Merle Schlief
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Merle Schlief has a total of 136 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Sonia Johnson
NIHR Mental Health Policy Research Unit, Division of Psychiatry, University College London, London, UK; Camden and Islington NHS Foundation Trust, UK
5 shared publicationsLuke Sheridan Rains
NIHR Mental Health Policy Research Unit, Division of Psychiatry, University College London, London, UK
4 shared publications- Alan Simpson
Health Service and Population Research, Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology and Neuroscience, King's College London, London, United Kingdom
3 shared publications - David Osborn
Division of Psychiatry, University College London, UK
3 shared publications - Helen Killaspy
Division of Psychiatry, University College London, London, United Kingdom
3 shared publications Karen Persaud
Department of Primary Care and Public Health, Brighton and Sussex Medical School, Brighton, UK
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 6 November 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 23 (11) , 1396
How Can Health and Social Care Services in the United Kingdom Be Improved for People from Sexual Minorities? A Systematic Review and Narrative Synthesis of Guidelines, Guidance, and Training
Sexual minorities (e.g., lesbian, gay, and bisexual individuals) experience significant health inequalities and report negative identity-related experiences within UK health and social care services. Despite staff training being recommended to improve care for this population, training provision remains inconsistent. This systematic review synthesised UK-focussed guidance documents, training materials, and training evaluations aimed at improving health and social care staff’s work with sexual minority people. We systematically searched nine databases (MEDLINE®, EMBASE, PsycINFO, Social Policy and Practice, CINAHL Plus, ERIC, Applied Social Sciences Index & Abstracts, International Bibliography of the Social Sciences, and Web of Science) and searched the supplementary grey literature. Studies of any design, training materials, and guidance documents, published from 2010 onwards, were eligible. Screening, data extraction, and quality assessment were conducted independently by two researchers. A narrative synthesis, and content analysis of the guidance documents, was conducted. Study quality was assessed using the QualSyst tool, and guidance documents were appraised using the AGREE II. Thirty-one guidance documents, five training evaluations, one good practice paper, and one set of training materials were included. Guidance documents targeted health and social care staff, services, and commissioners. Consistent recommendations included using neutral language, avoiding assumptions about sexual orientation, recognising the diversity of sexual minority identities, explicitly including sexual minorities in policies, addressing prejudice and discrimination, providing staff training, having visible signs of inclusivity, and routinely collecting and monitoring sexual orientation data. Training evaluations suggested that training can improve staff competence in working with sexual minorities. This review provides the most comprehensive synthesis to date of UK guidance and training relating to health and social care provision for sexual minority service users. It identifies a consistent set of practical, largely low-cost actions that organisations and staff can prioritise to create safe and inclusive services.
- 6 November 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 23 (11) , 1396
Open AccessHow Can Health and Social Care Services in the United Kingdom Be Improved for People from Sexual Minorities? A Systematic Review and Narrative Synthesis of Guidelines, Guidance, and Training
Sexual minorities (e.g., lesbian, gay, and bisexual individuals) experience significant health inequalities and report negative identity-related experiences within UK health and social care services. Despite staff training being recommended to improve care for this population, training provision remains inconsistent. This systematic review synthesised UK-focussed guidance documents, training materials, and training evaluations aimed at improving health and social care staff’s work with sexual minority people. We systematically searched nine databases (MEDLINE®, EMBASE, PsycINFO, Social Policy and Practice, CINAHL Plus, ERIC, Applied Social Sciences Index & Abstracts, International Bibliography of the Social Sciences, and Web of Science) and searched the supplementary grey literature. Studies of any design, training materials, and guidance documents, published from 2010 onwards, were eligible. Screening, data extraction, and quality assessment were conducted independently by two researchers. A narrative synthesis, and content analysis of the guidance documents, was conducted. Study quality was assessed using the QualSyst tool, and guidance documents were appraised using the AGREE II. Thirty-one guidance documents, five training evaluations, one good practice paper, and one set of training materials were included. Guidance documents targeted health and social care staff, services, and commissioners. Consistent recommendations included using neutral language, avoiding assumptions about sexual orientation, recognising the diversity of sexual minority identities, explicitly including sexual minorities in policies, addressing prejudice and discrimination, providing staff training, having visible signs of inclusivity, and routinely collecting and monitoring sexual orientation data. Training evaluations suggested that training can improve staff competence in working with sexual minorities. This review provides the most comprehensive synthesis to date of UK guidance and training relating to health and social care provision for sexual minority service users. It identifies a consistent set of practical, largely low-cost actions that organisations and staff can prioritise to create safe and inclusive services.
