İbRahim Delen
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
İbRahim Delen has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Bora Şenceylan
Istanbul Technical University
2 shared publications - Fatma Özüdoğru
Usak Universitesi
2 shared publications - Gökhan Ince
Istanbul Technical University
2 shared publications - Ayten Baykal1 shared publication
- Eceay Çeltik
Istanbul Technical University
1 shared publication - Michele Biasutti
University of Padova
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 2 September 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 16 (9) , 1420
Beyond Acceptance: How Early Childhood Preservice Teachers Critically Engage with GenAI Feedback in Lesson Planning
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is being investigated as a pedagogical tool in early childhood education, particularly for lesson planning and professional learning. This study examined preservice teachers’ reflections on GenAI-generated feedback during sustainability focused lesson planning. Fifty preservice teachers were involved in developing two lesson plans, receiving GenAI feedback, and revising their plans. Data collection included written reflections about two lesson plans. During the study, preservice teachers worked in 25 pairs, producing 25 lesson plans in each cycle. In total, the study analyzed 50 pair-authored reflections. These reflections were analyzed qualitatively to identify responses to GenAI feedback. Findings revealed that while GenAI feedback encouraged preservice teachers to reconsider lesson content and teaching strategies, they seldom accepted GenAI recommendations outright. Instead, they critically evaluated feedback, often modifying or discarding suggestions that did not align with developmental appropriateness or classroom realities. The study illustrates the value of GenAI engagement in supporting reflective decision-making among preservice teachers. It also underscores the importance of preparing future educators to leverage GenAI as a complement to professional reasoning, fostering critical thinking and contextual instructional design rather than replacing it.
- 2 September 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 16 (9) , 1420
Open AccessBeyond Acceptance: How Early Childhood Preservice Teachers Critically Engage with GenAI Feedback in Lesson Planning
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is being investigated as a pedagogical tool in early childhood education, particularly for lesson planning and professional learning. This study examined preservice teachers’ reflections on GenAI-generated feedback during sustainability focused lesson planning. Fifty preservice teachers were involved in developing two lesson plans, receiving GenAI feedback, and revising their plans. Data collection included written reflections about two lesson plans. During the study, preservice teachers worked in 25 pairs, producing 25 lesson plans in each cycle. In total, the study analyzed 50 pair-authored reflections. These reflections were analyzed qualitatively to identify responses to GenAI feedback. Findings revealed that while GenAI feedback encouraged preservice teachers to reconsider lesson content and teaching strategies, they seldom accepted GenAI recommendations outright. Instead, they critically evaluated feedback, often modifying or discarding suggestions that did not align with developmental appropriateness or classroom realities. The study illustrates the value of GenAI engagement in supporting reflective decision-making among preservice teachers. It also underscores the importance of preparing future educators to leverage GenAI as a complement to professional reasoning, fostering critical thinking and contextual instructional design rather than replacing it.
- Open Access
- 11 August 2026
- Published by UK Scientific Publishing Limited in Journal of Qualitative Research in Education
- No. 48,p. 19-34
From AI-Generated Student Analytics to Teacher Trust: Evidence from a Longitudinal Classroom Case Study
This case study examined how teacher trust in student analytics could be built when using Artificial Intelligence (AI) generated assessment. The case study included two data sources: (i) teacher evaluations of AI-generated student reports and (ii) a semi-structured interview with a science teacher who used the system in their classroom for three semesters (first pilot semester and two semesters of implementation). The teacher demonstrated an agreement rate exceeding 80% with Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) generated reports. However, the teacher also stated that she expected the reports to not only describe student characteristics but also provide actionable pedagogical recommendations to support the teaching process. In conclusion, the study provided evidence that the teacher trust in GenAI based student analytics could be developed as the teacher adopts AI based practices in her classroom. When GenAI tools are implemented for a longer period, they have potential to build trust underlined by other studies. Including GenAI represented students' learning characteristics and replicated it consistently across different students. The findings indicate that GenAI-supported learning analytics systems to be developed in the future should be designed not only as tools to describe student behavior, but also as explainable and pedagogical decision support systems that support teachers' professional judgment.
