Tamer Ahmed El-Sobky
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Tamer Ahmed El-Sobky has a total of 103 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Shady Samir
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Division of Pediatric Orthopedics, Faculty of Medicine, Ain Shams University, Cairo, Egypt
8 shared publicationsHala Abdulhady
Department of Physical Medicine & Rheumatology and Rehabilitation, Faculty of Medicine, Ain Shams University , Cairo
7 shared publicationsShady Mahmoud
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Ain Shams University
7 shared publications- Shady Mahmoud
Division of Paediatric Orthopaedics, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Ain-Shams University, Cairo, Egypt
6 shared publications - Solaf Mohamed Elsayed
Medical Genetics Department, Faculty of Medicine, Ain Shams University, Cairo, Egypt
6 shared publications John Amen
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Ain Shams University, Cairo, Egypt
4 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 September 2026
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 11, 1859654
Peer review contributions as a measure of academic distinction requirements of faculty promotion committees: rapid review of top-ranking universities
Introduction: Journal peer review expertise is a cornerstone of academic practice. However, research publication productivity often overshadows prepublication peer review as a marker of academic distinction. The objective of this review is to examine the status of peer review contributions as a criterion of academic performance within faculty promotion committees at leading universities. Methods: We reviewed handbooks, guidelines, and procedures related to faculty promotion and tenure on the official websites of the top 50 universities ranked by the QS World University Rankings 2025. Peer review, as a requirement of academic promotion, was identified and reported if it fell within the scope of, a) peer review reporting or authoring, b) peer review education or mentoring, or c) peer review training or learning. The primary assessment criteria governing academic promotion were reported. Results: Eight universities were excluded due to unavailable or inaccessible information on their websites, and 42 were included in the final analysis. Only 15 (36%) of the included top-ranking universities explicitly mentioned peer review as a criterion for assessing academic distinction. Of the 15 universities, 14 (93%) mentioned peer review in the context of peer review reporting or authoring such as peer reviewing of scientific manuscripts, sitting on editorial boards of major journals, and participation on peer review grant panels. Only 1 (2%) university mentioned peer review in the context of peer review education or mentoring. Discussion: Peer review contributions as a measure of academic distinction requirements of faculty promotion committees in top ranking universities are underrepresented and underrated. Faculty promotion committees are urged to reconsider the relative weight of peer review contributions in the promotion review process.
- 25 September 2026
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 11, 1859654
Open AccessPeer review contributions as a measure of academic distinction requirements of faculty promotion committees: rapid review of top-ranking universities
Introduction: Journal peer review expertise is a cornerstone of academic practice. However, research publication productivity often overshadows prepublication peer review as a marker of academic distinction. The objective of this review is to examine the status of peer review contributions as a criterion of academic performance within faculty promotion committees at leading universities. Methods: We reviewed handbooks, guidelines, and procedures related to faculty promotion and tenure on the official websites of the top 50 universities ranked by the QS World University Rankings 2025. Peer review, as a requirement of academic promotion, was identified and reported if it fell within the scope of, a) peer review reporting or authoring, b) peer review education or mentoring, or c) peer review training or learning. The primary assessment criteria governing academic promotion were reported. Results: Eight universities were excluded due to unavailable or inaccessible information on their websites, and 42 were included in the final analysis. Only 15 (36%) of the included top-ranking universities explicitly mentioned peer review as a criterion for assessing academic distinction. Of the 15 universities, 14 (93%) mentioned peer review in the context of peer review reporting or authoring such as peer reviewing of scientific manuscripts, sitting on editorial boards of major journals, and participation on peer review grant panels. Only 1 (2%) university mentioned peer review in the context of peer review education or mentoring. Discussion: Peer review contributions as a measure of academic distinction requirements of faculty promotion committees in top ranking universities are underrepresented and underrated. Faculty promotion committees are urged to reconsider the relative weight of peer review contributions in the promotion review process.