- Open Access
- 15 September 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
How Can Health and Social Care Services in the United Kingdom be Improved for People from Sexual Minorities? A Systematic Review and Narrative Synthesis of Guidelines, Guidance, and Training
Sexual minorities (e.g., lesbian, gay, and bisexual individuals) experience significant health inequalities and report negative identity-related experiences within UK health and social care services. Despite staff training being recommended to improve care for this population, training provision remains inconsistent. This systematic review synthesised UK-focussed guidance documents, training materials, and training evaluations aimed at improving health and social care staff’s work with sexual minority people. We systematically searched nine databases (MEDLINE®, EMBASE, PsycINFO, Social Policy and Practice, CINAHL Plus, ERIC, Applied Social Sciences Index & Abstracts, International Bibliography of the Social Sciences, and Web of Science) and searched supplementary grey literature. Studies of any design, training materials, and guidance documents, published from 2010 onwards were eligible. Screening, data extraction, and quality assessment were conducted independently by two researchers. A narrative synthesis, and content analysis of the guidance documents, was conducted. Study quality was assessed using the QualSyst tool, and guidance documents were appraised using the AGREE II. Thirty-one guidance documents, six training evaluations, and one set of training materials were included. Guidance targeted health and social care staff, services, and commissioners. Consistent recommendations included using neutral language, avoiding assumptions about sexual orientation, recognising the diversity of sexual minority identities, explicitly including sexual minorities in policies, addressing prejudice and discrimination, providing staff training, having visible signs of inclusivity, and routinely collecting and monitoring sexual orientation data. Training evaluations suggested that training can improve staff competence in working with sexual minorities. This review provides the most comprehensive synthesis to date of UK guidance and training relating to health and social care provision for sexual minority service users. It identifies a consistent set of practical, largely low-cost actions that organisations and staff can prioritise to create safe and inclusive services.
- 15 September 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessHow Can Health and Social Care Services in the United Kingdom be Improved for People from Sexual Minorities? A Systematic Review and Narrative Synthesis of Guidelines, Guidance, and Training
Sexual minorities (e.g., lesbian, gay, and bisexual individuals) experience significant health inequalities and report negative identity-related experiences within UK health and social care services. Despite staff training being recommended to improve care for this population, training provision remains inconsistent. This systematic review synthesised UK-focussed guidance documents, training materials, and training evaluations aimed at improving health and social care staff’s work with sexual minority people. We systematically searched nine databases (MEDLINE®, EMBASE, PsycINFO, Social Policy and Practice, CINAHL Plus, ERIC, Applied Social Sciences Index & Abstracts, International Bibliography of the Social Sciences, and Web of Science) and searched supplementary grey literature. Studies of any design, training materials, and guidance documents, published from 2010 onwards were eligible. Screening, data extraction, and quality assessment were conducted independently by two researchers. A narrative synthesis, and content analysis of the guidance documents, was conducted. Study quality was assessed using the QualSyst tool, and guidance documents were appraised using the AGREE II. Thirty-one guidance documents, six training evaluations, and one set of training materials were included. Guidance targeted health and social care staff, services, and commissioners. Consistent recommendations included using neutral language, avoiding assumptions about sexual orientation, recognising the diversity of sexual minority identities, explicitly including sexual minorities in policies, addressing prejudice and discrimination, providing staff training, having visible signs of inclusivity, and routinely collecting and monitoring sexual orientation data. Training evaluations suggested that training can improve staff competence in working with sexual minorities. This review provides the most comprehensive synthesis to date of UK guidance and training relating to health and social care provision for sexual minority service users. It identifies a consistent set of practical, largely low-cost actions that organisations and staff can prioritise to create safe and inclusive services.
