TVThomas Vaughn

Thomas Vaughn

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Thomas Vaughn has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Healthcare providers’ responses to healthcare delivery reform

    by Huang Huang, George Wehby, Keith Mueller, Dan Shane, Thomas Vaughn, Xi Zhu

    Facing the escalating cost and unsatisfying quality of care, the Accountable Care Organization model was designed to as a remedy for the fragmented US healthcare system. Under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010, CMS established the Medicare Shared Savings Program (MSSP) as an alternative to the traditional Fee-for-Service payment model. However, little empirical evidence exists on the extent to which MSSP changes how participating providers deliver healthcare services. Using a mixture of models aimed at causal inference and national provider-level datasets, I examined MSSP effects on primary care physicians’ (PCP) provision of preventive care, hospital financial sustainability, and nursing homes’ (NHs)’ staffing level and care deficiencies. The first study estimated how MSSP participation affected PCP preventive service delivery. To extends the literature on preventive care and primary care delivery in the context of VBP transition, I utilized a Difference-in-Differences (DD) model comparing within-provider changes over time between participating and non-participating physicians and controlling for demographic and health characteristics of served patients. PCPs who participated in MSSP had an increase in the likelihood and the volume of services delivered for most preventive services included in MSSP quality performance metrics except cancer screening. The second study assessed the impact of hospitals’ participation in MSSP on their financial performance. I used a DD model and an event study design to analyze 2011-2018 hospital cost reports. I found that MSSP participation was associated with small increases in net patient revenue and Medicare revenue share. No significant effects were found on outpatient and inpatient revenue, operating margin, and inpatient revenue share. The third study examined the potential influence of MSSP-affiliation on NH staffing level and deficiency citations. I analyzed the NH Compare data in the national universe of Medicare NHs and relied on the DD model and Instrumental variable approach to provide the causal estimates of MSSP effect. The IV estimates suggest that after MSSP participation, NHs increased registered nursing (RN) staffing but reduced licensed practical nurse staffing, which led to the growth of 2.02 percentage-points of RN in total staffing. NH participation in MSSP was related to an increase of 3 counts in total deficiency citations. This dissertation offers novel evidence on how MSSP may affect healthcare providers and organizations by using a mixture of causal inference models; and it would assist policymakers in understanding healthcare providers’ responses to policy reforms and refining future program design.

  • Work-life balance and the role of self-leadership

    by Ahmed Said Al-Saaidi, Amany Farag, Mary Clark, Jacinda Bunch, Beth Livingston, Thomas Vaughn