- Open Access
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Endocrinology
Severe Osteogenesis Imperfecta Due to Homozygous Glycine Substitutions in COL1A1 and COL1A2
Background: Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a rare monogenic bone fragility disorder most often caused by heterozygous pathogenic variants in COL1A1 and COL1A2, typically showing autosomal dominant inheritance. Biallelic pathogenic variants in these genes are rare and associated with Ehlers-Danlos–like features or severe OI forms. Methods: Within a collaborative study on paediatric bone fragility in Egyptian patients, we performed whole-exome sequencing and segregation analysis in families with suspected OI. Furthermore, we systematically analyzed triple-helical-domain glycine substitutions found in unaffected individuals using gnomAD 4.1. Results: Two unrelated females with severe OI were identified carrying homozygous glycine substitutions, one patient in COL1A1 (c.1012G>A; p.(Gly338Ser)), the other in COL1A2 (c.1730G>C; p.(Gly577Ala)). Both presented with features typical for OI type III/IV. The heterozygous parents carrying the COL1A1 variant were asymptomatic, whereas those carrying the COL1A2 variant had OI type I. Analysis of triple-helical-domain glycine substitutions found in unaffected individuals in gnomAD showed that glycine residues in proximity to the N-terminal region of the COL1A1 triple-helix domain exhibit greater tolerance to substitutions which was not found for COL1A2. Discussion: We report the second patient with a homozygous glycine substitution within the triple-helical domain of COL1A1 associated with severe OI, and the sixth patient with a homozygous glycine substitution within the triple-helical domain of COL1A2. While glycine substitutions in type I collagen genes are classically dominant and fully penetrant, some can cause severe OI with autosomal recessive or double-dominant inheritance patterns, highlighting the variable expressivity and complexity of type I collagen–related disorders.
- 15 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Endocrinology
Open AccessSevere Osteogenesis Imperfecta Due to Homozygous Glycine Substitutions in COL1A1 and COL1A2
Background: Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a rare monogenic bone fragility disorder most often caused by heterozygous pathogenic variants in COL1A1 and COL1A2, typically showing autosomal dominant inheritance. Biallelic pathogenic variants in these genes are rare and associated with Ehlers-Danlos–like features or severe OI forms. Methods: Within a collaborative study on paediatric bone fragility in Egyptian patients, we performed whole-exome sequencing and segregation analysis in families with suspected OI. Furthermore, we systematically analyzed triple-helical-domain glycine substitutions found in unaffected individuals using gnomAD 4.1. Results: Two unrelated females with severe OI were identified carrying homozygous glycine substitutions, one patient in COL1A1 (c.1012G>A; p.(Gly338Ser)), the other in COL1A2 (c.1730G>C; p.(Gly577Ala)). Both presented with features typical for OI type III/IV. The heterozygous parents carrying the COL1A1 variant were asymptomatic, whereas those carrying the COL1A2 variant had OI type I. Analysis of triple-helical-domain glycine substitutions found in unaffected individuals in gnomAD showed that glycine residues in proximity to the N-terminal region of the COL1A1 triple-helix domain exhibit greater tolerance to substitutions which was not found for COL1A2. Discussion: We report the second patient with a homozygous glycine substitution within the triple-helical domain of COL1A1 associated with severe OI, and the sixth patient with a homozygous glycine substitution within the triple-helical domain of COL1A2. While glycine substitutions in type I collagen genes are classically dominant and fully penetrant, some can cause severe OI with autosomal recessive or double-dominant inheritance patterns, highlighting the variable expressivity and complexity of type I collagen–related disorders.
- Open Access
- 26 March 2026
- Published by Scientific Scholar in Journal of Musculoskeletal Surgery and Research
- p. 1-7
Guidance on navigating the research gap in medical literature and points of caution
Delineating a relevant research gap is an intricate and multifold process. Research gaps may arise from deficiencies in research design, execution, or reporting of published studies. Therefore, study conclusions and interpretations should not be taken for granted. They should rather be weighed against the particulars of research design and execution. Basing research proposal decisions solely on unverified study conclusions and interpretations could lead to the delineation of irrelevant research gaps, wasteful research efforts, and the propagation of inaccurate information. Accurate outlining of a relevant research gap requires competent academic critical appraisal skills. Envisioning research ideas that are relevant to clinical practice or public health requires a thorough and systematic reassessment of the existing literature for breaches of evidence and integrity. The objective of this report was to provide guidance on the essential skills required to elaborate a clear and scientifically valid research gap and a research hypothesis thereof. Furthermore, we aimed to highlight areas of concern or potential pitfalls that require attention.
