Lack of agreement between different observers and methods in the measurement of capillary refill time in healthy volunteers: an observational study
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 January 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Associação de Medicina Intensiva Brasileira in Revista Brasileira de Terapia Intensiva
- Vol. 26 (3) , 269-76
Abstract
Peripheral perfusion abnormalities are relevant manifestations of shock. Capillary refill time is commonly used for their evaluation. However, the reproducibility of capillary refill time measurements and their correlation with other variables of peripheral perfusion, have not been comprehensively evaluated. Our goal was to determine, in healthy volunteers, the agreement between different methods of capillary refill time quantification and different observers, as well as their correlation with other markers of peripheral perfusion. Methods: We studied 63 healthy volunteers. Two observers measured capillary refill time by means of two methods, direct view (CRTchronome ter) and video analysis (CRTvideo). We also measured perfusion index (PI) derived from pulse plethysmography and finger pad temperature (T°peripheral). The agreement between observers and methods was assessed using the Bland and Altman method. Correlations were calculated using Pearson's correlation. A p-value<0.05 was considered significant. The 95% limits of agreement between the two observers were 1.9 sec for CRTchronometer and 1.7 sec for CRTvideo. The 95% limits of agreement between CRTchronometer and CRTvideo were 1.7 sec for observer 1 and 2.3 sec for observer 2. Measurements of CRTchronometer performed by the two observers were correlated with T°peripheral. Measurements of CRTvideo performed by the two observers were correlated with T°peripheral and perfusion index. In healthy volunteers, measurements of capillary refill time performed by either different observers or different methods showed poor agreement. Nevertheless, capillary refill time still reflected peripheral perfusion as shown by its correlation with objective variables of peripheral perfusion.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evolution of peripheral vs metabolic perfusion parameters during septic shock resuscitation. A clinical-physiologic studyJournal of Critical Care, 2012
- Capillary refill time and cardiac output in children undergoing cardiac catheterization *Pediatric Critical Care Medicine, 2012
- A multidisciplinary survey on capillary refill time: Inconsistent performance and interpretation of a common clinical testPediatric Critical Care Medicine, 2008
- Impact of patient and environmental factors on capillary refill time in adultsThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2008
- Noninvasive monitoring of peripheral perfusionIntensive Care Medicine, 2005
- Capillary refill and core-peripheral temperature gap as indicators of haemodynamic status in paediatric intensive care patientsArchives of Disease in Childhood, 1999
- Effect of Ambient Temperature on Capillary Refill in Healthy ChildrenPediatrics, 1993
- Capillary Refill: Is It a Useful Clinical Sign?Pediatrics, 1993
- Capillary refill — is it a useful predictor of hypovolemic states?Annals of Emergency Medicine, 1991
- Trauma scoreCritical Care Medicine, 1981