Melanie Steiner
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Melanie Steiner has a total of 34 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Richard McGee
Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine
7 shared publicationsAndrew K. Langi
Indiana University School of Medicine
6 shared publicationsHarlan P. Jones
University of North Texas Health
6 shared publicationsKolawole S. Okuyemi
Indiana University School of Medicine
6 shared publicationsPatrick O. Monahan
Indiana University School of Medicine
6 shared publicationsWenxian Zhou
Indiana University School of Medicine
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 November 2026
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 21 (11) , e0355883
Grant writing coaching groups: A randomized trial to discern the influences of coaching duration and engagement of scientific mentors on participants’ proposal submission and success rates
Introduction: The acquisition of National Institutes of Health (NIH) grants is an increasingly competitive undertaking. Many early-career biomedical investigators lack sufficient grant writing skills. This pragmatic, 2x2 factorial, group-randomized trial tested the effects of coaching duration and mode of engagement of participants’ scientific mentors in a grant writing coaching group intervention on grant application outcomes. Methods: A national US sample of 367 faculty and postdoctoral fellows, organized into 76 coaching groups across 6 cohorts (2020–2022), was randomized to 1 of 4 arms that differed by coaching duration (5 months vs 5 months plus 18 months of access to 1:1 coaching) and mode of scientific mentor engagement (structured vs unstructured). Primary outcomes were national-level grant application submissions and awards, and success rate among submitters, assessed via surveys and verified through award databases 30 months after study initiation. Results: Among 271 faculty and 96 postdoctoral fellows, 69% submitted at least 1 national application and 32% were awarded at least 1 grant. Submission rates did not differ by experimental arm. Among faculty, the structured engagement of a mentor in coaching was associated with significantly higher odds of any award (adjusted OR = 1.87) and any NIH mentored career development (K) award (adjusted OR = 3.32), and with higher success rates for these proposal types. Extended coaching duration showed a positive but not statistically significant association with faculty awards after adjustment. Neither factor significantly affected outcomes for postdoctoral fellows. Faculty success rates exceeded national NIH-reported success rates for research project grants equivalent to the R01 mechanism (43% vs 17.6%) and K awards (51% vs 36.5%). Conclusion: Participation in a national, cross-institutional, group coaching model yielded high grant submission outcomes, and award rates were higher relative to NIH benchmarks. Structured integration of scientific mentors with the coaching intervention had a greater effect than extended coaching duration on faculty outcomes.
- 10 November 2026
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 21 (11) , e0355883
Open AccessGrant writing coaching groups: A randomized trial to discern the influences of coaching duration and engagement of scientific mentors on participants’ proposal submission and success rates
Introduction: The acquisition of National Institutes of Health (NIH) grants is an increasingly competitive undertaking. Many early-career biomedical investigators lack sufficient grant writing skills. This pragmatic, 2x2 factorial, group-randomized trial tested the effects of coaching duration and mode of engagement of participants’ scientific mentors in a grant writing coaching group intervention on grant application outcomes. Methods: A national US sample of 367 faculty and postdoctoral fellows, organized into 76 coaching groups across 6 cohorts (2020–2022), was randomized to 1 of 4 arms that differed by coaching duration (5 months vs 5 months plus 18 months of access to 1:1 coaching) and mode of scientific mentor engagement (structured vs unstructured). Primary outcomes were national-level grant application submissions and awards, and success rate among submitters, assessed via surveys and verified through award databases 30 months after study initiation. Results: Among 271 faculty and 96 postdoctoral fellows, 69% submitted at least 1 national application and 32% were awarded at least 1 grant. Submission rates did not differ by experimental arm. Among faculty, the structured engagement of a mentor in coaching was associated with significantly higher odds of any award (adjusted OR = 1.87) and any NIH mentored career development (K) award (adjusted OR = 3.32), and with higher success rates for these proposal types. Extended coaching duration showed a positive but not statistically significant association with faculty awards after adjustment. Neither factor significantly affected outcomes for postdoctoral fellows. Faculty success rates exceeded national NIH-reported success rates for research project grants equivalent to the R01 mechanism (43% vs 17.6%) and K awards (51% vs 36.5%). Conclusion: Participation in a national, cross-institutional, group coaching model yielded high grant submission outcomes, and award rates were higher relative to NIH benchmarks. Structured integration of scientific mentors with the coaching intervention had a greater effect than extended coaching duration on faculty outcomes.
