Bo An
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Bo An has a total of 29 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Yongqiang Yu
State Key Laboratory of Earth System Numerical Modeling and Application, Institute of Atmospheric Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China
10 shared publications Hai Zhi
State Key Laboratory of Climate System Prediction and Risk Management/Key Laboratory of Meteorological Disaster, Ministry of Education/Collaborative Innovation Center on Forecast and Evaluation of Meteorological Disasters, Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology, Nanjing 210044, China
8 shared publicationsJiuwei Zhao
State Key Laboratory of Climate System Prediction and Risk Management/Key Laboratory of Meteorological Disaster, Ministry of Education/Collaborative Innovation Center on Forecast and Evaluation of Meteorological Disasters, Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology, Nanjing 210044, China
8 shared publications- Lin Chen
State Key Laboratory of Climate System Prediction and Risk Management/Key Laboratory of Meteorological Disaster, Ministry of Education/Collaborative Innovation Center on Forecast and Evaluation of Meteorological Disasters, Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology, Nanjing, China
8 shared publications Meng-Er Song
State Key Laboratory of Climate System Prediction and Risk Management/Key Laboratory of Meteorological Disaster, Ministry of Education/Collaborative Innovation Center on Forecast and Evaluation of Meteorological Disasters, Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology, Nanjing 210044, China
8 shared publications- Adam Tobias Blaker
National Oceanography Centre, Southampton, United Kingdom
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 September 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Oceans
- Vol. 131 (10)
Impact of Model Resolution on Antarctic Bottom Water Representation in Coupled Climate Models
Antarctic Bottom Water (AABW) formation plays a crucial role in the climate system by driving the lower branch of the global overturning circulation, redistributing heat and salt, storing anthropogenic carbon dioxide, and delivering oxygen to the deep ocean. However, the representation of AABW formation in most climate models remains inadequate, since coarse spatial resolution fails to capture the intense ocean‐ice‐atmospheric interactions in a few small areas around the Antarctic continental shelf. This study evaluates the impact of model resolution on AABW simulations, using three climate models from the High Resolution Model Intercomparison Project (HighResMIP). By comparing the climatological mean state and projected changes of AABW in both low‐ and high‐resolution simulations, we find that climate models with approximately 4 km resolution better capture AABW formation and export processes along the Antarctic continental shelf than their lower‐resolution counterparts. High‐resolution climate models also project more pronounced future AABW changes than low‐resolution models. However, spurious AABW formation through open‐ocean deep convection becomes more prevalent in two of the three high‐resolution models, and thus the overall property biases in these models remain comparable to those in the low‐resolution models. Our results advance the understanding of how climate model resolution affects climate simulations and offer insights into the progress and challenges in representing AABW in climate models.
- 28 September 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research: Oceans
- Vol. 131 (10)
Open AccessImpact of Model Resolution on Antarctic Bottom Water Representation in Coupled Climate Models
Antarctic Bottom Water (AABW) formation plays a crucial role in the climate system by driving the lower branch of the global overturning circulation, redistributing heat and salt, storing anthropogenic carbon dioxide, and delivering oxygen to the deep ocean. However, the representation of AABW formation in most climate models remains inadequate, since coarse spatial resolution fails to capture the intense ocean‐ice‐atmospheric interactions in a few small areas around the Antarctic continental shelf. This study evaluates the impact of model resolution on AABW simulations, using three climate models from the High Resolution Model Intercomparison Project (HighResMIP). By comparing the climatological mean state and projected changes of AABW in both low‐ and high‐resolution simulations, we find that climate models with approximately 4 km resolution better capture AABW formation and export processes along the Antarctic continental shelf than their lower‐resolution counterparts. High‐resolution climate models also project more pronounced future AABW changes than low‐resolution models. However, spurious AABW formation through open‐ocean deep convection becomes more prevalent in two of the three high‐resolution models, and thus the overall property biases in these models remain comparable to those in the low‐resolution models. Our results advance the understanding of how climate model resolution affects climate simulations and offer insights into the progress and challenges in representing AABW in climate models.
