Katharina Natter
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Katharina Natter has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Hélène Thiollet
Arabique/International Journal of Archaeology and Social Sciences Arabian Peninsula Revue internationale d'archéologie et de sciences sociales sur la péninsule
3 shared publications Hein de Haas
Department of Sociology, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands
2 shared publicationsMathias Czaika
Department for Migration and Globalization, Danube University Krems, Krems, Austria
2 shared publicationsEdo Mahendra
1 shared publication- Hein de Haas
University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
1 shared publication Kelsey Norman
Rice University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 July 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 122-143
The il/liberal paradox: conceptualising immigration policy trade-offs across the democracy/autocracy divide
This paper compares immigration reforms across democratic and autocratic states. Mobilising two large-scale datasets, it first challenges the prevailing notion that political regime types inherently dictate immigration policy outputs. The analysis shows that although immigration is central to political debates worldwide, reforms are not that frequent and, when enacted, their restrictiveness does not consistently differ by regime type. Instead, restrictions focus on border controls and openings on entry and integration policies regardless of the political regime in place. The paper then mobilises case studies from around the globe to delve into the policy dynamics underpinning immigration reforms across regimes. It shows that while all migration states grapple with the multifaceted challenges that immigration raises, autocratic politics offers a broader toolkit to resolve the trade-offs between cultural, rights-based, economic and security issues. This creates unexpected opportunities for open immigration reforms under autocratic politics, a dynamic I call the ‘illiberal paradox’ as a counterpart to the ‘liberal paradox’ observed under democratic politics. To advance theory-building across the democracy/autocracy divide, the paper concludes by arguing that the liberal and illiberal paradox concepts are not exclusive to democratic or autocratic regimes, respectively, but are valuable analytical tools to understand immigration politics across the political regime spectrum.
- 28 July 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 122-143
Open AccessThe il/liberal paradox: conceptualising immigration policy trade-offs across the democracy/autocracy divide
This paper compares immigration reforms across democratic and autocratic states. Mobilising two large-scale datasets, it first challenges the prevailing notion that political regime types inherently dictate immigration policy outputs. The analysis shows that although immigration is central to political debates worldwide, reforms are not that frequent and, when enacted, their restrictiveness does not consistently differ by regime type. Instead, restrictions focus on border controls and openings on entry and integration policies regardless of the political regime in place. The paper then mobilises case studies from around the globe to delve into the policy dynamics underpinning immigration reforms across regimes. It shows that while all migration states grapple with the multifaceted challenges that immigration raises, autocratic politics offers a broader toolkit to resolve the trade-offs between cultural, rights-based, economic and security issues. This creates unexpected opportunities for open immigration reforms under autocratic politics, a dynamic I call the ‘illiberal paradox’ as a counterpart to the ‘liberal paradox’ observed under democratic politics. To advance theory-building across the democracy/autocracy divide, the paper concludes by arguing that the liberal and illiberal paradox concepts are not exclusive to democratic or autocratic regimes, respectively, but are valuable analytical tools to understand immigration politics across the political regime spectrum.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Hague Journal on the Rule of Law
- Vol. 18 (1) , 1-12
Who Rules over Migrants? Autocratic Tools in Migration Policies
Across the world, political leaders – both democratic and autocratic –, are becoming more creative in mobilizing policy tools that circumvent judicial review or parliamentary oversight to enact migration policies in line with their economic, geopolitical or ideological goals. Such autocratic policy tools , as we call them, concentrate the power to make laws and rules in one hand, the hand that also executes the law. This is exemplified by straightforward ‘rule by decree’ situations, but also by the use of emergency powers or by the enactment of de facto policies that entirely lack a legal basis. The ten articles in this Special Issue bridge insights from Law and Political Science to examine such autocratic policy tools in migration policy across the globe. In this introduction, we (1) conceptualize the notion of autocratic policy tools and discuss implications for debates on autocratization and rule of law decline, (2) map the variety of such tools to showcase that they are mobilized by both democratic and autocratic regimes as well as for both restrictive and permissive goals, and (3) explore why autocratic policy tools are problematic by nature, irrespective of the content of the policy. Hereby, this Special Issue provides valuable insights for scholars to recognize those practices in other policy areas and to advance insights into autocratization and rule of law decay more broadly.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Hague Journal on the Rule of Law
- Vol. 18 (1) , 1-12
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessWho Rules over Migrants? Autocratic Tools in Migration Policies
Across the world, political leaders – both democratic and autocratic –, are becoming more creative in mobilizing policy tools that circumvent judicial review or parliamentary oversight to enact migration policies in line with their economic, geopolitical or ideological goals. Such autocratic policy tools , as we call them, concentrate the power to make laws and rules in one hand, the hand that also executes the law. This is exemplified by straightforward ‘rule by decree’ situations, but also by the use of emergency powers or by the enactment of de facto policies that entirely lack a legal basis. The ten articles in this Special Issue bridge insights from Law and Political Science to examine such autocratic policy tools in migration policy across the globe. In this introduction, we (1) conceptualize the notion of autocratic policy tools and discuss implications for debates on autocratization and rule of law decline, (2) map the variety of such tools to showcase that they are mobilized by both democratic and autocratic regimes as well as for both restrictive and permissive goals, and (3) explore why autocratic policy tools are problematic by nature, irrespective of the content of the policy. Hereby, this Special Issue provides valuable insights for scholars to recognize those practices in other policy areas and to advance insights into autocratization and rule of law decay more broadly.
