Mussa Niyazov School of Economics, Esil University, Astana, Kazakhstan
Mussa Niyazov School of Economics, Esil University, Astana, Kazakhstan has a total of 11 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Gulzhan Abauova Associate Professor, School of Economics, Esil University, Astana, Kazakhstan
Esil University
4 shared publications - Yerzhan Beisengaliyev Associate Professor, School of Economics, Esil University, Astana, Kazakhstan4 shared publications
- Aibek Imashev Associate Professor, Esil University, Astana, Kazakhstan
Esil University, Astana, Republic of Kazakhstan
2 shared publications - Assiya Turekulova Associate Professor, School of Economics, Esil University, Astana, Kazakhstan2 shared publications
- Karlygash Ramazanova PhD Student, School of Economics, Esil University, Astana, Kazakhstan2 shared publications
Aigerim Shametova Candidate of Economic Sciences, Associate Professor, School of Economics, Abylkas Saginov Karaganda Technical University, Karaganda, Kazakhstan
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 September 2026
- Published by Centre for Research on Islamic Banking and Finance and Business in Bangladesh Journal of Multidisciplinary Scientific Research
- Vol. 11 (6) , 43-54
THE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON THE LABOR MARKET: OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES FOR YOUTH DECENT WORK, QUALITY EDUCATION AND HUMAN CAPITAL IN THE CONTEXT OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION IN KAZAKHSTAN
The diffusion of artificial intelligence (AI), and of generative AI in particular, is reshaping the demand for labour and skills, and young people entering the labour market are the group most exposed to its opportunities and risks, with direct consequences for decent work, quality education and reduced inequalities. This study assesses the impact of AI and digital transformation on Kazakhstan's youth labour market, identifies the opportunities and risks they present, and determines directions for adapting youth human capital to changing labour market demands. The study combines a structured synthesis of empirical evidence published in 2023–2026, a content analysis of national strategic documents, and an economic-statistical analysis of national and regional employment data of the Bureau of National Statistics of Kazakhstan for 2020–2025, using growth rates, the regional differentiation coefficient, the coefficient of variation and the Gini coefficient. The results show that average employment rose from 8,966.9 thousand in 2022 to 9,298.2 thousand in 2025 (+3.69%) and the average unemployment rate fell from 4.90% to 4.60%. In contrast, the regional differentiation coefficient of employment rose from 9.89 to 11.74, the coefficient of variation from 44.31% to 49.12% and the Gini coefficient from 0.232 to 0.252. The findings suggest that the current phase of AI diffusion is accompanied by employment growth rather than contraction, that the effects of AI on youth are dual, combining the substitution of standardized cognitive tasks with the augmentation of inexperienced workers, and that these effects will unfold unevenly across regions with persistent, moderately widening disparities.
- 30 September 2026
- Published by Centre for Research on Islamic Banking and Finance and Business in Bangladesh Journal of Multidisciplinary Scientific Research
- Vol. 11 (6) , 43-54
Open AccessTHE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON THE LABOR MARKET: OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES FOR YOUTH DECENT WORK, QUALITY EDUCATION AND HUMAN CAPITAL IN THE CONTEXT OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION IN KAZAKHSTAN
The diffusion of artificial intelligence (AI), and of generative AI in particular, is reshaping the demand for labour and skills, and young people entering the labour market are the group most exposed to its opportunities and risks, with direct consequences for decent work, quality education and reduced inequalities. This study assesses the impact of AI and digital transformation on Kazakhstan's youth labour market, identifies the opportunities and risks they present, and determines directions for adapting youth human capital to changing labour market demands. The study combines a structured synthesis of empirical evidence published in 2023–2026, a content analysis of national strategic documents, and an economic-statistical analysis of national and regional employment data of the Bureau of National Statistics of Kazakhstan for 2020–2025, using growth rates, the regional differentiation coefficient, the coefficient of variation and the Gini coefficient. The results show that average employment rose from 8,966.9 thousand in 2022 to 9,298.2 thousand in 2025 (+3.69%) and the average unemployment rate fell from 4.90% to 4.60%. In contrast, the regional differentiation coefficient of employment rose from 9.89 to 11.74, the coefficient of variation from 44.31% to 49.12% and the Gini coefficient from 0.232 to 0.252. The findings suggest that the current phase of AI diffusion is accompanied by employment growth rather than contraction, that the effects of AI on youth are dual, combining the substitution of standardized cognitive tasks with the augmentation of inexperienced workers, and that these effects will unfold unevenly across regions with persistent, moderately widening disparities.
