John Rolfe Robertson
Research Subjects
John Rolfe Robertson has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Doug Lombardi
University of Maryland
2 shared publications - Josh Medrano
School of Education, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA
1 shared publication - Joshua M. Rosenberg
University of Tennessee, Knoxville
1 shared publication - Margaret W. Logan
University of Maryland
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 9 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Weakening the Alternative: Asymmetric Effects of Plausibility Reappraisal on Knowledge
Plausibility judgments are central to how students evaluate competing scientific explanations, yet less is known about which components of plausibility reappraisal are most closely associated with learning. In this study, we examined middle and high school students’ plausibility judgments during repeated Model-Evidence Link (MEL) activities focused on socially relevant Earth and environmental science topics. Students (N = 304; 1,191 observations) rated the plausibility of scientific and alternative explanations before and after each activity and completed topic-specific knowledge measures. Rather than treating plausibility change as a single net movement toward or away from science explanations, we modeled changes in the plausibility of competing explanations separately. This approach allowed us to test whether learning was associated with strengthening scientific explanations, weakening alternative explanations, or both. Mixed-effects models showed an asymmetric pattern that initial scientific plausibility positively predicted post-instruction knowledge, suggesting that seeing the scientific explanation as plausible provided a starting foothold for learning. However, the within-activity process most consistently associated with post-instruction knowledge was reducing the plausibility of the alternative explanation. This pattern was corroborated by a simpler decomposition model showing that alternative-down reappraisal predicted knowledge, whereas science-up reappraisal did not. Antecedent models indicated that students were most likely to reduce alternative plausibility when they initially viewed the alternative explanation as plausible. Findings suggest that science learning depends not only on increasing the perceived plausibility of scientific explanations, but also on reducing the explanatory appeal of competing alternatives.
- 9 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessWeakening the Alternative: Asymmetric Effects of Plausibility Reappraisal on Knowledge
Plausibility judgments are central to how students evaluate competing scientific explanations, yet less is known about which components of plausibility reappraisal are most closely associated with learning. In this study, we examined middle and high school students’ plausibility judgments during repeated Model-Evidence Link (MEL) activities focused on socially relevant Earth and environmental science topics. Students (N = 304; 1,191 observations) rated the plausibility of scientific and alternative explanations before and after each activity and completed topic-specific knowledge measures. Rather than treating plausibility change as a single net movement toward or away from science explanations, we modeled changes in the plausibility of competing explanations separately. This approach allowed us to test whether learning was associated with strengthening scientific explanations, weakening alternative explanations, or both. Mixed-effects models showed an asymmetric pattern that initial scientific plausibility positively predicted post-instruction knowledge, suggesting that seeing the scientific explanation as plausible provided a starting foothold for learning. However, the within-activity process most consistently associated with post-instruction knowledge was reducing the plausibility of the alternative explanation. This pattern was corroborated by a simpler decomposition model showing that alternative-down reappraisal predicted knowledge, whereas science-up reappraisal did not. Antecedent models indicated that students were most likely to reduce alternative plausibility when they initially viewed the alternative explanation as plausible. Findings suggest that science learning depends not only on increasing the perceived plausibility of scientific explanations, but also on reducing the explanatory appeal of competing alternatives.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 118 (5) , 829-851
Profiles of scientific thinking.
- 1 July 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 118 (5) , 829-851
Profiles of scientific thinking.