CDChantsalmaa Dalkhaa

Chantsalmaa Dalkhaa

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Chantsalmaa Dalkhaa has a total of 49 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Williston basin associated co2 storage field laboratory

    by Steven Smith, Grand Forks Univ. Of North Dakota, Trevor Richards, Neil Dotzenrod, Nidhal Badrouchi, Don Adams, Nicholas Azzolina, Ailin Assady, Chantsalmaa Dalkhaa, Stephen Guillot, et al.

    The Williston Basin Associated CO2 Storage Field Laboratory (WBCFL), led by the Energy & Environmental Research Center (EERC) in partnership with Denbury (now ExxonMobil), was established to advance understanding of CO2 enhanced oil recovery (EOR) and associated geologic CO2 storage in the Williston Basin. The specific objective of the WBCFL was to conduct field and laboratory activities to inform decisionmakers regarding the 1) efficacy of associated storage in stacked geologic reservoirs during EOR operations; 2) CO2 injectivity, oil production, and storage in residual oil zones (ROZs); 3) use of a novel CO2 storage monitoring, verification, and accounting (MVA) technology (active seismoelectric [ASE] monitoring), and 4) life cycle and techno-economic factors for EOR development scenarios targeting ROZs. The project location was the Pennel Field in southeast Montana, which is part of the Cedar Creek Anticline (CCA) geologic structure within the Williston Basin. The field was selected because it was being developed by Denbury for tertiary-phase CO2 EOR targeting the Red River Formation, and the availability of CO2, which was being supplied by the Greencore Pipeline, offered opportunities to evaluate the EOR potential of the other oil-bearing formations within the structure. The focus of this project was a vertically stacked reservoir system, including the Interlake Formation, a complex carbonate interval with both main pay zones (MPZs) and underlying ROZs. ROZs are oil-bearing zones that have been naturally waterflooded and, while they often contain moderate oil saturations, they cannot be economically produced using conventional primary or secondary recovery. However, CO2 EOR of ROZs in the Permian Basin have been successful, as the injected CO2 can mobilize oil trapped in the reservoir by swelling the oil, reducing oil viscosity, and achieving miscibility under reservoir conditions. The initial project activities focused on data collection and preparation of the field demonstration within the Pennel Field. Denbury drilled, logged, and cored a new well, 23-18B, as a CO2 injector paired with a nearby production well, 13-18B. Samples were collected from the field location, including rock, brine, and oil samples, for subsequent analysis at the EERC and to support the laboratory testing, geomodelling, and reservoir simulation components of the project. Comprehensive laboratory analyses were performed to characterize produced oil and brine, evaluate CO2–oil miscibility, and measure interfacial tension and contact angles at reservoir temperature and pressure. Results showed that Interlake oils achieve miscibility with CO2 at approximately 2600–2800 psi, indicating potential suitability for CO2 EOR. Brine and carbonatedbrine testing highlighted modest but measurable changes in interfacial properties, while contact angle measurements indicated predominantly water-wet rock—an important condition that can strongly influence CO2 storage and oil displacement behavior. These laboratory results were integrated into a geologic model of the Pennel Field, constructed from well logs, core data, structural horizons, and petrophysical properties. The Interlake Formation model was subdivided into six depositional cycles that capture heterogeneity between the MPZ and ROZ intervals. A 1-sq-mi dynamic reservoir simulation model was vii developed from this geologic framework, incorporating five producing wells and the drilled injection well. Historical well performance, including more than five decades of production, was used to history-match reservoir behavior and calibrate the simulation model. Using the calibrated simulation model, the EERC evaluated three CO2 injection strategies: continuous CO2 injection, a 1:1 water alternating gas (WAG) scheme, and a tapered WAG schedule designed to reduce early gas breakthrough. Across all strategies, CO2 injection increased oil production relative to primary depletion, including meaningful contributions from the ROZ. The tapered WAG strategy produced the highest incremental oil recovery and the most efficient CO2 utilization, aided by improved reservoir pressure support and reduced early gas migration toward producers. Notably, Well 22-18B, located farther from the injector and historically more productive, significantly outperformed the closer 13-18B, both in projected incremental oil and in CO2 storage amount. Simulations suggested that developing CO2 EOR in the 1-sq-mi area of interest in the Interlake MPZ/ROZ system could yield 34,000–54,000 barrels of incremental oil at 13-18B and 181,000–217,000 barrels at 22-18B over the 5- and 6-year modeled injection periods. Associated CO2 storage ranged from 80,000 to over 190,000 tonnes, depending on the case, with WAG strategies storing a larger fraction of the injected CO2. These high storage rates reflect the strong retention characteristics of carbonate ROZs and their compatibility with miscible CO2 flooding. Dimensionless curve analysis was used to extend these simulation results to 15 years, enabling long-term projections for economic and life cycle analysis (LCA). A screening-level LCA and techno-economic analysis evaluated the environmental and economic impacts of each EOR scenario, integrating simulation-based forecasts of oil production, recycled CO2, and long-term storage. Results emphasized that CO2 EOR—particularly tapered WAG—can provide substantial net storage while increasing oil recovery, producing favorable CO₂ storage per barrel, and strengthening alignment with federal incentives such as the Section 45Q tax credit. The stacked-storage development concept, targeting both MPZ and ROZ horizons together, offers a pathway for maximizing combined resource recovery and geologic CO2 containment at legacy oil fields. To explore the feasibility of cost-effective monitoring strategies, the project deployed a baseline active seismoelectric survey—a method...

