Michael J. Shott
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Michael J. Shott has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Eric Olson
Cuyahoga Community College, Parma, USA
2 shared publications- Alan Michael Slade
University of Southampton
1 shared publication Brian W. Trail
Department of Classical Studies, Anthropology and Archaeology, University of Akron, Akron, OH, USA 44325-1910.
1 shared publicationDesale Habtzghi
Dept. of Mathematical Sciences, DePaul University, Chicago, IL 60614, USA
1 shared publication- Erik Otárola-Castillo
Department of Anthropology, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA
1 shared publication Gilbert Tostevin
Department of Anthropology, University of Minnesota, 395 H. H. Humphrey Center, 301 19th Ave. S., Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 7 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Paleolithic Archaeology
- Vol. 7 (1) , 1-13
Dibble’s Reduction Thesis: Implications for Global Lithic Analysis
Harold Dibble demonstrated the systematic effects of reduction by retouch upon the size and shape of Middle Paleolithic tools. The result was the reduction thesis, with its far-reaching implications for the understanding of Middle Paleolithic assemblage variation that even now are incompletely assimilated. But Dibble’s influence extended beyond the European Paleolithic. Others identified additional reduction methods and measures that complement Dibble’s reduction thesis, and applied analytical concepts and methods consistent with it to industries and assemblages around the world. These developments facilitated comprehensive reduction analysis of archaeological tools and assemblages and their comparison in the abstract despite the great diversity of their time–space contexts. Dibble argued that many assemblages are time-averaged accumulations. In cases from New Zealand to North America, methods he pioneered and that others extended reveal the complex processes by which behavior, tool use, curation, and time interacted to yield those accumulations. We are coming to understand that the record is no mere collection of ethnographic vignettes, instead a body of data that requires macroarchaeological approaches. Archaeology’s pending conceptual revolution in part is a legacy of Dibble’s thought.
- 7 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Paleolithic Archaeology
- Vol. 7 (1) , 1-13
Open AccessDibble’s Reduction Thesis: Implications for Global Lithic Analysis
Harold Dibble demonstrated the systematic effects of reduction by retouch upon the size and shape of Middle Paleolithic tools. The result was the reduction thesis, with its far-reaching implications for the understanding of Middle Paleolithic assemblage variation that even now are incompletely assimilated. But Dibble’s influence extended beyond the European Paleolithic. Others identified additional reduction methods and measures that complement Dibble’s reduction thesis, and applied analytical concepts and methods consistent with it to industries and assemblages around the world. These developments facilitated comprehensive reduction analysis of archaeological tools and assemblages and their comparison in the abstract despite the great diversity of their time–space contexts. Dibble argued that many assemblages are time-averaged accumulations. In cases from New Zealand to North America, methods he pioneered and that others extended reveal the complex processes by which behavior, tool use, curation, and time interacted to yield those accumulations. We are coming to understand that the record is no mere collection of ethnographic vignettes, instead a body of data that requires macroarchaeological approaches. Archaeology’s pending conceptual revolution in part is a legacy of Dibble’s thought.
- 1 October 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Antiquity
- Vol. 88 (4) , 583-586
On Sherds, Vessels, and Pragmatics: Reaction to Feathers
Feathers addresses the dual challenges of inferring original vessel counts from sherds and inference to use life from reconstructed vessels. His solution assumes the validity of sherd assemblages as units of observation that considerable research invalidates and overlooks methods that estimate original vessels from sherds. Feathers also doubts that use life can be inferred for reconstructed vessels. Although not a focus of my article, the larger study from which it derived addresses this matter in detail that strongly warrants vessel size as use-life measure. Of course we must be pragmatic in quantifying pottery assemblages, but first we must identify valid units of observation, and only then attend to pragmatics. ResumenFeathers se dirige a los desafíos de la cuantificación de vasijas desde tiestos y la inferencia a vida útil desde vasijas reconstruidas. Su solución asume la validez de conjuntos de tiestos como unidades observacionales que investigaciónes previas invalidan, y descuida métodos para estimar vasijas originales desde tiestos. Tambien Feathers duda que se puede inferir la vida útil de vasijas. A pesar de que tantas inferencias no sirvieron como enfoque del artículo a que él respondió, el estudio largo de que se derivaron el artículo trataron del problema en detalle que soporte fuertemente el tamaño de vasijas como medida válida de la vida útil. Por supesto, tenemos que ser pragmáticos en la cuantificación de conjuntos cerámicos, pero primero tenemos que identificar las unidades de observación válidas, y solamente después nos dirigimos a las pragmáticas.
