KUKuralai Utzhanova

Kuralai Utzhanova

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Kuralai Utzhanova has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    EVIDENCE-BASED PRACTICE COMPETENCIES AND SKILL DEVELOPMENT NEEDS AMONG PRIMARY HEALTHCARE NURSES IN KAZAKHSTAN: A CROSS-SECTIONAL SURVEY

    by Kuralai Utzhanova, Dinara Makhanbetkulova, Gulshara Aimbetova, Aizat Aimakhanova, Bagymzhan Imanbek, Sultan Seidumanov, Arslan Indershiyev, Akerke Chshitanova

    Introduction. Evidence-based nursing practice requires nurses to possess the knowledge and skills needed to identify professional knowledge gaps, formulate research questions, search for and critically appraise scientific evidence, apply findings to clinical situations, review professional practice, and share evidence with colleagues. Assessing these competencies is important for identifying professional development needs among primary healthcare nurses.Aim. To assess self-reported knowledge and skills in evidence-based nursing practice among primary healthcare nurses in Kazakhstan and to identify relative strengths and priority areas for professional development.Materials and Methods. A descriptive cross-sectional survey was conducted from September to November 2025 among nurses employed in primary healthcare settings in six cities of Kazakhstan: Almaty, Astana, Shymkent, Karaganda, Semey, and Aktobe. A targeted convenience sample was recruited through professional and educational networks associated with six medical universities. A total of 507 questionnaires were received, of which 39 were excluded because of substantial missing data. The final analytical sample comprised 468 practicing nurses. Self-assessed evidence-based practice competence was evaluated using the 14-item Knowledge and Skills subscale of the Evidence-Based Practice Questionnaire (EBPQ). Each item was rated on a seven-point scale ranging from 1 (“poor”) to 7 (“best”). Data were collected anonymously using an online questionnaire and analyzed using descriptive statistics in IBM SPSS Statistics, version 29.0.Results. Mean scores across the 14 competencies ranged from 5.23 to 5.66 on the seven-point scale, and all mean item scores were above the theoretical midpoint of 4. The Knowledge and Skills subscale demonstrated high internal consistency (Cronbach’s α = 0.892). The highest mean scores were observed for disseminating new ideas related to patient care among colleagues (5.66 ± 1.19), sharing ideas and information with colleagues (5.64 ± 1.29), and applying scientific information to individual clinical cases (5.57 ± 1.29). Scores of 6–7 for these competencies were reported by 54.8%, 55.4%, and 53.4% of respondents, respectively. The lowest mean score was observed for conducting research (5.23 ± 1.36; 45.4% selected scores of 6–7), followed by awareness of the main types and sources of information (5.29 ± 1.36), converting an information need into a research question (5.31 ± 1.32), and critically appraising scientific evidence against established criteria (5.31 ± 1.33). Across all competencies, the proportion of respondents selecting scores of 6–7 ranged from 45.4% to 55.4%.Conclusion. The primary healthcare nurses surveyed in Kazakhstan reported above-midpoint but heterogeneous self-assessments of their knowledge and skills in evidence-based nursing practice. Competencies related to applying information, reviewing practice, and sharing knowledge with colleagues received comparatively higher ratings, whereas research-related competencies received comparatively lower ratings. These descriptive findings identify research methods, question formulation, evidence searching, and critical appraisal as priority areas for professional development. Practice-oriented education, mentorship, access to scientific information resources, and organizational support may help strengthen evidence-based practice competencies among primary healthcare nurses.

  • Open Access

    NURSES’ ATTITUDES TOWARD ADVERSE EVENT REPORTING BASED ON THE ROCAES SCALE: A CROSS-SECTIONAL SURVEY

    by Kuralai Utzhanova, Gulshara Aimbetova, Dinara Makhanbetkulova, Aizat Aimakhanova, Bagymzhan Imanbek

    Introduction. Patient safety is widely recognized as a priority in modern healthcare systems. Reporting adverse events is an important mechanism for identifying weaknesses in healthcare processes and improving the quality of care. Nevertheless, underreporting remains a common problem in many healthcare organizations. Nurses are closely involved in clinical care and therefore play a key role in patient safety. Their willingness to report adverse events may depend on several factors, including organizational culture, peer expectations, perceived blame, and the clarity of reporting procedures. The Reporting of Clinical Adverse Events Scale (RoCAES ) is frequently used to examine healthcare professionals’ attitudes toward reporting practices. Aim. To assess nurses’ attitudes toward adverse event reporting using the RoCAES scale. Materials and Methods. A cross-sectional study was carried out from September to November 2025 in primary healthcare organizations located in six cities of Kazakhstan. The study involved 468 practicing nurses who met the inclusion criteria and agreed to participate. Attitudes toward adverse event reporting were assessed using the 25-item RoCAES instrument, which includes five subscales: perceived blame, perceived criteria for reporting, perceptions of colleagues’ expectations, perceived benefits of reporting, and perceived clarity of reporting procedures. Data were collected anonymously using an online questionnaire. Statistical analysis was performed in IBM SPSS Statistics (version 29.0). Descriptive statistics were calculated and the internal consistency of the instrument was evaluated using Cronbach’s alpha. Results. The findings indicate differences in attitudes across the RoCAES dimensions. The highest mean score was observed for the subscale Perceptions of Colleagues’ Expectations (M = 2.43, mean score), suggesting that peer-related norms may influence reporting attitudes. Moderate values were found for Perceived Criteria for Reporting (M = 2.41) and Perceived Blame (M = 2.36). Lower mean scores were observed for Perceived Benefits of Reporting (M = 1.97) and Perceived Clarity of Reporting Procedures (M = 1.92), reflecting generally positive evaluations of these aspects. Overall, structural aspects of reporting were evaluated more positively than socio-cultural factors. Conclusion. The results suggest that nurses’ attitudes toward adverse event reporting are shaped by both structural and socio-cultural factors. While reporting procedures and perceived benefits appear to be relatively well understood, peer expectations, uncertainty regarding reporting criteria, and concerns about blame may still influence reporting behavior. Strengthening supportive professional norms and maintaining a non-punitive reporting environment may contribute to improving reporting practices in healthcare organizations.