- Open Access
- 30 September 2026
- Published by Centre for Research on Islamic Banking and Finance and Business in Bangladesh Journal of Multidisciplinary Scientific Research
- Vol. 6 (11) , 17-29
ASSESSING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INSTITUTIONAL MANAGEMENT IN THE ADAPTATION OF INCLUSIVE EDUCATION SYSTEMS: QUALITY EDUCATION, REDUCED INEQUALITIES AND STRONG INSTITUTIONS IN KAZAKHSTAN
The rapid growth in the number of children with special educational needs places increasing pressure on the institutional capacity of education systems, and the timeliness of coverage responses to changes in the target group has become a central concern for quality education and reducing inequalities. Formal expansion of inclusive Education is often not matched by a proportional adaptation of infrastructure, staffing, and financing, making the effectiveness of institutional management difficult to measure. This study examines the institutional adaptation of Kazakhstan's inclusive education system to changes in the target group size and the temporal structure of the demand–coverage relationship. The study employs annual official time-series data for 2011–2025 on the number of children with special educational needs and the share of children with disabilities covered by individual educational programmes, applying dynamic analysis, compound annual growth rates, elasticity coefficients, segmented regression with a structural-break dummy variable and lagged correlation, and proposes an Institutional Adaptation Index (IIA). The results show that the IIA declined from 100% in 2011 to 53.3% in 2023 while the uncovered share of the target group rose from 44.7% to 62.8%; in 2024–2025 the index recovered to 88.8% and 94.4%, the uncovered share fell to 17.6%, the structural break is significant (R² = 0.970; F = 159.20; p < 0.001), and the strongest association appears at a two-year lag (r = 0.827; p < 0.001). The findings suggest that the system moved from a prolonged accumulation of a relative institutional gap to its accelerated reduction, with a delayed response characteristic of strong institutions emerging after a lag.
- 30 September 2026
- Published by Centre for Research on Islamic Banking and Finance and Business in Bangladesh Journal of Multidisciplinary Scientific Research
- Vol. 6 (11) , 17-29
Open AccessASSESSING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INSTITUTIONAL MANAGEMENT IN THE ADAPTATION OF INCLUSIVE EDUCATION SYSTEMS: QUALITY EDUCATION, REDUCED INEQUALITIES AND STRONG INSTITUTIONS IN KAZAKHSTAN
The rapid growth in the number of children with special educational needs places increasing pressure on the institutional capacity of education systems, and the timeliness of coverage responses to changes in the target group has become a central concern for quality education and reducing inequalities. Formal expansion of inclusive Education is often not matched by a proportional adaptation of infrastructure, staffing, and financing, making the effectiveness of institutional management difficult to measure. This study examines the institutional adaptation of Kazakhstan's inclusive education system to changes in the target group size and the temporal structure of the demand–coverage relationship. The study employs annual official time-series data for 2011–2025 on the number of children with special educational needs and the share of children with disabilities covered by individual educational programmes, applying dynamic analysis, compound annual growth rates, elasticity coefficients, segmented regression with a structural-break dummy variable and lagged correlation, and proposes an Institutional Adaptation Index (IIA). The results show that the IIA declined from 100% in 2011 to 53.3% in 2023 while the uncovered share of the target group rose from 44.7% to 62.8%; in 2024–2025 the index recovered to 88.8% and 94.4%, the uncovered share fell to 17.6%, the structural break is significant (R² = 0.970; F = 159.20; p < 0.001), and the strongest association appears at a two-year lag (r = 0.827; p < 0.001). The findings suggest that the system moved from a prolonged accumulation of a relative institutional gap to its accelerated reduction, with a delayed response characteristic of strong institutions emerging after a lag.
