Jochen Papenbrock
Jochen Papenbrock has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Peter Schwendner
Institute of Wealth and Asset Management, Zurich University of Applied Sciences, Winterthur, Switzerland
4 shared publications Dimitri Marinelli
Firamis
2 shared publicationsMarkus Jaeger
Munich Reinsurance Company, Financial Solutions
2 shared publicationsStephan Krügel
Munich Reinsurance Company, Financial Solutions
2 shared publicationsBernhard Hein
Ernst & Young
1 shared publicationEduard Baitinger
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 June 2021
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Financial Risk Management and Explainable Trustworthy Responsible AI
Executive Summary This perspective paper is based on several sessions by the members of the Round Table AI at FIRM , with input from a number of external and international speakers. Its particular focus lies on the management of the model risk of productive models in banks and other financial institutions. The models in view range from simple rules-based approaches to Artificial Intelligence (AI) or Machine learning (ML) models with a high level of sophistication. The typical applications of those models are related to predictions and decision making around the value chain of credit risk (including accounting side under IFRS9 or related national GAAP approaches), insurance risk or other financial risk types. We expect more models of higher complexity in the space of anti money laundering, fraud detection and transaction monitoring as well as a rise of AI/ML models as alternatives to current methods in solving some of the more intricate stochastic differential equations needed for the pricing and/or valuation of derivatives. The same type of model is also successful in areas unrelated to risk management, such as sales optimization, customer lifetime value considerations, robo-advisory and other fields of applications. The paper makes reference to recent related publications from central banks, financial supervisors and regulators as well as by other relevant sources and working groups. It aims to give practical advice for establishing a risk-based governance and test framework for the mentioned model types and also discusses the use of recent technologies, approaches and platforms to support the establishment of responsible, trustworthy, explainable, auditable and manageable AI/ML in production. In view of the recent EU publication on AI (see European Commission 2021), also referred to as the EU Artificial Intelligence Act (AIA), we also see a certain added value for this paper as an instigator of further thinking outside of the financial services sector, in particular where “High Risk” models according to the mentioned EU consultation are concerned. Our key takeaways are: 1. There need to be general principles, requirements and tests to control model risk and fitness-for-purpose for each model. Particularly because AI is not a fixed category, we are talking about a spectrum of mathematical models of varying complexity, of which gradually more and more complex ones are becoming feasible. With regards to this fact, the mentioned governance elements (principles, requirements, tests to control model risk etc.) should hinge upon models’ respective purposes, influence on human lives and business impact, rather than upon model design or complexity. To satisfy these requirements of course, special tests will be necessary for more complex or even dynamic models. This holds true especially for the implementation of those models and their utilization in a scaling enterprise production environment. 2. To this end, it will be necessary and useful to combine the expertise and approaches of classical risk management and governance with those of data science and AI knowledge. 3. Many aspects of AI governance, algorithmic auditing and risk management of AI systems can be addressed with technology and computing platforms. In fact, an entire industry is about to emerge in this area. Many of the necessary techniques essentially consist of the use of somewhat less complex and more transparent models in their own right, with associated cost for maintenance and operation, and with inherent (more indirect and smaller) risks to operate them. Hence, there will always be residual risk and consequentially a need for human oversight. The level of residual risk should be covered via OpRisk Management (IT risk, mal-decisioning risk, reputational risk) and by AI incident management or AI model insurance. 4. Explainability, interpretability and transparency of models, data and decision making will be key to even enable an appropriate possibility to manage remaining model risks (“Explaining Explainable AI”). All three need to be directed towards the internal stakeholders of financial institutions, but – depending on model purpose – also towards the outside world, particularly to clients/consumers and supervisors. Each stakeholder needs to be informed about the model aspects in a different and specific way. There are technologies and experts to support interfacing the different domains involved. 5. One particular aspect of the “Explainable AI” agenda is to enable the fairness of AI decision making or decision support from a societal perspective (linked to the ESG agenda). The associated fairness considerations, starting from the need to explicitly define a notion of fairness and enable its implementation and ongoing validation, are by no means exclusive to AI modelling techniques. They pertain to classical decision making to the same extent; however, due to their lack of innate transparency, the cost of fairness will be higher for AI models. This should be taken into account in the business decisions around the choice of model design.
- 25 June 2021
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessFinancial Risk Management and Explainable Trustworthy Responsible AI
Executive Summary This perspective paper is based on several sessions by the members of the Round Table AI at FIRM , with input from a number of external and international speakers. Its particular focus lies on the management of the model risk of productive models in banks and other financial institutions. The models in view range from simple rules-based approaches to Artificial Intelligence (AI) or Machine learning (ML) models with a high level of sophistication. The typical applications of those models are related to predictions and decision making around the value chain of credit risk (including accounting side under IFRS9 or related national GAAP approaches), insurance risk or other financial risk types. We expect more models of higher complexity in the space of anti money laundering, fraud detection and transaction monitoring as well as a rise of AI/ML models as alternatives to current methods in solving some of the more intricate stochastic differential equations needed for the pricing and/or valuation of derivatives. The same type of model is also successful in areas unrelated to risk management, such as sales optimization, customer lifetime value considerations, robo-advisory and other fields of applications. The paper makes reference to recent related publications from central banks, financial supervisors and regulators as well as by other relevant sources and working groups. It aims to give practical advice for establishing a risk-based governance and test framework for the mentioned model types and also discusses the use of recent technologies, approaches and platforms to support the establishment of responsible, trustworthy, explainable, auditable and manageable AI/ML in production. In view of the recent EU publication on AI (see European Commission 2021), also referred to as the EU Artificial Intelligence Act (AIA), we also see a certain added value for this paper as an instigator of further thinking outside of the financial services sector, in particular where “High Risk” models according to the mentioned EU consultation are concerned. Our key takeaways are: 1. There need to be general principles, requirements and tests to control model risk and fitness-for-purpose for each model. Particularly because AI is not a fixed category, we are talking about a spectrum of mathematical models of varying complexity, of which gradually more and more complex ones are becoming feasible. With regards to this fact, the mentioned governance elements (principles, requirements, tests to control model risk etc.) should hinge upon models’ respective purposes, influence on human lives and business impact, rather than upon model design or complexity. To satisfy these requirements of course, special tests will be necessary for more complex or even dynamic models. This holds true especially for the implementation of those models and their utilization in a scaling enterprise production environment. 2. To this end, it will be necessary and useful to combine the expertise and approaches of classical risk management and governance with those of data science and AI knowledge. 3. Many aspects of AI governance, algorithmic auditing and risk management of AI systems can be addressed with technology and computing platforms. In fact, an entire industry is about to emerge in this area. Many of the necessary techniques essentially consist of the use of somewhat less complex and more transparent models in their own right, with associated cost for maintenance and operation, and with inherent (more indirect and smaller) risks to operate them. Hence, there will always be residual risk and consequentially a need for human oversight. The level of residual risk should be covered via OpRisk Management (IT risk, mal-decisioning risk, reputational risk) and by AI incident management or AI model insurance. 4. Explainability, interpretability and transparency of models, data and decision making will be key to even enable an appropriate possibility to manage remaining model risks (“Explaining Explainable AI”). All three need to be directed towards the internal stakeholders of financial institutions, but – depending on model purpose – also towards the outside world, particularly to clients/consumers and supervisors. Each stakeholder needs to be informed about the model aspects in a different and specific way. There are technologies and experts to support interfacing the different domains involved. 5. One particular aspect of the “Explainable AI” agenda is to enable the fairness of AI decision making or decision support from a societal perspective (linked to the ESG agenda). The associated fairness considerations, starting from the need to explicitly define a notion of fairness and enable its implementation and ongoing validation, are by no means exclusive to AI modelling techniques. They pertain to classical decision making to the same extent; however, due to their lack of innate transparency, the cost of fairness will be higher for AI models. This should be taken into account in the business decisions around the choice of model design.
- Open Access
- 30 January 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Understanding Machine Learning for Diversified Portfolio Construction by Explainable AI
In this paper, we construct a pipeline to investigate heuristic diversification strategies in asset allocation. We use machine learning concepts ("explainable AI") to compare the robustness of different strategies and back out implicit rules for decision making. In a first step, we augment the asset universe (the empirical dataset) with a range of scenarios generated with a block bootstrap from the empirical dataset. Second, we backtest the candidate strategies over a long period of time, checking their performance variability. Third, we use XGBoost as a regression model to connect the difference between the measured performances between two strategies to a pool of statistical features of the portfolio universe tailored to the investigated strategy. Finally, we employ the concept of Shapley values to extract the relationships that the model could identify between the portfolio characteristics and the statistical properties of the asset universe. We test this pipeline for studying risk-parity strategies with a volatility target, and in particular, comparing the machine learning-driven Hierarchical Risk Parity (HRP) to the classical Equal Risk Contribution (ERC) strategy. In the augmented dataset built from a multi-asset investment universe of commodities, equities and fixed income futures, we find that HRP better matches the volatility target, and shows better risk-adjusted performances. Finally, we train XGBoost to learn the difference between the realized Calmar ratios of HRP and ERC and extract explanations. The explanations provide fruitful ex-post indications of the connection between the statistical properties of the universe and the strategy performance in the training set. For example, the model confirms that features addressing the hierarchical properties of the universe are connected to the relative performance of HRP respect to ERC.
- 30 January 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessUnderstanding Machine Learning for Diversified Portfolio Construction by Explainable AI
In this paper, we construct a pipeline to investigate heuristic diversification strategies in asset allocation. We use machine learning concepts ("explainable AI") to compare the robustness of different strategies and back out implicit rules for decision making. In a first step, we augment the asset universe (the empirical dataset) with a range of scenarios generated with a block bootstrap from the empirical dataset. Second, we backtest the candidate strategies over a long period of time, checking their performance variability. Third, we use XGBoost as a regression model to connect the difference between the measured performances between two strategies to a pool of statistical features of the portfolio universe tailored to the investigated strategy. Finally, we employ the concept of Shapley values to extract the relationships that the model could identify between the portfolio characteristics and the statistical properties of the asset universe. We test this pipeline for studying risk-parity strategies with a volatility target, and in particular, comparing the machine learning-driven Hierarchical Risk Parity (HRP) to the classical Equal Risk Contribution (ERC) strategy. In the augmented dataset built from a multi-asset investment universe of commodities, equities and fixed income futures, we find that HRP better matches the volatility target, and shows better risk-adjusted performances. Finally, we train XGBoost to learn the difference between the realized Calmar ratios of HRP and ERC and extract explanations. The explanations provide fruitful ex-post indications of the connection between the statistical properties of the universe and the strategy performance in the training set. For example, the model confirms that features addressing the hierarchical properties of the universe are connected to the relative performance of HRP respect to ERC.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Matrix Evolutions: Synthetic Correlations and Explainable Machine Learning for Constructing Robust Investment Portfolios
In this article, the authors present a novel and highly flexible concept to simulate correlationmatrixes of financial markets. It produces realistic outcomes regarding stylized facts ofempirical correlation matrixes and requires no asset return input data. The matrix generationis based on a multiobjective evolutionary algorithm, so the authors call the approach "matrixevolutions". It is suitable for parallel implementation and can be accelerated by graphicsprocessing units and quantum-inspired algorithms. The approach is useful for backtesting,pricing, and hedging correlation-dependent investment strategies and financial products. Its potential is demonstrated in a machine learning case study for robust portfolio construction ina multi-asset universe: An explainable machine learning program links the synthetic matrixesto the portfolio volatility spread of hierarchical risk parity versus equal risk contribution.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessMatrix Evolutions: Synthetic Correlations and Explainable Machine Learning for Constructing Robust Investment Portfolios
In this article, the authors present a novel and highly flexible concept to simulate correlationmatrixes of financial markets. It produces realistic outcomes regarding stylized facts ofempirical correlation matrixes and requires no asset return input data. The matrix generationis based on a multiobjective evolutionary algorithm, so the authors call the approach "matrixevolutions". It is suitable for parallel implementation and can be accelerated by graphicsprocessing units and quantum-inspired algorithms. The approach is useful for backtesting,pricing, and hedging correlation-dependent investment strategies and financial products. Its potential is demonstrated in a machine learning case study for robust portfolio construction ina multi-asset universe: An explainable machine learning program links the synthetic matrixesto the portfolio volatility spread of hierarchical risk parity versus equal risk contribution.
- Open Access
- 18 December 2019
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Explainable AI in Credit Risk Management
The paper proposes an explainable AI model that can be used in credit risk management and, in particular, in measuring the risks that arise when credit is borrowed employing credit scoring platforms. The model applies similarity networks to Shapley values, so that AI predictions are grouped according to the similarity in the underlying explanatory variables. The empirical analysis of 15,000 small and medium companies asking for credit reveals that both risky and not risky borrowers can be grouped according to a set of similar financial characteristics, which can be employed to explain and understand their credit score and, therefore, to predict their future behaviour.
- 18 December 2019
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessExplainable AI in Credit Risk Management
The paper proposes an explainable AI model that can be used in credit risk management and, in particular, in measuring the risks that arise when credit is borrowed employing credit scoring platforms. The model applies similarity networks to Shapley values, so that AI predictions are grouped according to the similarity in the underlying explanatory variables. The empirical analysis of 15,000 small and medium companies asking for credit reveals that both risky and not risky borrowers can be grouped according to a set of similar financial characteristics, which can be employed to explain and understand their credit score and, therefore, to predict their future behaviour.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Interconnectedness Risk and Active Portfolio Management: The Information-Theoretic Perspective
Today's asset management academia and practice is dominated by mean-variance thinking. In consequence, this leads to the quantification of the dependence structure of asset returns by the covariance or the Pearson's correlation coefficient matrix. However, the respective dependence measures are linear by construction and hence unable to detect non-linear dependencies. This article tackles the described concern with regard to the previous publication of Baitinger and Papenbrock (2017). We introduce the mutual information measure, which is an information-theoretic concept and able to detect linear and non-linear dependencies. Next, correlation-based networks are extensively compared to mutual information-based networks. Lastly, the empirical study of Baitinger and Papenbrock (2017) is replicated using mutual information-based networks.