- Open Access
- 21 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Association between Family Income Trajectories in Childhood and Diagnosis of Psychotic or Bipolar Disorders by Parental Migrant Status: A Swedish Population-Based Study
Background: Low income is linked to higher rates of psychiatric disorders, but differences by parental migrant status remain unclear. We investigated associations between family income trajectories and non-affective psychotic disorders, affective psychotic disorders, and non-psychotic bipolar disorders, by parental migrant status.Methods: Register data for individuals born in Sweden between 1990-1996 were analysed, using group-based trajectory modelling to categorise individuals into family income trajectories from birth through age 14. Logistic regression estimated associations between income trajectories and psychiatric disorders by parental migrant status.Results: We categorised 767,337 individuals into six income trajectory groups: lowest, low-to-increasing, steady-increasing, fluctuating, moderate, and highest. Associations for non-affective psychotic disorders and affective psychotic disorders did not vary by migrant status. Children of migrants (CoM) and Swedish-born (CoSB) parents in the lowest (aORCoM: 1·89; 95%CI 1·22-2·92, aORCoSB: 1·36; 95%CI 1·14-1·63) and fluctuating income groups (aORCoM: 1·97; 95%CI 1·26-3·08, aORCoSB: 1·31; 95%CI 1·09-1·56) had the highest odds of non-affective psychotic disorders relative to the highest income group. No differences were observed for affective psychotic disorders across income groups. Non-psychotic bipolar disorder was elevated in the low-to-increasing (aOR: 1·68; 95%CI 1·12-2·54), steady-increasing (aOR: 1·95; 95%CI 1·28-2·96), fluctuating (aOR: 2·16; 95%CI 1·43-3·26), and moderate (aOR: 2·05; 95%CI 1·34-3·13) income groups among CoM only.Conclusions: Low and fluctuating family income were associated with increased odds of non-affective psychotic disorders regardless of parental migrant status. Family income was associated with non-psychotic bipolar disorders among CoM only, suggesting intersectional inequalities may exacerbate risk of non-psychotic bipolar disorder in this group.
- 21 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessAssociation between Family Income Trajectories in Childhood and Diagnosis of Psychotic or Bipolar Disorders by Parental Migrant Status: A Swedish Population-Based Study
Background: Low income is linked to higher rates of psychiatric disorders, but differences by parental migrant status remain unclear. We investigated associations between family income trajectories and non-affective psychotic disorders, affective psychotic disorders, and non-psychotic bipolar disorders, by parental migrant status.Methods: Register data for individuals born in Sweden between 1990-1996 were analysed, using group-based trajectory modelling to categorise individuals into family income trajectories from birth through age 14. Logistic regression estimated associations between income trajectories and psychiatric disorders by parental migrant status.Results: We categorised 767,337 individuals into six income trajectory groups: lowest, low-to-increasing, steady-increasing, fluctuating, moderate, and highest. Associations for non-affective psychotic disorders and affective psychotic disorders did not vary by migrant status. Children of migrants (CoM) and Swedish-born (CoSB) parents in the lowest (aORCoM: 1·89; 95%CI 1·22-2·92, aORCoSB: 1·36; 95%CI 1·14-1·63) and fluctuating income groups (aORCoM: 1·97; 95%CI 1·26-3·08, aORCoSB: 1·31; 95%CI 1·09-1·56) had the highest odds of non-affective psychotic disorders relative to the highest income group. No differences were observed for affective psychotic disorders across income groups. Non-psychotic bipolar disorder was elevated in the low-to-increasing (aOR: 1·68; 95%CI 1·12-2·54), steady-increasing (aOR: 1·95; 95%CI 1·28-2·96), fluctuating (aOR: 2·16; 95%CI 1·43-3·26), and moderate (aOR: 2·05; 95%CI 1·34-3·13) income groups among CoM only.Conclusions: Low and fluctuating family income were associated with increased odds of non-affective psychotic disorders regardless of parental migrant status. Family income was associated with non-psychotic bipolar disorders among CoM only, suggesting intersectional inequalities may exacerbate risk of non-psychotic bipolar disorder in this group.
