Social judgement of defensive and secure social identities among advantaged and disadvantaged groups
- 14 March 2025
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Group Processes & Intergroup Relations
Abstract
This research integrates social judgement and social identity theories to examine evaluations of defensive (narcissistic) and secure social identity (vs. lack of identification) expressed by targets with varying group statuses (advantaged vs. disadvantaged). Across three studies (total N = 2,915), we manipulated target group status and forms of identity. In socioeconomic groups (Study 1), an advantaged target with a defensive identity was deemed assertive, while a disadvantaged counterpart was perceived as moral. Unexpectedly, in ethnocultural groups (Studies 2–3), the disadvantaged target expressing a defensive identity was judged equally or more assertive than the advantaged target. Notably, defensive identity from a disadvantaged target consistently garnered higher moral judgement than from an advantaged target. These results highlight that defensive identity can receive positive evaluations and confer elevated status. Nonetheless, we observed differential evaluation strategies depending on intergroup settings, suggesting system justification in socioeconomic groups versus ingroup favouritism in U.S. ethnic groups.Keywords
Funding Information
- comue université Paris Lumières (OPE-2022 -0014)
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Defensive national identity relates to support for collective violence, in contrast to secure national identity, in a sample of displaced Syrian diaspora membersInternational Journal of Intercultural Relations, 2024
- Understanding identity processes in support for reactionary and progressive social movements among advantaged and disadvantaged groups: The role of collective narcissism and secure ingroup identityEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 2022
- Male, National, and Religious Collective Narcissism Predict SexismSex Roles, 2020
- Groups' warmth is a personal matter: Understanding consensus on stereotype dimensions reconciles adversarial models of social evaluationJournal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2020
- Comparing the facets of the big two in global evaluation of self versus other peopleEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 2019
- Economic inequality enhances inferences that the normative climate is individualistic and competitiveEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 2018
- An advantage of appearing mean or lazy: Amplified impressions of competence or warmth after mixed descriptionsJournal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2016
- Competence and warmth in context: The compensatory nature of stereotypic views of national groupsEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 2008
- System‐justifying ideologies moderate status = competence stereotypes: roles for belief in a just world and social dominance orientationEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 2007
- Status differences and in-group bias: A meta-analytic examination of the effects of status stability, status legitimacy, and group permeability.Psychological Bulletin, 2001