Abstract
A large share of political fundraising email is routed to spam. Inbox placement for Republican committee email varies by 30 percentage points across mailbox providers on a typical week and moves by comparable amounts within provider over time; higher spam placement tracks lower Google search interest for GOP senators and lower Republican Senate implied probabilities on Kalshi and Polymarket. Two natural experiments in 2025 pin down the fundraising cost: a 78-day episode in which Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo routed emails containing WinRed donation links to spam while routing otherwise-identical ActBlue-linked emails to the inbox, and a separate Outlook-only placement drop in February-April. First-time donors on WinRed decline-74.6% in donation count during the June episode and-83.2% during the Outlook drop, with no analogous movement in the other DDD cells. The two episodes together cost 142,126 first-time donations over 167 days of filteringroughly 850 missing first-time donations for every day a link-based filter was active, worth about $700,000 in eight-month lifetime donor value per day. Pre-episode WinRed new donors give $461 on their first gift and cumulatively $827 over eight months, so the dollar cost of each missing first gift compounds well beyond the contemporaneous shortfall.