DRDebra Richards

Debra Richards

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Debra Richards has a total of 85 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Development and evaluation of personalised post-diagnostic dementia support based in primary care: the D-PACT research programme

    by Tomasina M Oh, Hannah Wheat, Richard Byng, Sarah Morgan-Trimmer, Michael Clark, Sarah Griffiths, Paul Clarkson, Victoria Allgar, Angela Bate, Saqba Batool, et al.

    Background: Dementia affects nearly 1 million people in the United Kingdom and their unpaid carers physically, psychologically, socially and economically, highlighting that both need support. Post-diagnostic support is recognised as inadequate globally. In England, it is fragmented or absent apart from primary care – leaving many feeling unsupported as the condition progresses. The Dementia PersonAlised Care Team research programme began in 2018 to address evidence gaps on the effectiveness of dementia support roles and what constitutes ‘good’ support. Objective: Dementia PersonAlised Care Team aimed to develop and evaluate an intervention comprising dementia support workers based in primary care, supporting people with moderate to severe dementia and their carers. Phase 1 focused on intervention development and feasibility testing. Phase 2 evaluated the dementia support workers’ value and impact. Our Peer Research Group contributed to the design, analysis and interpretation of data in both phases. Design and methods: Phase 1 employed a realist approach to develop theory, the intervention and practitioner support package. This was informed by literature, consulting experts by experience, academics and practitioners and a formative evaluation. A pilot cluster randomised controlled trial tested the feasibility of recruitment, outcome measures and eligibility criteria. Phase 2 included a realist longitudinal mixed-methods evaluation to determine what worked, for whom and in what circumstances. High-volume qualitative data included realist interviews with participants with dementia and carers at two time points, interviews with dementia support workers and general practitioner staff/other practitioners, observations, dementia support worker case notes and reflections, and medical records. Quantitative measures of health- and quality of life-related outcomes, experience of care, carer well-being and support, and resource use were collected at three time points. A mixed-methods integration was conducted following separate qualitative, quantitative and economic analyses. Setting and participants: Phase 1 recruited participants with dementia (some without capacity) and their carers (if present) from general practitioner practices in rural Devon and Greater Manchester. In phase 2, participants were recruited from practices in rural and coastal areas in Devon (high deprivation) and urban Greater Manchester (including areas with higher representation of South Asian communities). Intervention: The Dementia PersonAlised Care Team intervention, developed in phase 1, delivers personalised, proactive and integrated dementia care via trained dementia support workers embedded in primary care. Drawing on coaching principles, dementia support workers empower decision-making and address psychosocial, health and practical needs through flexible, ongoing support. Support is tailored to individuals’ and carers’ needs. Consented participants were offered 12 months of support, which is flexibly stepped up or down based on need. Findings: In phase 1, the Dementia PersonAlised Care Team intervention was tested in 10 general practitioner practices. COVID-19 necessitated switching to remote intervention delivery, recruitment and data collection. Intervention and recruitment strategy (including capacity assessment) were acceptable. However, only 51% (56/110) of the recruitment target was met, making a fully powered cluster randomised controlled trial unfeasible within the funding envelope. A mixed-methods longitudinal realist approach was therefore adopted for the evaluation (phase 2). In phase 2, 126 PwD and 121 carers were recruited from 13 practices – reaching 70% (126/180) of the recruitment target. Retention in the intervention was high (79%). However, participation in follow-up data collection was poor for all quantitative measures, for example, only 22% (28/126) of participants completed the Engagement and Independence in Dementia Questionnaire at 9–12 months. The longitudinal realist analysis identified four areas of positive impact linked to dementia support worker actions: living well, proactive care, reactive care and care transitions. Participants spoke about improved social engagement, medication management and holistic care outcomes despite the inevitable functional decline. Supervision and peer support for dementia support workers, along with joint work with practice teams, were key to delivering this care. Quantitative data showed either stable or declining trends except for carer perceptions of support, which improved over time. Realist-informed economic analysis identified 23 cases where dementia support workers likely prevented high-cost care escalation through early intervention, access to general practitioner records and ability to prompt general practitioners’ care. Resource use shifted towards increased primary/community care and reduced secondary care costs. At a caseload of 53 dyads at any one time, mean annual cost per dyad was estimated at £1222.48. Limitations: Low data completion rates, individual variability and the non-randomised design significantly limited utility of quantitative findings. Conclusions: This work demonstrated how gaps in post-diagnostic support for people with dementia and carers can be addressed through tailored, proactive support and dementia support workers being fully embedded in primary care. A comprehensive training and ongoing support package is essential for enabling dementia support workers to carry out their role. Future work: Further implementation research is needed to test delivery in changing National Health Service contexts, including whether different roles can deliver personalised dementia support. Study registration: This study is registered as ISRCTN90828574. Funding: This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Programme Grants for Applied Research Programme (NIHR award ref: RP-PG-0217-20004) and is published in full in Programme Grants for Applied Research ; Vol. 14, No. 17. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information.