- Open Access
- 19 September 2026
- Published by Centre for Research on Islamic Banking and Finance and Business in Bangladesh Journal of Multidisciplinary Scientific Research
- Vol. 11 (5) , 35-44
SYSTEMIC EFFECTS OF QUASI-PUBLIC SECTOR REFORM IN KAZAKHSTAN: AN ANALYTICAL MODEL OF MULTIPLIER IMPACT ON SUSTAINABLE ECONOMIC GROWTH, INDUSTRY AND STRONG INSTITUTIONS
Reform of the quasi-public sector is a key direction of structural transformation in Kazakhstan, where state-owned and state-controlled organizations dominate the mining, energy, transport, and infrastructure sectors. Existing assessments of the reform focus on the number of privatized assets and budget revenues and do not capture its systemic impact on sustainable economic growth, industrial development, and the quality of institutions. This study develops and applies an analytical model to assess the systemic effects of reforming the quasi-public sector in Kazakhstan and to determine the potential for its multiplier impact across economic sectors. The study employs official annual time-series data of Kazakhstan's Bureau of National Statistics for 2018–2024 on gross value added (GVA), GDP share, labour productivity and enterprise-size structure, analyzed through structural-dynamic analysis, the Herfindahl–Hirschman Index (HHI), an integrated index of reform effectiveness (IQSR) and Leontief inter-sectoral analysis. The results show that sectoral GVA grew by 87.1% while its share of GDP declined from 16.15% to 13.67%, labour productivity of large enterprises rose by 59.3%, the share of large organizations in sectoral GVA fell by 6.37 percentage points and that of medium-sized organizations rose by 6.23 percentage points, the HHI decreased from 0.7352 to 0.6447, and the IQSR increased from 0.033 to 1.000. The findings suggest that the reform is accompanied by a gradual decentralization of economic activity and productivity gains that support decent work and economic growth. At the same time, state participation remains concentrated in strategic industries, so the reform's effectiveness depends on the quality of governance and institutions rather than on the scale of privatization alone.
- 19 September 2026
- Published by Centre for Research on Islamic Banking and Finance and Business in Bangladesh Journal of Multidisciplinary Scientific Research
- Vol. 11 (5) , 35-44
Open AccessSYSTEMIC EFFECTS OF QUASI-PUBLIC SECTOR REFORM IN KAZAKHSTAN: AN ANALYTICAL MODEL OF MULTIPLIER IMPACT ON SUSTAINABLE ECONOMIC GROWTH, INDUSTRY AND STRONG INSTITUTIONS
Reform of the quasi-public sector is a key direction of structural transformation in Kazakhstan, where state-owned and state-controlled organizations dominate the mining, energy, transport, and infrastructure sectors. Existing assessments of the reform focus on the number of privatized assets and budget revenues and do not capture its systemic impact on sustainable economic growth, industrial development, and the quality of institutions. This study develops and applies an analytical model to assess the systemic effects of reforming the quasi-public sector in Kazakhstan and to determine the potential for its multiplier impact across economic sectors. The study employs official annual time-series data of Kazakhstan's Bureau of National Statistics for 2018–2024 on gross value added (GVA), GDP share, labour productivity and enterprise-size structure, analyzed through structural-dynamic analysis, the Herfindahl–Hirschman Index (HHI), an integrated index of reform effectiveness (IQSR) and Leontief inter-sectoral analysis. The results show that sectoral GVA grew by 87.1% while its share of GDP declined from 16.15% to 13.67%, labour productivity of large enterprises rose by 59.3%, the share of large organizations in sectoral GVA fell by 6.37 percentage points and that of medium-sized organizations rose by 6.23 percentage points, the HHI decreased from 0.7352 to 0.6447, and the IQSR increased from 0.033 to 1.000. The findings suggest that the reform is accompanied by a gradual decentralization of economic activity and productivity gains that support decent work and economic growth. At the same time, state participation remains concentrated in strategic industries, so the reform's effectiveness depends on the quality of governance and institutions rather than on the scale of privatization alone.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2026
- Published by Centre for Research on Islamic Banking and Finance and Business in Bangladesh Journal of Multidisciplinary Scientific Research
