Navigating confidence–precision trade-offs in assessment
Open Access
- 14 May 2025
- journal article
- response
- Published by Springer Nature in Climatic Change
- Vol. 178 (5) , 1-6
Abstract
In this reply, we address a comment on our paper “Combining probability with qualitative degree-of-certainty metrics in assessment” (Helgeson et al. Clim Change 149(3):517–525, 2018). Our original paper proposes an incremental systematization of confidence and likelihood language used by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Our goals were to improve consistency across findings and support use of confidence judgments in decision making. The comment critiques our proposal and recommends against its adoption. We argue that this recommendation is based on two misunderstandings. The first concerns trading off confidence against the precision of a finding (our proposal endorses and systematizes the practice). We defend this practice and attribute opposition to an overzealous Bayesianism inapt for the IPCC context. The second misunderstanding concerns our purported commitment to a specific procedure for producing confidence judgements. We clarify that our proposal makes no such commitment. We also note, contrary to the comment’s claim, that a version of the procedure in question has been used in the IPCC’s Sixth Assessment Report.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ocean, Cryosphere and Sea Level Change2023
- Sea Level Rise and Implications for Low-Lying Islands, Coasts and Communities2022
- Updating confidence in beliefsJournal of Economic Theory, 2022
- Confident, likely, or both? The implementation of the uncertainty language framework in IPCC special reportsClimatic Change, 2020
- CONFIDENCE IN BELIEFS AND RATIONAL DECISION MAKINGEconomics and Philosophy, 2018
- Combining probability with qualitative degree-of-certainty metrics in assessmentClimatic Change, 2018
- Decision Theory with a Human Face2017
- Unleashing expert judgment in assessmentGlobal Environmental Change, 2017
- Confidence and decisionGames and Economic Behavior, 2013
- The IPCC AR5 guidance note on consistent treatment of uncertainties: a common approach across the working groupsClimatic Change, 2011