How standards compete: comparative impact of coffee certification schemes in Northern Nicaragua
Authors:
- 15 March 2011
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Supply Chain Management: An International Journal
- Vol. 16 (2) , 98-109
Abstract
Purpose – Smallholder farmers are increasingly subject to different types of standards that offer specific conditions for their market incorporation. The proliferation of private and voluntary (civic) standards raises questions regarding their impact on farmers' welfare and their role in the upgrading of value chains. This paper aims to address this issue. Design/methodology/approach – Based on extensive fieldwork and careful matching of 315 farmers in Northern Nicaragua who produce coffee under Fair Trade, Rainforest Alliance and Café Practices labels or deliver to independent traders, the effects on income, production and investments are compared. Moreover, the implications of different contract conditions for risk behaviour, organizational force, loyalty and gender attitudes are assessed. Findings – The paper finds that Fair Trade provides better prices compared with independent producers, but private labels out-compete Fair Trade in terms of yield and quality performance. While Fair Trade can be helpful to support initial market incorporation, private labels offer more suitable incentives for quality upgrading. Research limitations/implications – Civic standards exhibit major effects on local institutions' and farmers' behaviour, while B2B standards are more effective for improving production and management practices. Dynamic improvement standards may bridge the gap between both. Practical implications – Fair Trade standards are useful to provide initial market access to small-holders, but private standards offer better prospects for subsequent quality upgrading. Originality/value – This is the first large-scale comparative impact assessment of coffee standards that delivers unbiased empirical results.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Fair Trade organic coffee production in Nicaragua — Sustainable development or a poverty trap?Ecological Economics, 2009
- Impacts of Fair Trade certification on coffee farmers, cooperatives, and laborers in NicaraguaAgriculture and Human Values, 2009
- Managing quality heterogeneity in the mango supply chain: evidence from Costa RicaTrends in Food Science & Technology, 2009
- Are Sustainable Coffee Certifications Enough to Secure Farmer Livelihoods? The Millenium Development Goals and Nicaragua's Fair Trade CooperativesGlobalizations, 2008
- Intersectoral partnerships for a sustainable coffee chain: Really addressing sustainability or just picking (coffee) cherries?Global Environmental Change, 2008
- A techno-managerial approach in food quality management researchTrends in Food Science & Technology, 2006
- Is sustainable agriculture a viable strategy to improve farm income in Central America? A case study on coffeeJournal of Business Research, 2006
- 6. Matching with Multiple Controls to Estimate Treatment Effects in Observational StudiesSociological Methodology, 1997
- Quality guidance and quality formationFood Quality and Preference, 1996
- The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effectsBiometrika, 1983