Theresa Krause-Wichmann
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Theresa Krause-Wichmann has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Robin Stark
Department of Education, Saarland University, Saarbrücken, Germany
3 shared publications- Andrea Möller
Universität Wien
2 shared publications - Linda Hämmerle
Austrian Educational Competence Centre for Biology, Centre for Teacher Education, University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria
2 shared publications - Alexander Bergmann-Gering
University of Bamberg
1 shared publication - Christina Wekerle
University of Augsburg, Augsburg, Germany
1 shared publication Eric Klopp
Department of Education, Saarland University, Saarbrücken, Germany
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Instructional Science
- Vol. 54 (3) , 70
Learning the control-of-variables strategy through self-generated and vicarious errors: the mediating roles of affect, motivation, cognitive load, and error awareness
Controlled experiments are essential for causal reasoning, yet students struggle with the control-of-variables strategy (CVS). Self-generated errors, vicarious errors, or a combination could provide learning opportunities; however, error awareness, motivation, affect, and cognitive load may shape whether students benefit from different types of errors. This study examines the effect of self-generated, vicarious, combined, or no errors on CVS learning, and investigates affect, motivation, cognitive load, and error awareness as potential mediators. 255 seventh- and eighth-grade students (40% female) participated. In an experimental intervention study with three experimental groups and one control group, students engaged with experiments before receiving instruction and error-reflection prompts, following a problem-solving prior to instruction approach. We assessed CVS skills, affect, cognitive load, motivation, and error awareness. Analyses included ANCOVA, ANOVA, and path models. The self-generated errors group scored highest on the CVS-posttest, followed by the no-errors, vicarious errors, and combination groups. Group differences in CVS performance were not statistically significant, although all groups improved from pre- to posttest. No mediation effects were found for affect, motivation, or cognitive load. Error awareness positively predicted posttest performance, but negatively mediated the effect of self-generated errors on learning. Different types of errors and error-free examples were all associated with CVS learning gains, even though the different types did not differentially affect CVS learning outcomes when controlling for prior knowledge. Error awareness showed a complex pattern, being positively associated with performance while marginally negatively mediating the effect of self-generated errors. These findings highlight the need for further research to better understand the complex role of errors in science learning.
- 16 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Instructional Science
- Vol. 54 (3) , 70
Open AccessLearning the control-of-variables strategy through self-generated and vicarious errors: the mediating roles of affect, motivation, cognitive load, and error awareness
Controlled experiments are essential for causal reasoning, yet students struggle with the control-of-variables strategy (CVS). Self-generated errors, vicarious errors, or a combination could provide learning opportunities; however, error awareness, motivation, affect, and cognitive load may shape whether students benefit from different types of errors. This study examines the effect of self-generated, vicarious, combined, or no errors on CVS learning, and investigates affect, motivation, cognitive load, and error awareness as potential mediators. 255 seventh- and eighth-grade students (40% female) participated. In an experimental intervention study with three experimental groups and one control group, students engaged with experiments before receiving instruction and error-reflection prompts, following a problem-solving prior to instruction approach. We assessed CVS skills, affect, cognitive load, motivation, and error awareness. Analyses included ANCOVA, ANOVA, and path models. The self-generated errors group scored highest on the CVS-posttest, followed by the no-errors, vicarious errors, and combination groups. Group differences in CVS performance were not statistically significant, although all groups improved from pre- to posttest. No mediation effects were found for affect, motivation, or cognitive load. Error awareness positively predicted posttest performance, but negatively mediated the effect of self-generated errors on learning. Different types of errors and error-free examples were all associated with CVS learning gains, even though the different types did not differentially affect CVS learning outcomes when controlling for prior knowledge. Error awareness showed a complex pattern, being positively associated with performance while marginally negatively mediating the effect of self-generated errors. These findings highlight the need for further research to better understand the complex role of errors in science learning.
