Around-Body Versus On-Body Motion Sensing: A Comparison of Efficacy Across a Range of Body Movements and Scales
Authors:
- Katelyn RohrerKRKatelyn Rohrer
- Luis De AndaLALuis De Anda
- Camila GrubbCGCamila Grubb
- Zachary HansenZHZachary Hansen
- Jordan RodriguezJRJordan Rodriguez
- Greyson St PierreGPGreyson St Pierre
- Sara SheikhlarySSSara Sheikhlary
- Suleyman OmerSOSuleyman Omer
- Binh TranBTBinh Tran
- Mehrail LawendyMLMehrail Lawendy
- Farah AlqaraghuliFAFarah Alqaraghuli
- Chris HedgecokeCHChris Hedgecoke
Open Access
- 19 November 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Bioengineering
- Vol. 11 (11) , 1163
Abstract
Motion is vital for life. Currently, the clinical assessment of motion abnormalities is largely qualitative. We previously developed methods to quantitatively assess motion using visual detection systems (around-body) and stretchable electronic sensors (on-body). Here we compare the efficacy of these methods across predefined motions, hypothesizing that the around-body system detects motion with similar accuracy as on-body sensors. Six human volunteers performed six defined motions covering three excursion lengths, small, medium, and large, which were analyzed via both around-body visual marker detection (MoCa version 1.0) and on-body stretchable electronic sensors (BioStamp version 1.0). Data from each system was compared as to the extent of trackability and comparative efficacy between systems. Both systems successfully detected motions, allowing quantitative analysis. Angular displacement between systems had the highest agreement efficiency for the bicep curl and body lean motion, with 73.24% and 65.35%, respectively. The finger pinch motion had an agreement efficiency of 36.71% and chest abduction/adduction had 45.55%. Shoulder abduction/adduction and shoulder flexion/extension motions had the lowest agreement efficiencies with 24.49% and 26.28%, respectively. MoCa was comparable to BioStamp in terms of angular displacement, though velocity and linear speed output could benefit from additional processing. Our findings demonstrate comparable efficacy for non-contact motion detection to that of on-body sensor detection, and offers insight as to the best system selection for specific clinical uses based on the use-case of the desired motion being analyzed.Keywords
Funding Information
- ACABI—the Arizona Center for Accelerated Biomedical Innovation of the University of Arizona (R25DK128859)
- NIH NIDDK (R25DK128859)
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Online human motion analysis in industrial context: A reviewEngineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence, 2024
- Epidemiology of chronic kidney disease: an update 2022Kidney International Supplements, 2022
- Different metabolic changes between fast- and slow-twitch skeletal muscle underlie impaired muscle fatigue resistance in chronic kidney diseaseBiophysical Journal, 2022
- Movement Disorders in Chronic Kidney Disease – A Descriptive ReviewJournal of Stroke and Cerebrovascular Diseases, 2021
- A review of computer vision-based approaches for physical rehabilitation and assessmentMultimedia Systems, 2021
- Sensor-based and vision-based human activity recognition: A comprehensive surveyPattern Recognition, 2020
- Key Frame Proposal Network for Efficient Pose Estimation in Videos2020
- Skeletal muscle performance and ageingJournal of Cachexia, Sarcopenia and Muscle, 2017
- Vision-based motion detection, analysis and recognition of epileptic seizures—A systematic reviewComputer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 2012
- Recent developments in human motion analysisPattern Recognition, 2003