Mat Walton
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Mat Walton has a total of 34 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Emily F. Gates
Boston College Chestnut Hill Massachusetts USA
3 shared publications - Pablo Vidueira
Global Alliance for the Future of Food Washington DC USA
3 shared publications - Sudesh Raj Sharma
DIYASU Community Development Centre, Biratnagar, Nepal
3 shared publications - Suzanne Manning
Institute for Environmental Science and Research, Wellington, Aotearoa New Zealand
3 shared publications George Thomson
Health Promotion and Policy Research Unit, Department of Public Health, University of Otago, New Zealand
2 shared publications- Louise Signal
Health Promotion and Policy Research Unit, Department of Public Health, University of Otago, Wellington, New Zealand
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 26 May 2026
- Published by BMJ in Tobacco Control
Legitimacy of stakeholder voices in tobacco control in Aotearoa New Zealand
Introduction Achieving equitable and effective tobacco control policy in Aotearoa New Zealand requires an understanding of the broader policy system in which such policies are developed. This study applied a critical systems lens, using boundary critique, to explore how certain perspectives and actors become legitimised or excluded in the tobacco policy space. In Critical Systems Heuristics (CSH), a ‘boundary’ refers to the practical line that determines what and who are considered inside the system, such as which goals, actors and knowledge are included and what is positioned outside it. Using this lens, we examined how legitimacy is constructed and contested within the tobacco control system. Methods The research employed CSH to guide two sets of qualitative interviews: one with Indigenous Māori participants (n=10) and another with non-Māori participants (n=14). Thematic analysis was conducted separately for each group focusing on the four domains of CSH, knowledge, motivation, legitimacy and power followed by a comparative analysis to identify areas of overlap and divergence in perspectives. This paper focuses on the legitimacy domain as findings in this area were central to participant discussions and echoed in the other domains. Results Three key legitimacy boundary issues emerged from the analysis: (1) whether tobacco control policy should prioritise a tobacco-free versus addiction-free narrative; (2) the tension between biomedical and holistic health paradigms and (3) whether individual rights or collective rights should be the foundation of policy direction. These boundary issues influenced who was seen as a legitimate actor in policy development and how policy processes were shaped. Conclusions Understanding and navigating these boundary issues is crucial for progressing tobacco control policy that is both equitable and effective. Greater critical awareness of how perspectives are legitimised or marginalised can support more inclusive and transformative policy approaches in Aotearoa.
- 26 May 2026
- Published by BMJ in Tobacco Control
Legitimacy of stakeholder voices in tobacco control in Aotearoa New Zealand
Introduction Achieving equitable and effective tobacco control policy in Aotearoa New Zealand requires an understanding of the broader policy system in which such policies are developed. This study applied a critical systems lens, using boundary critique, to explore how certain perspectives and actors become legitimised or excluded in the tobacco policy space. In Critical Systems Heuristics (CSH), a ‘boundary’ refers to the practical line that determines what and who are considered inside the system, such as which goals, actors and knowledge are included and what is positioned outside it. Using this lens, we examined how legitimacy is constructed and contested within the tobacco control system. Methods The research employed CSH to guide two sets of qualitative interviews: one with Indigenous Māori participants (n=10) and another with non-Māori participants (n=14). Thematic analysis was conducted separately for each group focusing on the four domains of CSH, knowledge, motivation, legitimacy and power followed by a comparative analysis to identify areas of overlap and divergence in perspectives. This paper focuses on the legitimacy domain as findings in this area were central to participant discussions and echoed in the other domains. Results Three key legitimacy boundary issues emerged from the analysis: (1) whether tobacco control policy should prioritise a tobacco-free versus addiction-free narrative; (2) the tension between biomedical and holistic health paradigms and (3) whether individual rights or collective rights should be the foundation of policy direction. These boundary issues influenced who was seen as a legitimate actor in policy development and how policy processes were shaped. Conclusions Understanding and navigating these boundary issues is crucial for progressing tobacco control policy that is both equitable and effective. Greater critical awareness of how perspectives are legitimised or marginalised can support more inclusive and transformative policy approaches in Aotearoa.