- 1 October 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Antiquity
- Vol. 88 (4) , 583-586
On Sherds, Vessels, and Pragmatics: Reaction to Feathers
Feathers addresses the dual challenges of inferring original vessel counts from sherds and inference to use life from reconstructed vessels. His solution assumes the validity of sherd assemblages as units of observation that considerable research invalidates and overlooks methods that estimate original vessels from sherds. Feathers also doubts that use life can be inferred for reconstructed vessels. Although not a focus of my article, the larger study from which it derived addresses this matter in detail that strongly warrants vessel size as use-life measure. Of course we must be pragmatic in quantifying pottery assemblages, but first we must identify valid units of observation, and only then attend to pragmatics. ResumenFeathers se dirige a los desafíos de la cuantificación de vasijas desde tiestos y la inferencia a vida útil desde vasijas reconstruidas. Su solución asume la validez de conjuntos de tiestos como unidades observacionales que investigaciónes previas invalidan, y descuida métodos para estimar vasijas originales desde tiestos. Tambien Feathers duda que se puede inferir la vida útil de vasijas. A pesar de que tantas inferencias no sirvieron como enfoque del artículo a que él respondió, el estudio largo de que se derivaron el artículo trataron del problema en detalle que soporte fuertemente el tamaño de vasijas como medida válida de la vida útil. Por supesto, tenemos que ser pragmáticos en la cuantificación de conjuntos cerámicos, pero primero tenemos que identificar las unidades de observación válidas, y solamente después nos dirigimos a las pragmáticas.
- 15 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory
- Vol. 31 (2) , 593-618
Original Design and Allometric Variation in Kirk Points of the Central Ohio Archaeological Digitization Survey
- 15 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory
- Vol. 31 (2) , 593-618
Original Design and Allometric Variation in Kirk Points of the Central Ohio Archaeological Digitization Survey
- Open Access
Class Barriers to Merit in the American Professoriate: An Archaeology Example and Proposals for Reform
Consumers and academics alike perceive a status hierarchy among American universities. By this perception, professors are placed in the status hierarchy befitting their scholarly merit. However, a recent study of the archaeology professoriate found no consistent correlation between faculty placement and merit. This essay identifies reasons for the lack of meritocracy, some unique to archaeology and others common to many fields. Archaeology, similar to the American academy at large, ignores class as a bias that handicaps some while favoring others. Notwithstanding challenges of definition and measurement, class should be treated equally with race, gender, and other biases in an academy’s pursuit of true meritocracy.
Open AccessClass Barriers to Merit in the American Professoriate: An Archaeology Example and Proposals for Reform
Consumers and academics alike perceive a status hierarchy among American universities. By this perception, professors are placed in the status hierarchy befitting their scholarly merit. However, a recent study of the archaeology professoriate found no consistent correlation between faculty placement and merit. This essay identifies reasons for the lack of meritocracy, some unique to archaeology and others common to many fields. Archaeology, similar to the American academy at large, ignores class as a bias that handicaps some while favoring others. Notwithstanding challenges of definition and measurement, class should be treated equally with race, gender, and other biases in an academy’s pursuit of true meritocracy.
