RKRenana Keydar

Renana Keydar

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Renana Keydar has a total of 15 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    The testimony of the multitude: toward a computational model of listening to Holocaust testimony

    by Renana Keydar, Amit Pinchevski, Maxim Ifergan, Omri Abend

    Decades of effort collecting Holocaust testimonies have created a critical challenge for scholars: how to listen to thousands of stories as a collection of voices rather than as fragmentary data. Unlike text-mining methods, which reduce text to its basic components, this article proposes a new mode of “listening” via advanced computing. It argues that technology is foundational to bridging the gap between mass atrocity and mass testimony. This article presents a theoretical and computational model of “distant listening” that engages an entire archive without compromising the singular human experience. By treating each testimony as an unfolding conversational narrative and analyzing all testimonies within a select group simultaneously, the model listens to testimonies in relation to one another. This approach uncovers hidden characteristics and deviations from typical narrative schemas, ensuring that these safeguarded voices do not remain unheard.

  • Open Access

    Bending the Rules: On Large Language Models and Content Moderation

    by Yuval Shany, Renana Keydar, Noa Mor, Omri Abend

    This article examines the transformative impact of large language models (LLMs) on online content moderation, revealing a critical gap between platforms' rule-based policies and their AI-driven enforcement mechanisms. Using Facebook's hate speech moderation policies and practices as a case study, we identify a paradox: while content policies are increasingly rule-oriented, AI-driven enforcement seems to operate in a standard-like manner. This disconnect creates transparency, consistency and accountability challenges relating to the delineation of online freedom of expression that are not addressed in the literature, and require attention and mitigation. In this specific context, we introduce the concept of 'rules by the millions' to describe how AI systems actually operate through generating vast networks of micro-rules that evade traditional regulatory oversight. This phenomenon disrupts the conventional rules-versus-standards framework used in legal theory, raising urgent questions about the adequacy of current AI governance mechanisms. Indeed, the rapid adoption of LLMs in content moderation has outpaced the human capacity to monitor them, creating a pressing need for adaptive frameworks capable of managing the evolving capacities of AI.

  • The Discursive Evolution of Human Rights Law: Empirical Insights from a Computational Analysis of 180,000 UN Recommendations

    by Renana Keydar, Vera Shikhelman, Tomer Broude, Jonathan Elkobi

    Building on an independent database of 180,000 UN recommendations and a novel computational method, we present the most comprehensive study of human rights (HR) debates to date. We develop a unique empirical model that measures topical density of discourse. This innovative instrument measures the discursive activity of UN HR bodies through a machine-learning textual analysis of their outputs, offering a dynamic map of evolving trends in human rights, both over time (diachronically) and across different mechanisms (synchronically) within the UN HR ecosystem. Leveraging this comprehensive dataset and sophisticated computational methodologies, we identify which protected groups are central to different mechanisms’ attention and highlight the major human rights issues that have witnessed significant changes in attention. Our research presents significant findings on the density of UN HR discourse and its implications for two major debates in the field of HR law—HR proliferation and the structural critique of UN HR bodies.


  • Open Access

    The Perfect Victim

    by Eliya Habba, Renana Keydar, Dan Bareket, Gabriel Stanovsky


  • Open Access

    נייר מחקר מס׳ 1: ניתוח חישובי וכמותי של השבועיים הראשונים בדיוני ועדת החוקה על השינויים המשטריים המוצעים AI, Big Data, and the Design of Democratic Procedures - Research Paper No. 1

    by Ronit Levine-Schnur, Renana Keydar

    בנייר מחקר זה אנו מראות כי מניתוח חישובי וכמותי של פרוטוקולי הדיונים בשבועיים הראשונים של דיוני ועדת החוקה בשינויים המשטריים עולה כי הקואליציה מדברת בקול אחד, קולו של יושב הראש ח״כ רוטמן, והיא מדברת בעיקר עם עצמה. חלק הארי של זמן הדיבור בוועדה, כשליש, נלקח על ידי ח״כ רוטמן. זאת, כאשר על השולחן מונחות טיוטות הצעות חוק אשר הוא ניסח לבדו מבלי שקדם לכך תהליך היוועצות ובניית הסכמות, פורמלי או בלתי פורמלי. זמן הדיבור המוגבל של חברי האופוזיציה מפוצל בין קולות רבים, כאשר כמעט אף אחד מהם אינו מצליח לומר משהו משמעותי (בממוצע לכל אחד מהם כ-1.8% מזמן הדיבור). מומחים שאינם מתומכי הרפורמה מקבלים אמנם חלק מסוים מזמן הדיבור (בממוצע כ-7% לדובר) אולם מומחים רבים שמבקשים להשתתף לא מקבלים הזדמנות לכך. ממצאים ראשונים אלה אינם מתיישבים עם הצהרותיו הפומביות של ח״כ רוטמן על כוונתו לאפשר לכולם להישמע לעומק ובנחת, והם מעוררים ספק רב בשאלה האם הדיונים אינם אלא אחיזת עיניים. In this research paper, we perform a computational and quantitative analysis of the minutes of the first two weeks of deliberations in Israel’s Constitutional Committee, on the government’s proposed regime transformation. In this analysis we show that the coalition speaks with one voice, the voice of the chairman, MK Rothman, and it speaks mainly to itself. The lion's share of the speaking time, about third of the speaking time, was taken by MK Rotman. This, when the drafts of legislation before the Committee are ones that Rothman drafted all by himself, without any prior consultation and consensus-building processes, formal or informal. The limited speaking time of the opposition members is split between many voices, with almost none of them managing to say anything significant (on average each of them is allotted 1.8% of the speaking time). Experts who are not professed supporters of the reform do get a certain part of the speaking time (7% per speaker on average), but many experts who wished to...

