Tiina Randma-Liiv
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Tiina Randma-Liiv has a total of 40 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Wolfgang Drechsler
Tallinn University of Technology
3 shared publications - Külli Sarapuu
Ragnar Nurkse Department of Innovation and Governance Tallinn University of Technology Tallinn Estonia
2 shared publications - Steven Nõmmik
Tallinn University of Technology, Tallinn, Estonia
2 shared publications Annika Uudelepp
Praxis Centre for Policy Studies, Estonia
1 shared publication- Ayberk Soner Kalaycı
Tallinn University of Technology
1 shared publication Benedetta Bello
Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 29 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Policy and Administration
Combining democratic, regulatory and coordination hybridity for achieving robustness in turbulent times
In recent years, crisis has become the norm for governments. Rather than alternating between stable conditions and moments of crises, political and administrative institutions now experience consistent crisis-induced turbulence. This has affected the legitimacy of established institutions, as the overlap of short and long-term shocks puts pressure on existing structures, actors, processes and procedures. Governments have increasingly looked to foster both change and stability through robustness by means of reevaluating the decision-making venues (the ‘who’), the regulatory tools (the ‘what’) and modes of coordination (the ‘how’). This article aims to capture the complex dynamics in fostering robustness of policies through the lens of hybridity. To achieve this, the paper reconceptualizes hybridity in crisis response from the interconnected perspectives of democratic decision-making (representative; direct; deliberative), regulatory tools (substantive; framework; reflexive) and coordination (hierarchical; market; network). It does so through empirical examples drawn from 108 interviews across 19 case studies in nine European countries, focusing on responses to COVID-19 vaccination promotion and school closures. By understanding the interactions within the dimensions of governance in democratic decision-making, regulatory tools and coordination, we can better comprehend the enablers and limitations for robust crisis responses. The paper argues that hybridity is linked to robustness through the ability of actors to foster complementary effects by repurposing different ideal types (mixing) and substituting the conflicts that develop over time (matching).
- 29 July 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Policy and Administration
Open AccessCombining democratic, regulatory and coordination hybridity for achieving robustness in turbulent times
In recent years, crisis has become the norm for governments. Rather than alternating between stable conditions and moments of crises, political and administrative institutions now experience consistent crisis-induced turbulence. This has affected the legitimacy of established institutions, as the overlap of short and long-term shocks puts pressure on existing structures, actors, processes and procedures. Governments have increasingly looked to foster both change and stability through robustness by means of reevaluating the decision-making venues (the ‘who’), the regulatory tools (the ‘what’) and modes of coordination (the ‘how’). This article aims to capture the complex dynamics in fostering robustness of policies through the lens of hybridity. To achieve this, the paper reconceptualizes hybridity in crisis response from the interconnected perspectives of democratic decision-making (representative; direct; deliberative), regulatory tools (substantive; framework; reflexive) and coordination (hierarchical; market; network). It does so through empirical examples drawn from 108 interviews across 19 case studies in nine European countries, focusing on responses to COVID-19 vaccination promotion and school closures. By understanding the interactions within the dimensions of governance in democratic decision-making, regulatory tools and coordination, we can better comprehend the enablers and limitations for robust crisis responses. The paper argues that hybridity is linked to robustness through the ability of actors to foster complementary effects by repurposing different ideal types (mixing) and substituting the conflicts that develop over time (matching).
- Open Access
- 20 May 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Policy and Administration
Robust governance in response to societal turbulence: The conditioning role of multilevel governance, hybrid governance, and societal intelligence
This introductory article to the special issue of PP&A on “Robust Governance in Turbulent Times,” defines the concepts of societal turbulence and robust governance and explains their relevance for understanding the current predicament characterized by polycrisis. It also explains the reasons for expecting multilevel governance, hybrid governance and societal intelligence to support and scaffold robust governance, and why liquid professionalism may amplify the impact of these three governance factors. The arguments are brought together in a theoretical framework intended to inspire future crisis management research and has already generated interesting new research contributions. The conclusion points out avenues for future research.