- 26 March 2026
- Published by Scientific Scholar in Journal of Musculoskeletal Surgery and Research
- p. 1-7
Open AccessGuidance on navigating the research gap in medical literature and points of caution
Delineating a relevant research gap is an intricate and multifold process. Research gaps may arise from deficiencies in research design, execution, or reporting of published studies. Therefore, study conclusions and interpretations should not be taken for granted. They should rather be weighed against the particulars of research design and execution. Basing research proposal decisions solely on unverified study conclusions and interpretations could lead to the delineation of irrelevant research gaps, wasteful research efforts, and the propagation of inaccurate information. Accurate outlining of a relevant research gap requires competent academic critical appraisal skills. Envisioning research ideas that are relevant to clinical practice or public health requires a thorough and systematic reassessment of the existing literature for breaches of evidence and integrity. The objective of this report was to provide guidance on the essential skills required to elaborate a clear and scientifically valid research gap and a research hypothesis thereof. Furthermore, we aimed to highlight areas of concern or potential pitfalls that require attention.
- Open Access
- 16 December 2025
- Published by Scientific Scholar in Journal of Musculoskeletal Surgery and Research
- Vol. 10, 163-172
Development of a multicenter cerebral palsy registry in three Arabic-speaking countries: Preliminary results
Objectives: The objective of the study is to develop a multicenter cerebral palsy (CP) register in Arabic-speaking countries (ASCs) and nationally-driven evidence-based research to better inform clinical practice. Methods: A multicenter CP register study was conducted across five major institutions in three ASCs, namely Egypt, Tunisia, and Qatar. We included 390 children/adolescents, 217 males, who regularly attend the outpatient/inpatient wards aged 2–18 years with a medical diagnosis of CP. A physician-administered de-identified electronic form was used to collect data and collected data comprised patient- and physician-reported items. Results: CP burden was considerable. Perinatal risk factors included: prematurity (27.4%), antenatal illness (23.7%), and neonatal intensive care unit admission (55.1%). Comorbidities: Epilepsy (31.0%), cognitive (32.4%), visual (18.9%), auditory (6.4%), and speech (45.5%) impairments. Comorbidities were significantly correlated with musculoskeletal disease severity, for example, epilepsy (χ 2 = 23.31, P =0.000) and (χ 2 = 32.50, P = 0.000). Healthcare services were underutilized. 86.2% and 85.6% did not receive any form of orthopedic surgery or Botox injections, respectively. Only 59.0% received physiotherapy as part of regular healthcare follow-up. Conclusion: The health burden of CP in the studied sample of ASCs was considerable in terms of potentially controllable risk factors, comorbidities, and disease severity/complications. This suggests that the national burden of CP is substantial. Health policy makers in ASCs are urged to consider the current interpretations. Expanding the coverage of this Arabic CP register by including more participating medical institutions from ASCs can help us arrive at more reliable conclusions and better guide our clinical practice.
- 16 December 2025
- Published by Scientific Scholar in Journal of Musculoskeletal Surgery and Research
- Vol. 10, 163-172
Open AccessDevelopment of a multicenter cerebral palsy registry in three Arabic-speaking countries: Preliminary results
Objectives: The objective of the study is to develop a multicenter cerebral palsy (CP) register in Arabic-speaking countries (ASCs) and nationally-driven evidence-based research to better inform clinical practice. Methods: A multicenter CP register study was conducted across five major institutions in three ASCs, namely Egypt, Tunisia, and Qatar. We included 390 children/adolescents, 217 males, who regularly attend the outpatient/inpatient wards aged 2–18 years with a medical diagnosis of CP. A physician-administered de-identified electronic form was used to collect data and collected data comprised patient- and physician-reported items. Results: CP burden was considerable. Perinatal risk factors included: prematurity (27.4%), antenatal illness (23.7%), and neonatal intensive care unit admission (55.1%). Comorbidities: Epilepsy (31.0%), cognitive (32.4%), visual (18.9%), auditory (6.4%), and speech (45.5%) impairments. Comorbidities were significantly correlated with musculoskeletal disease severity, for example, epilepsy (χ 2 = 23.31, P =0.000) and (χ 2 = 32.50, P = 0.000). Healthcare services were underutilized. 86.2% and 85.6% did not receive any form of orthopedic surgery or Botox injections, respectively. Only 59.0% received physiotherapy as part of regular healthcare follow-up. Conclusion: The health burden of CP in the studied sample of ASCs was considerable in terms of potentially controllable risk factors, comorbidities, and disease severity/complications. This suggests that the national burden of CP is substantial. Health policy makers in ASCs are urged to consider the current interpretations. Expanding the coverage of this Arabic CP register by including more participating medical institutions from ASCs can help us arrive at more reliable conclusions and better guide our clinical practice.