  • Wyoming CarbonSAFE Phase III: Site Characterization and Permitting Commercial-Scale Carbon Storage Complex Feasibility Study at Dry Fork Station, Wyoming

    by Tao Bai, Laramie Univ. Of Wyoming, Trihydro, Carbon GeoCycle, Sarah Buckhold, Daniel Cooley, Autumn Eakin, Daniel Eakin, Scarlett Forrest, Yuri Ganshin, et al.

    This report presents the findings of the technical and non-technical site characterization and permitting activities (“Phase III”) conducted under the Wyoming CarbonSAFE: Accelerating CCUS Commercialization and Deployment at Dry Fork Power Station (DFS) and the Wyoming Integrated Test Center project (“Wyoming CarbonSAFE”). Wyoming CarbonSAFE is part of the U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) Carbon Storage Assurance Facility Enterprise (“CarbonSAFE”) Initiative. The results of Phase III demonstrate that the Wyoming CarbonSAFE project - referred to as the Northern Powder River Basin Carbon Sequestration Hub (NPRB-CSH) - meets the technical, regulatory, and commercial feasibility requirements necessary to advance toward commercial development and construction. The activities completed under this project Phase make the NPRB-CSH one of the region’s most commercially ready carbon storage sites. Completion of this Phase included the finalization of all site surface and subsurface characterization activities, completion and testing of two Class VI standard wells, 10 draft Class VI permits-to construct to address the future needs of a storage complex, finalized NEPA assessments, transportation and capture FEED studies, and a full commercialization strategy with economic modeling, operation and site closure strategies. The NPRB-CSH meets all requirements to progress to a CarbonSAFE Phase IV program or advance to full commercial operations under the development of a business partner.

  • Open Access

    Williston Basin Resource Study for Commercial-Scale Subsurface Hydrogen Storage

    by Usdoe, Chantsalmaa Dalkhaa, Lu Jin, Shane K. Butler, Matthew E. Burton-Kelly, Neil W. Dotzenrod, Steven A. Smith, Kerryanne M. Leroux, Kirk D. Williams

