Top nine pitfalls to avoid when writing a journal peer review report
Open Access
- 21 March 2025
- journal article
- Published by Scientific Scholar in Journal of Musculoskeletal Surgery and Research
- Vol. 9, 165-169
Abstract
Journal editors fundamentally rely on peer reviewers to make informed decisions on the scientific validity of submitted manuscripts and whether or not to publish them. Consequently, improving the peer reviewers’ skills of early career researchers is paramount to a critical appraisal of evidence and the credibility of the medical literature. Academic institutions are responsible for developing early career researchers’ peer review skills. However, extra-curricular efforts are also needed to achieve that goal. Undue manuscript rejection or acceptance could mislead clinical practice, misguide public health policies, and even discourage authors from disseminating their research outcomes. Attention to the most common pitfalls of writing a peer review report and adherence to standard reviewer reporting guidelines could improve the quality of evidence and reliability of recommendations delivered to the scientific community. This report underscores the most common pitfalls to avoid, together with tips to follow when writing a journal peer-review report. It specifically uncovers misconceptions regarding research novelty, level of evidence, clinical versus academic skills, handling of methodologic flaws, reporting bias, discussion functions, study limitations, formulating valid conclusions, and judging reference lists.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Inaccurate Citations Are Prevalent Within Orthopaedic Sports Medicine LiteratureArthroscopy, Sports Medicine, and Rehabilitation, 2024
- A Gap Between Evidence-Based Research and Clinical Practice in Management of Hip FracturesJAMA Network Open, 2023
- A Pilot Survey of Authors’ Experiences with Poor Peer Review PracticesbioRxiv, 2022
- Peer review: concepts, variants and controversiesSingapore Medical Journal, 2022
- Overburdening of peer reviewers: A multi‐stakeholder perspective on causes and effectsLearned Publishing, 2021
- Reasons for Manuscript Rejection After Peer Review From the Journal HeadacheHeadache: The Journal of Head and Face Pain, 2018
- Methodological reporting quality of randomized controlled trials: A survey of seven core journals of orthopaedics from Mainland China over 5 years following the CONSORT statementOrthopaedics & Traumatology: Surgery & Research, 2016
- Bias due to selective inclusion and reporting of outcomes and analyses in systematic reviews of randomised trials of healthcare interventionsCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2014
- Manuscript rejection in ophthalmology and visual science journals: identifying and avoiding the common pitfallsClinical & Experimental Ophthalmology, 2009
- Study design, originality and overall consistency influence acceptance or rejection of manuscripts submitted to the JournalCanadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie, 2004