- 20 May 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Policy and Administration
Open AccessRobust governance in response to societal turbulence: The conditioning role of multilevel governance, hybrid governance, and societal intelligence
This introductory article to the special issue of PP&A on “Robust Governance in Turbulent Times,” defines the concepts of societal turbulence and robust governance and explains their relevance for understanding the current predicament characterized by polycrisis. It also explains the reasons for expecting multilevel governance, hybrid governance and societal intelligence to support and scaffold robust governance, and why liquid professionalism may amplify the impact of these three governance factors. The arguments are brought together in a theoretical framework intended to inspire future crisis management research and has already generated interesting new research contributions. The conclusion points out avenues for future research.
- 9 February 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Public Management Journal
- p. 1-26
Bridging the trust gap through proactive transparency: evidence from a survey experiment
- 9 February 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Public Management Journal
- p. 1-26
Bridging the trust gap through proactive transparency: evidence from a survey experiment
- 4 July 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Public Administration
- Vol. 49 (9) , 567-582
Advancing Citizen Engagement Through Digital Tools: A Comparative Study of the Baltic States
- 4 July 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Public Administration
- Vol. 49 (9) , 567-582
Advancing Citizen Engagement Through Digital Tools: A Comparative Study of the Baltic States
- 28 April 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Policy and Administration
- Vol. 41 (3-4) , 265-286
Deconstructing complexity: A comparative study of government collaboration in national digital platforms and smart city networks in Europe
This research deconstructs complexity as a key challenge of intergovernmental digitalisation projects. While much of the literature acknowledges that the fundamental restructuring coupled with technical capacity that these joint projects require leads to increased complexity, little is known about how different types of complexity interact within the collaborative process. Using established concepts of substantive, strategic, and institutional complexity, we apply complexity theory in collaborative digital environments. To do so, eight digital projects are analysed that differ by state structure and government level. Using a cross-case design with 50 semi-structured expert interviews, we find that each digitalisation project exhibits all types of complexity and that these complexities overlap. However, clear differences emerge between national and local level projects, suggesting that complexity in digitalisation processes presents different challenges for collaborative digitalisation projects across contexts.
- 28 April 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Policy and Administration
- Vol. 41 (3-4) , 265-286
Deconstructing complexity: A comparative study of government collaboration in national digital platforms and smart city networks in Europe
This research deconstructs complexity as a key challenge of intergovernmental digitalisation projects. While much of the literature acknowledges that the fundamental restructuring coupled with technical capacity that these joint projects require leads to increased complexity, little is known about how different types of complexity interact within the collaborative process. Using established concepts of substantive, strategic, and institutional complexity, we apply complexity theory in collaborative digital environments. To do so, eight digital projects are analysed that differ by state structure and government level. Using a cross-case design with 50 semi-structured expert interviews, we find that each digitalisation project exhibits all types of complexity and that these complexities overlap. However, clear differences emerge between national and local level projects, suggesting that complexity in digitalisation processes presents different challenges for collaborative digitalisation projects across contexts.
- 26 January 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Policy and Administration
- Vol. 38 (3) , 329-351
Adoption is not enough: Institutionalization of e-participation initiatives
This study investigates the institutionalization of e-participation initiatives in six European countries—Estonia, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Scotland, and Spain—using a multiple case study. The following research questions are addressed: How have recently established e-participation initiatives been institutionalized in public administrations? What are the formal and informal aspects of their institutionalization? It is concluded that the adoption of a digital solution does not in itself trigger a change in the policy-making process because the institutionalization of e-participation is not a linear process. The formal institutionalization increases the sustainability, transparency, and throughput legitimacy of e-participation and allows citizen proposals to be handled in a standardized way. Although the formal institutionalization of e-participation is key for an institutional change towards deliberative democracy, it needs to be accompanied by informal institutionalization through the supporting ideas, values, and preferences of politicians and public officials who have the power to change public institutions.
