Coming a long way: Switzerland’s transformation from a majoritarian to a consensus democracy (1848–2018)
- 13 May 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Democratization
- Vol. 27 (6) , 970-989
Abstract
How did relevant key events shape the long-term transformation of Swiss democracy in terms of horizontal and vertical power-sharing? And why did existing systems, that is “role models”, inspire this transformation? Renowned for being one of the oldest democracies in Europe, Switzerland offers a unique, case-based research opportunity to scrutinize the evolutionary process of democratization. We argue that Lijphart’s seminal “consensus-versus-majoritarian”-democracy model constitutes a suitable tool to study the long-term evolution of democracies. In order to make it applicable across time, however, conceptual pitfalls need to be tackled. The conceptual part is thus concerned with the problem of identifying relevant time periods. Empirically, Switzerland’s 170 years of democratic change are analysed based on Lijphart’s framework. Moreover, mechanisms of transnational diffusion that explain why “role models” (the United States, the Weimar Republic, and the Netherlands) inspired the transformation of Swiss democracy are explored. The analysis draws on new, historic data going as far back as the late eighteenth and early nineteenth century. The longitudinal design reveals a long-term transformation of Switzerland from an almost purely majoritarian democracy to post-war “paradigmatic consensualism”. The article thereby offers new insights into how changes in the formal-institutional setting are related to the paradox of democratization.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Conflict, choice or geography? Explaining patterns of democracy in continental EuropeEuropean Journal of Political Research, 2017
- Patterns of democracy: Coalition governance and majoritarian modification in the United Kingdom, 2010–2015British Politics, 2016
- Le néocorporatisme suisse en déclin? Les commissions extra‐parlementaires dans un environnement en mutation (1957–2010)Swiss Political Science Review, 2015
- Der schweizerische Bundesstaat von 1848 bis 1874: Mehrheits‐ oder Konsensusdemokratie?Swiss Political Science Review, 2014
- Subnational Patterns of Democracy in Austria, Germany and SwitzerlandWest European Politics, 2013
- Namibia: Consensus institutions and majoritarian politicsDemocratization, 2006
- The Rise and Fall of Western Europe's Democratic Age, 1945–1973Contemporary European History, 2004
- Corporatism in 24 industrial democracies: Meaning and measurementEuropean Journal of Political Research, 1999
- Proportionality, disproportionality and electoral systemsElectoral Studies, 1991
- Pennsylvania and Switzerland: The American Origins of the Swiss Constitution1941