- Open Access
- 16 May 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Responsible Innovation
- Vol. 11 (1)
Journeys towards decolonising research practices in Aotearoa New Zealand
- 16 May 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Responsible Innovation
- Vol. 11 (1)
Open AccessJourneys towards decolonising research practices in Aotearoa New Zealand
- Open Access
Realist Review and System Dynamics as a Multimethod Qualitative Synthesis Approach for Analyzing Waste Minimization in Aotearoa New Zealand
Many of society’s most pressing problems, such as climate change, poverty, and waste, are categorized as “wicked” problems because they are seemingly resistant to change. Interventions designed to address these problems can produce unintended consequences, which then perpetuate the problem. Evaluating the effectiveness of such interventions is challenging and requires understanding of the social systems in which the problems are embedded. Multimethodology approaches can support such holistic understanding by combining different methodologies which complement and overlap with each other. This article reports on a study that combined two different methodologies—realist review and qualitative system dynamics. The result was a program theory for waste minimization interventions in Aotearoa New Zealand and a causal loop diagram, which allowed us to identify potential leverage points for change. The two methodologies highlighted different aspects of the problem in complementary ways. For example, the first program theory proposition emphasized the important role of people who were critically conscious of the need for sustainability, while the causal loop diagram showed that there needed to be enough critically conscious people for change to be embedded in the system. The program theory’s third and fourth propositions noted the important role of leadership and resource allocation in shifting interventions away from waste management initiatives, such as recycling plastic bags, towards waste minimization initiatives, such as banning single-use plastic bags. The causal loop diagram demonstrated why resource allocation to waste management initiatives, such as recycling, are not effective in addressing the overall problem of waste by showing the feedback loops that operate in the system. Such insights show that realist reviews and qualitative system dynamics can usefully complement each other for greater understanding of wicked problems.
Open AccessRealist Review and System Dynamics as a Multimethod Qualitative Synthesis Approach for Analyzing Waste Minimization in Aotearoa New Zealand
Many of society’s most pressing problems, such as climate change, poverty, and waste, are categorized as “wicked” problems because they are seemingly resistant to change. Interventions designed to address these problems can produce unintended consequences, which then perpetuate the problem. Evaluating the effectiveness of such interventions is challenging and requires understanding of the social systems in which the problems are embedded. Multimethodology approaches can support such holistic understanding by combining different methodologies which complement and overlap with each other. This article reports on a study that combined two different methodologies—realist review and qualitative system dynamics. The result was a program theory for waste minimization interventions in Aotearoa New Zealand and a causal loop diagram, which allowed us to identify potential leverage points for change. The two methodologies highlighted different aspects of the problem in complementary ways. For example, the first program theory proposition emphasized the important role of people who were critically conscious of the need for sustainability, while the causal loop diagram showed that there needed to be enough critically conscious people for change to be embedded in the system. The program theory’s third and fourth propositions noted the important role of leadership and resource allocation in shifting interventions away from waste management initiatives, such as recycling plastic bags, towards waste minimization initiatives, such as banning single-use plastic bags. The causal loop diagram demonstrated why resource allocation to waste management initiatives, such as recycling, are not effective in addressing the overall problem of waste by showing the feedback loops that operate in the system. Such insights show that realist reviews and qualitative system dynamics can usefully complement each other for greater understanding of wicked problems.