- 1 January 2017
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessInterconnectedness Risk and Active Portfolio Management: The Information-Theoretic Perspective
Today's asset management academia and practice is dominated by mean-variance thinking. In consequence, this leads to the quantification of the dependence structure of asset returns by the covariance or the Pearson's correlation coefficient matrix. However, the respective dependence measures are linear by construction and hence unable to detect non-linear dependencies. This article tackles the described concern with regard to the previous publication of Baitinger and Papenbrock (2017). We introduce the mutual information measure, which is an information-theoretic concept and able to detect linear and non-linear dependencies. Next, correlation-based networks are extensively compared to mutual information-based networks. Lastly, the empirical study of Baitinger and Papenbrock (2017) is replicated using mutual information-based networks.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2015
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Tail-Risk Protection Trading Strategies
Starting from well-known empirical stylised facts of financial time series, we develop dynamic portfolio protection trading strategies based on econometric methods. As a criterion for riskiness we consider the evolution of the value-at-risk spread from a GARCH model with normal innovations relative to a GARCH model with generalised innovations. These generalised innovations may for example follow a Student t, a generalized hyperbolic (GH), an alpha-stable or a Generalised Pareto (GPD) distribution. Our results indicate that the GPD distribution provides the strongest signals for avoiding tail risks. This is not surprising as the GPD distribution arises as a limit of tail behavior in extreme value theory and therefore is especially suited to deal with tail risks. Out-of-sample backtests on 11 years of DAX futures data, indicate that the dynamic tail-risk protection strategy effectively reduces the tail risk while outperforming traditional portfolio protection strategies. The results are further validated by calculating the statistical significance of the results obtained using bootstrap methods. A number of robustness tests including application to other assets further underline the effectiveness of the strategy. Finally, by empirically testing for second order stochastic dominance, we find that risk averse investors would be willing to pay a positive premium to move from a static buy-and-hold investment in the DAX future to the tail-risk protection strategy.
- 1 January 2015
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessTail-Risk Protection Trading Strategies
Starting from well-known empirical stylised facts of financial time series, we develop dynamic portfolio protection trading strategies based on econometric methods. As a criterion for riskiness we consider the evolution of the value-at-risk spread from a GARCH model with normal innovations relative to a GARCH model with generalised innovations. These generalised innovations may for example follow a Student t, a generalized hyperbolic (GH), an alpha-stable or a Generalised Pareto (GPD) distribution. Our results indicate that the GPD distribution provides the strongest signals for avoiding tail risks. This is not surprising as the GPD distribution arises as a limit of tail behavior in extreme value theory and therefore is especially suited to deal with tail risks. Out-of-sample backtests on 11 years of DAX futures data, indicate that the dynamic tail-risk protection strategy effectively reduces the tail risk while outperforming traditional portfolio protection strategies. The results are further validated by calculating the statistical significance of the results obtained using bootstrap methods. A number of robustness tests including application to other assets further underline the effectiveness of the strategy. Finally, by empirically testing for second order stochastic dominance, we find that risk averse investors would be willing to pay a positive premium to move from a static buy-and-hold investment in the DAX future to the tail-risk protection strategy.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
The Use of Correlation Networks in Parametric Portfolio Policies
Correlation networks reveal a rich picture of market risk structure dynamics. A rather compact and well-organized sector correlation network is indicative of a
- 1 January 2014
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessThe Use of Correlation Networks in Parametric Portfolio Policies
Correlation networks reveal a rich picture of market risk structure dynamics. A rather compact and well-organized sector correlation network is indicative of a
- Open Access
- 2 January 2013
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Handling Risk On/Risk Off Dynamics with Correlation Regimes and Correlation Networks
In this paper, we present a framework to detect distinct correlation regimes and to analyze the emerging state dependences for a multi-asset futures portfolio f
- 2 January 2013
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessHandling Risk On/Risk Off Dynamics with Correlation Regimes and Correlation Networks
In this paper, we present a framework to detect distinct correlation regimes and to analyze the emerging state dependences for a multi-asset futures portfolio f