Hiroyuki Yamada
Research Subjects
Hiroyuki Yamada has a total of 1 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Ken Hidaka
Social Systems Research-Domain, Toyota Central R&D Labs., Inc., 41-1, Yokomichi, Nagakute, 4801192, Aichi, Japan
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 29 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Why Reported Scope 3 Category 7 Emissions are Difficult to Compare: Structural Separation between Counting and Accounting
Scope 3 greenhouse gas emissions are increasingly central to corporate decarbonization, yet interorganizational comparability remains limited. Among the fifteen Scope 3 categories, employee commuting (Category 7) provides an illustrative case: emissions arise from diverse individual mobility behaviors but are aggregated and disclosed as a single organizational figure. However, it remains unclear why reported Category 7 emissions may still be difficult to compare meaningfully across organizations. To address this gap, this study develops and applies a conceptual framework that distinguishes between counting and accounting in carbon emissions. The framework is informed by prior research and applied through a structured disclosure analysis of publicly available corporate documents from 35 large firms across seven major economies, supplemented by a group-level analysis of 17 firms. The analysis focuses on whether key underlying assumptions relevant to comparisons-such as system boundaries, calculation methods, data sources, and emission factor references-can be identified from public disclosure. The study shows that comparability challenges go beyond data limitations or inconsistent reporting. Rather, they are linked to structural separation between counting and accounting. This separation appears in corporate disclosure as variation in assumptions and their identifiability. As a result, reported figures may appear formally comparable while still offering limited meaningful comparability. By framing Category 7 emissions at the interface between counting and accounting, this study provides a conceptual explanation of persistent comparability challenges and highlights the need to disclose the assumptions required to interpret reported differences across firms.
- 29 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessWhy Reported Scope 3 Category 7 Emissions are Difficult to Compare: Structural Separation between Counting and Accounting
Scope 3 greenhouse gas emissions are increasingly central to corporate decarbonization, yet interorganizational comparability remains limited. Among the fifteen Scope 3 categories, employee commuting (Category 7) provides an illustrative case: emissions arise from diverse individual mobility behaviors but are aggregated and disclosed as a single organizational figure. However, it remains unclear why reported Category 7 emissions may still be difficult to compare meaningfully across organizations. To address this gap, this study develops and applies a conceptual framework that distinguishes between counting and accounting in carbon emissions. The framework is informed by prior research and applied through a structured disclosure analysis of publicly available corporate documents from 35 large firms across seven major economies, supplemented by a group-level analysis of 17 firms. The analysis focuses on whether key underlying assumptions relevant to comparisons-such as system boundaries, calculation methods, data sources, and emission factor references-can be identified from public disclosure. The study shows that comparability challenges go beyond data limitations or inconsistent reporting. Rather, they are linked to structural separation between counting and accounting. This separation appears in corporate disclosure as variation in assumptions and their identifiability. As a result, reported figures may appear formally comparable while still offering limited meaningful comparability. By framing Category 7 emissions at the interface between counting and accounting, this study provides a conceptual explanation of persistent comparability challenges and highlights the need to disclose the assumptions required to interpret reported differences across firms.