- 11 August 2026
- Published by UK Scientific Publishing Limited in Journal of Qualitative Research in Education
- No. 48,p. 19-34
Open AccessFrom AI-Generated Student Analytics to Teacher Trust: Evidence from a Longitudinal Classroom Case Study
This case study examined how teacher trust in student analytics could be built when using Artificial Intelligence (AI) generated assessment. The case study included two data sources: (i) teacher evaluations of AI-generated student reports and (ii) a semi-structured interview with a science teacher who used the system in their classroom for three semesters (first pilot semester and two semesters of implementation). The teacher demonstrated an agreement rate exceeding 80% with Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) generated reports. However, the teacher also stated that she expected the reports to not only describe student characteristics but also provide actionable pedagogical recommendations to support the teaching process. In conclusion, the study provided evidence that the teacher trust in GenAI based student analytics could be developed as the teacher adopts AI based practices in her classroom. When GenAI tools are implemented for a longer period, they have potential to build trust underlined by other studies. Including GenAI represented students' learning characteristics and replicated it consistently across different students. The findings indicate that GenAI-supported learning analytics systems to be developed in the future should be designed not only as tools to describe student behavior, but also as explainable and pedagogical decision support systems that support teachers' professional judgment.
- 27 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 469-478
Automated Evaluation of Student-Chatbot Interactions in Climate Education Using Large Language Models
- 27 June 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 469-478
Automated Evaluation of Student-Chatbot Interactions in Climate Education Using Large Language Models
- Open Access
- 1 February 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 18 (3) , 1437
The Impact of Out-of-School Learning on Academic Achievement in Elementary and Secondary Education: A Meta-Analysis
Students’ learning experiences are typically confined to structured classroom environments, although out-of-school learning offers opportunities to extend and enrich academic development. Despite growing interest in this field, no prior meta-analysis has systematically examined how different out-of-school settings influence student achievement across disciplines and educational levels. This study addresses that gap through a meta-analysis of 42 peer-reviewed studies comprising 54 effect sizes following PRISMA guidelines. Overall, out-of-school learning had a statistically significant, medium-to-large effect ( = 0.529). Moderator analyses indicated that the effectiveness of out-of-school learning varied by educational level, disciplinary focus, geographical context, and study design, with stronger effects generally observed in elementary education, and science and social sciences. These findings highlight the context-dependent nature of out-of-school learning and underscore the importance of instructional alignment and implementation quality. The results also confirmed the lack of consistency in planning and assessing the outcomes of out-of-school learning. Investigating variations across disciplines and the decline among school levels would be beneficial for future studies.- 1 February 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 18 (3) , 1437
Open AccessThe Impact of Out-of-School Learning on Academic Achievement in Elementary and Secondary Education: A Meta-Analysis
Students’ learning experiences are typically confined to structured classroom environments, although out-of-school learning offers opportunities to extend and enrich academic development. Despite growing interest in this field, no prior meta-analysis has systematically examined how different out-of-school settings influence student achievement across disciplines and educational levels. This study addresses that gap through a meta-analysis of 42 peer-reviewed studies comprising 54 effect sizes following PRISMA guidelines. Overall, out-of-school learning had a statistically significant, medium-to-large effect ( = 0.529). Moderator analyses indicated that the effectiveness of out-of-school learning varied by educational level, disciplinary focus, geographical context, and study design, with stronger effects generally observed in elementary education, and science and social sciences. These findings highlight the context-dependent nature of out-of-school learning and underscore the importance of instructional alignment and implementation quality. The results also confirmed the lack of consistency in planning and assessing the outcomes of out-of-school learning. Investigating variations across disciplines and the decline among school levels would be beneficial for future studies.