    Background Working in hospitals requires nurses to function within less than ideal and stressful circumstances such as shift work, tight schedules, and understaffing. Work stress and life demands have impacted nurses’ ability to maintain a good work-life balance. Research evidence shows that nurses’ poor work-life balance is significantly associated with negative nurse (e.g., emotional exhaustion, mental distress, and poor self-rated health) and organizational outcomes (e.g., poor job satisfaction and high turnover). Despite the importance of work-life balance in nursing, the extent to which the concept has been studied is relatively low. In addition, work-life balance relies on contextual factors such as social environment, culture, and economic status, however, majority of studies were conducted in Western countries. Our understanding of how contextual factors in non-Western countries, such as Oman, is limited. Moreover, most of the available studies are descriptive and focus on examining organizational and personal predictors of work-life balance with limited information about tools that could help nurses achieve the desired balance. Self-leadership, an individual attribute, represents the way by which individuals influence themselves to achieve self-direction and motivation, and could thus play a significant role in shaping how nurses respond to work and life demands and attempt to achieve work-life balance. Study Purpose and Research Questions The two-fold purpose of this quantitative, cross-sectional, correlational study was to: 1) investigate the relationship between work and personal factors and work-life balance among Omani nurses working in Ministry of Health (MOH) institutions, and 2) explore the moderating effect of self-leadership on the relationship between both work and personal factors and work-life balance. The current study was guided by the following research questions: 1) to what extent do nurses’ personal factors explain variance in work-life balance?, 2) to what extent do nurses’ work factors explain variance in work-life balance?, and 3) to what extent does self-leadership moderate the relationships of both work and personal factors to nurses’ work-life balance? Methods A quantitative, cross-sectional, correlational study design was used to investigate work-life balance among nurses working in MOH institutions in Oman. Nurses completed an online questionnaire measuring work-life balance (Valcour’s Satisfaction with work-life balance scale, Carlson’s Work-Family Balance scale, and Greenhaus’s Work-Family Balance scale), self-leadership (Abbreviated Self-Leadership Questionnaire), nursing practice environment (Practice Environment Scale of Nursing Work Index), job demands (Job Demands in Nursing Scale), and job characteristics and personal factors (using investigator developed questions). The three scales measuring work-life balance were combined into two scales labeled as “Satisfaction with work-life balance” and “Actual work-life balance.” Multiple linear regressions were performed for each research question twice using the two work-life balance scales that were identified by the factor analysis. Results The final study sample comprised of 1,741 Omani nurses. The majority of the participants were females (84.4%) and married (85.9%); 59.4% of the participants worked in acute care hospitals while 36.2% worked in primary care institutions and nearly half of the participants worked rotating shifts (53.8%). The overall regression model involving personal factors explained 22% and 8% of the variance in satisfaction with work-life balance and actual work-life balance respectively. The overall regression model involving work factors explained 44% and 23% of the variance in satisfaction with work-life balance and actual work-life balance. Age, using an in-house helper, and satisfaction with support at home were the significant personal predictors of satisfaction with work-life balance and actual work-life balance. Significant work predictors of satisfaction with work-life balance and actual work-life balance included nursing practice environment and job demands. Self-leadership was computed as a moderating variable for personal and work factors with criterion variables satisfaction and actual work-life balance. Regression models involving self-leadership interaction with personal factors explained 33% and 22% of the variance in satisfaction and actual work-life balance respectively; and regression models involving self-leadership interactions with work factors explained 46% and 30% of the variance in satisfaction and actual work-life balance respectively. Conclusion Certain personal and work factors explained the variance in work-life balance among nurses in Oman and self-leadership was found to moderate the relationship between some personal and work factors. Implications for nursing practice include providing nurse mangers with information that can be used to develop initiatives and strategies to improve nurses’ work-life balance and inform the development of work-life friendly policies.

  • Strategies to improve health in rural areas

    by Mochamad Muska Nataliansyah, Xi Zhu, Marcia Ward, Thomas Vaughn, Keith Mueller, Amy Colbert

    Rural Americans face more health disadvantages than those living in urban and suburban areas. The literature on rural health has found that health inequalities between rural and urban populations continue to grow. Healthcare organizations in rural areas face constraints in improving their communities' health due to institutional barriers complicated by cultural and regulatory factors. Robust strategies are needed to strengthen rural health across the care continuum (prevention, treatment, and maintenance). Accordingly, this dissertation explores three potential strategies for improving rural health – community health programs, telehealth, and home health care. The first study examines rural hospitals' motivations to engage in community health programs and discusses their strategies to address community health issues. In rural communities, hospitals are frequently the primary organization with the resources and capabilities to address health issues. This characteristic highlights their potential to be a partner and leader for community health initiatives. We conducted semi-structured interviews with key leaders from four rural hospitals in a Midwest state in the U.S. These hospitals are located in rural counties that have demonstrated progress in creating healthier communities. On-site and telephone interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed. We applied the combination of inductive and deductive qualitative analysis to identify common themes and categories. We identified three categories of motivations that drove rural hospitals' community health improvement efforts: internal values, economic conditions, and social responsibilities. We also identified three categories of strategies that rural hospitals used to address community health issues: building capacity, building relationships, and building programs. Studies have shown the benefits of telehealth service in rural areas. However, there is evidence of limited adoption and utilization. The second study investigates health systems' experience in implementing telehealth services in rural hospital emergency departments (TeleED) and by analyzing factors influencing its implementation and sustainability. We conducted semi-structured interviews with 18 key informants from six health systems (hub sites) that provided TeleED services to 65 rural emergency departments (spoke sites). All used synchronous high-definition video to provide the service. We applied an inductive qualitative analysis approach to identify relevant quotes and themes related to TeleED service uptake facilitators and barriers. We identified three stages of implementation: 1) the start-up stage; 2) the utilization stage; and 3) the sustainment stage. At each stage, we identified emerging factors that can facilitate or impede the process. We categorized these factors into eight domains: 1) strategies; 2) capability; 3) relationships; 4) financials; 5) protocols; 6) environment; 7) service characteristics; and 8) accountability. The third study examines the impact of Certificate of Need (CON) laws on access to and quality of home health care. Home health care has a significant role in the care of Medicare beneficiaries. It can keep the patients at home while receiving efficient post-acute care services, potentially reducing Medicare expenditures. The CON laws can affect home health agencies' accessibility and quality by limiting their number in affected states. We compared the availability, utilization pattern, and quality performance of urban and rural home health agencies in CON states and non-CON states. Findings indicate that CON states have fewer urban and rural home health agencies available for their Medicare population than non-CON states. Furthermore, the results suggest that urban and rural home health agencies in CON states have less utilization in terms of care episodes and visits. The findings also indicated that the CON laws have a mixed effect on home health agencies' quality in urban and rural areas of CON states. The results showed asymmetrical effects across different star-rating quality categories and locations. Also, there is evidence of some quality measures that home health agencies in CON states performed better and poorer than home health agencies in non-CON states.

