Abstract
For L2 Portuguese learners in Macau, artificial intelligence (AI) has become a primary source of immediate writing feedback for Chinese university students. This study investigates authentic learner prompting practices and the accuracy of resulting AI-generated revisions in L2 Portuguese writing. Forty-six second-year Portuguese Studies majors, divided into a control condition and a justification condition that required them to rationalize every modification, revised a first-year learner composition using their preferred AI tools. Results reveal that students predominantly prompted in Chinese, employed highly anthropomorphic and polite language, relied on generic or grammar-focused requests, and frequently exhibited misalignment between intended goals and actual prompts. The requirement to justify revisions increased interaction turns and shifted attention toward smaller textual units and explanation-seeking, though it also produced higher error rates in the resulting revisions. Experiments with researcher-designed prompts demonstrated the potential of simple prompt engineering strategies, with the Rephrase-and-Respond technique eliciting the most accurate revisions. The findings underscore the immaturity of untrained prompting, the context-sensitive nature of prompt engineering, and the practical pedagogical value of current LLMs even under naïve use. To foster critical and reflective human-AI collaboration in L2 writing, pedagogical interventions such as explicit instruction in prompting strategies and the use of tasks that require justification or explanation-seeking are recommended.

This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit: