Legitimacy of stakeholder voices in tobacco control in Aotearoa New Zealand
- 26 May 2026
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Tobacco Control
Abstract
Introduction Achieving equitable and effective tobacco control policy in Aotearoa New Zealand requires an understanding of the broader policy system in which such policies are developed. This study applied a critical systems lens, using boundary critique, to explore how certain perspectives and actors become legitimised or excluded in the tobacco policy space. In Critical Systems Heuristics (CSH), a ‘boundary’ refers to the practical line that determines what and who are considered inside the system, such as which goals, actors and knowledge are included and what is positioned outside it. Using this lens, we examined how legitimacy is constructed and contested within the tobacco control system. Methods The research employed CSH to guide two sets of qualitative interviews: one with Indigenous Māori participants (n=10) and another with non-Māori participants (n=14). Thematic analysis was conducted separately for each group focusing on the four domains of CSH, knowledge, motivation, legitimacy and power followed by a comparative analysis to identify areas of overlap and divergence in perspectives. This paper focuses on the legitimacy domain as findings in this area were central to participant discussions and echoed in the other domains. Results Three key legitimacy boundary issues emerged from the analysis: (1) whether tobacco control policy should prioritise a tobacco-free versus addiction-free narrative; (2) the tension between biomedical and holistic health paradigms and (3) whether individual rights or collective rights should be the foundation of policy direction. These boundary issues influenced who was seen as a legitimate actor in policy development and how policy processes were shaped. Conclusions Understanding and navigating these boundary issues is crucial for progressing tobacco control policy that is both equitable and effective. Greater critical awareness of how perspectives are legitimised or marginalised can support more inclusive and transformative policy approaches in Aotearoa.Keywords
Funding Information
- Health Research Council of New Zealand (19/641)
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Looking back and planning ahead: the tobacco endgame and controlling tobacco industry interference in Aotearoa New ZealandJournal of the Royal Society of New Zealand, 2025
- Up in smoke. The unravelling of world-leading policy changes in Smokefree legislation in Aotearoa New ZealandAustralian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health, 2024
- Enhancing cross‐cultural evaluation practice through kaupapa Māori evaluation and boundary critique: Insights from Aotearoa New ZealandNew Directions for Evaluation, 2021
- Tobacco harm reduction in the 21st centuryDrugs and Alcohol Today, 2020
- Useful Complex Causality2012
- Integrative system dynamics: analysis of policy options for tobacco control in New ZealandSystems Research and Behavioral Science, 2008
- A ‘Multiple Lenses’ Approach to Policy Change: The Case of Tobacco Policy in the UKBritish Politics, 2007
- Why Methodology2000
- The theory and practice of boundary critique: developing housing services for older peopleJournal of the Operational Research Society, 1998
- Critical heuristics of social systems designEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 1987