- Vol. 11 (4) , 54-61
TRANSFORMATION OF TACTICS FOR CONDUCTING VERBAL INVESTIGATIVE ACTIONS IN THE CONTEXT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE TOOLS: STRENGTHENING JUSTICE, STRONG INSTITUTIONS AND RESPONSIBLE INNOVATION
Artificial intelligence (AI) is entering criminal proceedings faster than forensic tactics governing interrogations, confrontations, on-site verification, and clarification of testimony can be rethought. These verbal investigative actions remain the stage at which the fairness of a criminal process, and hence access to justice and strong institutions, is most exposed to coercion, error and false confession. The study develops a scientifically grounded model of how the tactics of verbal investigative actions are transformed when an investigator gains access to AI tools, and it tests three propositions about the assistive nature of AI, the loop structure of its influence, and the need for legally informed data labelling. The study employs a doctrinal, comparative-legal, and modelling design, applied to 25 scholarly sources published in 2010–2026, five normative acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the European Union, the practice of five European jurisdictions, and the technical specification of a patented prototype developed under project BR28712219. The results show that the tactical effect of AI is distributed across four functionally linked loops (preparatory, communicative, recording-analytical and control), that each loop carries one dominant risk and one procedural safeguard, and that the prototype records four synchronized video channels at 1920×1080 and at least 25 fps together with 16 kHz PCM audio, the format required by current speech-recognition engines. The findings of this study suggest that AI transforms verbal investigative actions by changing the quality of information support rather than the subject of decision-making, that a human-centric model is the only one compatible with procedural safeguards, and that responsible innovation in this field depends on a systematic annotation methodology, because arbitrary labeling reproduces annotator errors instead of forensic patterns.
- 18 September 2026
- Published by Centre for Research on Islamic Banking and Finance and Business in Bangladesh Journal of Multidisciplinary Scientific Research
- Vol. 11 (4) , 54-61
Open AccessTRANSFORMATION OF TACTICS FOR CONDUCTING VERBAL INVESTIGATIVE ACTIONS IN THE CONTEXT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE TOOLS: STRENGTHENING JUSTICE, STRONG INSTITUTIONS AND RESPONSIBLE INNOVATION
Artificial intelligence (AI) is entering criminal proceedings faster than forensic tactics governing interrogations, confrontations, on-site verification, and clarification of testimony can be rethought. These verbal investigative actions remain the stage at which the fairness of a criminal process, and hence access to justice and strong institutions, is most exposed to coercion, error and false confession. The study develops a scientifically grounded model of how the tactics of verbal investigative actions are transformed when an investigator gains access to AI tools, and it tests three propositions about the assistive nature of AI, the loop structure of its influence, and the need for legally informed data labelling. The study employs a doctrinal, comparative-legal, and modelling design, applied to 25 scholarly sources published in 2010–2026, five normative acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the European Union, the practice of five European jurisdictions, and the technical specification of a patented prototype developed under project BR28712219. The results show that the tactical effect of AI is distributed across four functionally linked loops (preparatory, communicative, recording-analytical and control), that each loop carries one dominant risk and one procedural safeguard, and that the prototype records four synchronized video channels at 1920×1080 and at least 25 fps together with 16 kHz PCM audio, the format required by current speech-recognition engines. The findings of this study suggest that AI transforms verbal investigative actions by changing the quality of information support rather than the subject of decision-making, that a human-centric model is the only one compatible with procedural safeguards, and that responsible innovation in this field depends on a systematic annotation methodology, because arbitrary labeling reproduces annotator errors instead of forensic patterns.