- 5 August 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Antiquity
- Vol. 87 (4) , 794-815
Inferring Use-Life Mean and Distribution: A Pottery Ethnoarchaeological Case Study from Michoacán
Archaeologists see the value, if not the allure, of formation theory. Before inferring what happened in the past and why, we must know how the material record formed. Pottery is abundant and informative, therefore a common analytical subject. Understanding size and composition of ceramics assemblages requires formation theory, including knowledge of vessel use life. This fundamental quantity has two salient properties. The first—central tendency measured by mean or median—is widely acknowledged. Use life's second, equally important, property is the distribution of failure-age by specimen across assemblages. This article considers how and why both use-life properties affect size and composition of pottery assemblages. From a longitudinal ethnoarchaeology of household pottery in Michoacán, Mexico, it identifies vessel-size measures that correlate with use-life mean, and it demonstrates archaeologically innovative ways to characterize distributions that improve both analysis of assemblages and comparison between them. Los arqueólogos reconocen el valor, si no la apelación, de la teoría de formación. Antes de inferir lo que pasó en el pasado o porqué, debemos saber cómo el registro material se formó. La alfarería es abundante y informativa, entonces un sujeto analítico popular. Se necesita la teoría de formación, incluso la vida-útil, para estudiar el tamaño y la composición de los conjuntos cerámicos. La vida-útil posee dos propiedades salientes. La primera —tendencia central como promedio o número medio— se reconoce. La segunda, de importancia igual pero descuidada, es la distribución de edad de fracaso por especímene entre conjuntos. Aqui se considera cómo y porqué la vida-útil afecta los conjuntos cerámicos. A partir de indagaciónes etnoarqueológicas longitudinales de alfarería cotidiana en Michoacán, Mexico, se identifiquen medidas del tamaño de las vasijas que correlacionan con el promedio de la vida-útil, y se demuestran métodos innovadoros en contexto arqueológico para caracterizar las distribuciónes, todo que mejora el análisis de conjuntos y la comparación entre ellos.
- 5 August 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Antiquity
- Vol. 87 (4) , 794-815
Inferring Use-Life Mean and Distribution: A Pottery Ethnoarchaeological Case Study from Michoacán
Archaeologists see the value, if not the allure, of formation theory. Before inferring what happened in the past and why, we must know how the material record formed. Pottery is abundant and informative, therefore a common analytical subject. Understanding size and composition of ceramics assemblages requires formation theory, including knowledge of vessel use life. This fundamental quantity has two salient properties. The first—central tendency measured by mean or median—is widely acknowledged. Use life's second, equally important, property is the distribution of failure-age by specimen across assemblages. This article considers how and why both use-life properties affect size and composition of pottery assemblages. From a longitudinal ethnoarchaeology of household pottery in Michoacán, Mexico, it identifies vessel-size measures that correlate with use-life mean, and it demonstrates archaeologically innovative ways to characterize distributions that improve both analysis of assemblages and comparison between them. Los arqueólogos reconocen el valor, si no la apelación, de la teoría de formación. Antes de inferir lo que pasó en el pasado o porqué, debemos saber cómo el registro material se formó. La alfarería es abundante y informativa, entonces un sujeto analítico popular. Se necesita la teoría de formación, incluso la vida-útil, para estudiar el tamaño y la composición de los conjuntos cerámicos. La vida-útil posee dos propiedades salientes. La primera —tendencia central como promedio o número medio— se reconoce. La segunda, de importancia igual pero descuidada, es la distribución de edad de fracaso por especímene entre conjuntos. Aqui se considera cómo y porqué la vida-útil afecta los conjuntos cerámicos. A partir de indagaciónes etnoarqueológicas longitudinales de alfarería cotidiana en Michoacán, Mexico, se identifiquen medidas del tamaño de las vasijas que correlacionan con el promedio de la vida-útil, y se demuestran métodos innovadoros en contexto arqueológico para caracterizar las distribuciónes, todo que mejora el análisis de conjuntos y la comparación entre ellos.
- Open Access
- 31 January 2022
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 17 (1) , e0259038
Merit and placement in the American faculty hierarchy: Cumulative advantage in archaeology
If faculty placement in the American academic hierarchy is by merit, then it correlates with scholarly productivity at all career stages. Recently developed data-collection methods and bibliometric measures test this proposition in a cross-sectional sample of US academic archaeologists. Precocity—productivity near the point of initial hire—fails to distinguish faculty in MA- and PhD-granting programs or among ranked subsets of PhD programs. Over longer careers, on average archaeologists in PhD-granting programs outperform colleagues in lower programs, as do those in higher-ranked compared to lower-ranked PhD programs, all in the practical absence of mobility via recruitment to higher placement. Yet differences by program level lie mostly in the tails of productivity distributions; overlap between program levels is high, and many in lower-degree programs outperform many PhD-program faculty even when controlling for career length. Results implicate cumulative advantage to explain the pattern and suggest particularism as its cause.