- Open Access
A Randomized Trial of Grant Writing Coaching Groups: Qualitative Interviews Revealing Key Elements of Intervention Efficacy
Background: Training in grant proposal writing is an essential component of professional development for academic scientists in the biomedical and behavioral sciences. Despite the expansion of inter- and intra-institutional grant writing coaching groups as an approach to honing these skills, specific features that enhance or limit coaching group effectiveness have not been rigorously studied. Methods: Qualitative interviews were conducted with a subset of early-career investigators (n=204 and coaches (n=36) engaged in a national, U.S. based, group-randomized trial of grant writing coaching groups to test the effects of two variables on submission and funding of national-level proposals: (1) coaching duration (regular/extended dose) and (2) mode of engaging a scientific advisor (someone with content-aligned expertise) in the coaching process. This report focuses on interviews conducted upon completion of the regular coaching dose – 5 months of biweekly, group-based coaching sessions to support active proposal writing. Interviews were designed to identify which coaching group elements were perceived to be the most critical. Transcribed interviews were analyzed using deductive (participants) or open (coaches) coding to identify themes. Results: Triangulation of results from participant and coach interviews showed strong concordance that coaches, peers, and scientific advisors all played key roles in supporting intervention efficacy. Sufficient alignment of scientific fields and/or methodologies among group members was important, although breadth of perspectives was also valued. Other critical group features were skilled and well-organized coaches, detailed feedback, peer-to-peer support (technical and psychosocial), and clear expectations for group functioning. Factors attenuating impact included variation in participants’ engagement and “readiness to write,” within-group mismatches of expertise or grant mechanisms, and limited research support at some participants’ home institutions. Conclusion: This study identified key elements of successful grant writing coaching groups and potential barriers to their effectiveness, while yielding insights about tailoring this approach for individuals at different stages of proposal development.
Open AccessA Randomized Trial of Grant Writing Coaching Groups: Qualitative Interviews Revealing Key Elements of Intervention Efficacy
Background: Training in grant proposal writing is an essential component of professional development for academic scientists in the biomedical and behavioral sciences. Despite the expansion of inter- and intra-institutional grant writing coaching groups as an approach to honing these skills, specific features that enhance or limit coaching group effectiveness have not been rigorously studied. Methods: Qualitative interviews were conducted with a subset of early-career investigators (n=204 and coaches (n=36) engaged in a national, U.S. based, group-randomized trial of grant writing coaching groups to test the effects of two variables on submission and funding of national-level proposals: (1) coaching duration (regular/extended dose) and (2) mode of engaging a scientific advisor (someone with content-aligned expertise) in the coaching process. This report focuses on interviews conducted upon completion of the regular coaching dose – 5 months of biweekly, group-based coaching sessions to support active proposal writing. Interviews were designed to identify which coaching group elements were perceived to be the most critical. Transcribed interviews were analyzed using deductive (participants) or open (coaches) coding to identify themes. Results: Triangulation of results from participant and coach interviews showed strong concordance that coaches, peers, and scientific advisors all played key roles in supporting intervention efficacy. Sufficient alignment of scientific fields and/or methodologies among group members was important, although breadth of perspectives was also valued. Other critical group features were skilled and well-organized coaches, detailed feedback, peer-to-peer support (technical and psychosocial), and clear expectations for group functioning. Factors attenuating impact included variation in participants’ engagement and “readiness to write,” within-group mismatches of expertise or grant mechanisms, and limited research support at some participants’ home institutions. Conclusion: This study identified key elements of successful grant writing coaching groups and potential barriers to their effectiveness, while yielding insights about tailoring this approach for individuals at different stages of proposal development.
