We identify a novel mechanism under which a revenue-maximizing platform may decide to host some harmful sellers, even when they are identifiable and removable at zero cost. We model monopolistic sellers in independent markets: normal sellers differ in intrinsic quality and can improve quality through costly, unobservable effort. Bad sellers supply either zero-quality or harmful products, and exert no effort. The platform operates a binary certification and chooses how many bad sellers to remove. Hosting some bad sellers thickens the left tail of the quality distribution, lowering the expected quality of uncertified products and thereby raising normal sellers' effort. However, it also lowers average quality and trade value. We show that hosting bad sellers is optimal if they are not too harmful. Relative to a planner, the platform hosts too many bad sellers. Platform liability reduces this distortion, whereas seller liability and compensation schemes for consumers may be ineffective.