- Open Access
- 19 September 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Migration Review
- Vol. 58 (4) , 1669-1700
Why Has Migration Research So Little Impact? Examining Knowledge Practices in Migration Policy Making and Migration Studies
Scientific and expert knowledge on migration is often disregarded in policy making and plays only a minor role in public debates - despite the massive growth and institutionalization of migration research in recent years. This article interrogates the limited impact of migration research(ers) by examining knowledge practices in both policy making and academia. We first look “outwards” at migration policy making. Revisiting and integrating the hitherto separate scholarship on knowledge use and knowledge production, we identify the main mechanisms that characterize knowledge practices of policy actors, such as individual and institutional self-preservation, issue politicization, or unequal power dynamics. We then mobilize these insights to look “inwards” at our own knowledge practices in migration studies, showing that similar mechanisms shape how migration scholars produce and use knowledge. In particular, we identify a fragmentation of migration studies into ever-more fine-grained sub-fields, each with their own knowledge practices and impact strategies - and with little dialogue across them. In fact, rather than acknowledging their complementarity, these sub-fields tend to delegitimize each other's knowledge and efforts to achieve socio-political change. We argue that such “academic tribalism” creates a self-sabotaging dynamic that undermines the field's wider credibility and impact. Ultimately, we hope that this paper empowers migration researchers to act upon this diagnosis and inspires a collective discussion on how to foster more mutually-reinforcing knowledge practices that strengthen the field's role in political debates and public life.
- 19 September 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Migration Review
- Vol. 58 (4) , 1669-1700
Open AccessWhy Has Migration Research So Little Impact? Examining Knowledge Practices in Migration Policy Making and Migration Studies
Scientific and expert knowledge on migration is often disregarded in policy making and plays only a minor role in public debates - despite the massive growth and institutionalization of migration research in recent years. This article interrogates the limited impact of migration research(ers) by examining knowledge practices in both policy making and academia. We first look “outwards” at migration policy making. Revisiting and integrating the hitherto separate scholarship on knowledge use and knowledge production, we identify the main mechanisms that characterize knowledge practices of policy actors, such as individual and institutional self-preservation, issue politicization, or unequal power dynamics. We then mobilize these insights to look “inwards” at our own knowledge practices in migration studies, showing that similar mechanisms shape how migration scholars produce and use knowledge. In particular, we identify a fragmentation of migration studies into ever-more fine-grained sub-fields, each with their own knowledge practices and impact strategies - and with little dialogue across them. In fact, rather than acknowledging their complementarity, these sub-fields tend to delegitimize each other's knowledge and efforts to achieve socio-political change. We argue that such “academic tribalism” creates a self-sabotaging dynamic that undermines the field's wider credibility and impact. Ultimately, we hope that this paper empowers migration researchers to act upon this diagnosis and inspires a collective discussion on how to foster more mutually-reinforcing knowledge practices that strengthen the field's role in political debates and public life.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 1 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies
- Vol. 50 (3) , 680-701
The il/liberal paradox: conceptualising immigration policy trade-offs across the democracy/autocracy divide
- 1 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies
- Vol. 50 (3) , 680-701
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThe il/liberal paradox: conceptualising immigration policy trade-offs across the democracy/autocracy divide
- Open Access
- 9 November 2023
- Published by Stichting SciPost in Migration Politics
- Vol. 2 (1) , 004
Strategic non-regulation as migration governance
Over the last decade, critical migration scholarship has been increasingly concerned with how state actors in both the Global South and Global North deploy forms of inaction and ambivalent action to govern migrants. Scholars have mobilized and developed concepts to capture such strategic non-regulation, ranging from notions of standoffishness, ignorance, indifference, ambiguity, adhocracy, and informality in political science, IR and sociology, to necropolitics, ignorance, opacity, obfuscation, non-recording and liminality in anthropology, socio-legal studies and political geography. Scholars thus seem to agree that the strategic use of non-regulation by state actors is a significant aspect of migration governance. Yet, conceptual and methodological advances remain fragmented and scattered across geographical regions and disciplines. This paper argues that much can be gained by putting the different conceptual and methodological innovations on strategic non-regulation into dialogue. First, consolidating insights from different bodies of scholarly work moves analyses of strategic non-regulation from the fringes of migration scholarship to its center and demonstrates that strategic non-regulation is a core feature of migration governance. Second, bringing these different works together enables us to synthesize the variety of analytical strategies that scholars have devised to empirically locate the elusive phenomenon of strategic non-regulation. Overcoming disciplinary and geographical divides in the study of strategic non-regulation will also be key to advance broader social science debates on the political functionality of policy failure and on the interplay between state capacity and political will - in migration governance but also beyond.