- 3 July 2025
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics
Most Coronal Knee Deformities of Healed Nutritional Rickets Under 8 Years of Age Remodel Spontaneously: Building Evidence for Practice Change
Background: Nutritional rickets remains a global health burden. The optimal management of coronal knee deformities in children/adolescents with healed nutritional rickets as to the indications of conservative treatment versus guided growth surgery remains unsettled. The objective was to report the natural history of disease regarding the remodeling potential of coronal knee deformities and isolate potential patient- and deformity-related factors that are predictors of favorable deformity remodeling. Methods: We prospectively assessed 109 knees in 57 patients—mean age, 6.1 years (range, 2 to 12)—for spontaneous correction of their coronal knee deformities over a period of 1 year. Male/female:33/24, valgum/varum:34/23, bilateral/unilateral:52/5 patients. Outcome variables were, radiologic tibiofemoral angle and a questionnaire to assess parent satisfaction. They were correlated to independent patient- and deformity-related variables, including age, sex, deformity direction/severity, and laterality. Results: The mean age of patients that achieved complete knee remodeling (4.9 y) was significantly lower compared with patients who experienced complete failure of remodeling (8.4 y), P=0.000, (95% CI, 4.3-5.4). In 109 knees, there was a highly significant negative Spearman correlation coefficient between age and degrees of coronal correction, patient satisfaction, and complete failure of remodeling R=−0.660, R=−0.475, R=−0.434, respectively, P8 years of age that failed to remodel (87.5%) was significantly higher compared with patients ≤8 years (29.9%), P=0.000, OR=16.4, (95% CI, 5.2-52.2). There were statistically significant correlations between deformity severity/tibiofemoral angle and the remodeling potential, with a cutoff angle of 16.5 degrees/13 degrees for valgum/varum above which deformities were less likely to remodel spontaneously, P=0.03, P=0.007. Complete knee remodeling in unilateral deformities was statistically but not clinically significant. Correlations of sex and deformity direction with remodeling outcomes were insignificant. The inter- and intrarater agreements were excellent for the radiologic tibiofemoral angle measurements (ICC=0.993, CI, 0.982-0.997, P P <0.01), respectively. Conclusion: Children with coronal knee deformities of healed nutritional rickets under the age of 8 years should be given the full opportunity to remodel spontaneously for at least 1 year, particularly children with moderate deformities ≤16 degrees. This is irrespective of sex, deformity direction, and laterality. Most deformities remodel spontaneously. This suggests that these deformities may be overtreated. This could reduce unnecessary surgeries and potentiate cost-effectiveness of treatment and risk-benefit profile. Level of Evidence: Level IV prognostic studies—investigating the effect of a patient characteristic on the outcome of disease.
