Why Has Migration Research So Little Impact? Examining Knowledge Practices in Migration Policy Making and Migration Studies
Open Access
- 19 September 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Migration Review
- Vol. 58 (4) , 1669-1700
Abstract
Scientific and expert knowledge on migration is often disregarded in policy making and plays only a minor role in public debates - despite the massive growth and institutionalization of migration research in recent years. This article interrogates the limited impact of migration research(ers) by examining knowledge practices in both policy making and academia. We first look “outwards” at migration policy making. Revisiting and integrating the hitherto separate scholarship on knowledge use and knowledge production, we identify the main mechanisms that characterize knowledge practices of policy actors, such as individual and institutional self-preservation, issue politicization, or unequal power dynamics. We then mobilize these insights to look “inwards” at our own knowledge practices in migration studies, showing that similar mechanisms shape how migration scholars produce and use knowledge. In particular, we identify a fragmentation of migration studies into ever-more fine-grained sub-fields, each with their own knowledge practices and impact strategies - and with little dialogue across them. In fact, rather than acknowledging their complementarity, these sub-fields tend to delegitimize each other's knowledge and efforts to achieve socio-political change. We argue that such “academic tribalism” creates a self-sabotaging dynamic that undermines the field's wider credibility and impact. Ultimately, we hope that this paper empowers migration researchers to act upon this diagnosis and inspires a collective discussion on how to foster more mutually-reinforcing knowledge practices that strengthen the field's role in political debates and public life.Keywords
Funding Information
- Horizon Europe (N 101094279)
This publication has 107 references indexed in Scilit:
- South–South Migration and Inequality: An Introduction2023
- Mapping the use of knowledge in policymaking: barriers and facilitators from a subjectivist perspective (1990–2020)Policy Sciences, 2022
- After the reflexive turn in migration studies: Towards the doing migration approachPopulation, Space and Place, 2020
- Migrants Before the Law2019
- Research-Policy Dialogues in Italy2015
- Cultures of Knowledge Use in Policymaking: The Functions of Research in German and UK Immigration Policy2015
- Integrating Immigrants in Europe2015
- Einleitung: Die reflexive Wende in der Migrationsforschung2014
- Rethinking the science-policy nexus: from knowledge utilization and science technology studies to types of boundary arrangementsPoiesis & Praxis, 2005
- The paradox of policy analysis: If it is not used, why do we produce so much of it?Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 1999