnell, Diana Fritz Cates, Hyaeweol Choi, Christopher-Rasheem McMillan, Kristy Nabhan-Warren, Jenna Supp-Montgomerie

    Can anger be a virtuous emotion and yield virtuous action? US culture implicitly and explicitly constrains performances of anger, especially by women. This religious ethics study probes the possibility of virtuous anger in order to show that anger and its expressions can both be morally good. I conduct structured interviews and participant observations with three women community organizers of different religious and cultural backgrounds and examine their insights alongside Thomas Aquinas’s virtue ethics and philosophy of emotion as well as performance studies’ choreographic practices. The results reveal that multiple forms of anger exist, some of which are morally commendable, which challenges existing notions about the homogeneity and morality of anger. There is a form, which I call transformation-anger, that is rooted in love, characterized by hope and courage, and in relation to which people can feel well, choose well, and do well. Not only is a virtuous form of anger possible, it appears to be requisite in the pursuit of communal justice. Three movements collaborate in a deliberate cultivation of a virtuous habit of transformation-anger: interior movements of emotions of anger, intellective movements of deliberation and choice, and bodily movements and expressions. The organizers intentionally and informally work on their anger while they invite others to transform their own anger through a expertly nuanced social choreography, which they all enact in communities of accountability and mutual flourishing. The cultivation of justice-attuned anger transforms people’s other angers, transforms the people themselves, and increases potential for social transformation. Angry behaviors associated with transformation-anger include exposing for people the gap between who they say they want to be and how they behave, filtering out vicious angers, focusing chaotic angers on something beneficial, aiming toward realistic change on a structural level, connecting with others who share one’s concern, motivating action, and coordinating public actions that counteract harmful social systems on behalf of vulnerable populations. In a world where injustice hampers communal flourishing, people do well to cultivate transformation-anger in order to support their pursuit of justice.


  • Faith, news, and truth

    by John P Haman, Frank D. Durham, Daniel A. Berkowitz, Diana Fritz Cates, David Dowling, Daniel Lathrop

    The central argument of this dissertation is that dissident religious journalism played an important role in the early social gospel movement in American Christianity. Ministers who entered the field of print journalism in the 1890s sought to use the pulpit of the press to directly engage the public and prominent opinion leaders within the church. This study centers on these efforts in the context of one prominent religious publication of the time, The Kingdom. A unique paper edited by a cast of the central figures of the early social gospel movement, it illustrates how complex issues, and strenuous disagreements over those issues, were mediated through specific journalistic practices. This dissertation tells the story of the paper, the process by which it mediated differences in opinion, and its significance in the print media environment of the 1890s. In addition to addressing basic details of the Kingdom’s existence and its place within the Protestant and nonreligious reform movements, the primary research questions in this study seek to understand the motivations that led the editors and contributors of the Kingdom to turn journalism in the first place. Why did they create alternative publications instead of utilizing more mainstream outlets? Answering these questions will entail close examination of the stated purposes of the paper and examination of how the editors and contributors understood and attempted to fulfill those purposes. A second research question stems directly from the first and asks what void these journalists were trying to fill in relation to the mainstream press environment of the 1890s. The methods and practices utilized by these editors provides an independent model of journalism motivated by an alternative understanding of the relation between democracy, the social gospel, and public responsibility. By providing an example of a religiously-informed social ethic of news reporting, these papers “walked the walk” of their outspoken criticisms of the mainstream press. This analysis reveals an unconventional model of journalism that competed for popular attention. I also compare the journalism of the Kingdom to the mainstream and religious papers of the period. The dissident Protestant press was situated at the intersection of many conflicting viewpoints that helped shape the media landscape at the time. Analyzing the impact of the complex cultural context of the Kingdom provides a fertile opportunity to describe in detail the development of social gospel ideas. Ministers were the primary editors and writers for the Kingdom, yet many non-clerical reformers like Henry Demarest Lloyd played significant roles in shaping the movement by contributing articles and providing material support. Many editors and leading figures of the dissident Protestant press maintained close contact with public thinkers outside the religious fold who were also writing and organizing on behalf of reform. Although their perspectives may have differed slightly, the network was largely one of mutual support. I argue that the Kingdom was one specific site that helped to facilitate these connections in the last decade of the nineteenth century.

  • Unsettling religion

    by Kaitlyn Lindgren-Hansen, Jenna Supp-Montgomerie, Lori Branch, Diana Cates

    This thesis examines the clash of seemingly dissonant passages in Hannah Crafts’s The Bondwoman’s Narrative to consider how the text can and should anger the reader through the juxtaposition of multiple literary genres. In particular, the placement of scenes of gothic horror alongside expressions of piety unsettles the reader, forcing them to confront a complex array of social institutions (slavery, racism, religion, and the justice system) and their own complicity in those systems. Drawing on philosophical analyses of the structure and the morality of emotion, I argue that the text is intended to elicit anger that is both moderated by reason and rooted in love. I contest the notion that anger necessarily includes a problematic desire for payback and suggest that the desire that accompanies anger is better conceptualized as a desire for recognition of an injury that may include payback but is not fixated on payback. My reading of The Bondwoman’s Narrative contests multiple claims that the moments of dissonance in the text were a result of the author’s lack of skill. Instead, I posit that these juxtapositions are intentional and seek to engage the reader in a process of ethical formation that literature is uniquely able to provide. Anger is an essential part of the formation process, pushing the reader to consider their own complicity in injustice and to work to change unjust social systems.