- 3 July 2025
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics
Most Coronal Knee Deformities of Healed Nutritional Rickets Under 8 Years of Age Remodel Spontaneously: Building Evidence for Practice Change
Background: Nutritional rickets remains a global health burden. The optimal management of coronal knee deformities in children/adolescents with healed nutritional rickets as to the indications of conservative treatment versus guided growth surgery remains unsettled. The objective was to report the natural history of disease regarding the remodeling potential of coronal knee deformities and isolate potential patient- and deformity-related factors that are predictors of favorable deformity remodeling. Methods: We prospectively assessed 109 knees in 57 patients—mean age, 6.1 years (range, 2 to 12)—for spontaneous correction of their coronal knee deformities over a period of 1 year. Male/female:33/24, valgum/varum:34/23, bilateral/unilateral:52/5 patients. Outcome variables were, radiologic tibiofemoral angle and a questionnaire to assess parent satisfaction. They were correlated to independent patient- and deformity-related variables, including age, sex, deformity direction/severity, and laterality. Results: The mean age of patients that achieved complete knee remodeling (4.9 y) was significantly lower compared with patients who experienced complete failure of remodeling (8.4 y), P=0.000, (95% CI, 4.3-5.4). In 109 knees, there was a highly significant negative Spearman correlation coefficient between age and degrees of coronal correction, patient satisfaction, and complete failure of remodeling R=−0.660, R=−0.475, R=−0.434, respectively, P8 years of age that failed to remodel (87.5%) was significantly higher compared with patients ≤8 years (29.9%), P=0.000, OR=16.4, (95% CI, 5.2-52.2). There were statistically significant correlations between deformity severity/tibiofemoral angle and the remodeling potential, with a cutoff angle of 16.5 degrees/13 degrees for valgum/varum above which deformities were less likely to remodel spontaneously, P=0.03, P=0.007. Complete knee remodeling in unilateral deformities was statistically but not clinically significant. Correlations of sex and deformity direction with remodeling outcomes were insignificant. The inter- and intrarater agreements were excellent for the radiologic tibiofemoral angle measurements (ICC=0.993, CI, 0.982-0.997, P P <0.01), respectively. Conclusion: Children with coronal knee deformities of healed nutritional rickets under the age of 8 years should be given the full opportunity to remodel spontaneously for at least 1 year, particularly children with moderate deformities ≤16 degrees. This is irrespective of sex, deformity direction, and laterality. Most deformities remodel spontaneously. This suggests that these deformities may be overtreated. This could reduce unnecessary surgeries and potentiate cost-effectiveness of treatment and risk-benefit profile. Level of Evidence: Level IV prognostic studies—investigating the effect of a patient characteristic on the outcome of disease.
- Open Access
- 21 March 2025
- Published by Scientific Scholar in Journal of Musculoskeletal Surgery and Research
- Vol. 9, 165-169
Top nine pitfalls to avoid when writing a journal peer review report
Journal editors fundamentally rely on peer reviewers to make informed decisions on the scientific validity of submitted manuscripts and whether or not to publish them. Consequently, improving the peer reviewers’ skills of early career researchers is paramount to a critical appraisal of evidence and the credibility of the medical literature. Academic institutions are responsible for developing early career researchers’ peer review skills. However, extra-curricular efforts are also needed to achieve that goal. Undue manuscript rejection or acceptance could mislead clinical practice, misguide public health policies, and even discourage authors from disseminating their research outcomes. Attention to the most common pitfalls of writing a peer review report and adherence to standard reviewer reporting guidelines could improve the quality of evidence and reliability of recommendations delivered to the scientific community. This report underscores the most common pitfalls to avoid, together with tips to follow when writing a journal peer-review report. It specifically uncovers misconceptions regarding research novelty, level of evidence, clinical versus academic skills, handling of methodologic flaws, reporting bias, discussion functions, study limitations, formulating valid conclusions, and judging reference lists.
- 21 March 2025
- Published by Scientific Scholar in Journal of Musculoskeletal Surgery and Research
- Vol. 9, 165-169
Open AccessTop nine pitfalls to avoid when writing a journal peer review report
Journal editors fundamentally rely on peer reviewers to make informed decisions on the scientific validity of submitted manuscripts and whether or not to publish them. Consequently, improving the peer reviewers’ skills of early career researchers is paramount to a critical appraisal of evidence and the credibility of the medical literature. Academic institutions are responsible for developing early career researchers’ peer review skills. However, extra-curricular efforts are also needed to achieve that goal. Undue manuscript rejection or acceptance could mislead clinical practice, misguide public health policies, and even discourage authors from disseminating their research outcomes. Attention to the most common pitfalls of writing a peer review report and adherence to standard reviewer reporting guidelines could improve the quality of evidence and reliability of recommendations delivered to the scientific community. This report underscores the most common pitfalls to avoid, together with tips to follow when writing a journal peer-review report. It specifically uncovers misconceptions regarding research novelty, level of evidence, clinical versus academic skills, handling of methodologic flaws, reporting bias, discussion functions, study limitations, formulating valid conclusions, and judging reference lists.