- Open Access
Grant writing coaching groups: A randomized trial to discern the influences of coaching duration and engagement of scientific mentors on participants’ proposal submission and success rates
Introduction: The acquisition of National Institutes of Health (NIH) grants is an increasingly competitive undertaking. Many early-career biomedical investigators lack sufficient grant writing skills. This pragmatic, 2x2 factorial, group-randomized trial tested the effects of coaching duration and mode of engagement of participants’ scientific mentors in a grant writing coaching group intervention on grant application outcomes. Methods: A national US sample of 367 faculty and postdoctoral fellows, organized into 76 coaching groups across 6 cohorts (2020-2022), was randomized to 1 of 4 arms that differed by coaching duration (5 months vs 5 months plus 18 months of access to 1:1 coaching) and mode of scientific mentor engagement (structured vs unstructured). Primary outcomes were national-level grant application submissions and awards, and success rate among submitters, assessed via surveys and verified through award databases 30 months after study initiation. Results: Among 271 faculty and 96 postdoctoral fellows, 69% submitted at least 1 national application and 32% were awarded at least 1 grant. Submission rates did not differ by experimental arm. Among faculty, the structured engagement of a mentor in coaching was associated with significantly higher odds of any award (adjusted OR = 1.87) and any NIH mentored career development (K) award (adjusted OR = 3.32), and with higher success rates for these proposal types. Extended coaching duration showed a positive but not statistically significant association with faculty awards after adjustment. Neither factor significantly affected outcomes for postdoctoral fellows. Faculty success rates exceeded national NIH-reported success rates for research project grants equivalent to the R01 mechanism (43% vs 17.6%) and K awards (51% vs 36.5%). Conclusion: Participation in a national, cross-institutional, group coaching model yielded high grant submission outcomes, and award rates were higher relative to NIH benchmarks. Structured integration of scientific mentors with the coaching intervention had a greater effect than extended coaching duration on faculty outcomes.
Open AccessGrant writing coaching groups: A randomized trial to discern the influences of coaching duration and engagement of scientific mentors on participants’ proposal submission and success rates
Introduction: The acquisition of National Institutes of Health (NIH) grants is an increasingly competitive undertaking. Many early-career biomedical investigators lack sufficient grant writing skills. This pragmatic, 2x2 factorial, group-randomized trial tested the effects of coaching duration and mode of engagement of participants’ scientific mentors in a grant writing coaching group intervention on grant application outcomes. Methods: A national US sample of 367 faculty and postdoctoral fellows, organized into 76 coaching groups across 6 cohorts (2020-2022), was randomized to 1 of 4 arms that differed by coaching duration (5 months vs 5 months plus 18 months of access to 1:1 coaching) and mode of scientific mentor engagement (structured vs unstructured). Primary outcomes were national-level grant application submissions and awards, and success rate among submitters, assessed via surveys and verified through award databases 30 months after study initiation. Results: Among 271 faculty and 96 postdoctoral fellows, 69% submitted at least 1 national application and 32% were awarded at least 1 grant. Submission rates did not differ by experimental arm. Among faculty, the structured engagement of a mentor in coaching was associated with significantly higher odds of any award (adjusted OR = 1.87) and any NIH mentored career development (K) award (adjusted OR = 3.32), and with higher success rates for these proposal types. Extended coaching duration showed a positive but not statistically significant association with faculty awards after adjustment. Neither factor significantly affected outcomes for postdoctoral fellows. Faculty success rates exceeded national NIH-reported success rates for research project grants equivalent to the R01 mechanism (43% vs 17.6%) and K awards (51% vs 36.5%). Conclusion: Participation in a national, cross-institutional, group coaching model yielded high grant submission outcomes, and award rates were higher relative to NIH benchmarks. Structured integration of scientific mentors with the coaching intervention had a greater effect than extended coaching duration on faculty outcomes.
