Expert evidence on trial: Social researchers in the international criminal courtroom
- 22 November 2016
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in American Ethnologist
- Vol. 43 (4) , 730-744
Abstract
Social researchers often feature as expert witnesses in international criminal trials, and they can exert a strong influence on a court's understandings of mass atrocities. Analysis of over 400 expert appearances shows that, overall, international judges prefer experts who use scientific methods, but when social researchers are called, courts favor qualitative researchers over quantitative ones. In two international speech‐crimes trials, a language expert was preferred to a quantitative sociologist because the former did not challenge the sovereignty of judges or the status hierarchy of the courtroom. When excluding quantitative experts, judges cite “common sense” as the basis of facticity and knowledge. The prevailing epistemological framework at international criminal tribunals results from the knowledge strategies of legal actors operating in a structurally fragile context.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Quiet Power of Indicators2015
- ‘Illuminating the broader context’: anthropological and historical knowledge at the International Criminal Tribunal for R wandaJournal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 2013
- Testifying about ‘Uncivilized Events’: Problematic Representations of Africa in the Trial against Charles TaylorLeiden Journal of International Law, 2011
- Rethinking Africa through its Exclusions: The Politics of Naming Criminal ResponsibilityAnthropological Quarterly, 2010
- Fictions of Justice2009
- Cultural evidence in courts of lawJournal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 2008
- Anthropology, Human Rights, and Legal Knowledge: Culture in the Iron CageAmerican Anthropologist, 2006
- EXPERT EVIDENCE AFTERDAUBERTAnnual Review of Law and Social Science, 2005
- The Influence of Amicus Curiae Briefs on the Supreme CourtUniversity of Pennsylvania Law Review, 2000
- The Anthropologist as Expert WitnessAmerican Anthropologist, 1977