- Open Access
- 18 September 2026
- Published by Centre for Research on Islamic Banking and Finance and Business in Bangladesh Journal of Multidisciplinary Scientific Research
- Vol. 11 (4) , 41-53
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT OF THE EDUCATIONAL PROCESS UNDER ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IMPLEMENTATION: QUALITY EDUCATION, DECENT WORK, AND HUMAN CAPITAL FOR THE TRANSFORMING LABOR MARKET OF KAZAKHSTAN
The accelerated diffusion of generative artificial intelligence in higher education has outpaced the institutional rules that define where machine assistance should end and academic judgement should begin, leaving universities without clear boundaries for substituting for teaching labour and placing the quality education and decent work agendas at risk. This study examines how Kazakhstan's educational potential relates to labour productivity and develops a strategic model that allocates functions between the instructor and artificial intelligence. The study employs annual time-series data from the Bureau of National Statistics of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2018-2025, covering eleven labour market and human capital indicators. It applies Pearson correlation analysis to indicator levels, first differences, and growth rates, and is complemented by functional-systemic classification and expert-analytical generalisation. The results reveal that gross value added per employee correlates strongly with wage employees (r = 0.995, p < 0.001), with employees holding higher and postgraduate qualifications (r = 0.913, p = 0.002), and with technical and vocational graduates (r = 0.931, p = 0.001), and inversely with total (r = -0.857, p = 0.007) and youth unemployment (r = -0.886, p = 0.003). In first differences, the education-productivity association falls to r = 0.297 (p = 0.518) and to r = 0.074 (p = 0.876) in growth rates, while wage employment retains r = 0.797 (p = 0.032). The findings suggest that level associations reflect a shared trend rather than an annual return in graduate numbers, and that productivity responds to the composition of competencies rather than to the volume of educational output.
- 18 September 2026
- Published by Centre for Research on Islamic Banking and Finance and Business in Bangladesh Journal of Multidisciplinary Scientific Research
- Vol. 11 (4) , 41-53
Open AccessSTRATEGIC MANAGEMENT OF THE EDUCATIONAL PROCESS UNDER ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IMPLEMENTATION: QUALITY EDUCATION, DECENT WORK, AND HUMAN CAPITAL FOR THE TRANSFORMING LABOR MARKET OF KAZAKHSTAN
The accelerated diffusion of generative artificial intelligence in higher education has outpaced the institutional rules that define where machine assistance should end and academic judgement should begin, leaving universities without clear boundaries for substituting for teaching labour and placing the quality education and decent work agendas at risk. This study examines how Kazakhstan's educational potential relates to labour productivity and develops a strategic model that allocates functions between the instructor and artificial intelligence. The study employs annual time-series data from the Bureau of National Statistics of the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2018-2025, covering eleven labour market and human capital indicators. It applies Pearson correlation analysis to indicator levels, first differences, and growth rates, and is complemented by functional-systemic classification and expert-analytical generalisation. The results reveal that gross value added per employee correlates strongly with wage employees (r = 0.995, p < 0.001), with employees holding higher and postgraduate qualifications (r = 0.913, p = 0.002), and with technical and vocational graduates (r = 0.931, p = 0.001), and inversely with total (r = -0.857, p = 0.007) and youth unemployment (r = -0.886, p = 0.003). In first differences, the education-productivity association falls to r = 0.297 (p = 0.518) and to r = 0.074 (p = 0.876) in growth rates, while wage employment retains r = 0.797 (p = 0.032). The findings suggest that level associations reflect a shared trend rather than an annual return in graduate numbers, and that productivity responds to the composition of competencies rather than to the volume of educational output.