    The Energy & Environmental Research Center (EERC), in partnership with the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL), the EERC’s State Energy Research Center (SERC), MPLX Operations LLC, and TC Energy Development Holdings Inc. (a subsidiary of TC Energy Corporation), studied the potential for subsurface hydrogen storage and recovery in the Williston Basin of western North Dakota. The project’s goal was to evaluate the feasibility of large-scale, secure geologic H2 storage to support future hydrogen generation, storage, and use. This work included laboratory testing, H2–rock–fluid exposure experiments, literature reviews on H2 embrittlement, and reservoir modeling and simulations. The study included an assessment of storage potential across three types of storage reservoirs using both reservoir simulation and DOE’s web-based tool SHASTA-HELP (Subsurface Hydrogen Assessment, Storage, and Technology Acceleration – Hydrogen Estimator for Logistical Planning), as well as investigation of potential H2 production and markets for commercial-scale deployment. Building on prior EERC gas storage research, three storage options were selected for detailed evaluation: the Broom Creek Formation (a clastic saline reservoir), the Dickinson Lodgepole Mounds (DLM) complex (carbonate mud mound structures) of the Lodgepole Formation (an active oil and gas producing reservoir), and the Dunham Salt Interval of the Piper Formation (to be used for engineered salt cavern development). These targets were prioritized based on prior EERC research using datasets related to seal capacity, reservoir quality, mechanical integrity, and injectivity. Exposure tests on Broom Creek and DLM samples showed mineral dissolution and precipitation that increased brine salinity and altered reservoir rock surfaces. Although these results provide useful insight, they are limited by small sample sizes and short-term (30-day) exposure, requiring further study to assess long-term storage integrity. Salt formations were not tested because of their known nonreactivity and established mechanical stability. Results of reservoir simulations performed for a single site demonstrated that the Broom Creek Formation may be capable of receiving up to 42,000 tonnes of injected H2 over 7 months via one well. H2 recovery took place over 5 months, resulting in approximately 26,000 tonnes (~62% without cushion gas [CG]). This work suggests water production may be important and subsequent cycles of injection and production may perform more efficiently; however, significant site-specific work in the future is needed to assess actual reservoir performance of injection and withdrawal of H2 storage. For oil reservoir potential, a multiple-well model was used to simulate injection of approximately 32,000 tonnes of H2 into a single wellbore while simultaneously producing in place reservoir fluids from four offset wells to maintain reservoir pressure. The simulation results suggested a high recovery (~98%); in addition, cost advantages through existing infrastructure could be realized. Challenges in this reservoir include vi managing gas purity and leakage risks. In both scenarios, production of H2 takes place in a single-well scenario with 10 cycles (7 months of injection and 5 months of production) over 10 years. Finally, the use of engineered caverns in the Dunhan Salt was evaluated, and the results suggest that while they have a smaller capacity (99%), fast response times, and low purity risk. While caverns in North Dakota may be smaller in capacity, fields can be developed in galleries to accommodate the volumetric needs and rapid turnaround times necessary to meet market demands. Geographic limitations and thin salt intervals in North Dakota may represent less total storage potential than salt domes elsewhere, but significant opportunities exist to expand this market for gas storage in North Dakota. A basinwide assessment was performed to estimate a first-of-its-kind value for H2 storage on a large scale. DOE’s SHASTA-HELP, combined with EERC simulation work, was used to perform the assessment. Estimated H2 storage potential varied widely for each formation type. The Broom Creek saline formation was estimated to have a storage potential of approximately 1.7–90.5 million tonnes (MMt). The DLM oil reservoirs were estimated to have 0.07–0.19 MMt of capacity. Notably, each of these estimates relies on significant assumptions regarding reservoir thickness, porosity, permeability, and CG needed for operation. Much research is needed to understand the true site-specific storage resource potential of each formation. Using the Dunham Salt Interval for cavern development may result in as much as 4.79 MMt (up to 2.87 MMt working gas) of H2 storage potential. An important note for consideration is that the values presented here need significantly more geological characterization and engineering assessments prior to gaining confidence in performance. This will be a focal point for future research and development needs. The basinwide evaluation also indicated that North Dakota has significant H2 generation potential, with estimates up to a possible 13 MMt annually, suggesting a substantial opportunity for H2 market development and thus the need for commercial-scale H2 storage to facilitate growth and resilience. Key Recommendations 1. Conduct detailed site characterization (3D seismic, well logs, core sampling) to reduce geologic uncertainty. 2. Perform techno-economic analyses incorporating market, regulatory, and incentive frameworks. 3. Investigate long-term interactions among H2, CGs, well materials, and formations to assess risks. 4. Develop pilot- and field-scale demonstrations to validate models and establish best practices.

  • Open Access

    Subsurface H2 Storage: A Williston Basin Commercial-Scale Resource Study

    by Chantsalmaa Dalkhaa, North Dakota Industrial Commission, Kerryanne M. Leroux, Shane K. Butler, Lu Jin, Matthew E. Burton-Kelly, Kirk D. Williams, Steven A. Smith

    Poster for the 2024 NETL Resource Sustainability Project Review Meeting, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, April 2-4, 2024. This poster presents a commercial‑scale assessment of subsurface hydrogen storage potential in the North Dakota portion of the Williston Basin, evaluating saline formations, depleted oil and gas reservoirs, and salt formations. The study integrates laboratory characterization, reservoir simulation, and basinwide analysis to assess storage capacity, injectivity, recovery, and risks related to geochemical, microbial, and wellbore interactions. Results support the feasibility of large‑volume, secure hydrogen storage and provide a framework to guide future hydrogen commercialization and infrastructure development.