- Open Access
The Experiences of Sexual Minority Service Users and Staff in Statutory Mental Health Services in the United Kingdom: a Systematic Review and Narrative Synthesis
Background: Despite improving legal protections in recent decades for sexual minorities in the UK, sexual minorities continue to experience significant mental health disparities relative to heterosexuals, and report negative experiences within mental health services that is related to their sexual identity. However, little attention has been paid to the impact of these negative experiences on outcomes within services, or to the experiences of sexual minority staff. To overcome these gaps, the aim of this review is to explore the experiences of sexual minority staff and service users in statutory mental health services in the UK, including a focus on outcomes for service users. Methods: For the systematic search, we searched: Applied Social Sciences Index & Abstracts, EMBASE, MEDLINE®, PsycINFO, CINAHL Plus, and Web of Science for relevant articles, and for the suppementaty search, we searched the websites of relevant organisations, in addition to searching Google, Google Scholar, and DuckDuckGo. We included all study designs, published from 2010 onwards, that included first-hand accounts of sexual minority staff or service users in statutory mental health services in the UK. We used a narrative synthesis to synthesise the findings. Results: Of 7427 articles identified, 84 were assessed at full text screening, with 11 being included in the review. 9 of the included studies were with adults, with the majority being conducted in the context of Talking Therapies and primary care counselling services (n = 7). Across studies, sexual minorities reported anticipatory anxiety about experiencing prejudice and discrimination in services, microaggressions (e.g., heteronormative assumptions) and the pathologization of their sexual minority identities. There are mixed findings about whether certain sexual minority groups have worse outcomes in Talking Therapies services. We found no studies that explored the experiences of sexual minority staff. Conclusions: Sexual minority service users are reporting negative experiences in some statutory mental health services in the UK that are related to their sexual identity. In line with service user recommendations, services should consider introducing sexual minority training for staff to improve the experiences of service users. An absence of research on sexual minority staff, and little research on the experiences of young people from sexual minorities, highlight the need for research in this area
Open AccessThe Experiences of Sexual Minority Service Users and Staff in Statutory Mental Health Services in the United Kingdom: a Systematic Review and Narrative Synthesis
Background: Despite improving legal protections in recent decades for sexual minorities in the UK, sexual minorities continue to experience significant mental health disparities relative to heterosexuals, and report negative experiences within mental health services that is related to their sexual identity. However, little attention has been paid to the impact of these negative experiences on outcomes within services, or to the experiences of sexual minority staff. To overcome these gaps, the aim of this review is to explore the experiences of sexual minority staff and service users in statutory mental health services in the UK, including a focus on outcomes for service users. Methods: For the systematic search, we searched: Applied Social Sciences Index & Abstracts, EMBASE, MEDLINE®, PsycINFO, CINAHL Plus, and Web of Science for relevant articles, and for the suppementaty search, we searched the websites of relevant organisations, in addition to searching Google, Google Scholar, and DuckDuckGo. We included all study designs, published from 2010 onwards, that included first-hand accounts of sexual minority staff or service users in statutory mental health services in the UK. We used a narrative synthesis to synthesise the findings. Results: Of 7427 articles identified, 84 were assessed at full text screening, with 11 being included in the review. 9 of the included studies were with adults, with the majority being conducted in the context of Talking Therapies and primary care counselling services (n = 7). Across studies, sexual minorities reported anticipatory anxiety about experiencing prejudice and discrimination in services, microaggressions (e.g., heteronormative assumptions) and the pathologization of their sexual minority identities. There are mixed findings about whether certain sexual minority groups have worse outcomes in Talking Therapies services. We found no studies that explored the experiences of sexual minority staff. Conclusions: Sexual minority service users are reporting negative experiences in some statutory mental health services in the UK that are related to their sexual identity. In line with service user recommendations, services should consider introducing sexual minority training for staff to improve the experiences of service users. An absence of research on sexual minority staff, and little research on the experiences of young people from sexual minorities, highlight the need for research in this area
- 15 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Mental Health
- Vol. 2 (3) , 257-258
Mental health inequality in young LGBT+ people demands early universal interventions
- 15 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Mental Health
- Vol. 2 (3) , 257-258
Mental health inequality in young LGBT+ people demands early universal interventions
- Open Access
- 7 October 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Psychiatry Research
- Vol. 330, 115529
Ethnic differences in receipt of psychological interventions in Early Intervention in Psychosis services in England – a cross-sectional study
- 7 October 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Psychiatry Research
- Vol. 330, 115529
Open AccessEthnic differences in receipt of psychological interventions in Early Intervention in Psychosis services in England – a cross-sectional study
- Open Access
Ethnic differences in receipt of psychological interventions in Early Intervention in Psychosis services in England: a cross-sectional study
Background There is some evidence of inequitable psychosis care provision by ethnicity. We investigated variations in the receipt of CBTp and family intervention across ethnic groups in Early Intervention in Psychosis (EIP) teams throughout England, where national policy mandates offering these interventions to all. Methods We included data on 29,610 service users from the National Clinical Audit of Psychosis (NCAP), collected between 2018 and 2021. We conducted mixed effects logistic regression to examine odds ratios of receiving an intervention (CBTp, family intervention, or either intervention) across 17 ethnic groups while accounting for the effect of years and variance between teams and adjusting for individual- (age, gender, occupational status) and team-level covariates (care-coordinator caseload and mental health inequalities strategies). Findings Compared with White British people, every minoritized ethnic group, except those of mixed Asian-White and mixed Black African-White ethnicities, had lower adjusted odds of receiving CBTp (aOR 0·39, 95%CI 0·32-0·47 to 0·80, 0·64-1·00). People of Black African (0·61, 0·53-0·69), Black Caribbean (0·67, 0·56-0·81), non-African/Caribbean Black (0·63, 0·51-0·79), non-British/Irish White (0·73, 0·64-0·84), and of “any other” (0·66, 0·54-0·81) ethnicity also experienced lower adjusted odds of receiving family intervention. Interpretation Pervasive inequalities in receiving CBTp for first episode psychosis exist for almost all minoritized ethnic groups, and family intervention for many groups. Investigating how these inequalities arise should be a research priority, allowing co-produced development and testing of approaches to address them. Funding Independent research commissioned and funded by the National Institute for Health Research Policy Research Programme.
