One Book, Many Gains: On Saemi’s Morality and Revelation in Islamic Thought and Beyond
Open Access
- 28 November 2025
- journal article
- Published by University of Gävle in AGATHEOS – European Journal for Philosophy of Religion
- Vol. 2 (3) , 1-5
Abstract
Over the past twenty years, many scholars have argued that the analytic philosophy of religion is unhealthy for the following reasons, among others: Most analytic philosophers of religion are Christian theists or are significantly influenced by Christianity more than by any other religion. Most of the field's central problems have arisen through engagement with Christian beliefs. Most philosophical theories developed in defence of religious belief are proposed from a Christian perspective, and most arguments against religious belief are primarily targeted at Christianity. Until very recently, all the leading journals in the field were Christianity-oriented, and most of the major funded research projects centred on themes inspired by or formed in reaction to Christianity. 1 In recent years, a collective awareness has emerged among analytic philosophers of religion that the aforementioned biases and lack of diversity are prevalent in the field. Although there is no consensus on how harmful these issues are to the field, many philosophers of religion believe that change is needed anyway. Even if there is no agreement on its precise extent, it seems indisputable that the field should be more diverse. The field is, to a debatable-though not dismissible-extent, sick and in need of urgent treatment. 2 However, bringing about any progressive change in this regard is challenging. And this is partly because it requires sympathetic collaboration among various parties, including the funding bodies (many of which have not previously been interested in non-Christian philosophy of religion), the Christianity-inspired majority of philosophers of religion, and the minority primarily influenced by non-Christian religious traditions. Funding bodies must be receptive to projects planned to run from non-Christian perspectives. The Christianity-inspired majority should be open to the development of approaches that do not focus primarily on Christianity, whether in support or opposition, and must foster opportunities for such growth (e.g., by welcoming presentations inspired by underrepresented traditions at major philosophy of religion conferences, dedicating special issues of leading journals to papers on these traditions,Keywords
This publication has 1 reference indexed in Scilit:
- If analytic philosophy of religion is sick, can it be cured?Religious Studies, 2019