- 26 January 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Policy and Administration
- Vol. 38 (3) , 329-351
Adoption is not enough: Institutionalization of e-participation initiatives
This study investigates the institutionalization of e-participation initiatives in six European countries—Estonia, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Scotland, and Spain—using a multiple case study. The following research questions are addressed: How have recently established e-participation initiatives been institutionalized in public administrations? What are the formal and informal aspects of their institutionalization? It is concluded that the adoption of a digital solution does not in itself trigger a change in the policy-making process because the institutionalization of e-participation is not a linear process. The formal institutionalization increases the sustainability, transparency, and throughput legitimacy of e-participation and allows citizen proposals to be handled in a standardized way. Although the formal institutionalization of e-participation is key for an institutional change towards deliberative democracy, it needs to be accompanied by informal institutionalization through the supporting ideas, values, and preferences of politicians and public officials who have the power to change public institutions.
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 135-166
Public Service Development in Estonia: From Patronage to Meritocracy
- 1 January 2022
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 135-166
Public Service Development in Estonia: From Patronage to Meritocracy
- Open Access
- 7 October 2021
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration
- Vol. 100 (4) , 1037-1053
Organizing e‐participation: Challenges stemming from the multiplicity of actors
Multiple actors involved in the provision of e‐participation initiatives add to the complexity of organizational design and blur accountability and ownership relations. This study addresses the following research questions: How are different organizations and their units involved in the supply of e‐participation initiatives? How does the multiplicity of actors affect cross‐boundary collaboration, ownership, and accountability relations in the implementation of e‐participation initiatives? The empirical analysis is based on comparative case studies on e‐participation platforms in seven European countries. The case studies indicate that cross‐organizational issues—ownership and accountability, in particular—have often been insufficiently addressed during the development of e‐participation initiatives. Ambiguous ownership and diffused accountability are particularly challenging in the cases of multilevel governance and in “bottom‐up” e‐participation initiatives. The “distance” between the unit responsible for the administration of an e‐participation initiative and the decision‐makers appears to be a critical factor for the functioning of the platforms.
- 7 October 2021
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration
- Vol. 100 (4) , 1037-1053
Open AccessOrganizing e‐participation: Challenges stemming from the multiplicity of actors
Multiple actors involved in the provision of e‐participation initiatives add to the complexity of organizational design and blur accountability and ownership relations. This study addresses the following research questions: How are different organizations and their units involved in the supply of e‐participation initiatives? How does the multiplicity of actors affect cross‐boundary collaboration, ownership, and accountability relations in the implementation of e‐participation initiatives? The empirical analysis is based on comparative case studies on e‐participation platforms in seven European countries. The case studies indicate that cross‐organizational issues—ownership and accountability, in particular—have often been insufficiently addressed during the development of e‐participation initiatives. Ambiguous ownership and diffused accountability are particularly challenging in the cases of multilevel governance and in “bottom‐up” e‐participation initiatives. The “distance” between the unit responsible for the administration of an e‐participation initiative and the decision‐makers appears to be a critical factor for the functioning of the platforms.
- 23 July 2019
- Published by SAGE Publications in The British Journal of Politics and International Relations
- Vol. 21 (3) , 504-512
The politics of bureaucracy: The Central and Eastern European perspective
- 23 July 2019
- Published by SAGE Publications in The British Journal of Politics and International Relations
- Vol. 21 (3) , 504-512
The politics of bureaucracy: The Central and Eastern European perspective
- 18 August 2018
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 71-81
EGPA and the European Administrative Space: Strategic Partnership with NISPAcee and the Trans-European Dialogue (TED)
- 18 August 2018
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 71-81
EGPA and the European Administrative Space: Strategic Partnership with NISPAcee and the Trans-European Dialogue (TED)