- Open Access
- 21 October 2024
- Published by Scientific Scholar in Journal of Musculoskeletal Surgery and Research
- Vol. 8 (4) , 326-334
Low prevalence of spin in conclusions of interventional pediatric orthopedic studies
Interpretation bias as a factor of research reporting quality has not been thoroughly investigated in the conclusions of pediatric orthopedic publications. Our objective was to investigate the prevalence, subtypes, and severity of research reporting bias or spin of the conclusions in full-texts and abstracts of published studies investigating the effects of treatment/intervention in the pediatric orthopedic literature. We systematically searched ten high-ranking orthopedic journals on MEDLINE/PubMed. Inclusion criteria were pediatric orthopedic studies investigating the effects of treatment/intervention. We used descriptive statistics to report the prevalence, subtype, and severity of reporting bias in the studies’ conclusions according to validated classification criteria. We checked the results to ensure that data were neither misreported nor misinterpreted/extrapolated in the conclusions of the full-texts and their abstracts. Out of 93 included studies in the final analysis, 17 (18%) had at least one count of bias. Nine (10%) studies had bias in both full-text and the corresponding abstract conclusions. In four (4%) studies, bias was restricted to conclusions of abstracts only, and in four (4%) studies was restricted to a bias criterion assigned to the classification criteria of conclusions of full-text only and not the We analyzed 2511 spin/bias items across 93 studies and reported 30 (1%) counts of bias in conclusions of full-text and/or abstracts. The intervention was surgical in (71%) of studies. Interventional pediatric orthopedic studies published in high-ranking journals showed a low prevalence of reporting bias, namely, misleading reporting, misinterpretation, and inadequate extrapolation of conclusions. A comparative analysis with lower-ranking journals as a control group may reveal if our favorable results are an attribute of journal rank/quality. In general, editorial policies should emphasize skilled interpretation and extrapolation of research results.
- 21 October 2024
- Published by Scientific Scholar in Journal of Musculoskeletal Surgery and Research
- Vol. 8 (4) , 326-334
Open AccessLow prevalence of spin in conclusions of interventional pediatric orthopedic studies
Interpretation bias as a factor of research reporting quality has not been thoroughly investigated in the conclusions of pediatric orthopedic publications. Our objective was to investigate the prevalence, subtypes, and severity of research reporting bias or spin of the conclusions in full-texts and abstracts of published studies investigating the effects of treatment/intervention in the pediatric orthopedic literature. We systematically searched ten high-ranking orthopedic journals on MEDLINE/PubMed. Inclusion criteria were pediatric orthopedic studies investigating the effects of treatment/intervention. We used descriptive statistics to report the prevalence, subtype, and severity of reporting bias in the studies’ conclusions according to validated classification criteria. We checked the results to ensure that data were neither misreported nor misinterpreted/extrapolated in the conclusions of the full-texts and their abstracts. Out of 93 included studies in the final analysis, 17 (18%) had at least one count of bias. Nine (10%) studies had bias in both full-text and the corresponding abstract conclusions. In four (4%) studies, bias was restricted to conclusions of abstracts only, and in four (4%) studies was restricted to a bias criterion assigned to the classification criteria of conclusions of full-text only and not the We analyzed 2511 spin/bias items across 93 studies and reported 30 (1%) counts of bias in conclusions of full-text and/or abstracts. The intervention was surgical in (71%) of studies. Interventional pediatric orthopedic studies published in high-ranking journals showed a low prevalence of reporting bias, namely, misleading reporting, misinterpretation, and inadequate extrapolation of conclusions. A comparative analysis with lower-ranking journals as a control group may reveal if our favorable results are an attribute of journal rank/quality. In general, editorial policies should emphasize skilled interpretation and extrapolation of research results.
- Open Access
- 13 September 2024
- Published by Medknow in African Journal of Paediatric Surgery
- Vol. 21 (4) , 273-277
Staged Shoulder and Elbow Reconstruction in a Child with Obstetric Brachial Plexus Palsy: Six-year Follow-up
The management of obstetric brachial plexus palsy (OBPP) can be challenging, particularly in neglected patients. We report the long-term results of the surgical management of a late-presenting adolescent girl with severe left shoulder and elbow flexor paralysis secondary to OBPP. She was subjected to staged shoulder and elbow reconstruction in the form of trapezius transfer and latissimus and teres major transfer to enhance shoulder abduction and lateral rotation, and flexor-pronator transfer to the anterior distal humerus to enhance elbow flexion. Flexor-pronator plasty was successful in restoring elbow flexion and function and maintaining joint stability in the long term in a patient with severe OBPP. This further consolidates its role as a feasible secondary reconstructive procedure in carefully selected patients with elbow flexor paralysis. Shoulder function improved less remarkably, yet it augmented the overall upper extremity function and correlated with pre-operative residual shoulder function. Fulfilling the candidacy for each surgical procedure is important to a successful outcome.