- Open Access
- 17 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Instructional Science
- Vol. 53 (6) , 1691-1714
Promoting future teachers’ pedagogical knowledge: The role of self-generated vs. provided illustrative examples after instruction
Illustrative examples demonstrate how abstract information can be applied in real-world. In the context of advancing evidence-informed teaching practice, the current intervention study investigated to what extent student teachers should be supported in learning educational theories and findings by different example-based approaches. Conducting a 1 × 3-factorial design, N = 105 student teachers were randomly assigned to three experimental groups: After a pre-test, all groups received the same learning instruction on the topic of cooperative learning. Then, (1) n = 35 students were prompted to generate own examples for the instructional text, (2) n = 35 students received examples along with the text, and (3) n = 35 students studied the text only, without any prompts or examples. In a post-questionnaire, it was retrospectively assessed how students perceived their learning control in engaging with the material; in a post-test, knowledge retention and knowledge transfer were measured. As assumed, findings revealed that generating examples enhanced perceived learning control and learning outcomes compared to studying provided examples. Students who learned with the instructional text only achieved lowest learning outcomes; but contrary to the expectations, these students perceived their learning control comparably high as those who generated examples. Mediation analyses indicated that for students who received illustrative examples or the instructional text only, a greater learning control perception was positively associated with knowledge retention, subsequently enhancing knowledge transfer. The study underscores the benefits of illustrative examples in teacher education, particularly when students engage in generating them. It suggests further examination of how and why example generation facilitates learning.
- 17 April 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Instructional Science
- Vol. 53 (6) , 1691-1714
Open AccessPromoting future teachers’ pedagogical knowledge: The role of self-generated vs. provided illustrative examples after instruction
Illustrative examples demonstrate how abstract information can be applied in real-world. In the context of advancing evidence-informed teaching practice, the current intervention study investigated to what extent student teachers should be supported in learning educational theories and findings by different example-based approaches. Conducting a 1 × 3-factorial design, N = 105 student teachers were randomly assigned to three experimental groups: After a pre-test, all groups received the same learning instruction on the topic of cooperative learning. Then, (1) n = 35 students were prompted to generate own examples for the instructional text, (2) n = 35 students received examples along with the text, and (3) n = 35 students studied the text only, without any prompts or examples. In a post-questionnaire, it was retrospectively assessed how students perceived their learning control in engaging with the material; in a post-test, knowledge retention and knowledge transfer were measured. As assumed, findings revealed that generating examples enhanced perceived learning control and learning outcomes compared to studying provided examples. Students who learned with the instructional text only achieved lowest learning outcomes; but contrary to the expectations, these students perceived their learning control comparably high as those who generated examples. Mediation analyses indicated that for students who received illustrative examples or the instructional text only, a greater learning control perception was positively associated with knowledge retention, subsequently enhancing knowledge transfer. The study underscores the benefits of illustrative examples in teacher education, particularly when students engage in generating them. It suggests further examination of how and why example generation facilitates learning.
