EIElza Ibragimov

Elza Ibragimov

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Elza Ibragimov has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Understanding Influence of Self-identified Gender and Race on Social Norm Violations in an Immersive Doctor’s Office

    by Elza Ibragimov, Natasha Kholgade Banerjee, Sean Banerjee, Ashutosh Shivakumar

  • Open Access

    Dine in or take out dataset: user behavior in an interactive virtual reality café

    by Elza Ibragimov, Natasha Kholgade Banerjee, Sean Banerjee, Ashutosh Shivakumar


  • Open Access

    Descriptor: Line Cutting While Waiting in Line at a Doctor’s Office in Virtual Reality Dataset (LC-WAIT)

    by Elza Ibragimov, Natasha Kholgade Banerjee, Sean Banerjee, Ashutosh Shivakumar

    Waiting in line for service provision is ubiquitous to any customer-facing service environment such as a doctor’s office, bank, or coffee shop. In this paper, we describe the LC-WAIT dataset consisting of 45 participants waiting in line at a virtual doctor’s office receptionist area. In our dataset, participants experience two scenarios, or treatments—line-cutter allowed and denied, where the line-cutter is a non-playable character (NPC) that is allowed to join the front of the queue by an in-queue NPC. The LC-WAIT dataset contains participant demographics as well as responses to the Frustration Discomfort Scale (FDS), NASA Task Load Index (TLX) and System Usability Scale (SUS), and per treatment participant responses to perceived frustration due to line-cutter’s intrusive behavior, likelihood to allow the line-cutter to cut in line, and likelihood to exit due to the line-cutter’s actions. Our dataset also contains head, left, and right-hand position and orientation, and the names and hit positions of objects the participant visually interacts with. The LC-WAIT dataset can be used by interdisciplinary researchers in computer science, psychology, and human factors to study how participant behavior changes when a line-cutter is allowed to cut into a queue. These findings can be used to design social VR applications with responsive NPCs that modulate behavior based on participant states. Researchers may also use pre-trained algorithms to predict participant responses to the post-treatment questions on perception of time, frustration, and likelihood to exit. Using these models, empathetic agents or gamifications can be designed to reduce negative states due to the line-cutter and enable the participant to complete the task.

  • Open Access

    Descriptor: Waiting in Line in Virtual Reality Dataset (WAIT)

    by Elza Ibragimov, Ava Megyeri, Natasha Kholgade Banerjee, Sean Banerjee, Ashutosh Shivakumar

    As immersive social virtual reality (VR) applications emerge, users may expect to wait in virtual queues as part of the social experience or due to delays with the service provider. This paper describes the WAIT dataset containing data from 36 human participants who partook in a study on waiting in line in VR at a virtual doctor’s office receptionist area to check in for an appointment. Participants took part in three treatments using the Meta Quest Pro head mounted device (HMD)—no waiting in line, waiting for 3 minutes, and waiting for 6 minutes, with non-playable characters (NPCs) introduced to explain the reason for wait in the 3- and 6-minute treatments. The dataset contains demographics data, pre- and post-study subject reports of frustration using the Frustration Discomfort Scale (FDS), subject ratings of perceived frustration, likelihood to exit, and perception of elapsed time after each treatment, and post-study responses to the NASA Task Load Index, the System Usability Scale, and the Virtual Reality Sickness Questionnaire. The dataset also contains quantitative data on the position and orientation of the headset and the left and right hands, and names and hit positions of objects interacted with. The WAIT dataset has value for research in computer science, human factors and psychology by enabling behavior understanding in stressful scenarios, design of interruption management systems to engage participants during delays based on frustration states, and development of behavior-based security measures for critical applications in healthcare. The dataset is shared on IEEE DataPort at: https://dx.doi.org/10.21227/0jq7-nm37.


  • Open Access

    Understanding User Perceptions Toward Waiting For Service Provision in Virtual Reality

    by Elza Ibragimov, Natasha Kholgade Banerjee, Sean Banerjee, Ashutosh Shivakumar

    We analyze user perceptions of queue waits prior to receiving service in a virtual reality (VR) service provision environment. Waiting is a natural part of service receipt in real-world and online environments. As service providers such as clinics, banks, airlines, and retailers transition to VR, the process of serving multiple clients’ needs will require clients to wait in VR as well. Though users are likely to wait for a valuable service, prolonged waits have the potential to generate negative emotions such as anxiety, boredom, and frustration, and leave them facing the difficult decision of waiting versus abandoning service. To evaluate user perceptions toward wait in VR, we provide a VR environment representing the receptionist’s desk of a doctor’s office, together with non-playable character (NPC) avatars representing the receptionist and clients standing in a queue. We evaluate perceptions toward three conditions—no wait, 3-minute wait and 6-minute wait—with client NPCs in the latter two conditions. Using data on subjective responses from 33 participants interacting with our environment, we find significant differences in frustration level, exit likelihood, and absolute deviation of perceived wait time from actual time between no wait versus 3-minute wait and no wait versus 6-minute wait conditions, with higher values for longer wait times. Using quantitative data tracked from the VR system, we find significant differences between the same two condition sets for variance in eye gaze hit locations and count of object viewed, quantities that represent user motivation to occupy time through viewing-based engagement with the scene.