Merit and placement in the American faculty hierarchy: Cumulative advantage in archaeology
Open Access
- 31 January 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 17 (1) , e0259038
Abstract
If faculty placement in the American academic hierarchy is by merit, then it correlates with scholarly productivity at all career stages. Recently developed data-collection methods and bibliometric measures test this proposition in a cross-sectional sample of US academic archaeologists. Precocity—productivity near the point of initial hire—fails to distinguish faculty in MA- and PhD-granting programs or among ranked subsets of PhD programs. Over longer careers, on average archaeologists in PhD-granting programs outperform colleagues in lower programs, as do those in higher-ranked compared to lower-ranked PhD programs, all in the practical absence of mobility via recruitment to higher placement. Yet differences by program level lie mostly in the tails of productivity distributions; overlap between program levels is high, and many in lower-degree programs outperform many PhD-program faculty even when controlling for career length. Results implicate cumulative advantage to explain the pattern and suggest particularism as its cause.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Quality Versus Quantity: Assessing Individual Research PerformanceScience Translational Medicine, 2011
- Nine Criteria for a Measure of Scientific OutputFrontiers in Computational Neuroscience, 2011
- The state of h index researchEMBO Reports, 2008
- International ranking systems for universities and institutions: a critical appraisalBMC Medicine, 2007
- How Liberal Arts Colleges Perpetuate Class BiasAcademe, 2006
- The allocation of prestigious positions in organizational science: accumulative advantage, sponsored mobility, and contest mobilityJournal of Organizational Behavior, 2005
- Reputational quality of academic programs: The institutional haloResearch in Higher Education, 1988
- The Academic Elite in American Anthropology: Linkages Among Top-ranked Graduate ProgramsCurrent Anthropology, 1986
- How Far to Meritocracy? Empirical Tests of a Controversial ThesisSocial Forces, 1985
- Introduction: The Structure of the Academic ProfessionsSociology of Education, 1974