- Open Access
- 25 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Science Education
- Vol. 48 (8) , 1197-1219
Investigating students’ awareness of their own and others’ deviations from controlled science experiments
- 25 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Science Education
- Vol. 48 (8) , 1197-1219
Open AccessInvestigating students’ awareness of their own and others’ deviations from controlled science experiments
- Open Access
- 5 May 2023
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 8
Promoting future teachers’ evidence-informed reasoning scripts: Effects of different forms of instruction after problem-solving
Pre-service teachers face difficulties when dealing with problem situations in the classroom if their evidence-informed reasoning script (EIRS) is not adequately developed. An EIRS might be promoted by demonstrating how to implement evidence-informed reasoning after a problem-solving activity on an authentic case. However, it is unclear what form of instruction is appropriate to promote pre-service teachers in the development of an EIRS. The present 2×3-factorial experimental intervention study investigated how different forms of instruction on functional procedures (example-free vs. example-based) and on dysfunctional procedures (without vs. example-free vs. example-based) affect the development of an EIRS. N = 384 pre-service teachers worked on a written case vignette of a problem situation in a problem-solving phase, in which the crucial steps of the EIRS were prompted externally. In the subsequent instruction phase, the participants compared their own solution with an example-free or example-based instruction on functional procedures, which was either supplemented by an example-free or example-based instruction on typical dysfunctional procedures or not at all. The participants’ learning success (declarative EIRS; near and far transfer problem-solving performance) and error awareness were assessed. The results revealed that the example-based instruction on functional procedures led to a higher learning success than the example-free instruction. Both forms of instruction on dysfunctional procedures improved learning success compared to learning without one. During learning, error awareness was higher for learners who worked with an example-free instruction on dysfunctional procedures. In order to promote the development of an EIRS in pre-service teachers, it is promising to provide instruction after problem-solving that presents a functional example of evidence-informed reasoning for the given problem and that also points out typical dysfunctional approaches to solving the problem. The results highlight the importance of selecting appropriate scaffolds in case-based learning approaches that aim to develop cognitive schemata. The mechanisms that explain when and why instructions on dysfunctional procedures work need to be further explored.
- 5 May 2023
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Education
- Vol. 8
Open AccessPromoting future teachers’ evidence-informed reasoning scripts: Effects of different forms of instruction after problem-solving
Pre-service teachers face difficulties when dealing with problem situations in the classroom if their evidence-informed reasoning script (EIRS) is not adequately developed. An EIRS might be promoted by demonstrating how to implement evidence-informed reasoning after a problem-solving activity on an authentic case. However, it is unclear what form of instruction is appropriate to promote pre-service teachers in the development of an EIRS. The present 2×3-factorial experimental intervention study investigated how different forms of instruction on functional procedures (example-free vs. example-based) and on dysfunctional procedures (without vs. example-free vs. example-based) affect the development of an EIRS. N = 384 pre-service teachers worked on a written case vignette of a problem situation in a problem-solving phase, in which the crucial steps of the EIRS were prompted externally. In the subsequent instruction phase, the participants compared their own solution with an example-free or example-based instruction on functional procedures, which was either supplemented by an example-free or example-based instruction on typical dysfunctional procedures or not at all. The participants’ learning success (declarative EIRS; near and far transfer problem-solving performance) and error awareness were assessed. The results revealed that the example-based instruction on functional procedures led to a higher learning success than the example-free instruction. Both forms of instruction on dysfunctional procedures improved learning success compared to learning without one. During learning, error awareness was higher for learners who worked with an example-free instruction on dysfunctional procedures. In order to promote the development of an EIRS in pre-service teachers, it is promising to provide instruction after problem-solving that presents a functional example of evidence-informed reasoning for the given problem and that also points out typical dysfunctional approaches to solving the problem. The results highlight the importance of selecting appropriate scaffolds in case-based learning approaches that aim to develop cognitive schemata. The mechanisms that explain when and why instructions on dysfunctional procedures work need to be further explored.