- Open Access
Social Determinants of Health Influencing the New Zealand COVID-19 Response and Recovery: A Scoping Review and Causal Loop Diagram
The Coronavirus pandemic of 2019–20 (COVID-19) affected multiple social determinants of health (SDH) across the globe, including in New Zealand, exacerbating health inequities. Understanding these system dynamics can support decision making for the pandemic response and recovery measures. This study combined a scoping review with a causal loop diagram to further understanding of the connections between SDH, pandemic measures, and both short- and long-term outcomes in New Zealand. The causal loop diagram showed the reinforcing nature of structural SDH, such as colonization and socio-economic influences, on health inequities. While balancing actions taken by government eliminated COVID-19, the diagram showed that existing structural SDH inequities could increase health inequities in the longer term, unless the opportunity is taken for socio-economic policies to be reset. Such policy resets would be difficult to implement, as they are at odds with the current socio-economic system. The causal loop diagram highlighted that SDH significantly influenced the dynamics of the COVID-19 impact and response, pointing to a need for purposeful systemic action to disrupt the reinforcing loops which increase health inequities over time. This will require strong systems leadership, and coordination between policy makers and implementation at local level.
Open AccessSocial Determinants of Health Influencing the New Zealand COVID-19 Response and Recovery: A Scoping Review and Causal Loop Diagram
The Coronavirus pandemic of 2019–20 (COVID-19) affected multiple social determinants of health (SDH) across the globe, including in New Zealand, exacerbating health inequities. Understanding these system dynamics can support decision making for the pandemic response and recovery measures. This study combined a scoping review with a causal loop diagram to further understanding of the connections between SDH, pandemic measures, and both short- and long-term outcomes in New Zealand. The causal loop diagram showed the reinforcing nature of structural SDH, such as colonization and socio-economic influences, on health inequities. While balancing actions taken by government eliminated COVID-19, the diagram showed that existing structural SDH inequities could increase health inequities in the longer term, unless the opportunity is taken for socio-economic policies to be reset. Such policy resets would be difficult to implement, as they are at odds with the current socio-economic system. The causal loop diagram highlighted that SDH significantly influenced the dynamics of the COVID-19 impact and response, pointing to a need for purposeful systemic action to disrupt the reinforcing loops which increase health inequities over time. This will require strong systems leadership, and coordination between policy makers and implementation at local level.
- 1 June 2021
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2021 (170) , 7-11
Editors’ notes
- Open Access
- 1 June 2021
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2021 (170) , 159-171
Insights and future directions for systems and complexity‐informed evaluation
With the increasing maturity of systems thinking and complexity science (STCS) within evaluation, this issue of NDE provides case examples of contemporary application. This article identifies themes across case examples to identify emergent patterns and opportunities for the continued development of evaluation practices that draw upon STCS. Each article describes STCS and its applications within specific evaluation contexts. Our review across cases identified three themes: (1) the importance of setting boundaries around what is included and excluded from within the STCS field in a specific evaluation; (2) using STCS concepts and theories to enhance program and evaluation theory, and (3) broadly drawing upon STCS to support changes in systems and develop capacity within organizations. While these implications show some promise for systems and complexity informed evaluation, they, more importantly, underscore the need for deeper engagement with STCS theories and methods while simultaneously remaining accessible for evaluators.
- 1 June 2021
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2021 (170) , 159-171
Open AccessInsights and future directions for systems and complexity‐informed evaluation
With the increasing maturity of systems thinking and complexity science (STCS) within evaluation, this issue of NDE provides case examples of contemporary application. This article identifies themes across case examples to identify emergent patterns and opportunities for the continued development of evaluation practices that draw upon STCS. Each article describes STCS and its applications within specific evaluation contexts. Our review across cases identified three themes: (1) the importance of setting boundaries around what is included and excluded from within the STCS field in a specific evaluation; (2) using STCS concepts and theories to enhance program and evaluation theory, and (3) broadly drawing upon STCS to support changes in systems and develop capacity within organizations. While these implications show some promise for systems and complexity informed evaluation, they, more importantly, underscore the need for deeper engagement with STCS theories and methods while simultaneously remaining accessible for evaluators.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2021
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2021 (170) , 13-25
Introducing systems‐ and complexity‐informed evaluation
For the last several decades and recently amidst the COVID‐19 pandemic, many in the global evaluation communities call for shifts from linear, reductionist ways of thinking and working to approaches that embrace systems and complexity. In this introductory chapter, we orient readers to key systems and complexity traditions and terms and how these have been put to use in the evaluation field. Doing so provides a foundation from which to engage with the subsequent chapters. We close this chapter with highlights from the case examples featured in this issue.
