A virtual trial framework for quantifying the detectability of masses in breast tomosynthesis projection data
Authors:
- Predrag R. BakicPBPredrag R. Bakic
- Kyle J. MyersKMKyle J. Myers
- Robert J. JenningsRJRobert J. Jennings
- Subok ParkSPSubok Park
- 25 April 2013
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 40 (5) , 051914
Abstract
Purpose:: Digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) is a promising breast cancer screening tool that has already begun making inroads into clinical practice. However, there is ongoing debate over how to quantitatively evaluate and optimize these systems, because different definitions of image quality can lead to different optimal design strategies. Powerful and accurate tools are desired to extend our understanding of DBT system optimization and validate published design principles.Methods:: The authors developed a virtual trial framework for task‐specific DBT assessment that uses digital phantoms, open‐source x‐ray transport codes, and a projection‐space, spatial‐domain observer model for quantitative system evaluation. The authors considered evaluation of reconstruction algorithms as a separate problem and focused on the information content in the raw, unfiltered projection images. Specifically, the authors investigated the effects of scan angle and number of angular projections on detectability of a small (3 mm diameter) signal embedded in randomly‐varying anatomical backgrounds. Detectability was measured by the area under the receiver‐operating characteristic curve (AUC). Experiments were repeated for three test cases where the detectability‐limiting factor was anatomical variability, quantum noise, or electronic noise. The authors also juxtaposed the virtual trial framework with other published studies to illustrate its advantages and disadvantages.Results:: The large number of variables in a virtual DBT study make it difficult to directly compare different authors’ results, so each result must be interpreted within the context of the specific virtual trial framework. The following results apply to 25% density phantoms with 5.15 cm compressed thickness and 500 μm3 voxels (larger 500 μm2 detector pixels were used to avoid voxel‐edge artifacts): 1. For raw, unfiltered projection images in the anatomical‐variability‐limited regime, AUC appeared to remain constant or increase slightly with scan angle. 2. In the same regime, when the authors fixed the scan angle, AUC increased asymptotically with the number of projections. The threshold number of projections for asymptotic AUC performance depended on the scan angle. In the quantum‐ and electronic‐noise dominant regimes, AUC behaviors as a function of scan angle and number of projections sometimes differed from the anatomy‐limited regime. For example, with a fixed scan angle, AUC generally decreased with the number of projections in the electronic‐noise dominant regime. These results are intended to demonstrate the capabilities of the virtual trial framework, not to be used as optimization rules for DBT.Conclusions:: The authors have demonstrated a novel simulation framework and tools for evaluating DBT systems in an objective, task‐specific manner. This framework facilitates further investigation of image quality tradeoffs in DBT.Keywords
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- Breast TomosynthesisAcademic Radiology, 2011
- Tomosynthesis imaging: At a translational crossroadsMedical Physics, 2009
- Experimental validation of a three‐dimensional linear system model for breast tomosynthesisMedical Physics, 2008
- Optimization of Tomosynthesis Acquisition Parameters: Angular Range and Number of Projections2008
- Optimizing breast-tomosynthesis acquisition parameters with scanning model observers2008
- Effect of dose reduction on the detection of mammographic lesions: A mathematical observer model analysisMedical Physics, 2007
- A computer simulation study comparing lesion detection accuracy with digital mammography, breast tomosynthesis, and cone‐beam CT breast imagingMedical Physics, 2006
- Dose to population as a metric in the design of optimised exposure control in digital mammographyRadiation Protection Dosimetry, 2005
- Optimization of peak kilovoltage and spectral shape for digital mammography1992
- Optimal x‐ray spectra for screen‐film mammographyMedical Physics, 1981