Open AccessEthnic differences in receipt of psychological interventions in Early Intervention in Psychosis services in England: a cross-sectional study
Background There is some evidence of inequitable psychosis care provision by ethnicity. We investigated variations in the receipt of CBTp and family intervention across ethnic groups in Early Intervention in Psychosis (EIP) teams throughout England, where national policy mandates offering these interventions to all. Methods We included data on 29,610 service users from the National Clinical Audit of Psychosis (NCAP), collected between 2018 and 2021. We conducted mixed effects logistic regression to examine odds ratios of receiving an intervention (CBTp, family intervention, or either intervention) across 17 ethnic groups while accounting for the effect of years and variance between teams and adjusting for individual- (age, gender, occupational status) and team-level covariates (care-coordinator caseload and mental health inequalities strategies). Findings Compared with White British people, every minoritized ethnic group, except those of mixed Asian-White and mixed Black African-White ethnicities, had lower adjusted odds of receiving CBTp (aOR 0·39, 95%CI 0·32-0·47 to 0·80, 0·64-1·00). People of Black African (0·61, 0·53-0·69), Black Caribbean (0·67, 0·56-0·81), non-African/Caribbean Black (0·63, 0·51-0·79), non-British/Irish White (0·73, 0·64-0·84), and of “any other” (0·66, 0·54-0·81) ethnicity also experienced lower adjusted odds of receiving family intervention. Interpretation Pervasive inequalities in receiving CBTp for first episode psychosis exist for almost all minoritized ethnic groups, and family intervention for many groups. Investigating how these inequalities arise should be a research priority, allowing co-produced development and testing of approaches to address them. Funding Independent research commissioned and funded by the National Institute for Health Research Policy Research Programme.
- Open Access
- 13 February 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Human Behaviour
- Vol. 7 (4) , 556-567
A rapid realist review of universal interventions to promote inclusivity and acceptance of diverse sexual and gender identities in schools
Universal interventions to promote inclusivity and acceptance of diverse sexual and gender identities in schools could help to prevent mental health problems in this population. We reviewed evidence and developed programme theories to explain which universal interventions work, for whom, in which contexts and why. We conducted a rapid realist review and extracted data in context–mechanism–outcome configurations, to develop and refine programme theories. We included 53 sources and identified five intervention themes: student pride clubs, inclusive antibullying and harassment policies, inclusive curricula, workshops and staff training. Here, we show that these interventions could work by reducing discrimination, bullying and marginalization. Interventions appear to work best when school staff are trained and the school climate is supportive and may be less effective for boys, gender minority students and bisexual students. Our findings provide guiding principles for schools to develop interventions and should encourage primary research to confirm, refute or refine our programme theories.
- 13 February 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Human Behaviour
- Vol. 7 (4) , 556-567
Open AccessA rapid realist review of universal interventions to promote inclusivity and acceptance of diverse sexual and gender identities in schools
Universal interventions to promote inclusivity and acceptance of diverse sexual and gender identities in schools could help to prevent mental health problems in this population. We reviewed evidence and developed programme theories to explain which universal interventions work, for whom, in which contexts and why. We conducted a rapid realist review and extracted data in context–mechanism–outcome configurations, to develop and refine programme theories. We included 53 sources and identified five intervention themes: student pride clubs, inclusive antibullying and harassment policies, inclusive curricula, workshops and staff training. Here, we show that these interventions could work by reducing discrimination, bullying and marginalization. Interventions appear to work best when school staff are trained and the school climate is supportive and may be less effective for boys, gender minority students and bisexual students. Our findings provide guiding principles for schools to develop interventions and should encourage primary research to confirm, refute or refine our programme theories.
