True Motives: Prosocial and Instrumental Justifications for Behavioral Change in Organizations
- 1 August 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Management Science
- Vol. 67 (8) , 5032-5051
Abstract
When organizations want their employees to adopt behaviors that advance prosocial and instrumental aims, which motive should they express? A groundswell of recent work suggests that highlighting prosocial actions inspires and motivates employees. Building on this work, we embed a field experiment in the context of an organizational change initiative (Study 1). A large university sought to change the behavior of administrative employees who purchase office supplies, encouraging them to place orders of at least $50, referred to as “bundling.” We exploit the fact that the organization could justify the same behavior in contrasting ways. We randomly assign employees to view either a prosocial (“limiting pollution”), instrumental (“limiting costs”), or mixed motive (“limiting pollution and limiting costs”) for caring about bundling each time they access the organization’s procurement system. We then evaluate changes in employees’ behavior by comparing a six-month baseline to a six-month experimental period, covering 10,169 purchases in 556 offices. Contrary to expectations from related research, the instrumental motive was most effective for changing behavior, leading to significantly more bundling than the prosocial motive. Two follow-up vignette experiments probe theoretical mechanisms. They indicate that an instrumental motive seems more genuine (i.e., reflecting the organization’s true motive) than a prosocial motive (Study 2) and that seeming genuine increases individuals’ intention to bundle (Study 3). This research reveals that prosocial justifications can be less effective than instrumental ones and suggests that perceptions of genuineness may shape the effectiveness of behavioral change efforts in organizations. This paper was accepted by Yuval Rottenstreich, decision analysis.Keywords
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Prosocial Bonuses Increase Employee Satisfaction and Team PerformancePLOS ONE, 2013
- Comparing the effectiveness of monetary versus moral motives in environmental campaigningNature Climate Change, 2012
- Mixed reasons, missed givings: The costs of blending egoistic and altruistic reasons in donation requestsJournal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2012
- Leading with Meaning: Beneficiary Contact, Prosocial Impact, and the Performance Effects of Transformational LeadershipAcademy of Management Journal, 2012
- Corporate social responsibility as a source of employee satisfactionResearch in Organizational Behavior, 2012
- When and Why Incentives (Don't) Work to Modify BehaviorJournal of Economic Perspectives, 2011
- Going green to be seen: Status, reputation, and conspicuous conservation.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2010
- The contribution of corporate social responsibility to organizational commitmentThe International Journal of Human Resource Management, 2007
- When Consumers Do Not Recognize “Benign” Intention Questions as Persuasion AttemptsJournal of Consumer Research, 2004
- Social Comparisons in Boundary-Spanning Work: Effects of Community Outreach on Members' Organizational Identity and IdentificationAdministrative Science Quarterly, 2001