Promoting future teachers’ evidence-informed reasoning scripts: Effects of different forms of instruction after problem-solving
Open Access
- 5 May 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 8
Abstract
Pre-service teachers face difficulties when dealing with problem situations in the classroom if their evidence-informed reasoning script (EIRS) is not adequately developed. An EIRS might be promoted by demonstrating how to implement evidence-informed reasoning after a problem-solving activity on an authentic case. However, it is unclear what form of instruction is appropriate to promote pre-service teachers in the development of an EIRS. The present 2×3-factorial experimental intervention study investigated how different forms of instruction on functional procedures (example-free vs. example-based) and on dysfunctional procedures (without vs. example-free vs. example-based) affect the development of an EIRS. N = 384 pre-service teachers worked on a written case vignette of a problem situation in a problem-solving phase, in which the crucial steps of the EIRS were prompted externally. In the subsequent instruction phase, the participants compared their own solution with an example-free or example-based instruction on functional procedures, which was either supplemented by an example-free or example-based instruction on typical dysfunctional procedures or not at all. The participants’ learning success (declarative EIRS; near and far transfer problem-solving performance) and error awareness were assessed. The results revealed that the example-based instruction on functional procedures led to a higher learning success than the example-free instruction. Both forms of instruction on dysfunctional procedures improved learning success compared to learning without one. During learning, error awareness was higher for learners who worked with an example-free instruction on dysfunctional procedures. In order to promote the development of an EIRS in pre-service teachers, it is promising to provide instruction after problem-solving that presents a functional example of evidence-informed reasoning for the given problem and that also points out typical dysfunctional approaches to solving the problem. The results highlight the importance of selecting appropriate scaffolds in case-based learning approaches that aim to develop cognitive schemata. The mechanisms that explain when and why instructions on dysfunctional procedures work need to be further explored.Keywords
This publication has 72 references indexed in Scilit:
- Toward a Script Theory of Guidance in Computer-Supported Collaborative LearningEducational Psychologist, 2013
- Use of research-based information by school practitioners and determinants of use: a review of empirical researchEvidence & Policy, 2012
- Designing for Productive FailureJournal of the Learning Sciences, 2012
- Example-Based Learning: Integrating Cognitive and Social-Cognitive Research PerspectivesEducational Psychology Review, 2010
- Distinctive qualities of expert teachersTeachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice, 2009
- Why Minimal Guidance During Instruction Does Not Work: An Analysis of the Failure of Constructivist, Discovery, Problem-Based, Experiential, and Inquiry-Based TeachingEducational Psychologist, 2006
- Learning from Examples: Instructional Principles from the Worked Examples ResearchReview of Educational Research, 2000
- A Time For TellingCognition and Instruction, 1998
- ACT: A simple theory of complex cognition.American Psychologist, 1996
- Computer use by School-Age Children: Trends, Patterns, and PredictorsJournal of Educational Computing Research, 1995