Realist assessment of fidelity during the implementation of the PARTNERS collaborative care intervention for people with diagnoses of severe mental illness within a cluster randomised controlled trial
Open Access
- 15 November 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS Mental Health
- Vol. 1 (6) , e0000130
Abstract
Many with severe mental illnesses are underserved by disjointed service provision. PARTNERS aims to address this via collaborative care with recovery-based coaching. PARTNERS was evaluated in a randomised controlled trial. Understanding how intervention delivery compared to the model, why this was, and under what circumstances, aids interpretation of trial results and optimisation of future implementation. This paper reports the results of a Realist assessment of fidelity, exploring delivery compared to model and refining programme theory. Practitioners, service users, supervisors, primary care representatives, and researchers (n = 39) were interviewed. Additional data included session recordings, follow up interviews, practitioner reflective logs, supervision logs, contact data, service user surveys, and meeting minutes. A framework analysis with evaluative coding was used to assess the extent to which delivery matched the Realist initial programme theory, and how, why and under what circumstances this was the case. Retroductive analysis was used to refine the programme theory. Delivery was good, but varied by practitioner and over time. Delivery improved over time, as practitioner understanding of the intervention increased. Refinements to the programme theory include training leading to practitioners forming collaborative relationships with service users most of the time, but unidentified contextual factors causing variation in consistency. Whether training led to practitioners liaising across different bodies was dependant on the contextual factors of existing relationship skills and previous connections. System-level difficulties in providing consistent supervision made it difficult to assess the impact of this mechanism on delivery. Variation in delivering means caution should be applied when interpreting trial results. Implementation of practitioner-level change without implementing system-level change limits the ability to fully implement the model and to draw conclusions as to effectiveness. Current changes to NHS community mental health care may make this more achievable. Further research is needed to understand the role of supervision and optimal training. Trial registration: This is the realist process evaluation of the cluster randomised controlled trial ISRCTN95702682. REC approval: West Midlands–Edgbaston Research Committee 29/06/2017, ref: 14/WM/0052 (trial registration number ISRCTN95702682).Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR200625)
- National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR200167)
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- How coaching can assist the mental healthcare professional in the operationalization of the recovery approachPerspectives in Psychiatric Care, 2020
- Using interpersonal process recall to understand empowerment processes in a collaborative care intervention for people with a diagnosis of psychosisPsychosis, 2019
- A worked example of initial theory-building: PARTNERS2 collaborative care for people who have experienced psychosis in EnglandEvaluation, 2019
- Refining a model of collaborative care for people with a diagnosis of bipolar, schizophrenia or other psychoses in England: a qualitative formative evaluationBMC Psychiatry, 2019
- A realist process evaluation within the Facilitating Implementation of Research Evidence (FIRE) cluster randomised controlled international trial: an exemplarImplementation Science, 2018
- What’s in a mechanism? Development of a key concept in realist evaluationImplementation Science, 2015
- Process evaluation of complex interventions: Medical Research Council guidanceBMJ, 2015
- Mental health care clusters and payment by results: considerations for social inclusion and recoveryMental Health and Social Inclusion, 2011
- A systematic review of complex system interventions designed to increase recovery from depression in primary careBMC Health Services Research, 2006
- The Experience of Recovery from Schizophrenia: Towards an Empirically Validated Stage ModelAustralian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 2003