Modeling Repressive Policing: Computational Analysis of Protocols from the Israeli State Commission of Inquiry into the October 2000 Events
- 20 December 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Law & Social Inquiry
- Vol. 47 (4) , 1075-1105
Abstract
This article addresses the gap between normative expectations of the right to protest in liberal democracies and the continued practice of repressive protest policing. The empirical literature has identified three types of factors explaining repressive policing: macro- or societal-level factors, meso-level factors relating to the police organization, and micro-level factors pertaining to specific events. Yet these factors provide only a fragmented understanding of the phenomenon. In this article, we put forward a novel three-tiered methodology of scaled reading, which is able to examine all these explanations together. We use scaled reading to analyze the protocols of the Or Commission of Inquiry, which investigated lethal clashes between the Israeli police and Israel’s Arab minority in October 2000. Through large-scale algorithmic topic modeling, we found that all types of empirical explanations of repressive policing co-exist within the October events. The mid-scale analysis revealed that no type of explanation exclusively belongs to a specific group of actors. The small-scale reading of the most representative documents for each topic demonstrated that this coexistence of mechanisms is also present within single testimonies. Together, our findings challenge existing empirical categories and illuminate repressive policing as a nonlinear, nonbinary, noncausal, and nonunitary phenomenon. These insights help make sense of the phenomenon’s persistence in deeply divided societies.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Describing and Accounting for the Trends in US Protest Policing, 1960−1995Journal of Conflict Resolution, 2012
- Legitimating police violenceTheoretical Criminology, 2010
- The excluded citizenship identity: Palestinian/Arab Israeli young people negotiating their political identitiesBritish Journal of Sociology of Education, 2008
- Police Power and Race Riots in ParisPolitics & Society, 2008
- From Negotiated Management to Command and Control: How the New York Police Department Polices ProtestsPolicing and Society, 2005
- The Temporal Relationship Between Police Killings of Civilians and Criminal Homicide: A Refined Version of the Danger-Perception TheoryCrime & Delinquency, 2001
- Controlling Police Decisions to Use Deadly Force: Reexamining the Importance of Administrative PolicyCrime & Delinquency, 2001
- Questioning the Militarization of U.S. police: Critical versus advocacy scholarship∗Policing and Society, 1999
- Swatting police Paramilitarism: A comment on Kraska and PaulsenPolicing and Society, 1999
- Reckoning Schemes of Legitimation: On Commissions of Inquiry as Power/Knowledge FormsJournal of Historical Sociology, 1990