  • Open Access

    Implementation of the PARTNERS model of care within two UK community mental health transformation systems: a qualitative realist evaluation

    by Jo Day, Julia Frost, Alex Stirzaker, Debra Richards, John Gibson, Vanessa Pinfold, Richard Byng

    Introduction: PARTNERS is a model of care that was co-designed with service users and carers to address the needs of people with severe mental illness to receive better support in primary care. Taking learning from a randomised controlled trial and process evaluation of this complex person-centred goal and coaching-based approach to care, our aim was to understand better the challenges of implementing PARTNERS in complex dynamic service delivery systems. Methods: We identified two Integrated Care Systems that were interested in adopting the PARTNERS model of care. We trained practitioners to adopt PARTNERS to their local settings and provided meta-supervision (supervision of supervisors). We examined the implementation period that covered site engagement, training of staff and initial delivery of the new PARTNERS model of care, undertaking a qualitative realist evaluation informed by the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR). Data collection involved semi-structured interviews with 10 System Change Leads, Supervisors, and trained intervention practitioners or ‘Care Partners’; augmented by observations of supervision and practice within the systems and collation of documents. Analysis was qualitative informed by a realist approach and the CFIR. Results: Analysis identified complex overlapping configurations of teams and roles within them, leadership, and individual characteristics influenced the systems’ ability to implement the PARTNERS model of care. The presence or absence of leadership was instrumental in providing clarity regarding where the delivery of PARTNERS sat within newly emerging systems and was an important indicator of successful implementation. Collaborative leadership and supervision, alongside training tailored to the needs of individual practitioners, increased or decreased perceived self-efficacy amongst individual practitioners and their confidence in delivering the PARTNERS model of care. Conclusions: We identified that both internal and external supervision and system leadership are crucial to the implementation of PARTNERS, backed up by training delivered by a clinician and people with lived experience, to ensure that this new model of care is embedded in everyday practice. It is likely that the absence of any one of these mechanisms could make implementation and sustainability of the PARTNERS model challenging. Clinical trial number: Not applicable.

  • Open Access

    Realist assessment of fidelity during the implementation of the PARTNERS collaborative care intervention for people with diagnoses of severe mental illness within a cluster randomised controlled trial

    by Charley Hobson-Merrett, Julia Frost, Ruth Gwernan-Jones, Vanessa Pinfold, Michael Clark, Shamiaa El Naggar, Linda Gask, Bliss Gibbons, John Gibson, Siobhan Reilly, et al.

    Many with severe mental illnesses are underserved by disjointed service provision. PARTNERS aims to address this via collaborative care with recovery-based coaching. PARTNERS was evaluated in a randomised controlled trial. Understanding how intervention delivery compared to the model, why this was, and under what circumstances, aids interpretation of trial results and optimisation of future implementation. This paper reports the results of a Realist assessment of fidelity, exploring delivery compared to model and refining programme theory. Practitioners, service users, supervisors, primary care representatives, and researchers (n = 39) were interviewed. Additional data included session recordings, follow up interviews, practitioner reflective logs, supervision logs, contact data, service user surveys, and meeting minutes. A framework analysis with evaluative coding was used to assess the extent to which delivery matched the Realist initial programme theory, and how, why and under what circumstances this was the case. Retroductive analysis was used to refine the programme theory. Delivery was good, but varied by practitioner and over time. Delivery improved over time, as practitioner understanding of the intervention increased. Refinements to the programme theory include training leading to practitioners forming collaborative relationships with service users most of the time, but unidentified contextual factors causing variation in consistency. Whether training led to practitioners liaising across different bodies was dependant on the contextual factors of existing relationship skills and previous connections. System-level difficulties in providing consistent supervision made it difficult to assess the impact of this mechanism on delivery. Variation in delivering means caution should be applied when interpreting trial results. Implementation of practitioner-level change without implementing system-level change limits the ability to fully implement the model and to draw conclusions as to effectiveness. Current changes to NHS community mental health care may make this more achievable. Further research is needed to understand the role of supervision and optimal training. Trial registration: This is the realist process evaluation of the cluster randomised controlled trial ISRCTN95702682. REC approval: West Midlands–Edgbaston Research Committee 29/06/2017, ref: 14/WM/0052 (trial registration number ISRCTN95702682).