- Open Access
- 9 July 2026
- Published by Society of Teachers of Family Medicine in Family Medicine
- Vol. 58 (7) , 511-515
Piloting the Clinician Scholars Program: Structured Mentoring, Staff Support, and Dedicated Academic Time to Build Family Medicine Research Capacity
Designed as a scholarship pathway for research-curious faculty clinicians in a combined academic family medicine/public health department, the Clinician Scholars Program is a structured engagement between clinicians and research faculty who collaborate on two research projects over 1 to 2 years with support from master-level research staff. The program covers academic time of both the clinician and the research faculty without reduction of salary level, and it provides teams with research funds and dedicated staff effort. Five clinicians completed the 2-year pilot program; outcomes thus far include five manuscripts, one internal grant, and acceptance of one clinician into an institutional 2-year research mentoring program toward the development of a National Institutes of Health career development (K) proposal. Funded in part by a department-level endowment and independent of other institutional and national research pathways programs, the Clinician Scholars Program shows promise in building family medicine research capacity and fostering collaboration between clinicians and research faculty.
- 9 July 2026
- Published by Society of Teachers of Family Medicine in Family Medicine
- Vol. 58 (7) , 511-515
Open AccessPiloting the Clinician Scholars Program: Structured Mentoring, Staff Support, and Dedicated Academic Time to Build Family Medicine Research Capacity
Designed as a scholarship pathway for research-curious faculty clinicians in a combined academic family medicine/public health department, the Clinician Scholars Program is a structured engagement between clinicians and research faculty who collaborate on two research projects over 1 to 2 years with support from master-level research staff. The program covers academic time of both the clinician and the research faculty without reduction of salary level, and it provides teams with research funds and dedicated staff effort. Five clinicians completed the 2-year pilot program; outcomes thus far include five manuscripts, one internal grant, and acceptance of one clinician into an institutional 2-year research mentoring program toward the development of a National Institutes of Health career development (K) proposal. Funded in part by a department-level endowment and independent of other institutional and national research pathways programs, the Clinician Scholars Program shows promise in building family medicine research capacity and fostering collaboration between clinicians and research faculty.
- Open Access
- 22 October 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (10) , e0334039
A randomized trial of grant writing coaching groups: Baseline analysis of early-career scientists’ research background, demographics, and mentorship variables
Introduction: Racial, ethnic, and gender disparities in academic career advancement persist in biomedical disciplines. One approach to addressing this problem is systematizing access to mentorship in critical skills such as grant writing. This report summarizes the baseline characteristics of early-career investigators who enrolled in a randomized trial of a group coaching intervention focused on National Institutes of Health (NIH) grant application development. Methods: Surveys assessed participants’ demographic characteristics, research focus, prior publications and grant submissions, self-efficacy for grantsmanship and career advancement, and access to mentorship. Two-sided t-test and Fisher’s exact test were performed to compare baseline variables by gender identity (male/female) and by background from a racial or ethnic population that is an underrepresented minority group in biomedical research (non-URM/URM). Results: The study sample includes 271 faculty and 96 postdoctoral fellows. Sixty-two percent of faculty and 76.0% of postdoctoral fellows identified as female. Nearly half (45.4% of faculty, 49.0% of postdocs) were from URM populations in biomedical research. At baseline, most were conducting clinical and translational research at institutions with high levels of research activity. Past submission of NIH R-series applications was limited; 29.9% of faculty had submitted K applications. On average, participants had moderate levels of self-efficacy (in grantsmanship and career advancement) and research-related mentoring support. Male and non-URM participants had a higher mean number of previous publications. For the remaining variables, there were no or minimal differences by gender identity and URM status. Conclusions: Early-career investigators from diverse backgrounds are motivated to engage in external grant writing coaching programs regardless of existing mentorship and other supports at their home institutions, suggesting that grant coaching can provide complementary value.