- 1 June 2021
- Published by Wiley in New Directions for Evaluation
- Vol. 2021 (170) , 13-25
Open AccessIntroducing systems‐ and complexity‐informed evaluation
For the last several decades and recently amidst the COVID‐19 pandemic, many in the global evaluation communities call for shifts from linear, reductionist ways of thinking and working to approaches that embrace systems and complexity. In this introductory chapter, we orient readers to key systems and complexity traditions and terms and how these have been put to use in the evaluation field. Doing so provides a foundation from which to engage with the subsequent chapters. We close this chapter with highlights from the case examples featured in this issue.
- Open Access
- 23 September 2020
- Published by Wiley in Kōtuitui: New Zealand Journal of Social Sciences Online
- Vol. 16 (1) , 180-195
Contracting public health and social services: insights from complexity theory for Aotearoa New Zealand
Public health and social services are often hard to specify, complex to deliver and challenging to measure. This research uses a complexity theory‐informed lens to explore the challenges and opportunities of contracting out for public health and social services in Aotearoa New Zealand. This qualitative study considers the implications of complexity concepts with ten public sector managers experienced in contracting out for public health and social services. Our findings show that public sector managers are experimenting with different ways of contracting out, yet the underlying New Public Management ethos, which is being applied in many administrative arms of government, can hamper initiatives. There is a growing impetus to find alternative approaches to contract out more effectively. An alternative, complexity theory‐informed, framing highlights where changes to contracting out organisation and practices may support more effective service provision. This research also provides insights into why achieving change is hard.
- 23 September 2020
- Published by Wiley in Kōtuitui: New Zealand Journal of Social Sciences Online
- Vol. 16 (1) , 180-195
Open AccessContracting public health and social services: insights from complexity theory for Aotearoa New Zealand
Public health and social services are often hard to specify, complex to deliver and challenging to measure. This research uses a complexity theory‐informed lens to explore the challenges and opportunities of contracting out for public health and social services in Aotearoa New Zealand. This qualitative study considers the implications of complexity concepts with ten public sector managers experienced in contracting out for public health and social services. Our findings show that public sector managers are experimenting with different ways of contracting out, yet the underlying New Public Management ethos, which is being applied in many administrative arms of government, can hamper initiatives. There is a growing impetus to find alternative approaches to contract out more effectively. An alternative, complexity theory‐informed, framing highlights where changes to contracting out organisation and practices may support more effective service provision. This research also provides insights into why achieving change is hard.
- 8 September 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Health Promotion International
- Vol. 35 (5) , 947-957
Strengthening prevention in communities through systems change: lessons from the evaluation of Healthy Families NZ
This article presents the findings from the first 3 years of the evaluation of Healthy Families NZ, a systems-change intervention to prevent chronic diseases in 10 communities. The initiative, which builds on existing prevention activities, aims to strengthen the health prevention system through evidence-driven action to enable people to make good food choices, be physically active, smoke-free and free from alcohol-related harm. Key investment areas are a dedicated systems thinking and acting health promotion workforce, and activating leaders who can influence transformational change. The evaluation to date has found the initiative is being implemented with integrity. Evidence indicates a shift towards greater action on prevention, and the prevention system being strengthened. Māori ownership has been enabled, and prioritizing equity has led teams to utilize methods that amplify diverse local perspectives. There is progress on developing a flexible workforce through adaptive learning, flexible resources, professional development and a responsive National team. There is also progress in activating local leadership and empowering local teams. The initiative design has explicitly taken into account the context of complexity within which it is being implemented. It has evolved to focus on action that can accelerate sharing information and practices within communities, and between policy and decision-makers. Healthy Families NZ and its evaluation have been refunded to 2022. This provides an important opportunity to gather further insight into effective ways to strengthen the community agency and trust needed to promote and deliver evidence-based action on prevention.