- 31 January 2022
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 17 (1) , e0259038
Open AccessMerit and placement in the American faculty hierarchy: Cumulative advantage in archaeology
If faculty placement in the American academic hierarchy is by merit, then it correlates with scholarly productivity at all career stages. Recently developed data-collection methods and bibliometric measures test this proposition in a cross-sectional sample of US academic archaeologists. Precocity—productivity near the point of initial hire—fails to distinguish faculty in MA- and PhD-granting programs or among ranked subsets of PhD programs. Over longer careers, on average archaeologists in PhD-granting programs outperform colleagues in lower programs, as do those in higher-ranked compared to lower-ranked PhD programs, all in the practical absence of mobility via recruitment to higher placement. Yet differences by program level lie mostly in the tails of productivity distributions; overlap between program levels is high, and many in lower-degree programs outperform many PhD-program faculty even when controlling for career length. Results implicate cumulative advantage to explain the pattern and suggest particularism as its cause.
- 26 January 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Advances in Archaeological Practice
- Vol. 10 (1) , 83-90
The Central Ohio Archaeological Digitization Survey
Significant parts of the archaeological record are in private hands, including those of responsible and responsive stewards (RRS). This is not necessarily a bad thing. The Central Ohio Archaeological Digitization Survey (COADS) engages RRS in collaborative study of central Ohio prehistory. COADS leverages the mass of RRS data constructively to add depth and breadth to a regional archaeological record. We recorded over 12,000 diagnostic points and about 5,000 other stone tools from 32 RRS collections. All were scanned as two-dimensional (2D) images, and a sample as three-dimensional (3D) models for landmark-based geometric morphometric (LGM) analysis and GIS analysis of prehistoric land use. The resulting dataset is >4.7 times the number of diagnostics recorded in the Ohio SHPO database for the region, shedding new light on land use and tool use over millennia. In addition to academic research, COADS creates an accessible collection of 3D models available to RRS colleagues and to society at large. This reciprocal sharing mutually benefits professionals and the RRS community. Professionals are not the only ones who research the cultural past; the more and better we collaborate with RRS and others with legitimate interests, the better our common understanding of that past.
- 26 January 2022
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Advances in Archaeological Practice
- Vol. 10 (1) , 83-90
The Central Ohio Archaeological Digitization Survey
Significant parts of the archaeological record are in private hands, including those of responsible and responsive stewards (RRS). This is not necessarily a bad thing. The Central Ohio Archaeological Digitization Survey (COADS) engages RRS in collaborative study of central Ohio prehistory. COADS leverages the mass of RRS data constructively to add depth and breadth to a regional archaeological record. We recorded over 12,000 diagnostic points and about 5,000 other stone tools from 32 RRS collections. All were scanned as two-dimensional (2D) images, and a sample as three-dimensional (3D) models for landmark-based geometric morphometric (LGM) analysis and GIS analysis of prehistoric land use. The resulting dataset is >4.7 times the number of diagnostics recorded in the Ohio SHPO database for the region, shedding new light on land use and tool use over millennia. In addition to academic research, COADS creates an accessible collection of 3D models available to RRS colleagues and to society at large. This reciprocal sharing mutually benefits professionals and the RRS community. Professionals are not the only ones who research the cultural past; the more and better we collaborate with RRS and others with legitimate interests, the better our common understanding of that past.