  • Modeling Repressive Policing: Computational Analysis of Protocols from the Israeli State Commission of Inquiry into the October 2000 Events

    by Renana Keydar, Yael Litmanovitz, Badi Hasisi, Yoav Kan-Tor

    This article addresses the gap between normative expectations of the right to protest in liberal democracies and the continued practice of repressive protest policing. The empirical literature has identified three types of factors explaining repressive policing: macro- or societal-level factors, meso-level factors relating to the police organization, and micro-level factors pertaining to specific events. Yet these factors provide only a fragmented understanding of the phenomenon. In this article, we put forward a novel three-tiered methodology of scaled reading, which is able to examine all these explanations together. We use scaled reading to analyze the protocols of the Or Commission of Inquiry, which investigated lethal clashes between the Israeli police and Israel’s Arab minority in October 2000. Through large-scale algorithmic topic modeling, we found that all types of empirical explanations of repressive policing co-exist within the October events. The mid-scale analysis revealed that no type of explanation exclusively belongs to a specific group of actors. The small-scale reading of the most representative documents for each topic demonstrated that this coexistence of mechanisms is also present within single testimonies. Together, our findings challenge existing empirical categories and illuminate repressive policing as a nonlinear, nonbinary, noncausal, and nonunitary phenomenon. These insights help make sense of the phenomenon’s persistence in deeply divided societies.


  • ‘Lessons in Humanity’

    by Renana Keydar

    A narrative of progressive evolution of law and society has been dominating international legal discourse for some time now. This is evident in both practice and scholarship. This progress narrative provocatively mocked as ‘lessons in humanity’ in Quentin Tarantino’s Inglourious Basterds, has been created through a rejection of revenge as a possible individual as well as collective response to mass atrocities and human rights violations. However, through an analysis of counter terrorism measures and cultural narratives of the post 9/11 era, this article argues that international criminal law’s anti-revenge narrative proves increasingly incommensurable with contemporary zeitgeist and undermines international law’s relevance to today’s reality. The article traces the origins of the anti-revenge narrative to the Nuremberg International Military Tribunal and analyses the impact of its idea of progressive retribution on contemporary international criminal tribunals. It examines the growing divide between the progress narrative of the law and the reemergence of state revenge in response to threats of terror in the post 9/11 era, in contemporary military practices and popular culture. The article shows that while international legal narrative treats the rejection of revenge as a settled question, state practice and cultural outputs suggest a ‘return of the repressed’ and that in fact the question is far from resolved.


  • Open Access

    Mass Atrocity, Mass Testimony, and the Quantitative Turn in International Law

    by Renana Keydar

    The article identifies and analyses the development it labels the “quantitative turn” in international criminal law. Addressing the cumulative effect of the large numbers of witnesses in international processes, the article considers quantity as an integral, and substantively beneficial, component of the law’s response to atrocity crimes. The article develops a theorized understanding of the relationship between mass atrocity and mass testimony and provides a taxonomy of the functions that the quantity of testimonies fulfills in international trials: the evidentiary, didactic, epistemic, and restorative functions. Focusing on a recent case before the International Criminal Court in the matter of The Prosecutor v. Bemba, the article demonstrates how the different players in the international justice system — Prosecution, Defense, Victims, and the Court — employ the functions of quantity, while negotiating concerns over manageability and scale. The goal of this article is to prompt a debate and a more careful consideration of the potential benefits of a meaningful participation of witnesses and victims in post-atrocity proceedings. This is particularly important given the dominance of the efficiency paradigm in international criminal law (ICL) discourse, which directly impacts the quantitative turn. The article forges new ways for ICL institutions to maintain a plurality of voices and their commitment to victims while safeguarding the rights of the accused.

  • Mass Atrocity, Mass Testimony, and the Quantitative Turn in International Law

    by Renana Keydar

    The article identifies and analyses the development it labels the “quantitative turn” in international criminal law. Addressing the cumulative effect of the large numbers of witnesses in international processes, the article considers quantity as an integral, and substantively beneficial, component of the law's response to atrocity crimes. The article develops a theorized understanding of the relationship between mass atrocity and mass testimony and provides a taxonomy of the functions that the quantity of testimonies fulfills in international trials: the evidentiary, didactic, epistemic, and restorative functions. Focusing on a recent case before the International Criminal Court in the matter of The Prosecutor v. Bemba, the article demonstrates how the different players in the international justice system—Prosecution, Defense, Victims, and the Court—employ the functions of quantity, while negotiating concerns over manageability and scale. The goal of this article is to prompt a debate and a more careful consideration of the potential benefits of a meaningful participation of witnesses and victims in post-atrocity proceedings. This is particularly important given the dominance of the efficiency paradigm in international criminal law (ICL) discourse, which directly impacts the quantitative turn. The article forges new ways for ICL institutions to maintain a plurality of voices and their commitment to victims while safeguarding the rights of the accused.


  • Open Access

    Rethinking Plurality: On Ethics and Storytelling in the Search for Justice

    by Renana Keydar

    The essay takes as its starting point the observation that contemporary legal mechanisms and cultural institutions confront mass atrocity by turning to multiple acts of storytelling by the survivors. As I show, judicial tribunals, truth commissions, museums, historical archives, and film and literature have replaced the once-singular, authoritative voice of the Storyteller with a choir comprising a multitude of narrators and narratives of survival. Focusing on two historic legal processes in which survivors' storytelling played a key role, the Eichmann trial (1961) and the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission (1995), I explore the underlying condition of plurality and its ethical implications from a joint perspective of law and the humanities.