- 9 November 2023
- Published by Stichting SciPost in Migration Politics
- Vol. 2 (1) , 004
Open AccessStrategic non-regulation as migration governance
Over the last decade, critical migration scholarship has been increasingly concerned with how state actors in both the Global South and Global North deploy forms of inaction and ambivalent action to govern migrants. Scholars have mobilized and developed concepts to capture such strategic non-regulation, ranging from notions of standoffishness, ignorance, indifference, ambiguity, adhocracy, and informality in political science, IR and sociology, to necropolitics, ignorance, opacity, obfuscation, non-recording and liminality in anthropology, socio-legal studies and political geography. Scholars thus seem to agree that the strategic use of non-regulation by state actors is a significant aspect of migration governance. Yet, conceptual and methodological advances remain fragmented and scattered across geographical regions and disciplines. This paper argues that much can be gained by putting the different conceptual and methodological innovations on strategic non-regulation into dialogue. First, consolidating insights from different bodies of scholarly work moves analyses of strategic non-regulation from the fringes of migration scholarship to its center and demonstrates that strategic non-regulation is a core feature of migration governance. Second, bringing these different works together enables us to synthesize the variety of analytical strategies that scholars have devised to empirically locate the elusive phenomenon of strategic non-regulation. Overcoming disciplinary and geographical divides in the study of strategic non-regulation will also be key to advance broader social science debates on the political functionality of policy failure and on the interplay between state capacity and political will - in migration governance but also beyond.
- 18 October 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 37-55
Open Access: Tunisia's migration politics throughout the 2011 revolution: revisiting the democratisation–migrant rights nexus
- 18 October 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 37-55
Open Access: Tunisia's migration politics throughout the 2011 revolution: revisiting the democratisation–migrant rights nexus
- 18 October 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 1-16
Introduction
- 18 October 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis
Migration Politics across the World
- Open Access
- 12 April 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Mediterranean Politics
- Vol. 29 (5) , 617-641
Forced migration governance in Tunisia: Balancing risks and assets for state-making during independence and democratization
What explains the variation in states’ governance of forced migration? Why are some groups of forced migrants welcomed and others not? We argue that this depends on whether accommodating a particular group of forced migrants is perceived as an asset or risk to broader political developments at play. Drawing on qualitative material from Tunisia between 1950 and 2020, the paper analyses how the Tunisian state has dealt differently with the large-scale arrival of forced migrants from neighbouring countries after its independence in 1956 and throughout its democratic opening since 2011. We show that during the Algerian War of Independence, perceptions of displaced Algerians as international assets outweighed perceptions of domestic economic and political risks. This resulted in Tunisia’s supportive-open approach towards the nearly 200,000 Algerians who were welcomed as prima facie refugees and provided humanitarian assistance. In contrast, the estimated 500,000 Libyans who arrived after 2011 have been perceived both as domestic economic and ideological assets and as important political risks – domestically and internationally. This explains Tunisia’s largely laissez-faire approach, whereby state authorities initially welcomed Libyans but refrained from providing humanitarian assistance and residence permits. In both cases, Tunisian authorities had to carefully balance national sovereignty and international obligations in their forced migration governance.
- 12 April 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Mediterranean Politics
- Vol. 29 (5) , 617-641
Open AccessForced migration governance in Tunisia: Balancing risks and assets for state-making during independence and democratization
What explains the variation in states’ governance of forced migration? Why are some groups of forced migrants welcomed and others not? We argue that this depends on whether accommodating a particular group of forced migrants is perceived as an asset or risk to broader political developments at play. Drawing on qualitative material from Tunisia between 1950 and 2020, the paper analyses how the Tunisian state has dealt differently with the large-scale arrival of forced migrants from neighbouring countries after its independence in 1956 and throughout its democratic opening since 2011. We show that during the Algerian War of Independence, perceptions of displaced Algerians as international assets outweighed perceptions of domestic economic and political risks. This resulted in Tunisia’s supportive-open approach towards the nearly 200,000 Algerians who were welcomed as prima facie refugees and provided humanitarian assistance. In contrast, the estimated 500,000 Libyans who arrived after 2011 have been perceived both as domestic economic and ideological assets and as important political risks – domestically and internationally. This explains Tunisia’s largely laissez-faire approach, whereby state authorities initially welcomed Libyans but refrained from providing humanitarian assistance and residence permits. In both cases, Tunisian authorities had to carefully balance national sovereignty and international obligations in their forced migration governance.
- 31 August 2022
- Published by The Middle East Journal in The Middle East Journal
- Vol. 76 (2) , 282-283
Morocco: Immigration Nation: Aid, Control, and Border Politics in Morocco, by Lorena Gazzotti (book review)
MOROCCO: Immigration Nation: Aid, Control, and Border Politics in Morocco, by Lorena Gazzotti. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2021. 256 pages. $110.<
- 31 August 2022
- Published by The Middle East Journal in The Middle East Journal
- Vol. 76 (2) , 282-283
Morocco: Immigration Nation: Aid, Control, and Border Politics in Morocco, by Lorena Gazzotti (book review)
MOROCCO: Immigration Nation: Aid, Control, and Border Politics in Morocco, by Lorena Gazzotti. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2021. 256 pages. $110.<