- 31 August 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Antiquity
- Vol. 87 (1) , 80-99
Parts and Wholes: Reduction Allometry and Modularity in Experimental Folsom Points
Projectile points are a common subject of archaeological study. In the past decade, landmark-based geometric morphometrics (LGM) has increasingly been used to analyze points as whole objects. LGM and other studies document allometric changes in points—change in shape with change in size—as a product of resharpening. Allometry registers in part because different segments or modules of points are subject to different degrees of resharpening, with blades often experiencing more reduction than stems. Different modules retain varying degrees of morphological integrity as points move through their use lives. Most previous LGM studies involved two-dimensional point models, and few tested directly for modularity. We apply LGM methods to three-dimensional models of Folsom point replicas whose degree and pattern of reduction are known, finding evidence for both allometry and modularity, with modest integration. Complementary non-LGM data reveal similar results, indicating a robust pattern and ways to approximate LGM results in other data. Moreover, our dataset's experimental control clearly identifies the results as a function of the progressive reduction in use experienced by points. Cabezales líticos son sujetos populares en análises arqueológicos. Recientemente, la geometría morfométrica basada en hitos (LGM en inglés) se ve aumentanda en el análisis de cabezales como objetos enteros. La LGM y otros estudios documentan cambios alométricos —cambio de forma con cambio en tamaño— entre los cabezales como producto de la reactivación. En parte, se registre la alometría porque segmentos distintos, es decir módulos, de los cabezales se sujetan a grados diferentes de la reactivación, los limbos a menudo soportando mas reducción que las pedúnculas. Módulos distintos conservan grados diferentes de la integridad morfológica como pasan los cabezales a lo largo de sus vidas útiles. La mayoría de estudios anteriores de la LGM involucran modelos 2-dimensionales de los cabezales, y pocos investigaron directamente la modularidad. Aplicamos métodos de la LGM a modelos 3-dimensionales de réplicas cabezales del tipo Folsom, entre quienes se conocen grado y patrón de la reactivación. Encontramos prueba de ambas de la alometría y la modularidad, con integración intermedia. Medidas complementarias no-LGM revelan resultados semejantes, indicando un patrón bien fuerte, y tambien maneras a aproximar los datos y resultados de la LGM en otros fuentes o tipos de datos. Más bien, los controles experimentales que residen en nuestros datos identifiquen claramente los resultados como función de la reducción en uso secuencial a que los cabezales se sujetaron.
- 31 August 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Antiquity
- Vol. 87 (1) , 80-99
Parts and Wholes: Reduction Allometry and Modularity in Experimental Folsom Points
Projectile points are a common subject of archaeological study. In the past decade, landmark-based geometric morphometrics (LGM) has increasingly been used to analyze points as whole objects. LGM and other studies document allometric changes in points—change in shape with change in size—as a product of resharpening. Allometry registers in part because different segments or modules of points are subject to different degrees of resharpening, with blades often experiencing more reduction than stems. Different modules retain varying degrees of morphological integrity as points move through their use lives. Most previous LGM studies involved two-dimensional point models, and few tested directly for modularity. We apply LGM methods to three-dimensional models of Folsom point replicas whose degree and pattern of reduction are known, finding evidence for both allometry and modularity, with modest integration. Complementary non-LGM data reveal similar results, indicating a robust pattern and ways to approximate LGM results in other data. Moreover, our dataset's experimental control clearly identifies the results as a function of the progressive reduction in use experienced by points. Cabezales líticos son sujetos populares en análises arqueológicos. Recientemente, la geometría morfométrica basada en hitos (LGM en inglés) se ve aumentanda en el análisis de cabezales como objetos enteros. La LGM y otros estudios documentan cambios alométricos —cambio de forma con cambio en tamaño— entre los cabezales como producto de la reactivación. En parte, se registre la alometría porque segmentos distintos, es decir módulos, de los cabezales se sujetan a grados diferentes de la reactivación, los limbos a menudo soportando mas reducción que las pedúnculas. Módulos distintos conservan grados diferentes de la integridad morfológica como pasan los cabezales a lo largo de sus vidas útiles. La mayoría de estudios anteriores de la LGM involucran modelos 2-dimensionales de los cabezales, y pocos investigaron directamente la modularidad. Aplicamos métodos de la LGM a modelos 3-dimensionales de réplicas cabezales del tipo Folsom, entre quienes se conocen grado y patrón de la reactivación. Encontramos prueba de ambas de la alometría y la modularidad, con integración intermedia. Medidas complementarias no-LGM revelan resultados semejantes, indicando un patrón bien fuerte, y tambien maneras a aproximar los datos y resultados de la LGM en otros fuentes o tipos de datos. Más bien, los controles experimentales que residen en nuestros datos identifiquen claramente los resultados como función de la reducción en uso secuencial a que los cabezales se sujetaron.
- 1 July 2021
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Archaeological Science
- Vol. 131
Measuring allometry in dimensions of western North American Clovis points
- 1 July 2021
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Archaeological Science
- Vol. 131
Measuring allometry in dimensions of western North American Clovis points
- 26 October 2020
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 517-524
Archaeological Record