- Open Access
A scoping review of trauma informed approaches in acute, crisis, emergency and residential mental health care
Experiences of trauma in childhood and adulthood are highly prevalent among service users accessing acute, crisis, emergency, and residential mental health services. These settings, and restraint and seclusion practices used, can be extremely traumatic, leading to a growing awareness for the need for trauma informed care (TIC). The aim of TIC is to acknowledge the prevalence and impact of trauma and create a safe environment to prevent re-traumatisation. This scoping review maps the TIC approaches delivered in these settings and reports related service user and staff experiences and attitudes, staff wellbeing, and service use outcomes. We searched seven databases (EMBASE; PsycINFO; MEDLINE; Web of Science; Social Policy and Practice; Maternity and Infant Care Database; Cochrane Library Trials Register) between 24/02/2022-10/03/2022, used backwards and forwards citation tracking, and consulted academic and lived experience experts, identifying 4244 potentially relevant studies. Thirty-one studies were included. Most studies (n=23) were conducted in the USA and were based in acute mental health services (n=16). We identified few trials, limiting inferences that can be drawn from the findings. The Six Core Strategies (n=7) and the Sanctuary Model (n=6) were the most commonly reported approaches. Rates of restraint and seclusion reportedly decreased. Some service users reported feeling trusted and cared for, while staff reported feeling empathy for service users and having a greater understanding of trauma. Staff reported needing training to deliver TIC effectively. TIC principles should be at the core of all mental health service delivery. Implementing TIC approaches may integrate best practice into mental health care, although significant time and financial resources are required to implement organisational change at scale. Most evidence is preliminary in nature, and confined to acute and residential services, with little evidence on community crisis or emergency services. Clinical and research developments should prioritise lived experience expertise in addressing these gaps.
Open AccessA scoping review of trauma informed approaches in acute, crisis, emergency and residential mental health care
Experiences of trauma in childhood and adulthood are highly prevalent among service users accessing acute, crisis, emergency, and residential mental health services. These settings, and restraint and seclusion practices used, can be extremely traumatic, leading to a growing awareness for the need for trauma informed care (TIC). The aim of TIC is to acknowledge the prevalence and impact of trauma and create a safe environment to prevent re-traumatisation. This scoping review maps the TIC approaches delivered in these settings and reports related service user and staff experiences and attitudes, staff wellbeing, and service use outcomes. We searched seven databases (EMBASE; PsycINFO; MEDLINE; Web of Science; Social Policy and Practice; Maternity and Infant Care Database; Cochrane Library Trials Register) between 24/02/2022-10/03/2022, used backwards and forwards citation tracking, and consulted academic and lived experience experts, identifying 4244 potentially relevant studies. Thirty-one studies were included. Most studies (n=23) were conducted in the USA and were based in acute mental health services (n=16). We identified few trials, limiting inferences that can be drawn from the findings. The Six Core Strategies (n=7) and the Sanctuary Model (n=6) were the most commonly reported approaches. Rates of restraint and seclusion reportedly decreased. Some service users reported feeling trusted and cared for, while staff reported feeling empathy for service users and having a greater understanding of trauma. Staff reported needing training to deliver TIC effectively. TIC principles should be at the core of all mental health service delivery. Implementing TIC approaches may integrate best practice into mental health care, although significant time and financial resources are required to implement organisational change at scale. Most evidence is preliminary in nature, and confined to acute and residential services, with little evidence on community crisis or emergency services. Clinical and research developments should prioritise lived experience expertise in addressing these gaps.
