Tsunami evacuation route determination using AHP–TOPSIS with a participatory approach in Gumukmas, Jember, Indonesia
Authors:
- Retno Utami Agung WiyonoRWRetno Utami Agung Wiyono
- Fidyasari Kusuma PutriFPFidyasari Kusuma Putri
- Rafli Rizaldi Luthfan HakimRHRafli Rizaldi Luthfan Hakim
- Daffa Fulvian Wildani AlfiansyahDADaffa Fulvian Wildani Alfiansyah
- Entin HidayahEntin Hidayah
- Wiwik Yunarni WidiartiWWWiwik Yunarni Widiarti
- Vanadani PranantyaVPVanadani Pranantya
- Hilma Wasilah RobbaniHRHilma Wasilah Robbani
- 1 June 2026
- journal article
- Published by IWA Publishing in Water Practice & Technology
- Vol. 21 (6) , 2383-2404
Abstract
A flowchart consists of six main points: (1) participatory criteria and weighting of analytic hierarchy process based on eight criteria, followed by AH pairwise comparison and weight of criteria, (2) process of technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution ranking, (3) spatial implementation using geographic information systems (from preparing tsunami hazard map using Delft3D modeling) and creating evacuation route, (4) focus group discussion for validation purpose, and (5) final evacuation route and early warning system web application. Extreme coastal flooding caused by a tsunami could cause a high number of casualties and economic loss. Effective coastal flood risk management, therefore, requires a well-prepared tsunami evacuation strategy. Evacuation planning in coastal areas requires not only technically optimal solutions but also socially executable strategies. This study aims to identify and validate suitable temporary evacuation sites (TES) and evacuation routes in Gumukmas, Indonesia, by integrating multicriteria decision analysis with participatory validation. A hybrid Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) approach was applied to prioritize thirteen TES alternatives based on eight evaluation criteria, and the resulting priorities were integrated into evacuation route mapping. To ensure operational relevance, the analytical results were validated through a focus group discussion (FGD). The results show that evacuation time and tsunami disaster risk are the most influential criteria and that TES rankings shift substantially when trade-offs among criteria are considered using TOPSIS. The FGD did not invalidate the analytical results but redefined their functional application by introducing a staged evacuation concept and additional TES based on local experience and perceived safety. This study demonstrates that participatory processes are essential for translating numerical optimality into realistic coastal flood protection practice.Keywords
Funding Information
- Universitas Jember (2679/UN25.2.1/L/T/2025)
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Enhancing consistency of AHP-based expert judgements: A new approach and its implementation in an interactive toolMethodsX, 2025
- Tsunami risk mitigation: the role of evacuation routes, preparedness and urban planningNatural Hazards, 2024
- Integrated tsunami risk framework considering agent-based evacuation modelling: The case of Saga, Kochi Prefecture, JapanInternational Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2023
- Land cover and potential for tsunami evacuation in rapidly growing urban areas. The case of Boca Sur (San Pedro de la Paz, Chile)International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2022
- Stakeholder perceptions in flood risk assessment: A hybrid fuzzy AHP-TOPSIS approach for Istanbul, TurkeyInternational Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2021
- Pedestrian flow-path modeling to support tsunami evacuation and disaster relief planning in the U.S. Pacific NorthwestInternational Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2016
- Beat-the-wave evacuation mapping for tsunami hazards in Seaside, Oregon, USANatural Hazards, 2015
- Sensitivity of tsunami evacuation modeling to direction and land cover assumptionsApplied Geography, 2015
- Tsunami vertical-evacuation planning in the U.S. Pacific Northwest as a geospatial, multi-criteria decision problemInternational Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2014
- Field survey of the East Java earthquake and tsunami of June 3, 1994Pure and Applied Geophysics, 1995