A STUDY ON POSSIBILITY OF USING VR SPACE IN DESIGN EDUCATION PART 1: VERIFICATION OF VR SPACE EFFECTIVENESS BY LEARNING EXPERIMENT OF SCALE FEELING
Open Access
- 30 July 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Architectural Institute of Japan in Journal of Environmental Engineering (Transactions of AIJ)
- Vol. 86 (785) , 670-679
Abstract
The presentation technology about architectural design has been developed in recent years. Virtual Reality as one of the newest method which was born from the modern technology, has been used at practical design. In addition, some of the universities had set up VR laboratories for design education. Compared to the traditional method using 2D drawings and models for presentation, VR will be expected to understand the space more easily without specialized knowledge, and it will be more useful for improving the designers’ ability. Therefore, in order to grasp the designers’ awareness about the applicability of VR Space, we conducted a hearing survey with 12 university professors in Chugoku region who worked in the field of architectural design or design education. According to the results, many of the professors thought “Scale feeling” was “the ability to measure the distance with the eyes”, and they had negative viewpoints about to learn “Scale feeling” in VR space, such as “It is difficult to understand the distance in VR Space” or “Drawing by hand is more useful to nurture the scale feeling than VR”. Therefore, this research was focused on the “Scale feeling”, and conducted an experiment to verify the effectiveness of VR by comparing the learning effect about “Scale feeling” in “VR Space” with “Real Space”. The procedure of this experiment, first, for grasping the original “Scale feeling” of subjects, the subjects were asked to answer the length of 15 objects in Test Space. Then, the subjects were divided into two groups to learn “Scale feeling” in two types of learning spaces. One group learned in “VR Space” and another group learned in “Real Space”. After learning, the subjects came back to “Test Space” and answered the length of 15 objects as the same manner at first. The difference between the “Answered length” and “Actual length” in “Test Space” was defined as the “Inaccuracy”. Finally, we compared the learning effects by the average and the standard deviation in “Inaccuracy” between the two groups. The degree of “Inaccuracy” reduction was similar. Therefore, the “Scale feeling” can be developed in VR space as same as Real space. Although, in “VR space”, the objects which have no actual shape have a larger standard deviation of the “Inaccuracy” than “Real Space”, we considered that it’s more difficult to grasp the distance between objects without shape in “VR space”. For the future research, we will consider in more detail based on the visual characteristics of the learning method.Keywords
This publication has 4 references indexed in Scilit:
- VERIFICATION OF THE INFLUENCING FACTORS CONCERNING THE ACCURACY OF DISTANCE PERCEPTION IN IMMERSIVE VIRTUAL ENVIRONMENTAIJ Journal of Technology and Design, 2017
- A STUDY OF WHAT IS THE CONCEPT OF "SENSE OF SCALE" AND HOW TO TRAIN ITS ABILITY THROUGH THE DESIGN EXERCISES IN THE UNIVERSITIESJournal of Architecture and Planning (Transactions of AIJ), 2005
- A BASIC STUDY ON THE SPACE PERCEPTION WITH DIFFERENT PROPERTIES OF SUBJECTS AND EQUIPMENT OF PRESENTATION : A study on the reproduction of the actual space on the virtual simulation system for the residential environment design Part 3Journal of Environmental Engineering (Transactions of AIJ), 2005
- A STUDY ON THE REPRODUCTION OF THE ACTUAL SPACE ON THE VIRTUAL SIMULATION SYSTEM FOR THE RESIDENTIAL ENVIRONMENT : The evaluation on brightness, space and length perception and a sense of realityJournal of Architecture and Planning (Transactions of AIJ), 2001