HSHishma Shah

Hishma Shah

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Hishma Shah has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Protocol for the Extraction of Safety Critical Automated Driving Scenarios

    by Huw Davies, Richard Hillman, Hishma Shah

    Assessment of safety critical driving scenarios is considered as key to consumer and market acceptance of automated driving systems. A protocol for the efficient and effective extraction of safety critical driving scenarios is proposed. This protocol is premised on capture of corner cases – these are the rare situations that cannot be easily identified and that can challenge the limits of reliable automated driving. The automated driving environment is a complex highly-dimensional problem space and corner case driving scenarios are members of this problem space. Providing the capability to navigate and compartmentalise this space will enable adoption of statistical based approaches to the assessment of automated vehicle system. Further, as corner case driving scenarios will be members of this compartmentalised space, and within each compartmentalised space all scenarios will be considered to exhibit similar behaviours, the premise is that corner case scenarios don’t have to be directly identified or assessed for performance to be known. The resulting protocol consists of five distinct steps. Step 1 charts the automated driving environment as a complex highly-dimensional space. Step 2 compartmentalises this automated driving environment into safety critical and non-safety critical. Step 3 takes the safety critical component and further compartmentalises based on the approach of equivalence clustering. Step 4 applies the concept of a Target Operating Domain (TOD) with the purpose to relate the system under test to specific equivalence classes. Step 5 defines a system of measurement to support evaluation. The above protocol can be used to assist developers and regulators in evaluating automated driving system behaviour in safety critical situations, and responds to concerns around consumer and market acceptance.

  • Open Access

    Policy ambition vs. capability: reviewing UK's readiness for safe deployment of connected and automated vehicles

    by Hishma Shah, Huw Davies, Christophe Bastien, Ashim Kumar Debnath

    The UK government's ambition for the safe deployment of Connected and Automated Vehicles (CAVs) is now formalised in the Automated Vehicles Act 2024 (the Act), through the Statement of Safety Principles, which requires that authorised CAVs achieve a level of safety equivalent to, or higher than, that of a "careful and competent" human driver. This paper examines whether the UK's regulatory, institutional, and technical capabilities are aligned with the ambition for safe CAV deployment and how they compare internationally, by using a policy-capacity framework. A narrative review was conducted using consultation responses to the Law Commissions' recommendations, stakeholder responses, Transport Committee reports, and associated legislative documents. Findings indicate that the concept of a "careful and competent" driver remains undefined and lacks measurable criteria. While the UK endorses a positive risk balance, there is no consensus on how risk should be quantified or what level of risk is acceptable. For example, should the trade-off between fewer high-risk events and a greater number of low-risk events be acceptable. Although various stakeholders are working toward solutions, there is no harmonised framework to assess whether CAVs meet this safety benchmark or a method to measure real-time risk. Addressing these challenges and closing the gap between ambition and capability requires a solution to determine the risk present in the system. The forthcoming Statement of Safety Principles will be a litmus test of whether the UK can translate ambition into a risk governance model that the public trusts.

  • Open Access

    Policy Ambition Vs.Capability: Reviewing UK's Readiness for Safe Deployment of Connected and Automated Vehicles

    by Hishma Shah, Huw Davies, Christophe Bastien, Ashim Kumar Debnath

    The UK government’s ambition for the safe deployment of Connected and Automated Vehicles (CAVs) is now formalised in the Automated Vehicles Act 2024 (the Act), through the Statement of Safety Principles, which requires that authorised CAVs achieve a level of safety equivalent to, or higher than, that of a “careful and competent” human driver. This paper examines whether the UK’s regulatory, institutional, and technical capabilities are aligned with the ambition for safe CAV deployment and how they compare internationally, by using a policy-capacity framework. A narrative review was conducted using consultation responses to the Law Commissions’ recommendations, stakeholder responses, Transport Committee reports, and associated legislative documents. Findings indicate that the concept of a “careful and competent” driver remains undefined and lacks measurable criteria. While the UK endorses a positive risk balance, there is no consensus on how risk should be quantified or what level of risk is acceptable. For example, should the trade-off between fewer high-risk events and a greater number of low-risk events be acceptable. Although various stakeholders are working toward solutions, there is no harmonised framework to assess whether CAVs meet this safety benchmark or a method to measure real-time risk. Addressing these challenges and closing the gap between ambition and capability requires a solution to determine the risk present in the system. The forthcoming Statement of Safety Principles will be a litmus test of whether the UK can translate ambition into a risk governance model that the public trusts.