- 22 October 2025
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 20 (10) , e0334039
Open AccessA randomized trial of grant writing coaching groups: Baseline analysis of early-career scientists’ research background, demographics, and mentorship variables
Introduction: Racial, ethnic, and gender disparities in academic career advancement persist in biomedical disciplines. One approach to addressing this problem is systematizing access to mentorship in critical skills such as grant writing. This report summarizes the baseline characteristics of early-career investigators who enrolled in a randomized trial of a group coaching intervention focused on National Institutes of Health (NIH) grant application development. Methods: Surveys assessed participants’ demographic characteristics, research focus, prior publications and grant submissions, self-efficacy for grantsmanship and career advancement, and access to mentorship. Two-sided t-test and Fisher’s exact test were performed to compare baseline variables by gender identity (male/female) and by background from a racial or ethnic population that is an underrepresented minority group in biomedical research (non-URM/URM). Results: The study sample includes 271 faculty and 96 postdoctoral fellows. Sixty-two percent of faculty and 76.0% of postdoctoral fellows identified as female. Nearly half (45.4% of faculty, 49.0% of postdocs) were from URM populations in biomedical research. At baseline, most were conducting clinical and translational research at institutions with high levels of research activity. Past submission of NIH R-series applications was limited; 29.9% of faculty had submitted K applications. On average, participants had moderate levels of self-efficacy (in grantsmanship and career advancement) and research-related mentoring support. Male and non-URM participants had a higher mean number of previous publications. For the remaining variables, there were no or minimal differences by gender identity and URM status. Conclusions: Early-career investigators from diverse backgrounds are motivated to engage in external grant writing coaching programs regardless of existing mentorship and other supports at their home institutions, suggesting that grant coaching can provide complementary value.
- Open Access
- 26 June 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Clinical and Translational Science
- Vol. 9 (1) , e183
Health Equity Leadership and Mentoring (HELM): A health equity-focused early-career development program to promote biomedical workforce diversity
Intentionally enhancing and supporting the early careers of individuals from populations underrepresented in science and medicine (URSM) is essential to achieving health equity. The Health Equity Leadership and Mentoring (HELM) Program at the University of Minnesota and the University of Utah is designed to foster academic excellence and build leadership capacity of postdoctoral fellows, clinical fellows, and early-career faculty who identify as URSM and/or who are committed to careers in health equity research and clinical care. HELM models a culture of psychosocial safety to create a sense of belonging and uses evidence-based and culturally aware mentoring and career development strategies with the goal of retaining diverse faculty. HELM proved agile and adaptive during the Covid-19 pandemic and has been successful in states with and without legislation limiting diversity programs. Across the 2 institutions, the HELM program has supported over 200 trainees and early-career faculty through mid-2024. Among HELM participants who joined the program as faculty, 85%–95% have remained in their faculty positions.
- 26 June 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Clinical and Translational Science
- Vol. 9 (1) , e183
Open AccessHealth Equity Leadership and Mentoring (HELM): A health equity-focused early-career development program to promote biomedical workforce diversity
Intentionally enhancing and supporting the early careers of individuals from populations underrepresented in science and medicine (URSM) is essential to achieving health equity. The Health Equity Leadership and Mentoring (HELM) Program at the University of Minnesota and the University of Utah is designed to foster academic excellence and build leadership capacity of postdoctoral fellows, clinical fellows, and early-career faculty who identify as URSM and/or who are committed to careers in health equity research and clinical care. HELM models a culture of psychosocial safety to create a sense of belonging and uses evidence-based and culturally aware mentoring and career development strategies with the goal of retaining diverse faculty. HELM proved agile and adaptive during the Covid-19 pandemic and has been successful in states with and without legislation limiting diversity programs. Across the 2 institutions, the HELM program has supported over 200 trainees and early-career faculty through mid-2024. Among HELM participants who joined the program as faculty, 85%–95% have remained in their faculty positions.