Responsible Use of Kinematic Models: Correspondence on “Navigating Ball Mill Specifications for Theory‐to‐Practice Reproducibility in Mechanochemistry”
- 23 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Angewandte Chemie International Edition
- Vol. 64 (43) , e202512324
Abstract
In their recent article, Jafter et al. present “refined” kinematic models for planetary and mixer mills. While the improvement of such models is a valuable pursuit, we find that aspects of the presentation and application of these models raise concerns. The authors modify an existing planetary mill model, yet the altered equations offer no clear advantage and obscure the underlying milling dynamics. The mixer mill model is similar to known models, but includes additional parameters, such as an empirical scaling factor, that lack theoretical justification. Furthermore, the models are applied using estimated or hypothetical values for important milling parameters, contributing to overestimations of the energy metrics. Rather than dismissing the use of kinematic models, we emphasize the importance of applying them with care by using accurate input parameters, being aware of their assumptions and limitations, and interpreting their outputs in the context of what the energy metrics represent (maximum energies released from impacts). When employed responsibly, kinematic models can provide valuable insight, and thus, we encourage a more rigorous and transparent application of these models to support the broader goal of reproducibility in mechanochemistry.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Research Foundation of Korea (RS‐2024‐00451478)
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- Balancing processability and percolation behavior of ultrahigh aspect ratio carbon nanotubes in polymers through ball millingPolymer Composites, 2025
- Using Near‐Infrared Irradiation for Heating Mechanochemical Reactions in Organic‐Dye‐Doped Epoxy Milling JarsAngewandte Chemie International Edition, 2024
- Navigating Ball Mill Specifications for Theory‐to‐Practice Reproducibility in MechanochemistryAngewandte Chemie International Edition, 2024
- Response of Lanthanide Sesquioxides to High‐Energy Ball MillingAdvanced Engineering Materials, 2024
- Solid‐State Enzymatic Hydrolysis of Mixed PET/Cotton Textiles**ChemSusChem, 2022
- Temperature‐Controlled Mechanochemistry for the Nickel‐Catalyzed Suzuki–Miyaura‐Type Coupling of Aryl Sulfamates via Ball Milling and Twin‐Screw Extrusion.**Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2022
- Direct Amidation of Esters by Ball Milling**Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 2021
- Solvent‐Free Enzyme Activity: Quick, High‐Yielding Mechanoenzymatic Hydrolysis of Cellulose into GlucoseAngewandte Chemie International Edition, 2018
- Temperature rise during mechanical alloyingScripta Metallurgica et Materialia, 1992
- Mechanical alloying of the Fe−Zr system. Correlation between input energy and end productsIl Nuovo Cimento D, 1991