Combining democratic, regulatory and coordination hybridity for achieving robustness in turbulent times
Open Access
- 29 July 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Policy and Administration
Abstract
In recent years, crisis has become the norm for governments. Rather than alternating between stable conditions and moments of crises, political and administrative institutions now experience consistent crisis-induced turbulence. This has affected the legitimacy of established institutions, as the overlap of short and long-term shocks puts pressure on existing structures, actors, processes and procedures. Governments have increasingly looked to foster both change and stability through robustness by means of reevaluating the decision-making venues (the ‘who’), the regulatory tools (the ‘what’) and modes of coordination (the ‘how’). This article aims to capture the complex dynamics in fostering robustness of policies through the lens of hybridity. To achieve this, the paper reconceptualizes hybridity in crisis response from the interconnected perspectives of democratic decision-making (representative; direct; deliberative), regulatory tools (substantive; framework; reflexive) and coordination (hierarchical; market; network). It does so through empirical examples drawn from 108 interviews across 19 case studies in nine European countries, focusing on responses to COVID-19 vaccination promotion and school closures. By understanding the interactions within the dimensions of governance in democratic decision-making, regulatory tools and coordination, we can better comprehend the enablers and limitations for robust crisis responses. The paper argues that hybridity is linked to robustness through the ability of actors to foster complementary effects by repurposing different ideal types (mixing) and substituting the conflicts that develop over time (matching).Keywords
This publication has 67 references indexed in Scilit:
- Varieties of Democracies in the COVID-19 Pandemic2024
- Simple Solutions to Complex Catastrophes2024
- Governing the Pandemic2021
- Understanding the Creeping Crisis2021
- The European Response to COVID-19: From Regulatory Emulation to Regulatory Coordination?European Journal of Risk Regulation, 2020
- Toward comparative institutional analysis of polycentric social‐ecological systems governanceEnvironmental Policy and Governance, 2018
- The two orders of governance failure: Design mismatches and policy capacity issues in modern governancePolicy and Society, 2014
- Informing adaptation responses to climate change through theories of transformationGlobal Environmental Change, 2012
- Direct Democracy Worldwide2010
- The Coordination of Public Sector Organizations2010