- 8 September 2019
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Health Promotion International
- Vol. 35 (5) , 947-957
Strengthening prevention in communities through systems change: lessons from the evaluation of Healthy Families NZ
This article presents the findings from the first 3 years of the evaluation of Healthy Families NZ, a systems-change intervention to prevent chronic diseases in 10 communities. The initiative, which builds on existing prevention activities, aims to strengthen the health prevention system through evidence-driven action to enable people to make good food choices, be physically active, smoke-free and free from alcohol-related harm. Key investment areas are a dedicated systems thinking and acting health promotion workforce, and activating leaders who can influence transformational change. The evaluation to date has found the initiative is being implemented with integrity. Evidence indicates a shift towards greater action on prevention, and the prevention system being strengthened. Māori ownership has been enabled, and prioritizing equity has led teams to utilize methods that amplify diverse local perspectives. There is progress on developing a flexible workforce through adaptive learning, flexible resources, professional development and a responsive National team. There is also progress in activating local leadership and empowering local teams. The initiative design has explicitly taken into account the context of complexity within which it is being implemented. It has evolved to focus on action that can accelerate sharing information and practices within communities, and between policy and decision-makers. Healthy Families NZ and its evaluation have been refunded to 2022. This provides an important opportunity to gather further insight into effective ways to strengthen the community agency and trust needed to promote and deliver evidence-based action on prevention.
- Open Access
- 1 September 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 40 (3) , 606-613
Evaluating a community-based public health intervention using a complex systems approach
This article outlines the methods being used to evaluate a community-based public health intervention. This evaluation approach recognizes that not only is the intervention, Healthy Families NZ, complex, but the social systems within which it is being implemented are complex. To address challenges related to complexity, we discuss three developing areas within evaluation theory and apply them to an evaluation case example. The example, Healthy Families NZ, aims to strengthen the prevention system in Aotearoa/New Zealand to prevent chronic disease in 10 different geographic areas. Central to the evaluation design is the comparative case method which recognizes that emergent outcomes are the result of ‘configurations of causes’. ‘Thick’, mixed-data, case studies are developed, with each case considered a view of a complex system. Qualitative Comparative Analysis is the analytical approach used to systematically compare the cases over time. This article describes an approach to evaluating a community-based public health intervention that considers the social systems in which the initiative is being implemented to be complex. The evaluation case example provides a unique opportunity to operationalize and test these methods, while extending their more frequent use within other fields to the field of public health.
- 1 September 2017
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 40 (3) , 606-613
Open AccessEvaluating a community-based public health intervention using a complex systems approach
This article outlines the methods being used to evaluate a community-based public health intervention. This evaluation approach recognizes that not only is the intervention, Healthy Families NZ, complex, but the social systems within which it is being implemented are complex. To address challenges related to complexity, we discuss three developing areas within evaluation theory and apply them to an evaluation case example. The example, Healthy Families NZ, aims to strengthen the prevention system in Aotearoa/New Zealand to prevent chronic disease in 10 different geographic areas. Central to the evaluation design is the comparative case method which recognizes that emergent outcomes are the result of ‘configurations of causes’. ‘Thick’, mixed-data, case studies are developed, with each case considered a view of a complex system. Qualitative Comparative Analysis is the analytical approach used to systematically compare the cases over time. This article describes an approach to evaluating a community-based public health intervention that considers the social systems in which the initiative is being implemented to be complex. The evaluation case example provides a unique opportunity to operationalize and test these methods, while extending their more frequent use within other fields to the field of public health.