- Open Access
- 29 September 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Interactive Journal of Medical Research
- Vol. 11 (2) , e38239
Synthesis of the Evidence on What Works for Whom in Telemental Health: Rapid Realist Review
Background: Telemental health (delivering mental health care via video calls, telephone calls, or SMS text messages) is becoming increasingly widespread. Telemental health appears to be useful and effective in providing care to some service users in some settings, especially during an emergency restricting face-to-face contact, such as the COVID-19 pandemic. However, important limitations have been reported, and telemental health implementation risks the reinforcement of pre-existing inequalities in service provision. If it is to be widely incorporated into routine care, a clear understanding is needed of when and for whom it is an acceptable and effective approach and when face-to-face care is needed. Objective: This rapid realist review aims to develop a theory about which telemental health approaches work (or do not work), for whom, in which contexts, and through what mechanisms. Methods: Rapid realist reviewing involves synthesizing relevant evidence and stakeholder expertise to allow timely development of context-mechanism-outcome (CMO) configurations in areas where evidence is urgently needed to inform policy and practice. The CMO configurations encapsulate theories about what works for whom and by what mechanisms. Sources included eligible papers from 2 previous systematic reviews conducted by our team on telemental health; an updated search using the strategy from these reviews; a call for relevant evidence, including “gray literature,” to the public and key experts; and website searches of relevant voluntary and statutory organizations. CMO configurations formulated from these sources were iteratively refined, including through discussions with an expert reference group, including researchers with relevant lived experience and frontline clinicians, and consultation with experts focused on three priority groups: children and young people, users of inpatient and crisis care services, and digitally excluded groups. Results: A total of 108 scientific and gray literature sources were included. From our initial CMO configurations, we derived 30 overarching CMO configurations within four domains: connecting effectively; flexibility and personalization; safety, privacy, and confidentiality; and therapeutic quality and relationship. Reports and stakeholder input emphasized the importance of personal choice, privacy and safety, and therapeutic relationships in telemental health care. The review also identified particular service users likely to be disadvantaged by telemental health implementation and a need to ensure that face-to-face care of equivalent timeliness remains available. Mechanisms underlying the successful and unsuccessful application of telemental health are discussed. Conclusions: Service user choice, privacy and safety, the ability to connect effectively, and fostering strong therapeutic relationships need to be prioritized in delivering telemental health care. Guidelines and strategies coproduced with service users and frontline staff are needed to optimize telemental health implementation in real-world settings. Trial Registration: International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO); CRD42021260910; https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?ID=CRD42021260910
- 29 September 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Interactive Journal of Medical Research
- Vol. 11 (2) , e38239
Open AccessSynthesis of the Evidence on What Works for Whom in Telemental Health: Rapid Realist Review
Background: Telemental health (delivering mental health care via video calls, telephone calls, or SMS text messages) is becoming increasingly widespread. Telemental health appears to be useful and effective in providing care to some service users in some settings, especially during an emergency restricting face-to-face contact, such as the COVID-19 pandemic. However, important limitations have been reported, and telemental health implementation risks the reinforcement of pre-existing inequalities in service provision. If it is to be widely incorporated into routine care, a clear understanding is needed of when and for whom it is an acceptable and effective approach and when face-to-face care is needed. Objective: This rapid realist review aims to develop a theory about which telemental health approaches work (or do not work), for whom, in which contexts, and through what mechanisms. Methods: Rapid realist reviewing involves synthesizing relevant evidence and stakeholder expertise to allow timely development of context-mechanism-outcome (CMO) configurations in areas where evidence is urgently needed to inform policy and practice. The CMO configurations encapsulate theories about what works for whom and by what mechanisms. Sources included eligible papers from 2 previous systematic reviews conducted by our team on telemental health; an updated search using the strategy from these reviews; a call for relevant evidence, including “gray literature,” to the public and key experts; and website searches of relevant voluntary and statutory organizations. CMO configurations formulated from these sources were iteratively refined, including through discussions with an expert reference group, including researchers with relevant lived experience and frontline clinicians, and consultation with experts focused on three priority groups: children and young people, users of inpatient and crisis care services, and digitally excluded groups. Results: A total of 108 scientific and gray literature sources were included. From our initial CMO configurations, we derived 30 overarching CMO configurations within four domains: connecting effectively; flexibility and personalization; safety, privacy, and confidentiality; and therapeutic quality and relationship. Reports and stakeholder input emphasized the importance of personal choice, privacy and safety, and therapeutic relationships in telemental health care. The review also identified particular service users likely to be disadvantaged by telemental health implementation and a need to ensure that face-to-face care of equivalent timeliness remains available. Mechanisms underlying the successful and unsuccessful application of telemental health are discussed. Conclusions: Service user choice, privacy and safety, the ability to connect effectively, and fostering strong therapeutic relationships need to be prioritized in delivering telemental health care. Guidelines and strategies coproduced with service users and frontline staff are needed to optimize telemental health implementation in real-world settings. Trial Registration: International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO); CRD42021260910; https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?ID=CRD42021260910