Breaking bad news: a cross-sectional study assessing SPIKES protocol adherence and other methods employed among medical doctors in Nigeria
Authors:
- Tope Michael IpinnimoTITope Michael Ipinnimo
- Olumide Temitope AsakeOAOlumide Temitope Asake
- Oluwafemi Oreoluwa OlowoseluOOOluwafemi Oreoluwa Olowoselu
- Taofeek Adedayo SanniTSTaofeek Adedayo Sanni
- Abolaji Paul AdekeyeAAAbolaji Paul Adekeye
- Rasheed Adeyemi AdepojuRARasheed Adeyemi Adepoju
- Gbenga Damilola AkinluaGAGbenga Damilola Akinlua
- Paul Oladapo AjayiPAPaul Oladapo Ajayi
- Oluwole Michael AdeojoOAOluwole Michael Adeojo
- Christiana Aderonke AfolayanCAChristiana Aderonke Afolayan
- Tolulope Ayodeji BamideleTBTolulope Ayodeji Bamidele
- Olaoye Michael FalekeOFOlaoye Michael Faleke
Open Access
- 28 April 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Primary Care
- Vol. 26 (1) , 1-11
Abstract
The SPIKES (Setting, Perception, Invitation, Knowledge, Empathy, and Strategy) protocol has been widely used in many developed countries for breaking bad news (BBN), however, serious uncertainty remains in its understanding and implementation in many developing nations. This study aims to assess adherence to SPIKES protocol and its associated factors, in addition to exploring alternative techniques used to BBN among medical doctors in Nigeria. A cross-sectional study was conducted in Ekiti State, Nigeria among 245 medical doctors selected through a systematic sampling technique in May, 2024. A semi-structured questionnaire, adapted from a previous study was used to collect information on biodata, practice of SPIKES protocol, and an open-ended question that asked how the respondents break bad news. Frequencies, logistic regression, and content analysis (for the open-ended question) were conducted. Overall, 178 (72.7%) doctors fully adhered to the SPIKES protocol with Settings (98.4%), Perception (93.9%), Invitation (76.7%), Knowledge (99.2%), Empathy (98.0%) and Strategy (98.4%). Clinical position(p = 0.002) and education or training(p = 0.034) were significant on bivariate. Predictors of full SPIKES adherence were doctors at public tertiary (AOR = 0.132; 95%CI = 0.029–0.600) and public secondary/primary health facilities (AOR = 0.079; 95%CI = 0.012–0.502) than those in private health facilities; doctors that are pediatricians (AOR = 0.109; 95%CI = 0.023–0.515) than the general practitioners. Content analysis shows many doctors adopt the full SPIKES protocol, use different aspects of it (SPIKES variants viz the Knowledge and Empathy (KE), Setting and Knowledge (SK), and the Setting, Knowledge, and Empathy (SKE)), some use no specific protocol, adopt the religious/spiritual approach, and other (Blunt, Diplomatic and BATHE) methods/Approaches. Achieving consistent BBN practice requires continuous training and more support as shown by variability in adherence influenced by factors such as training and education, healthcare facility, and specialty.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Communication strategies used by medical physicians when delivering bad news at the Maputo Central Hospital, Mozambique: a cross-sectional studyBMC Palliative Care, 2023
- Patients’ preferences for delivering bad news in palliative care in Ethiopia: a qualitative studyBMC Palliative Care, 2023
- SIR-PRESS Protocol: Ensuring the Safety of Healthcare Providers in Breaking Bad NewsInternational Journal of Health and Medical Sciences, 2023
- Cost of illness of non-communicable diseases in private and public health facilities in Nigeria: a qualitative and quantitative approachPan African Medical Journal, 2023
- A study of Chinese medical students’ communication pattern in delivering bad news: an ethnographic discourse analysis approachBMC Medical Education, 2021
- Effectiveness of Online Teaching for Development of Resident Beliefs and Understandings: A Study on Breaking Bad News to PatientsHealth Professions Education, 2019
- Terminally ill patients’ perception on healthcare providers’ communication of prognostic information: A qualitative study from Nigeria, West AfricaCogent Medicine, 2018
- The P-A-C-I-E-N-T-E Protocol: An instrument for breaking bad news adapted to the Brazilian medical realityRevista da Associação Médica Brasileira, 2017
- Doctors' Attentiveness to the Spirituality/Religion of their Patients in Pediatric and Oncology Settings in the Northwest USAJournal of Health Care Chaplaincy, 2013
- Is breaking of bad news indeed unacceptable to native Africans? A cross-sectional survey of patients in a Nigerian neurosurgical serviceActa Neurologica Scandinavica, 2012