- Open Access
- 7 July 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Unterrichtswissenschaft
- Vol. 51 (2) , 289-313
Probleme evidenzorientierter Unterrichtspraxis
Zusammenfassung: In diesem Beitrag soll anhand eines fiktiven Anwendungsbeispiels aus der schulischen Unterrichtspraxis exemplarisch dargestellt werden, mit welchen Barrieren sich Lehrkräfte konfrontiert sehen, wenn sie individuelle unterrichtsbezogene Entscheidungen evidenzbasiert zu treffen versuchen. Es werden Stärken und Schwächen des Konzeptes der Evidenzbasierung sowie unterschiedlicher Arten von Evidenz und Forschungsdesigns (zum Beispiel Meta-Metaanalysen, Metaanalysen, Fallstudien) reflektiert und diskutiert. Unter anderem wird ein Vorgehen vorgeschlagen, welches sich weniger an der gängigen Evidenzhierarchie orientiert, an deren Spitze sich als „Gold-Standard“ systematische Reviews, Metaanalysen und randomisierte kontrollierte Studien finden, sondern vielmehr an übergeordneten Wissensbeständen (d. h. insbesondere an wissenschaftlichen Theorien und Konzepten, aber auch an einschlägigen wissenschaftlichen Ansätzen, Prinzipien und Modellen), welche aus der bildungswissenschaftlichen Forschung hervorgegangen sind. Zudem werden exemplarisch Planungsprozesse skizziert, welche die Qualität der Unterrichtspraxis mit einfachen Mitteln unterstützen können, indem wissenschaftliches Wissen, Erfahrungswissen und Kontextwissen sowie praktisches Handlungswissen integriert werden. Abschließend werden als eine mögliche Förderkomponente evidenzorientierter Unterrichtspraxis verschiedene Möglichkeiten zum weiteren Ausbau von Clearing Houses vorgeschlagen. Zudem wird auf Forschungsdesiderate hinsichtlich der Integration verschiedener, möglicherweise inkohärenter Wissensbestände hingewiesen. Dieser Beitrag hat nicht zum Ziel, die aktuellen Entwicklungen hin zu einer evidenzbasierten Schul- und Unterrichtspraxis in Frage zu stellen. Vielmehr wird eine evidenzorientierte Praxis im Sinne einer Orientierung anübergeordneten Wissensbeständenausdrücklich befürwortet.
- 7 July 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in Unterrichtswissenschaft
- Vol. 51 (2) , 289-313
Open AccessProbleme evidenzorientierter Unterrichtspraxis
Zusammenfassung: In diesem Beitrag soll anhand eines fiktiven Anwendungsbeispiels aus der schulischen Unterrichtspraxis exemplarisch dargestellt werden, mit welchen Barrieren sich Lehrkräfte konfrontiert sehen, wenn sie individuelle unterrichtsbezogene Entscheidungen evidenzbasiert zu treffen versuchen. Es werden Stärken und Schwächen des Konzeptes der Evidenzbasierung sowie unterschiedlicher Arten von Evidenz und Forschungsdesigns (zum Beispiel Meta-Metaanalysen, Metaanalysen, Fallstudien) reflektiert und diskutiert. Unter anderem wird ein Vorgehen vorgeschlagen, welches sich weniger an der gängigen Evidenzhierarchie orientiert, an deren Spitze sich als „Gold-Standard“ systematische Reviews, Metaanalysen und randomisierte kontrollierte Studien finden, sondern vielmehr an übergeordneten Wissensbeständen (d. h. insbesondere an wissenschaftlichen Theorien und Konzepten, aber auch an einschlägigen wissenschaftlichen Ansätzen, Prinzipien und Modellen), welche aus der bildungswissenschaftlichen Forschung hervorgegangen sind. Zudem werden exemplarisch Planungsprozesse skizziert, welche die Qualität der Unterrichtspraxis mit einfachen Mitteln unterstützen können, indem wissenschaftliches Wissen, Erfahrungswissen und Kontextwissen sowie praktisches Handlungswissen integriert werden. Abschließend werden als eine mögliche Förderkomponente evidenzorientierter Unterrichtspraxis verschiedene Möglichkeiten zum weiteren Ausbau von Clearing Houses vorgeschlagen. Zudem wird auf Forschungsdesiderate hinsichtlich der Integration verschiedener, möglicherweise inkohärenter Wissensbestände hingewiesen. Dieser Beitrag hat nicht zum Ziel, die aktuellen Entwicklungen hin zu einer evidenzbasierten Schul- und Unterrichtspraxis in Frage zu stellen. Vielmehr wird eine evidenzorientierte Praxis im Sinne einer Orientierung anübergeordneten Wissensbeständenausdrücklich befürwortet.