  • Socioeconomic status and outcomes post-surgery

    by Mehwish Qasim, Bruce Weiss, Thomas Vaughn, George Wehby, Keith Mueller, André Brock

    Compared to wealthy individuals, individuals with low socioeconomic status (SES) often receive health services of lower intensity or quality and have difficulty accessing care. This is particularly true in the area of inpatient surgery. Individuals with low socioeconomic status are often less likely than individuals associated with high socioeconomic status to receive timely surgical care, and less likely than high SES to receive evidence-based treatments for surgical care. Despite these large gaps, there is a lack of consensus whether disparities in surgical outcomes are primarily due to differences in patient characteristics such as acuity or whether they are attributable to disparities in the quality of surgical care among those with access. The overall goal of this dissertation is to illuminate the relationship between socioeconomic status and surgical outcomes. The project aims are: 1) classify trends in post-surgical quality and analyze data on the relationship between socioeconomic status and surgical outcomes; 2) to evaluate whether changes in access to care can eliminate disparities in outcomes by analyzing the impact of the Massachusetts health reform on socioeconomic disparities in inpatient surgery; and 3) to show the potential effects of SES on surgical outcomes by using the Theory of Fundamental Causes. To meet the study objectives, this study proposes to use data from the Nationwide Inpatient Sample (NIS) and the State Inpatient Database (SID). This approach uses socioeconomic information in the NIS and SID that is a quartile classification of the estimated median household income of residents in the patient’s ZIP Code. The outcomes of interest are widely used quality measures: post-surgery mortality and complications at the national level, post-surgical mortality in Massachusetts for select inpatient surgeries, and difference-in-difference estimates. The approach used to identify trends in post-surgical quality uses two analytical software products to analyze the NIS using a regression-based approach. Study findings will identify progress and gaps in the quality of inpatient surgical care over recent years and further determine whether improving access to care through policy design can eliminate or reduce disparities in surgical care outcomes. In the face of health reform, this research will offer important insight into the study of surgical disparities and potential impact following health policy changes such as the expansion of Medicaid, implementation of health insurance exchanges, and the individual mandate requiring individuals to obtain health coverage.

