Research environments vis-à-vis biological environments: ontological parallels, epistemic parallax, and metaphilosophical parallelization
Open Access
- 13 September 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal for Philosophy of Science
- Vol. 14 (3) , 1-23
Abstract
In a recent development of what may be called biological philosophy of science, scholars have proposed that aligning notions of research environments with biological concepts of environment holds great promise for understanding the socio-material contexts in and through which science happens. Here, I explore the prospects and potential shortcomings of building sound research environment concepts by contrasting them with biological environment concepts. In doing so, I emphasize the importance of adhering to two central desiderata: the need to clarify what is being environed (i.e., what the counter relatum of an environment is) and what is doing the environing (i.e., what type of environmental partition is instantiated). Subsequently, I juxtapose two biological construals of environment—organismal environments and population environments—with possible articulations of what ‘research environments’ might stand for, and I maintain that each presents distinct epistemic upshots and limitations. More generally, I argue that there are two broad relations that could exist between biological and research environments: ontological parallels and ontic discordance. Finally, employing the visual metaphor of epistemic parallax, I conclude by conveying some lessons and cautionary notes arising from these comparisons and the importation of biological environment concepts into philosophy of science. While environment concepts may come with epistemic purchase, we should be careful when ontologizing them.Keywords
Funding Information
- Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (BA 5808/2-1)
- Fonds Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek (G070122N)
- Ruhr-Universität Bochum
This publication has 63 references indexed in Scilit:
- ‘Does the Claim that there are no Theories Imply that there is no History of Theories to be Written?(!)’*Journal for General Philosophy of Science, 2023
- The Generalized Selective Environment2023
- The Organism in Evolutionary Explanation: From Early Twentieth Century to the Extended Evolutionary Synthesis2023
- The strong program in embodied cognitive sciencePhenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences, 2022
- Unknotting reciprocal causation between organism and environmentBiology & Philosophy, 2021
- Conformity in scientific networksSynthese, 2020
- Redrawing the boundaries of molecular biology: The case of photosynthesisJournal of the History of Biology, 1993
- Knowers talking about the known: Ecological realism as a philosophy of scienceSynthese, 1992
- The Effect of the Scientific Environment in Britain on Refugee Scientists from Germany and Their Effects on Science in BritainBerichte Zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte, 1984
- The concept of population in biologyActa Biotheoretica, 1973