  • Open Access

    Collaborative care intervention for individuals with severe mental illness: the PARTNERS2 programme including complex intervention development and cluster RCT

    by Humera Plappert, Richard Byng, Siobhan Theresa Reilly, Charley Hobson-Merrett, Jon Allard, Elina Baker, Nicky Britten, Melanie Calvert, Michael Clark, Siobhan Creanor, et al.

    Background and aims: Individuals living with severe mental illness such as schizophrenia and bipolar can have significant emotional, cognitive, physical and social challenges. Most people with severe mental illness in the United Kingdom do not receive specialist mental health care. Collaborative care is a system of support that combines clinical and organisational components to provide integrated and person-centred care. It has not been tested for severe mental illness in the United Kingdom. We aimed to develop and evaluate a primary care-based collaborative care model (PARTNERS) designed to improve quality of life for people with diagnoses of schizophrenia, bipolar or other psychoses when compared with usual care. Methods: Phase 1 included studies to (1) understand context: an observational retrospective study of primary and secondary care medical records and an update of the Cochrane review ‘Collaborative care approaches for people with severe mental illness’; (2) develop and formatively evaluate the PARTNERS intervention: a review of literature on collaborative care and recovery, interviews with key leaders in collaborative care and recovery, focus groups with service users and a formative evaluation of a prototype intervention model; and (3) develop trial science work in this area: a core outcome set for bipolar and recruitment methods. In phase 2 we conducted a cluster randomised controlled trial measuring quality of life using the Manchester Short Assessment of Quality of Life and secondary outcomes including time use, recovery and mental well-being; a cost-effectiveness study; and a mixed-methods process evaluation. Public involvement underpinned all of the workstream activity through the study Lived Experience Advisory Panel and the employment of service user researchers in the project team. Results phase 1: The study of records showed that care for individuals under secondary care is variable and substantial and that people are seen every 2 weeks on average. The updated Cochrane review showed that collaborative care interventions were highly variable, and no reliable conclusions can be drawn about effectiveness. The PARTNERS model incorporated change at organisational, practitioner and individual levels. Coaching was selected as the main form of support for individuals’ personal goals. In the formative evaluation, we showed that more intensive supervision and ‘top-up’ training were needed to achieve the desired shifts in practice. A core outcome set was developed for bipolar, and measures were selected for the trial. We developed a stepped approach to recruitment including initial approach and appointment. Results phase 2: The trial was conducted in four areas. In total, 198 participants were recruited from 39 practices randomised. Participants received either the PARTNERS intervention or usual care. The follow-up rate was 86% at 9–12 months. The mean change in overall Manchester Short Assessment Quality of Life score did not differ between the groups [0.25 (standard deviation 0.73) for intervention vs. 0.21 (standard deviation 0.86) for control]. We also found no difference for any secondary measures. Safety outcomes (e.g. crises) did not differ between those receiving and those not receiving the intervention. Although the costs of intervention and usual care were similar, there is insufficient evidence to draw conclusions about the overall cost-effectiveness of PARTNERS. The mixed-methods process evaluation demonstrated that a significant proportion of individuals did not receive the full intervention. This was partly due to care partner absence and participant choice. The in-depth realist informed case studies showed that participants generally appreciated the support, with some describing having a ‘professional friend’ as very important. For some people there was evidence that delivery of the intervention had led to specific personal changes. Strengths and limitations: The phase 1 records study provided insights into usual care that had not been previously documented. The realist informed complex intervention development was both theoretical and pragmatic. The trial continued through the COVID-19 pandemic with high levels of follow-up. The process evaluation had the depth to explore individual changes in participants’ response to the intervention. Weaknesses in the trial methodology included suboptimal implementation, outcome measures that may not have been sensitive to changes patients most appreciated and difficulties collecting some outcomes. Conclusions: While PARTNERS was not shown to be superior to usual care, the change to PARTNERS care was not shown to be unsafe. Full intervention implementation was challenging, but this is to be expected in studies of care that include those with psychosis. Some individuals responded well to the intervention when psychological support in the form of individualised goal setting was flexibly deployed, with evidence that having access to a ‘professional friend’ was experienced as particularly helpful for some individuals. Future work: Key components of the PARTNERS model could be developed further and tested, along with improved supervision in the context of ongoing community mental health care change. Trial registration: This trial is registered as ISRCTN95702682. Funding: This award was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Programme Grants for Applied Research programme (NIHR award ref: NIHR200625) and is published in full in Programme Grants for Applied Research; Vol. 12, No. 6. See the NIHR Funding and Awards website for further award information.