Synthesis of the Evidence on What Works for Whom in Telemental Health: Rapid Realist Review
Authors:
- Merle SchliefMSMerle Schlief
- Katherine R K SaundersKSKatherine R K Saunders
- Rebecca AppletonRARebecca Appleton
- Phoebe BarnettPBPhoebe Barnett
- Norha Vera San JuanNJNorha Vera San Juan
- Una FoyeUFUna Foye
- Rachel Rowan OliveRORachel Rowan Olive
- Karen MachinKMKaren Machin
- Prisha ShahPSPrisha Shah
- Beverley ChippBCBeverley Chipp
- Natasha LyonsNLNatasha Lyons
- Camilla TamworthCamilla Tamworth
Open Access
- 29 September 2022
- journal article
- review article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Interactive Journal of Medical Research
- Vol. 11 (2) , e38239
Abstract
Background: Telemental health (delivering mental health care via video calls, telephone calls, or SMS text messages) is becoming increasingly widespread. Telemental health appears to be useful and effective in providing care to some service users in some settings, especially during an emergency restricting face-to-face contact, such as the COVID-19 pandemic. However, important limitations have been reported, and telemental health implementation risks the reinforcement of pre-existing inequalities in service provision. If it is to be widely incorporated into routine care, a clear understanding is needed of when and for whom it is an acceptable and effective approach and when face-to-face care is needed. Objective: This rapid realist review aims to develop a theory about which telemental health approaches work (or do not work), for whom, in which contexts, and through what mechanisms. Methods: Rapid realist reviewing involves synthesizing relevant evidence and stakeholder expertise to allow timely development of context-mechanism-outcome (CMO) configurations in areas where evidence is urgently needed to inform policy and practice. The CMO configurations encapsulate theories about what works for whom and by what mechanisms. Sources included eligible papers from 2 previous systematic reviews conducted by our team on telemental health; an updated search using the strategy from these reviews; a call for relevant evidence, including “gray literature,” to the public and key experts; and website searches of relevant voluntary and statutory organizations. CMO configurations formulated from these sources were iteratively refined, including through discussions with an expert reference group, including researchers with relevant lived experience and frontline clinicians, and consultation with experts focused on three priority groups: children and young people, users of inpatient and crisis care services, and digitally excluded groups. Results: A total of 108 scientific and gray literature sources were included. From our initial CMO configurations, we derived 30 overarching CMO configurations within four domains: connecting effectively; flexibility and personalization; safety, privacy, and confidentiality; and therapeutic quality and relationship. Reports and stakeholder input emphasized the importance of personal choice, privacy and safety, and therapeutic relationships in telemental health care. The review also identified particular service users likely to be disadvantaged by telemental health implementation and a need to ensure that face-to-face care of equivalent timeliness remains available. Mechanisms underlying the successful and unsuccessful application of telemental health are discussed. Conclusions: Service user choice, privacy and safety, the ability to connect effectively, and fostering strong therapeutic relationships need to be prioritized in delivering telemental health care. Guidelines and strategies coproduced with service users and frontline staff are needed to optimize telemental health implementation in real-world settings. Trial Registration: International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO); CRD42021260910; https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?ID=CRD42021260910Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 151 references indexed in Scilit:
- A time-responsive tool for informing policy making: rapid realist reviewImplementation Science, 2013
- Telehealth Cognitive Behavior Therapy for Co‐Occurring Insomnia and Depression Symptoms in Older AdultsJournal of Clinical Psychology, 2013
- Reaching Rural Communities with Culturally Appropriate Care: A Model for Adapting Remote Monitoring to American Indian Veterans with Posttraumatic Stress DisorderTelemedicine and e-Health, 2013
- Evidence summaries: the evolution of a rapid review approachSystematic Reviews, 2012
- Why social anxiety persists: An experimental investigation of the role of safety behaviours as a maintaining factorJournal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 2008
- Online counselling: The experience of counsellors providing synchronous single‐session counselling to young peopleCounselling and Psychotherapy Research, 2008
- Online counselling: The motives and experiences of young people who choose the Internet instead of face to face or telephone counsellingCounselling and Psychotherapy Research, 2006
- Realist review - a new method of systematic review designed for complex policy interventionsJournal of Health Services Research & Policy, 2005
- Evaluation of a Rural Telepsychiatry ServiceAustralasian Psychiatry, 2004
- Treatment Teams that Work (and those that don't): An Application of Hackman's Group Effectiveness Model to Interdisciplinary Teams in Psychiatric HospitalsThe Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 1995