  • Faith and the incommensurable

    by Devon Wootten, Steven Ungar, Sabine Golz, Roland Racevskis, Diana Cates, Kevin Kopelson

    This dissertation examines the way the Pythagorean conception of the incommensurable structures the assertions of subjective agency in Blaise Pascal’s Pensées (1670), Søren Kierkegaard’s Concluding Unscientific Postscript (1846), and Alain Badiou’s Being and Event (1988). The Pythagoreans coined the term “incommensurable,” alogos, to describe magnitudes that cannot emerge within a specific system of signification. Across three chapters, I extend the Pythagorean understanding of the incommensurable into the areas of philosophy, religious studies, and mathematics in order to posit the fundamental instability at the core of subjective agency. Moving from Thomas S. Kuhn’s failure to define the incommensurable logically in his Structures of Scientific Revolutions, I argue that such a conception of the incommensurable must be understood as fundamentally faith-based. Given the fact that the incommensurable cannot emerge into signification, its existence must be posited on faith. Pascal, Kierkegaard, and Badiou each move from a faith-based assertion of the incommensurable to offer a conception of subjective agency within a specific system of signification. Thus, against the work of Bonaventura Cavalieri and Evangelista Torricelli, Pascal refigures the incommensurably infinite to establish a heterodox subjective agency within Augustinian faith-by-grace; Kierkegaard manages to navigate the incommensurability of direct communication and personal faith by effacing his pseudonym Johannes Climacus; and Alain Badiou relies on the incommensurable “event” to imagine the possibility the subject’s calling into being of the new. In each of these three texts, the incommensurable functions to guarantee the possibility of subject agency within a specific system of signification.

  • The battle for the Sabbath in the Dutch Reformation

    by Kyle James Dieleman, Julie Hochstrasser, Kristy Nabhan-Warren, Raymond A. Mentzer, Diana F. Cates, Paul Dilley

    My dissertation research project focuses on the doctrinal and practical importance of Sunday observance, also known as Sabbath observance, in the sixteenth-and-seventeenth-century Reformed communities in the Low Countries. My project investigates the theological import of the Sabbath and its practical applications. In tracing the development of the Sabbath in the Dutch Reformation, the first step is to focus on how Dutch Reformed theologians conceived of the Sabbath. When studying theologians important for the Dutch Reformed tradition the importance of the Sabbath cannot be ignored, but it is also evident that the theological issues regarding the Sabbath were complex and hotly contested. The theology of the Sabbath, I will argue, moves over time from an emphasis on spiritual rest to participating in the ministries of the church to a strict rest from all work and recreation.Having examined the theological understanding of the Sabbath in the Dutch Reformed tradition, the next step is to explore congregants’ actual Sunday practices. By attending to church governance records at the national, regional, and local levels the importance of proper Sabbath observance quickly becomes clear. The provicinal synod records, classes’ records, and consistory records indicate that church authorities in the Dutch Republic were adamant that church members faithfully attend sermon and catechism services, refrain from sinful practices, and abstain from recreational activities. Equally as telling as the observance demanded of church members is how church authorities responded. The church records portray the church authorities as fretting over the disordered and unregulated nature of improper Sabbath observance. Furthermore, the church authorities frequently place the issue of Sabbath observance in the context of difficulties with other confessional groups.Having established the importance of the Sabbath in Dutch Reformed theology and lived piety, I argue the emphasis on Sunday observance is best understood as resulting from two main factors. First, the emphasis on the Sabbath took place within a religiously plural situation where the Dutch Reformed Church was seeking to distinguish itself from Catholics, Anabaptists, and Remonstrants. In other words, my thesis is that emphasis on proper Sunday observance is a result of the Reformed church authorities attempting to maintain the pious reputation of the Reformed faith and establish the identity of the Reformed Church in the midst of multiple other confessional identities. Second, proper observance of the Sabbath was important because it was a way to ensure order within the church and society more broadly. Sunday observance was part of the religious authorities’ desire to maintain religious and moral order within the church and broader society.My project leads to several conclusions. First, the theological issues regarding the Sabbath were not straight-forward in the Dutch Reformed tradition and received nuanced and varied treatment from different theologians. Second, strict Sabbath observance in the Dutch Reformed churches was not primarily the result of the influence of the English Purtians. Instead, the strict demands for Sunday observance were inherent within the Dutch Reformation. Finally, the interplay between church authorities and lay members regarding Sunday observance was complicated and contested. Lay members were quite willing to attend morning sermon services and, generally, abstain from work. However, they were much less willing to refrain from recreational activities, attend afternoon catechism services, and cease questionable, if not sinful, behaviors. The Dutch Reformation, then, was not simply handed down from above but was negotiated between church authorities and institutions and the lay members of the churches and the broader society.

  • Aquinas, Feminism, and the Common Good

    by Diana Fritz Cates, Philosophy Documentation Center