  • Assessment of the relationship between rural location and performance of Patient-Centered Medical Home processes among veterans health administration primary care clinics

    by Michelle Ann Lampman, Marcia M. Ward, Thomas E. Vaughn, Heather S. Reisinger, Mary S Vaughan Sarrazin, Keith J. Mueller

    The Patient-Centered Medical Home (PCMH) is a new model for primary care delivery intended to improve the care experience for both patients and providers, improve the health of populations, and reduce health care costs. Adopting the PCMH model into practice requires considerable investment of time and resources which often act as barriers for many small primary care practices; especially in rural areas. Few studies have examined performance of the PCMH model in rural clinics that have successfully implemented the model. It is important to obtain a comprehensive understanding of how context from the surrounding environment relates to implementation and performance of the model and whether there are differences between rural and urban primary care clinics. This study used a sequential explanatory mixed methods approach to assess differences in performance of the Patient Aligned Care Team (PACT) model between rural and urban primary care clinics within the Veterans Health Administration (VHA). Generalized Estimating Equations with repeated measures were used to estimate associations between rurality and five process-oriented endpoints among a national sample of 891 VHA primary care clinics. Results indicate that, after adjusting for patient characteristics and clinic structural capacity, clinics located in large rural or small/isolated rural areas demonstrated difficulty with enhancing access through use of non-traditional encounters (i.e. telephone visits, group visits, or secured messaging) and facilitating care coordination through post-discharge follow-up compared to urban clinics. Findings also suggest that rural clinics were more likely to struggle to meet system-wide performance standards for these same two PACT-related processes than their urban counterparts. A multiple-case study of five VHA primary care clinics was conducted to obtain a contextual understanding of the relationships between rurality and performance of PACT processes from the perspective of primary care staff engaged in PACT implementation. A comparison of the experiences of staff across the five cases revealed cross-cutting themes that are important to understanding the implementation and performance of PACT-related processes within these clinics. These themes included: both rural and urban clinics experience distance-related barriers; patient preferences and behavior impact performance of PACT-related processes; and primary care clinics experience frequent change. Findings from this qualitative assessment highlight the importance of understanding the unique context and circumstances experienced by each clinic and how they relate to performance and implementation of the PACT model. Insights gained through the qualitative assessment revealed that performance of PACT is influenced by complex relationships with both internal and external context. Combination of both quantitative and qualitative methods provided a more comprehensive understanding of these relationships beyond what could have been learned from a solitary assessment of standardized metrics by gaining additional context directly from the voices of those engaged in PACT care delivery. Identifying differences in PACT performance between rural and urban clinics calls attention to the possibility of unique advantages and challenges for PACTs delivering care to rural patients which need further exploration. Findings from this study contribute to the current understanding of PCMH implementation in rural settings by moving beyond the barriers related to structural capacity to performance of processes aligned with PCMH principles. More widespread implementation of PCMH will require additional attention to the complex relationships between the PCMH and surrounding context in order for primary care practices to successfully implement the model.

  • Transition to home study

    by Kirstin Manges, Greg L. Stewart, Thomas Vaughn, Andrea Wallace, Amany Farag, Patricia Groves, Kathy Clark