- 13 September 2024
- Published by Medknow in African Journal of Paediatric Surgery
- Vol. 21 (4) , 273-277
Open AccessStaged Shoulder and Elbow Reconstruction in a Child with Obstetric Brachial Plexus Palsy: Six-year Follow-up
The management of obstetric brachial plexus palsy (OBPP) can be challenging, particularly in neglected patients. We report the long-term results of the surgical management of a late-presenting adolescent girl with severe left shoulder and elbow flexor paralysis secondary to OBPP. She was subjected to staged shoulder and elbow reconstruction in the form of trapezius transfer and latissimus and teres major transfer to enhance shoulder abduction and lateral rotation, and flexor-pronator transfer to the anterior distal humerus to enhance elbow flexion. Flexor-pronator plasty was successful in restoring elbow flexion and function and maintaining joint stability in the long term in a patient with severe OBPP. This further consolidates its role as a feasible secondary reconstructive procedure in carefully selected patients with elbow flexor paralysis. Shoulder function improved less remarkably, yet it augmented the overall upper extremity function and correlated with pre-operative residual shoulder function. Fulfilling the candidacy for each surgical procedure is important to a successful outcome.
- Open Access
- 31 January 2024
- Published by Scientific Scholar in Journal of Musculoskeletal Surgery and Research
- Vol. 8 (1) , 11-23
Orthopedic manifestations of congenital muscular dystrophy subtypes in children: Emerging signatures need consolidation: a scoping review
Our objective was to screen the literature on congenital muscular dystrophy (CMD) children/adolescents regarding the extent/nature of reporting orthopedic manifestations/deformities and to assess its appropriateness in informing clinical practice/research. We searched PubMed for original research on orthopedic surgical/non-surgical manifestations of CMD. Eligible articles needed to focus on orthopedic manifestations/deformities as one of the study objectives with no restrictions on study designs/types or search period. Eight hundred and thirty articles were initially identified and screened. Following the exclusion of 501 articles for disagreeing titles/abstracts, 329 were available for eligibility assessment. Two hundred and fifty-five articles were excluded for reasons. Of one hundred articles, 15 were captured manually and 11 through pre-submission searches, with 1078 patients included in the final analysis. The most common subtype was Laminin alpha-2 (LAMA2)-relatedCMD. Orthopedic manifestations of CMD are generally underreported and insufficiently detailed. There is reliable evidence that accurate reporting of orthopedic manifestations can be a valuable clinical supplement to the complex differential diagnosis process in collagen VI-related CMD, LAMA2-related-CMD, LMNA-related-CMD, and SEPN1-related CMD (SELENON). For alpha dystroglycan-related CMD, there is insufficient information to delineate a subtype-specific pattern. There is emerging evidence that reporting spine surgery outcomes may facilitate orthopedic decision making. The greatest clinical/research utility was provided by articles with longitudinal, comprehensive, and correlative reporting of larger cohorts. Detailed reporting of the orthopedic phenotype of CMD in future research may further uncover its diagnostic potential.
- 31 January 2024
- Published by Scientific Scholar in Journal of Musculoskeletal Surgery and Research
- Vol. 8 (1) , 11-23
Open AccessOrthopedic manifestations of congenital muscular dystrophy subtypes in children: Emerging signatures need consolidation: a scoping review
Our objective was to screen the literature on congenital muscular dystrophy (CMD) children/adolescents regarding the extent/nature of reporting orthopedic manifestations/deformities and to assess its appropriateness in informing clinical practice/research. We searched PubMed for original research on orthopedic surgical/non-surgical manifestations of CMD. Eligible articles needed to focus on orthopedic manifestations/deformities as one of the study objectives with no restrictions on study designs/types or search period. Eight hundred and thirty articles were initially identified and screened. Following the exclusion of 501 articles for disagreeing titles/abstracts, 329 were available for eligibility assessment. Two hundred and fifty-five articles were excluded for reasons. Of one hundred articles, 15 were captured manually and 11 through pre-submission searches, with 1078 patients included in the final analysis. The most common subtype was Laminin alpha-2 (LAMA2)-relatedCMD. Orthopedic manifestations of CMD are generally underreported and insufficiently detailed. There is reliable evidence that accurate reporting of orthopedic manifestations can be a valuable clinical supplement to the complex differential diagnosis process in collagen VI-related CMD, LAMA2-related-CMD, LMNA-related-CMD, and SEPN1-related CMD (SELENON). For alpha dystroglycan-related CMD, there is insufficient information to delineate a subtype-specific pattern. There is emerging evidence that reporting spine surgery outcomes may facilitate orthopedic decision making. The greatest clinical/research utility was provided by articles with longitudinal, comprehensive, and correlative reporting of larger cohorts. Detailed reporting of the orthopedic phenotype of CMD in future research may further uncover its diagnostic potential.