  • CLINICAL ENVIRONMENT AND ADVERSE EVENT REPORTING PRACTICES AMONG ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSES

    by K.A. Utzhanova, G.E. Aimbetova, D.N. Makhanbetkulova, A.SH. Aimakhanova, Zh.M. Mukhamedkerim

    Introduction. A favorable professional environment is a key factor influencing advanced practice nurses’ (APNs) efficiency, motivation, and job satisfaction. Working conditions also affect their autonomy and willingness to report adverse events, which are essential for patient safety. Aim. To assess APNs’ attitudes toward their professional clinical environment and to examine the association between working conditions and their readiness to report adverse events. Materials and Methods. A descriptive cross–sectional study was conducted among 77 APNs working in municipal polyclinics in Almaty. Data were collected using the Revised Professional Practice Environment (RPPE) and Reporting of Clinical Adverse Events Scale (RoCAES). Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS 29.0 with Chi–square (χ²) and Fisher’s exact tests at a significance level of p < 0.05. Results. Overall, respondents evaluated their professional environment positively. The highest scores were observed for Leadership and Professional Autonomy in Clinical Practice (mean = 3.0) and Intrinsic Motivation (mean = 3.0). Lower scores were found for Teamwork (mean = 2.5) and Conflict Management (mean = 2.7), indicating challenges in interprofessional collaboration. Most nurses demonstrated a positive attitude toward adverse event reporting, particularly regarding procedural clarity and managerial support (mean = 2.9). A statistically significant association was identified between Clinical Communication with Patients and adverse event reporting (p = 0.046), with lower communication scores associated with more frequent reporting. Conclusion. A supportive professional environment is associated with higher levels of motivation, autonomy, and leadership among APNs. However, only limited associations were found between environmental factors and reporting behavior. Key challenges include weaknesses in teamwork, communication, and concerns about negative consequences of reporting. Strengthening interprofessional collaboration and non–punitive reporting culture may improve patient safety. Key words: Advanced Practice Nursing, Professional Practice Environment, Adverse Event Reporting, Patient Safety, Motivation, Teamwork. Введение. Благоприятная профессиональная среда является ключевым фактором, влияющим на эффективность, мотивацию и удовлетворённость трудом медицинских сестёр расширенной практики. Условия труда также влияют на автономию и готовность сообщать о неблагоприятных событиях, что имеет важное значение для обеспечения безопасности пациентов. Цель. Оценить отношение медицинских сестёр расширенной практики к их профессиональной клинической среде и изучить взаимосвязь между условиями труда и их готовностью сообщать о неблагоприятных событиях. Материалы и методы. Проведено описательное поперечное исследование среди 77 медицинских сестёр расширенной практики, работающих в муниципальных поликлиниках г. Алматы. Данные собирались с использованием шкал Revised Professional Practice Environment (RPPE) и Reporting of Clinical Adverse Events Scale (RoCAES). Статистический анализ выполнен с использованием программы SPSS 29.0 с применением критерия χ² и точного критерия Фишера при уровне значимости p < 0,05. Результаты. В целом респонденты положительно оценили свою профессиональную среду. Наиболее высокие показатели были отмечены по шкалам «Лидерство и профессиональная автономия в клинической практике» (среднее значение = 3,0) и «Внутренняя мотивация» (среднее значение = 3,0). Более низкие значения были выявлены по шкалам «Командная работа» (среднее значение = 2,5) и «Управление конфликтами» (среднее значение = 2,7), что указывает на трудности в межпрофессиональном взаимодействии. Большинство медицинских сестёр продемонстрировали положительное отношение к сообщению о неблагоприятных событиях, особенно в отношении ясности процедур и управленческой поддержки (среднее значение = 2,9). Была выявлена статистически значимая связь между подшкалой «Клиническая коммуникация с пациентами» и сообщением о неблагоприятных событиях (p = 0,046), более низкие показатели коммуникации были связаны с более частым сообщением. Заключение. Поддерживающая профессиональная среда связана с более высоким уровнем мотивации, автономии и лидерских качеств у медицинских сестёр расширенной практики. Однако...