    Background: The quality of team-based care impacts patient post-hospitalization outcomes, yet there is a gap in our understanding of how specific team processes impact patient post-hospitalization outcomes. Shared Mental Models (SMMs) is a team process from organizational psychology; it provides an understanding of how providers coordinate complex tasks as a team. SMMs are the team members’ organized knowledge needed for effective team performance. Military research shows that teams with more convergent SMMs have higher performance and better outcomes. In healthcare, patient discharge exemplifies an activity that requires a high level of coordination among interprofessional team members. Two relevant domains of SMMs are Taskwork SMM (team assessment of patient’s readiness for hospital discharge) and Teamwork SMM (quality of day of discharge teamwork). Because of the newness of SMM to healthcare, we lack measures to understand SMMs among interprofessional discharge teams.Study Purpose & Aims: The purpose was to pilot a novel measurement approach assessing SMMs of discharge teams, and explore their relationships to patient 30-day post-hospitalization outcomes (quality of care transition and utilization of unplanned medical services). Aim 1 determined the content and degree of convergence of discharge teams’ SMMs (taskwork and teamwork). Aim 2 examined the relationship between discharge team SMMs and patient post-hospitalization outcomes.Methods: A prospective longitudinal pilot study was used to examine the SMMs of 64 unique discharge events in three inpatient units at a single hospital. Discharge team members independently completed a questionnaire measuring the Teamwork SMM (using the Shared Mental Model Scale) and the Taskwork SMM (using the Discharge Provider-Readiness for Hospital Discharge Scale). Data were collected from the patient 30 days post-discharge to determine the quality of transition (using the Care Transition Measure or CTM-15) and use of unplanned utilization of medical services (unplanned readmission or ED visit). Interrater Agreement (r*wg(j)) was used to determine the SMM convergence (or level of agreement) among the discharge team. The relationship between SMMs and the quality of transition outcome (n = 42) was determined using standard regression analysis. Logistic regression was used determine the relationship of SMMs with utilization of unplanned medical services (n = 56).Results: Overall, discharge teams reported high levels of Taskwork SMMs (M = 8.46, SD =.91) and Taskwork SMM Convergence (M = .90, SD =.10), indicating that the discharge team perceived and agreed that patients had high levels of readiness for hospital discharge. Discharge teams also reported having high-quality Teamwork SMMs (M = 6.11, SD = 0.39) and Teamwork SMM Convergence (M = .85, SD = .10), suggesting that most discharge teams perceived and agreed that high quality teamwork was provided during the discharge process. Discharge events from the three inpatient units significantly differed in their Teamwork and Teamwork SMM content and convergence scores. Discharge teams’ Teamwork SMMs and Taskwork SMMs were positively associated with the CTM-15 score, while controlling for key contextual factors (t = 3.94, p = .001; t = 3.94, p = .001, respectively).Conclusion : Discharge teams’ Taskwork SMM and Teamwork SMM was positively associated with patient-reported quality of transition from the hospital. There was insufficient evidence to support that utilization of unplanned medical services is related to discharge teams’ SMMs. Measuring the SMMs of the discharge team provides a method for assessing a team process critical to safe patient discharges.

  • Implementing TeamSTEPPS in small rural hospitals

    by Jure Baloh, Xi Zhu, Greg L. Stewart, Tanya Uden-Holman, Thomas E. Vaughn, Marcia M. Ward

    Hospital personnel are commonly tasked with implementing innovative and evidence-based practices. However, successes are often limited and short-lived. One likely explanation is that implementation processes vary between sites, leading to differences in implementation outcomes. In this dissertation, I built on the organizational and implementation science literatures to improve our understanding of implementation processes and how they unfolded in small, rural hospitals in Iowa. I adopted two theoretical perspectives – process and variance models. Process models explain change as a series of steps or phases that organizations go through when implementing changes, while variance models explain variation in change outcomes as a relationship between variables. More specifically, I examined Kotter’s process model of change and tested the proposition that performance on earlier steps influences performance on subsequent steps. I then built on the literature on the Promoting Action on Research Implementation in Health Services (PARIHS) framework to examine the implementation processes from the variance model perspective. I first developed a typology of internal facilitation activities that hospital change agents engaged in throughout the implementation process, and then built on organizational implementation models to assess the influence of management support, time availability and team viability on sustainment and non-sustainment of facilitation activities. This study was based on a qualitative longitudinal evaluation of TeamSTEPPS implementation in critical access hospitals in Iowa. Our research team recruited 17 hospitals attending TeamSTEPPS Master Training in 2011, 2012 and 2013 and followed them for a period of two years, interviewing key informants quarterly to inquire about their goals, strategies and activities, barriers and facilitators, and the progress they were making. My analytic samples for the dissertation included 8-10 hospitals and varied depending on the research questions. For each construct, a group of student coders read and coded the interview transcripts (two coders per transcript) using both inductive and deductive coding approaches. The coded content was reviewed and disagreements discussed in a group meeting until differences have been resolved. To examine the Kotter model, hospitals were scored on their performance on the three phases, which allowed for assessing whether their performance was consistent across the three phases as the model proposes. To develop the typology of facilitation activities, I compared and contrasted the different types of activities to identify the characteristics that distinguish them. To test sustainment of facilitation activities, I used the fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis method to calibrate and test the relationships using set-theoretic methods. As needed, I also qualitatively re-examined the cases to identify exemplar cases or identify additional factors that helped develop our understanding of the implementation processes. I found that the Kotter model helped explain the implementation processes in half the hospitals, while the other hospitals followed different trajectories, depending on implementation scope. Next, four types of facilitation activities were identified – Leadership, Buy-in, Customization and Accountability. They are distinguished by who engaged in the activities, what or whom they targeted, and the timing patterns of the activities. I also found that facilitation activities were sustained in hospitals with both senior and middle manager support and whose facilitator team remained viable throughout the implementation process. These findings contributed to our understanding of implementation processes. Individual findings and their implications were discussed. Overall, both process and variance model perspectives provide useful but different insights into implementation processes. I concluded that both perspectives are needed to inform practice and future research.