- Open Access
- 2 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (11) , 4725-4747
Process-based evaluation of ENSO simulation sensitivity to horizontal resolution in the Chinese Academy of Sciences FGOALS-f3 Climate System Model
The El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent mode of interannual climate variability; its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the climate model performance; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behavior in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (∼100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (∼25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation irregularity, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution version severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The weak stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of the FGOALS model family.
- 2 June 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Geoscientific Model Development
- Vol. 19 (11) , 4725-4747
Open AccessProcess-based evaluation of ENSO simulation sensitivity to horizontal resolution in the Chinese Academy of Sciences FGOALS-f3 Climate System Model
The El Niño–Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent mode of interannual climate variability; its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the climate model performance; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behavior in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (∼100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (∼25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation irregularity, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution version severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The weak stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of the FGOALS model family.
- Open Access
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Reply on RC2
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Open AccessReply on RC2
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- Open Access
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Reply on RC1
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Open AccessReply on RC1
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- Open Access
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Reply on EC1
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Open AccessReply on EC1
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- Open Access
- 20 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Comment on egusphere-2025-6017
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- 20 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-6017
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- Open Access
- 21 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Comment on egusphere-2025-6017
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- 21 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-6017
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- Open Access
- 15 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Comment on egusphere-2025-6017
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- 15 February 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2025-6017
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- Open Access
- 21 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Process-based evaluation of ENSO simulation sensitivity to horizontal resolution in the Chinese Academy of Sciences FGOALS-f3 Climate System Model
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- 21 January 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-39
Open AccessProcess-based evaluation of ENSO simulation sensitivity to horizontal resolution in the Chinese Academy of Sciences FGOALS-f3 Climate System Model
El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the most prominent interannual climate variability, hence its simulation performance represents a critical benchmark for evaluating the fidelity of coupled climate models. Increasing model resolution is an effective approach to improve the model simulation; however, the impact of refining horizontal resolution from the hundred-kilometer scale to the tens-of-kilometer scale on ENSO simulation, as well as the underlying mechanisms, remains unclear. This study provides a process-based evaluation of ENSO behaviour in two versions of the Chinese Academy of Sciences Flexible Global Ocean–Atmosphere–Land System Finite-Volume version 3 (FGOALS-f3) climate system model: a low-resolution configuration (~100 km; FGOALS-f3-L, hereafter f3-L) and a high-resolution configuration (~25 km; FGOALS-f3-H, hereafter f3-H). Using a reproducible diagnostic framework, we assess how horizontal resolution influences ENSO amplitude, oscillation characteristics, key air–sea coupling processes, and high-frequency (HF) atmospheric variability. The low-resolution severely overestimates ENSO amplitude, whereas f3-H produces amplitude closer to the observation. Process-based diagnostics show that this improvement arises from the more realistic representation of thermocline and zonal advection feedback processes in f3-H, which arises from the more realistic representation of the meridional structure of ENSO-related zonal wind stress anomalies over equatorial Pacific in f3-H and can be traced back to its improved horizontal resolution. The ENSO cycle in f3-L exhibits excessive regularity, featuring periodic warm-cold transitions; while f3-H reproduces an irregular oscillation resembling the observation. The excessive regularity in f3-L is attributed to its coarser resolution, which limits the simulation performance of tropical cyclones and consequently weakens high-frequency westerly wind activity over the tropical Pacific. The feeble stochastic forcing in f3-L is insufficient to disrupt its overly intense ENSO cycle, yielding an overly regular oscillation. By identifying the structural sources of ENSO biases across resolutions, this study provides a reproducible and model-agnostic framework for diagnosing resolution effects on ENSO performance in climate models and informs future development of FGOALS-f3 model family.
- 31 October 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Ocean Modelling
- Vol. 199
Local effect of a submesoscale parameterization scheme and its remote influences on large-scale circulation in the Northwest Pacific
- 31 October 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Ocean Modelling
- Vol. 199
Local effect of a submesoscale parameterization scheme and its remote influences on large-scale circulation in the Northwest Pacific