- Open Access
- 23 August 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Integrity and Peer Review
- Vol. 8 (1) , 1-8
Reporting quality of abstracts and inconsistencies with full text articles in pediatric orthopedic publications
Background: Abstracts should provide a brief yet comprehensive reporting of all components of a manuscript. Inaccurate reporting may mislead readers and impact citation practices. It was our goal to investigate the reporting quality of abstracts of interventional observational studies in three major pediatric orthopedic journals and to analyze any reporting inconsistencies between those abstracts and their corresponding full-text articles. Methods: We selected a sample of 55 abstracts and their full-text articles published between 2018 and 2022. Included articles were primary therapeutic research investigating the results of treatments or interventions. Abstracts were scrutinized for reporting quality and inconsistencies with their full-text versions with a 22-itemized checklist. The reporting quality of titles was assessed by a 3-items categorical scale. Results: In 48 (87%) of articles there were abstract reporting inaccuracies related to patient demographics. The study's follow-up and complications were not reported in 21 (38%) of abstracts each. Most common inconsistencies between the abstracts and full-text articles were related to reporting of inclusion or exclusion criteria in 39 (71%) and study correlations in 27 (49%) of articles. Reporting quality of the titles was insufficient in 33 (60%) of articles. Conclusions: In our study we found low reporting quality of abstracts and noticeable inconsistencies with full-text articles, especially regarding inclusion or exclusion criteria and study correlations. While the current sample is likely not representative of overall pediatric orthopedic literature, we recommend that authors, reviewers, and editors ensure abstracts are reported accurately, ideally following the appropriate reporting guidelines, and that they double check that there are no inconsistencies between abstracts and full text articles. To capture essential study information, journals should also consider increasing abstract word limits.
- 23 August 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Integrity and Peer Review
- Vol. 8 (1) , 1-8
Open AccessReporting quality of abstracts and inconsistencies with full text articles in pediatric orthopedic publications
Background: Abstracts should provide a brief yet comprehensive reporting of all components of a manuscript. Inaccurate reporting may mislead readers and impact citation practices. It was our goal to investigate the reporting quality of abstracts of interventional observational studies in three major pediatric orthopedic journals and to analyze any reporting inconsistencies between those abstracts and their corresponding full-text articles. Methods: We selected a sample of 55 abstracts and their full-text articles published between 2018 and 2022. Included articles were primary therapeutic research investigating the results of treatments or interventions. Abstracts were scrutinized for reporting quality and inconsistencies with their full-text versions with a 22-itemized checklist. The reporting quality of titles was assessed by a 3-items categorical scale. Results: In 48 (87%) of articles there were abstract reporting inaccuracies related to patient demographics. The study's follow-up and complications were not reported in 21 (38%) of abstracts each. Most common inconsistencies between the abstracts and full-text articles were related to reporting of inclusion or exclusion criteria in 39 (71%) and study correlations in 27 (49%) of articles. Reporting quality of the titles was insufficient in 33 (60%) of articles. Conclusions: In our study we found low reporting quality of abstracts and noticeable inconsistencies with full-text articles, especially regarding inclusion or exclusion criteria and study correlations. While the current sample is likely not representative of overall pediatric orthopedic literature, we recommend that authors, reviewers, and editors ensure abstracts are reported accurately, ideally following the appropriate reporting guidelines, and that they double check that there are no inconsistencies between abstracts and full text articles. To capture essential study information, journals should also consider increasing abstract word limits.