  • Improving care delivery in critical access hospitals

    by Nabil M. Natafgi, Marcia M. Ward, Keith J. Mueller, Tanya Uden-Holman, Thomas E. Vaughn, Xi Zhu

    Critical Access Hospitals (CAHs) – the predominant type of hospital operating in rural areas – play an integral role in the US healthcare system, providing care for over 7 million rural residents each year who might otherwise have no local access to urgent care or inpatient services. This dissertation examines three aspects of care delivery in CAHs – effectiveness, cost/efficiency, and access – each of which has separate implications for policy and practice. The first study addresses effectiveness and evaluates the performance of CAHs on specific patient safety indicators compared to small Prospective Payment System (PPS) hospitals. A total of 35,674 discharges from 136 non-federal general hospitals with fewer than 50 beds were included in the analyses: 14,296 from 100 CAHs and 21,378 from 36 PPS hospitals. Outcome measures included six bivariate indicators of adverse events of surgical care that were developed from Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Patient Safety Indicators. Multiple logistic regression models were developed to examine the relationship between hospital adverse events and CAH status. The results indicated that compared to PPS hospitals, CAHs are less likely to have any observed (unadjusted) adverse event on all six indicators, four of which are statistically significant. After adjusting for patient mix and hospital characteristics, CAHs perform better on three of the six indicators. Accounting for the number of discharges eliminated the differences between CAHs and PPS hospitals in the likelihood of adverse events across all indicators except one. Tele-emergency (tele-ED) services can address several challenges facing emergency departments (EDs) in rural areas. The second study investigates access and characterizes the impact of a rural-ED-based telemedicine program on discharge disposition in terms of patient transfer, local hospital admission, and routine discharge. This study tests the hypothesis that telemedicine enhances access by allowing patients to receive care in the local community, and does so by looking at the probability of transfer and local admissions before and after telemedicine was implemented in CAHs. The results indicate that in the post-telemedicine period, patients were 38% less likely to be admitted to the local inpatient facility than to be routinely discharged [aOR=0.62, 95%CI=(0.57,0.67)] after adjusting for age, sex, race, time of visit, clinical diagnosis, CPT code, number of diagnoses, and admitting hospital. The third study addresses cost and efficiency by modeling the financial implications of using the same telemedicine program to avoid transfers and estimating the costs and benefits associated with tele-ED implementation in CAHs. Analysis is based on 9,048 tele-ED encounters generated by the Avera eEmergency program in 85 rural hospitals across seven states between October 2009 and February 2014. For each non-transfer patient, physicians indicated whether the transfer was avoided because of tele-ED activation. The cost-benefit analysis is conducted from the hospital, patient, and societal perspectives, and includes technology costs, local hospital revenues, and patient-associated savings. The results show that 1,175 avoided transfers could be attributed to tele-ED. From a rural hospital perspective, tele-ED costs around $1,739 to avoid a single transfer but saves approximately $5,563 in avoided transportation and indirect patient costs. From a societal perspective, tele-ED results in a net savings of $3,823 per avoided transfer while accounting for tele-ED technology costs, hospital revenues, and patient-associated savings. This study highlights various stakeholder perspectives on the financial impact of tele-ED in avoiding patient transfers in rural EDs. Telemedicine has the potential to reduce the number of transfers of ED patients and generate some revenue for rural hospitals despite associated technology costs, while incurring substantial patient savings.